Werewolf: HBO's Deadwood

Gertrude WW · 16-04-2019 11:51pm

Who shot him?

Steve WW · 16-04-2019 11:54pm

Katie WW wrote: »

I know that everyone says the same in my position but I am actually an NRV.

My vote was cast for Ewan.

Claimed NRV, I actually missed this early when posted.

Katie WW wrote: »

Wolf.

Calls me a wolf right after Conors accusation, wolves working together?

Katie WW wrote: »

My thoughts:

Vernon is dodge. Hence my vote on him.
Gertie is odd, but jury is out.
Tegan calling Frank out on suspicious post- could be my paranoia but it feels staged.
Frank calling the village “they” instead of “us” was odd.

Other than that, nothing major.

Oh I think Conor is good. Hunch.

Literally everything about this post. Katie is next on my list, call it a hunch

Desmond WW · 17-04-2019 12:31am

Steve WW wrote: »

Claimed NRV, I actually missed this early when posted.

Calls me a wolf right after Conors accusation, wolves working together?

Literally everything about this post. Katie is next on my list, call it a hunch

Conor , Tegan and Katie... all low posters remaining under the radar!!! Hmmm. I remember a barrage of abuse when I originally suggested we try to get lower posters posting.

It’s funny cause I thought Katie and Tegan might be on the same team. I thought they were trying to push the lynch back onto Mary by using the first goldrush that Vernon messes up.

My would be to look closer at them both tomorrow.

Gertrude WW · 17-04-2019 12:36am

Who shot Conor?

Abigail WW · 17-04-2019 5:35am

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Who shot Conor?

The vig who would not want to put themselves on the thread.

Speaking of whom, great work with Conor who I think had to be a wolf due to being on the failed 1-5 GR list while the others around him were since cleared. No point letting him live longer and allowing him to muddy the waters.

As Steve says Katie now looks a bit dodgy especially for me due to her only good lean having been the only wolf we’ve caught. That said I’m more inclined to follow Brendan or Gertie for now and wait to see how much and goldrush change things

Wish Ewan had fought the lynch - if you’re s villager always fight

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 7:21am

Abigail WW wrote: »

The vig who would not want to put themselves on the thread.

Speaking of whom, great work with Conor who I think had to be a wolf due to being on the failed 1-5 GR list while the others around him were since cleared. No point letting him live longer and allowing him to muddy the waters.

As Steve says Katie now looks a bit dodgy especially for me due to her only good lean having been the only wolf we’ve caught. That said I’m more inclined to follow Brendan or Gertie for now and wait to see how much and goldrush change things

Wish Ewan had fought the lynch - if you’re s villager always fight

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Hearst and his wolves had Frank surrounded. The outcome was inevitable...

Frank WW is dead

He was
Seth Bullock - Sheriff of Deadwood

Not sure if your just a lazy villager paying zero attention or a lazy wolf!

Tegan WW · 17-04-2019 7:23am

Desmond WW wrote: »

Conor , Tegan and Katie... all low posters remaining under the radar!!! Hmmm. I remember a barrage of abuse when I originally suggested we try to get lower posters posting.

It’s funny cause I thought Katie and Tegan might be on the same team. I thought they were trying to push the lynch back onto Mary by using the first goldrush that Vernon messes up.

My would be to look closer at them both tomorrow.

This is nonsense. AFTER it had been suggested that IF Ewan was good then Conor was likely bad I went back to look at all the goldrush stuff and noticed tjat everyone had been ignoring the first one in which Mary had first vote and wolves won. Just cause we'd found one wolf doesn't mean we stop looking and I've seen villages lose by overlooking the obvious or ignoring things that happen on the first day.

Abigail WW · 17-04-2019 7:27am

Holly WW wrote: »

Not sure if your just a lazy villager paying zero attention or a lazy wolf!

I didn’t read the sheriff as the vig at all, I’m guessing Al and his trusty blade are.

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 7:37am

Two players didn't post during Goldrush. First posts after gold rush from both of them. Just pointing it out if we are working on a wolf being MIA yesterday. Either that or they doubled up on a wolf buddy in the top 3 along with two villagers

Tegan WW wrote: »

Well those events mean my top two suspects are now gone.

quote="Angus WW;109949425"]I’m not going to get to catch up on thread before the lynch tonight. Anyone care to fill me in on who was wolfie today

[/quote]

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 7:38am

Two players didn't post during Goldrush. First posts after gold rush from both of them. Just pointing it out if we are working on a wolf being MIA yesterday. Either that or they doubled up on a wolf buddy in the top 3 along with two villagers

Tegan WW wrote: »

Well those events mean my top two suspects are now gone.

