What's the story with canned food?

13-07-2019 03:50PM #1

Was in the shop earlier perusing and there was a mad variety of canned stuff. Fish, pate, chicken etc.

Is it bad? Is it all full of salt like I've been led to believe? I know little about it since I only get the odd tin of tuna.

TheValeyard · 13-07-2019 03:51PM

It's food, in a can.

sullivlo · 13-07-2019 03:52PM

Ads by Google wrote: »

Was in the shop earlier perusing and there was a mad variety of canned stuff. Fish, pate, chicken etc.

Is it bad? Is it all full of salt like I've been led to believe? I know little about it since I only get the odd tin of tuna.

Full of salt and preservatives, but when faced with canned food vs no food, it's fine.

Some things are obviously better than others. Tinned tomatos etc = good. Tinned spam/entire chickens = poor.

ytpe2r5bxkn0c1 · 13-07-2019 03:53PM

It depends on what's in the can. Some canned foods are excellent others are rubbish.

sullivlo · 13-07-2019 03:55PM

Katalina Rough Gypsy wrote: »

It depends on what's in the can. Some canned foods are excellent others are rubbish.

A friend of mine is stereotypically French and she adores snails. Obviously we don't get them in Ireland, but she buys tinned snails in some mad exclusive shop in France. They're about €50 a can but they're actually quite tasty. They don't come in shells so she has a collection of shells that she puts them into if she's serving them at a party.

Del2005 · 13-07-2019 03:56PM

sullivlo wrote: »

Full of salt and preservatives, but when faced with canned food vs no food, it's fine.

Some things are obviously better than others. Tinned tomatos etc = good. Tinned spam/entire chickens = poor.

The whole point of the can is that you don't need salt or preservatives. So why would they add to the cost of production by using canning and preservatives when they could just use preservatives?

Infernal Racket · 13-07-2019 03:56PM

Get some cans of Guinness and you'll have no more worries about canned food

IAMAMORON · 13-07-2019 03:57PM

I have snails in my garden if she wants some.

Kat1170 · 13-07-2019 04:00PM

Food and drink in a can. What will they think of next :O

TheValeyard · 13-07-2019 04:00PM

IAMAMORON wrote: »

I have snails in my garden if she wants some.

The fcukers are everywhere these days!

nuyil simp · 13-07-2019 04:03PM

Kat1170 wrote: »

Food and drink in a can. What will they think of next :O

You can get wine in cans now

SEPT 23 1989 · 13-07-2019 04:06PM

nuyil simp wrote: »

You can get wine in cans now

Beer can size?

Interesting

Dramatik · 13-07-2019 04:08PM

Ads by Google wrote: »

Was in the shop earlier perusing and there was a mad variety of canned stuff. Fish, pate, chicken etc.

Is it bad? Is it all full of salt like I've been led to believe? I know little about it since I only get the odd tin of tuna.

[Andy Warhol likes this]

sullivlo · 13-07-2019 04:09PM

Del2005 wrote: »

The whole point of the can is that you don't need salt or preservatives. So why would they add to the cost of production by using canning and preservatives when they could just use preservatives?

Most will still have some form of salt or preservative though. Tuna in brine, for example.

odyssey06 · 13-07-2019 04:22PM

Pretty horrific story about what can go wrong with early attempts at canned food... lead poisoning and improperly sealed cans during the 1845 expedition to the Arctic by HMS Erebus and HMS Terror.
https://www.historytoday.com/archive/canned-food-sealed-icemens-fate

Without canned foods, it would not have been possible for the trench warfare of mass armies in World War One to have occurred, as there would have been no way to supply such numbers all year round with fresh food.

Thankfully things have moved on since then but with home canning there's a risk of botulism.

Graces7 · 13-07-2019 04:23PM

sullivlo wrote: »

Most will still have some form of salt or preservative though. Tuna in brine, for example.

it comes in sunflower oil too..

and baked beans... a staple...;

But tins are heat sealed

ytpe2r5bxkn0c1 · 13-07-2019 04:26PM

Canned fruit and vegetables are often more nutritional than fresh. Also, convenient, store for longer and less waste. Although items like baked beans can have half a cup of sugar per can. Tinned foods can a great benefit but always worth reading the ingredients.

