Werewolf: Friends

Gertrude WW · 24-06-2019 12:18pm

Orla WW wrote: »

To clarify, the "first impressions" point made me think that it was a decision that had to be taken very early. The alternatives are (i) vig - still a goodie pre-munch kill which makes little sense unless they just wanted to be sure they made a shot, and (ii) eddie/barry which is a baddie pre-munch death which also makes no sense to me if they could wait until later to do so.

I've yet to look at post-munch postings but Phil and Katie were feeling wolfy to me from pre-munch postings. They were both throwing shade just before munch, and didn't seem worried that this might draw wolfy eyes onto them.

First impression does sound like some early decision goodies have to make but a kill? That doesn’t sound like an overly good power when they don’t know who each other are (presumably) and they are more likely to hit a goody.

So that leaves:

- Vig - can shoot anytime
- Eddie - unknown quantity
- mindy concert - but no conversion

Ockhams razor would make it the VIG. I’m not confirming that’s what it is but it’s interesting reading all the different theories.

Orla WW · 24-06-2019 12:19pm

Phil WW wrote: »

That's odd right?

I don't want to have a look at the player list cause meta is melting my head so I'd prefer to not know, but do we have a new player?

That's a wolf move or q new player

and a little bit toward vernon

I wish I could muti-quote.

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 12:19pm

Does anyone think it would be good to see who believes what theory?
This might prove useful when we know who what happened, but that seems like much work if not useful

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 12:20pm

Orla WW wrote: »

Here you go phil - that's a little bit of shade near isla....

that's not shade :cool:
But okay

Orla WW · 24-06-2019 12:22pm

Phil WW wrote: »

that's not shade :cool:
But okay

Well, you said you were suspect, and it was 09.22 so if isla was a wolf and you're village, you've just thrown some suspicion her way just before munch...

whereas if you're a wolf, you don't care when you post as you know you're not up for being a chew toy.

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 12:31pm

Orla WW wrote: »

Well, you said you were suspect, and it was 09.22 so if isla was a wolf and you're village, you've just thrown some suspicion her way just before munch...

whereas if you're a wolf, you don't care when you post as you know you're not up for being a chew toy.

I don't care either way. But okay.
That's a nice tip to remember for future play though

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 12:31pm

Orla WW wrote: »

Well, you said you were suspect, and it was 09.22 so if isla was a wolf and you're village, you've just thrown some suspicion her way just before munch...

whereas if you're a wolf, you don't care when you post as you know you're not up for being a chew toy.

Katei asked me my thoughts I answered. Simples

Gertrude WW · 24-06-2019 12:33pm

Phil WW wrote: »

I don't wear a watch? I didnt; realise the time

Holly WW · 24-06-2019 12:39pm

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Sorry I meant to write after Holly’s “bury the duck” post:

So holly feels FFAs are more important then working out this mornings events?

Like i said earlier in response to conor getting grumpy. I thought the dead were dead and we should move on with something that could help the village. I wasn't really reading through the post munch conversation trying to figure out what happened. Then I pegged it that someone got shot, and started trying to figure out what happened.

All of my musings are out in the open for people to see and read.

Not sure what your issue is with my duck post. Somebody said we haven't even buried the duck and I replied with bury the duck but then do some useful work.

Fair enough at the time i didn't realise that investigating what happened to wendy and babs would be useful, but I read over and started to understand why it was useful....

I'm not a wolf, though keep pointing at me so I can keep showing why you are wrong.

Angus WW · 24-06-2019 1:09pm

Afternoon all, awake, caught up and ready for duty

Thoughts on kills: Barbara had to be targeted by both wolves and SK right? I tried thinking was it possible SK stabbed Barbara and then laughed thus causing the confusion on what killed her but as someone else pointed out that post had flavour and the shot fired one didn’t which is normally how it goes?

That’s a pretty impressive way to go as the first killed so be proud Barbara!

I don’t think it was Chandler that fired the shot. Why would a villager shoot someone who hadn’t really offered anything compared to other high posters? Maybe my logic here is different but it’s not how I’d do it.

Possible that Mindy was found but would that mean a conversion would take place? We’d surely get an on thread announcement for that.

So I’m left thinking it could only be Eddie right? He’s going to cause chaos each day so it fits.