Angus WW wrote: »

I’m not going to get to catch up on thread before the lynch tonight. Anyone care to fill me in on who was wolfie today

Feckin Quotes

Katie WW · 17-04-2019 7:44am

Steve WW wrote: »

Claimed NRV, I actually missed this early when posted.

Calls me a wolf right after Conors accusation, wolves working together?

Literally everything about this post. Katie is next on my list, call it a hunch

Your hunch is wrong unfortunately.

I am around for the gold rush if needed.

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 8:10am

WerewolfGM wrote: »

A shot has been fired.

Conor WW/George Hearst is dead.

Awesome!

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 8:17am

Morning all. Happier catching up this morning. Hearst gone seems to mean we’re using the GR mechanics correctly. Ballsy bastard Hearst though if the wolves took a risk on GR1 when he was in slot 5

For today’s GR, my take is we should again use it as a mechanism to clear villagers or tag groups of wolves for the seer to focus on. Prizes are good but cleared village core is better imho

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 8:21am

Mary WW wrote: »

Morning all. Happier catching up this morning. Hearst gone seems to mean we’re using the GR mechanics correctly. Ballsy bastard Hearst though if the wolves took a risk on GR1 when he was in slot 5

For today’s GR, my take is we should again use it as a mechanism to clear villagers or tag groups of wolves for the seer to focus on. Prizes are good but cleared village core is better imho

I'm on the opposite side to be honest, collect prizes and go from there! GR can be manipulated somewhat by wolves, I'd leave same top 3 and potentially switch 4 and 5 around throughout the day. With only 3 wolves left we are forcing them to stick or twist if one of the top 3 is a wolf while also clearing another villager each time.

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 8:43am

Holly WW wrote: »

I'm on the opposite side to be honest, collect prizes and go from there! GR can be manipulated somewhat by wolves, I'd leave same top 3 and potentially switch 4 and 5 around throughout the day. With only 3 wolves left we are forcing them to stick or twist if one of the top 3 is a wolf while also clearing another villager each time.

Well I do get where you’re coming from, but every cleared villager also gets us a prize so on balance we’re not actually that worse off prize wise either

Phil WW · 17-04-2019 8:50am

Katie WW wrote: »

Your hunch is wrong unfortunately.

I am around for the gold rush if needed.

We will see latter but I don’t feel it is a bad hunch.

Holly WW wrote: »

I'm on the opposite side to be honest, collect prizes and go from there! GR can be manipulated somewhat by wolves, I'd leave same top 3 and potentially switch 4 and 5 around throughout the day. With only 3 wolves left we are forcing them to stick or twist if one of the top 3 is a wolf while also clearing another villager each time.

Agreed.

I think we should lower the chances of wolves picking up bullets.if we have a stronger village core right now, any possible bonus powers should be kept in their hands.

Gertrude WW · 17-04-2019 9:00am

I still don't think Conor was the ring leader even though his character was. I thought it was Mary but she seems to helpful so we have to look to someone else who is intelligent, or else I'm giving Mary a pass and I shouldn't.

Maybe I was underestimating Conor, but I don't think I was. He was willing to risk himself at the start, to me that reaffirms ti as someone who was doing what they was told, rather than doing the telling.

Katie should 100% be the target next, by simple laws of deduction but if we can get the organizer, the rest should fall easily. The organizer is one of us, one who posts frequent enough that we've accepted them as safe. The question is who? If not Mary, who?

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 9:13am

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I still don't think Conor was the ring leader even though his character was. I thought it was Mary but she seems to helpful so we have to look to someone else who is intelligent, or else I'm giving Mary a pass and I shouldn't.

Maybe I was underestimating Conor, but I don't think I was. He was willing to risk himself at the start, to me that reaffirms ti as someone who was doing what they was told, rather than doing the telling.

Katie should 100% be the target next, by simple laws of deduction but if we can get the organizer, the rest should fall easily. The organizer is one of us, one who posts frequent enough that we've accepted them as safe. The question is who? If not Mary, who?

Looking at GR 3 and 4, and looking at how GR1 unfolded, I’d be thinking of des (sorry des). Would be saying seer peek (maybe two) rather than lynch tbh though

Gertrude WW · 17-04-2019 9:16am

Mary WW wrote: »

Looking at GR 3 and 4, and looking at how GR1 unfolded, I’d be thinking of des (sorry des). Would be saying seer peek (maybe two) rather than lynch tbh though

I'm not saying it is him but if it is he has been super clever for today. Get everyone to agree he is safe and then remove himself from today's discussion so he can't be seen to be influencing in the safe knowledge he won't be voted for.