Plumbthedepths · 13-07-2019 04:27PM

sullivlo wrote:

A friend of mine is stereotypically French and she adores snails. Obviously we don't get them in Ireland, but she buys tinned snails in some mad exclusive shop in France. They're about â‚¬50 a can but they're actually quite tasty. They don't come in shells so she has a collection of shells that she puts them into if she's serving them at a party.

I worked in several 5 star hotels in my younger days and what your friend does is common practice.

suicide_circus · 13-07-2019 04:31PM

canned tomatoes and pineapple are absolutely essential in ireland as the fresh versions we get here are dreadful

sullivlo · 13-07-2019 04:38PM

Plumbthedepths wrote: »

I worked in several 5 star hotels in my younger days and what your friend does is common practice.

Oh yeah I know! They have a collection of "nice" shells and are stored like any other bowl!

igCorcaigh · 13-07-2019 04:39PM

Ortiz tuna
Mutti tomatoes

Both very good.
Beer has to be bottled though.

Irish Praetorian · 13-07-2019 05:22PM

odyssey06 wrote: »

Pretty horrific story about what can go wrong with early attempts at canned food... lead poisoning and improperly sealed cans during the 1845 expedition to the Arctic by HMS Erebus and HMS Terror.
https://www.historytoday.com/archive/canned-food-sealed-icemens-fate

Without canned foods, it would not have been possible for the trench warfare of mass armies in World War One to have occurred, as there would have been no way to supply such numbers all year round with fresh food.

Thankfully things have moved on since then but with home canning there's a risk of botulism.

One of the maddest food achievements I ever saw was a guy eating from an Army Reserve Ration (some variety of beef if I recall correctly) which was assembled in 1901 for the Boer War. These things were long out of expiry by the time the First World War started and yet he nibbles away at it in 2018 with no bother. I can only presume after 100 or so years everything had decayed to have no life/bacteria left in it at all.

Problem Of Motivation · 13-07-2019 05:29PM

BPA

igCorcaigh · 13-07-2019 05:32PM

Problem Of Motivation wrote: »

BPA

Least of my worries

kneemos · 13-07-2019 05:35PM

Closet I've come to death was from a tin of mackeral fillets.
Three days to recover.

igCorcaigh · 13-07-2019 05:36PM

kneemos wrote: »

Closet I've come to death was from a tin of mackeral fillets.
Three days to recover.

What?
I'm constantly eating the stuff.

Did you leave it for a while after opening?

kneemos · 13-07-2019 05:44PM

igCorcaigh wrote: »

What?
I'm constantly eating the stuff.

Did you leave it for a while after opening?

Don't think so. Went through a spell of bad luck with food poisoning.
The fish was the worst though. Filled the wash had basin with projectile vomit,while filling the loo on the other end.

I was eating them for years as well without a problem. Just bad luck I imagine.

Atoms for Peace · 13-07-2019 05:49PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgzACnYsV8U

wakka12 · 13-07-2019 05:54PM

Ads by Google wrote: »

Was in the shop earlier perusing and there was a mad variety of canned stuff. Fish, pate, chicken etc.

Is it bad? Is it all full of salt like I've been led to believe? I know little about it since I only get the odd tin of tuna.

Read the labels. Plenty of canned food has no salt.

ToddyDoody · 13-07-2019 05:59PM

Ads by Google wrote: »

Was in the shop earlier perusing and there was a mad variety of canned stuff. Fish, pate, chicken etc.

Is it bad? Is it all full of salt like I've been led to believe? I know little about it since I only get the odd tin of tuna.

I agree, something very suspicious going on.

JohnnyFlash · 13-07-2019 06:00PM

igCorcaigh wrote: »

Ortiz tuna
Mutti tomatoes

Both very good.
Beer has to be bottled though.

Does beer have to be bottled? I drink cans of Guinness and they are lovely.

What's the story with canned food?

Comments