Sorry guys you all had this conversation earlier, I don’t want to drag it on all day but I’m playing catch up and just want to clarify my thinking

Desmond WW · 24-06-2019 1:13pm

Angus WW wrote: »

Afternoon all, awake, caught up and ready for duty

Thoughts on kills: Barbara had to be targeted by both wolves and SK right? I tried thinking was it possible SK stabbed Barbara and then laughed thus causing the confusion on what killed her but as someone else pointed out that post had flavour and the shot fired one didn’t which is normally how it goes?

That’s a pretty impressive way to go as the first killed so be proud Barbara!

I don’t think it was Chandler that fired the shot. Why would a villager shoot someone who hadn’t really offered anything compared to other high posters? Maybe my logic here is different but it’s not how I’d do it.

Possible that Mindy was found but would that mean a conversion would take place? We’d surely get an on thread announcement for that.

So I’m left thinking it could only be Eddie right? He’s going to cause chaos each day so it fits.

Sorry guys you all had this conversation earlier, I don’t want to drag it on all day but I’m playing catch up and just want to clarify my thinking

Holly WW · 24-06-2019 1:20pm

Angus WW wrote: »

Afternoon all, awake, caught up and ready for duty

Thoughts on kills: Barbara had to be targeted by both wolves and SK right? I tried thinking was it possible SK stabbed Barbara and then laughed thus causing the confusion on what killed her but as someone else pointed out that post had flavour and the shot fired one didn’t which is normally how it goes?

That’s a pretty impressive way to go as the first killed so be proud Barbara!

I don’t think it was Chandler that fired the shot. Why would a villager shoot someone who hadn’t really offered anything compared to other high posters? Maybe my logic here is different but it’s not how I’d do it.

Possible that Mindy was found but would that mean a conversion would take place? We’d surely get an on thread announcement for that.

So I’m left thinking it could only be Eddie right? He’s going to cause chaos each day so it fits.

Sorry guys you all had this conversation earlier, I don’t want to drag it on all day but I’m playing catch up and just want to clarify my thinking

Myself and Conor kinda went through this earlier. Eddie doesn't make sense on a symantics and balancing level, well for us anyway.

I don't see why Eddie's 'chaos causing' would be an extra kill. That completely overpowers the wolf team imo. Also, causing chaos as a term is very ambiguous. I can't see it specifically being an extra shot if that's how they've phrased it.

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 1:30pm

Holly WW wrote: »

Myself and Conor kinda went through this earlier. Eddie doesn't make sense on a symantics and balancing level, well for us anyway.

I don't see why Eddie's 'chaos causing' would be an extra kill. That completely overpowers the wolf team imo. Also, causing chaos as a term is very ambiguous. I can't see it specifically being an extra shot if that's how they've phrased it.

I think I've also explained it away as a day move rather than a night move. So agree not Eddie, therefore it's barry or chandler. I think Chandler

I tihnk Eddie coul d be given a kill though, I don't see why not.

Holly WW · 24-06-2019 1:36pm

Name | Status | Post Count
Abigail| Alive | 2
Angus| Alive | 4
Brendan | Alive | 3
Conor | Alive | 36
Derry| Alive | 5
Desmond| Alive | 13
Eva | Alive | 6
Ewan |Alive | 22
Fiona | Alive | 33
Gabriel | Alive | 28
Gertrude | Alive | 20
Henry | Alive | 27
Holly | Alive | 93
Isla | Alive | 80
Jake | Alive | 15
Katie | Alive |55
Liam | Alive | 0
Nigel| Alive |21
Orla| Alive | 12
Phil| Alive | 39
Steve | Alive | 7
Tegan | Alive | 11
Vernon | Alive |0
||
Wendy| Dead (SK & Wolves) |
Barbara | Dead (Shot) |

Katie WW · 24-06-2019 1:38pm

Ok I'm back.

Are we all on the same page now re: Babs likely being double munched? Or do I have to go through pages of the thread debunking silly theories.

Wendy's is more open to interpretation IMO. Orla's theory is certainly worth considering.

I don't believe it was Mindy/Barry. Two reasons:

No conversion announcement.

AND

It specifies here:
Barry Farber (Alpha Wolf) – Each day Barry has an opportunity to find Mindy. Should he be successful and find Mindy, he will convert Mindy to be his bride. Mindy has a gun and Barry has a shiny bullet.