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 9:16am

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I still don't think Conor was the ring leader even though his character was. I thought it was Mary but she seems to helpful so we have to look to someone else who is intelligent, or else I'm giving Mary a pass and I shouldn't.

Maybe I was underestimating Conor, but I don't think I was. He was willing to risk himself at the start, to me that reaffirms ti as someone who was doing what they was told, rather than doing the telling.

Katie should 100% be the target next, by simple laws of deduction but if we can get the organizer, the rest should fall easily. The organizer is one of us, one who posts frequent enough that we've accepted them as safe. The question is who? If not Mary, who?

(Boards doing something funny, apologies if double post)

Looking at how GR3 and GR4 played out yesterday and looking at how GR1 ran I’d be saying Des (sorry Des). Would probably wants. Deer peek (or two) rather than a lynch though

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 9:20am

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I'm not saying it is him but if it is he has been super clever for today. Get everyone to agree he is safe and then remove himself from today's discussion so he can't be seen to be influencing in the safe knowledge he won't be voted for.

I’m more interested in #4 winning twice yesterday. Looking at GR1 the wolves appear to have blocked 1,2,....etc. that was why I thought Conor was being ballsy and risking being caught. But another option is they take their place and then fill what they can after. That would mean if a wolf was assigned 5 there’s be a gap, at 4. And if a wolf fills it then 6 wins and they’re caught.

Just a theory I admit

Phil WW · 17-04-2019 9:25am

Mary WW wrote: »

(Boards doing something funny, apologies if double post)

Looking at how GR3 and GR4 played out yesterday and looking at how GR1 ran I’d be saying Des (sorry Des). Would probably wants. Deer peek (or two) rather than a lynch though

The issue there is, say...if the seer checked Des and he came back good, the chances of picking the one baddy who showed as good would have been quite low. Would the seer have risked a second peek, rather than going with the stats and trying someone else like Katie?

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 9:29am

Phil WW wrote: »

The issue there is, say...if the seer checked Des and he came back good, the chances of picking the one baddy who showed as good would have been quite low. Would the seer have risked a second peek, rather than going with the stats and trying someone else like Katie?

It’s a fair point, would he be worth peeking twice. I don’t know tbh, I’m really just putting a theory out there

Phil WW · 17-04-2019 9:29am

(BG, I hope you’re around....)

Brendan WW · 17-04-2019 9:30am

Great stuff with Conor gone last night. Saves us hoping for a prize to take him out or waiting all day to lynch him.

Depends on how we want to play this, but if we put me at 3 and Gertie at 4 or switch it about even then I don't think the wolves can cover the prizes.

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 9:30am

Mary WW wrote: »

I’m more interested in #4 winning twice yesterday. Looking at GR1 the wolves appear to have blocked 1,2,....etc. that was why I thought Conor was being ballsy and risking being caught. But another option is they take their place and then fill what they can after. That would mean if a wolf was assigned 5 there’s be a gap, at 4. And if a wolf fills it then 6 wins and they’re caught.

Just a theory I admit

There was 4 wolves yesterday,

They either blocked 1-3 on both occasions as someone was AWOL hoping for a Vern like mistake or one of the top 3 is a wolf and they doubled up in an effort to clear one of the top 3.

Today's gold rush will give us a bit of an idea on that tbh as they can't double up and block the first 3 following Conors bullet to the skull last night

Mary WW · 17-04-2019 9:31am

We also have only three wolves today. Does that give us a little more scope to control the GR?

Brendan WW · 17-04-2019 9:32am

Mary WW wrote: »

We also have only three wolves today. Does that give us a little more scope to control the GR?

Beat ya to it, Mary

Brendan WW wrote: »

Great stuff with Conor gone last night. Saves us hoping for a prize to take him out or waiting all day to lynch him.

Depends on how we want to play this, but if we put me at 3 and Gertie at 4 or switch it about even then I don't think the wolves can cover the prizes.

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 9:33am

Brendan WW wrote: »

Great stuff with Conor gone last night. Saves us hoping for a prize to take him out or waiting all day to lynch him.

Depends on how we want to play this, but if we put me at 3 and Gertie at 4 or switch it about even then I don't think the wolves can cover the prizes.

Leave top 3 the same, it'll confirm me or one of the others as villagers or it'll do the opposite and you've one wolf in three to pick from. Worst case scenario is the block first 3 and whoever is 4 gets the prize

Holly WW · 17-04-2019 9:34am

Also 4 needs to be Gertie or Brendan so we know for sure if we lose then it's a wolf in top 3

Werewolf: HBO's Deadwood

Comments