Today is Day 1 so first guess would be my opinion.

Orla care to point out where I was shading anyone post munch or were you just lumping me in with Phil in a weird two-for-one type accusation?

Holly WW · 24-06-2019 1:39pm

Phil WW wrote: »

I think I've also explained it away as a day move rather than a night move. So agree not Eddie, therefore it's barry or chandler. I think Chandler

I tihnk Eddie coul d be given a kill though, I don't see why not.

Agree, a kill could be a part of it, but not the only thing.

Chandler is my best guess right now. And if it was you Mr. Bing. I would suggest waiting for a bit before firing again, just so we have a bit more info. Killing randomers at this stage is only helping the baddies.

That said, if you think you're onto something then by all means go ahead. Or if you think you're in danger of getting the chop, and you think you can help the village with a death.

Remember, statistically you're more likely to hit a goodie, and we need to keep as many of us alive for as long as possible. Lylo was reached really fast in the last game and we don't wanna fall into that trap if at all possible.

Vernon WW · 24-06-2019 1:40pm

hey guys

my phone is not connecting to boards in the office, so stealing in for 2 minutes on my lunch

Conor WW · 24-06-2019 1:42pm

Hey folks, I've been having.trouble accessing Boards since around 11 today. Not sure what is going on but it didn't *seem* to be me as I was able to access other websites. Hopefully it's all sorted now anyway.

Vernon WW · 24-06-2019 1:42pm

I've read next to nothing - hoping to get an hour at around half 5 for a decent catch up and some decent posting. any cliffnotes apart from wendy and babs death

Holly WW · 24-06-2019 1:42pm

Vernon WW wrote: »

hey guys

my phone is not connecting to boards in the office, so stealing in for 2 minutes on my lunch

Genie after my table?

Katie WW · 24-06-2019 1:43pm

Vernon WW wrote: »

I've read next to nothing - hoping to get an hour at around half 5 for a decent catch up and some decent posting. any cliffnotes apart from wendy and babs death

Why'd you thank Isla's post yesterday and not comment is my only question for ya really

Isla WW · 24-06-2019 1:43pm

Holly WW wrote: »

Very true, never realised, but that's actually such a powerful tool in the village's arsenal... If it can be pulled off. GG brarbrara

Not really sure I'd call it a tool in the village's arsenal, but a handy feature of what is likely a lack of backroom communication between the wolves and the SK.

Katie WW · 24-06-2019 1:44pm

Nigel WW wrote: »

This.

@Orla - are you claiming a first impression?

Btw I'm just getting through the posts since I left.

This one is weird.

Why are you actively fishing for roles Nidge?

Abigail WW · 24-06-2019 1:44pm

Boards being poxxxy for me ATM, can't get anything to load properly.

Vernon WW · 24-06-2019 1:44pm

Katie WW wrote: »

Why'd you thank Isla's post yesterday and not comment is my only question for ya really

I was doing a little light reading in the morning before I was consumed by Sunday as per usual. I can almost never post on Sundays

Vernon WW · 24-06-2019 1:45pm

Holly WW wrote: »

Genie after my table?

lunchtime coincidences

Isla WW · 24-06-2019 1:45pm

Holly WW wrote: »

Would Phoebe's skill have taken place last night too, or does it just come into play now?

I'd imagine they got an auld go of their skill last night.

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 1:45pm

Let's talk about the Orla theory which is the "first impressions"

this is listed at the bottom of the good roles which means it's a thing that is for the good roles only.

It doesn't sound very good, make a good impression or you die....
What did Wendy do that didn't leave a good impression? Did someone else mention her, not nes something she posted?

Phil WW · 24-06-2019 1:46pm

Vernon WW wrote: »

hey guys

my phone is not connecting to boards in the office, so stealing in for 2 minutes on my lunch

Did you do it?

Katie WW · 24-06-2019 1:46pm

Phil WW wrote: »

Let's talk about the Orla theory which is the "first impressions"

this is listed at the bottom of the good roles which means it's a thing that is for the good roles only.

It doesn't sound very good, make a good impression or you die....
What did Wendy do that didn't leave a good impression? Did someone else mention her, not nes something she posted?

Wendy was NRV

Werewolf: Friends

Comments