The Weird, Wacky and Awesome World of the NFL - General Banter thread V3

Foxtrol · 31-12-2018 05:47PM

eagle eye wrote: »

As soon as I read that I immediately thought of Lincoln Riley.
I have no idea he would be interested but the job he has done with the offense in Oklahoma is insane.

He is definitely one of those names that I was thinking of. Oklahoma are a great watch but I'd fear what Alabama did to them in shutting them down, until they took their foot somewhat off the gas, would be repeated on a weekly basis in the NFL. Translating an offensive scheme from college into the NFL is a complete gamble. Even if he was reasonably successful in doing it with a team that is likely in poor shape, he'd need to surround himself by experienced and respected coaches, like McVay was with Wade, and I'm not sure if he can get that type of support.

Another coach I'd have concerns with is Bieniemy. I think he might fit the mold of being a good HC coach but I don't think a team is going to get some sort of offensive genius that they're expecting. I don't see much improvement in the scheme this year from what Reid/Nagy had previously, with the big difference being Mahomes

One that fitted the bill was DeFilippo, he was popping up a few weeks ago for the likes of the GB job and probably still would be if he wasn't fired by the Vikings.

jack presley · 31-12-2018 05:49PM

A tad harsh don't you think?

https://twitter.com/BoomBoomSKOL/status/1079526575132106752

Oat23 · 31-12-2018 06:07PM

jack presley wrote: »

A tad harsh don't you think?

https://twitter.com/BoomBoomSKOL/status/1079526575132106752

The personal attack, of course. Calling him an awful waste of $84m isn't.

Never seen a QB so good at padding stats as Kirk Cousins is. He's the king of garbage time. He's not a winner. Not a big game QB. He throws bad picks at crucial times, but focus on his stats only and what do you see? 4300 yards, 30TDs and only 10 INTs. He looks solid on paper but has never passed the eye test.

It's not all on him of course. Their o-line hasn't been playing well. They'll never win with Kirk though.

j8wk2feszrnpao · 31-12-2018 06:09PM

jack presley wrote: »

A tad harsh don't you think?

https://twitter.com/BoomBoomSKOL/status/1079526575132106752

Very harsh, seems like a childish account. Cousins didn't give himself the contract.

jack presley · 31-12-2018 06:13PM

Oat23 wrote: »

The personal attack, of course. Calling him an awful waste of $84m isn't.

Never seen a QB so good at padding stats as Kirk Cousins is. He's the king of garbage time. He's not a winner. Not a big game QB. He throws bad picks at crucial times, but focus on his stats only and what do you see? 4300 yards, 30TDs and only 10 INTs. He looks solid on paper but has never passed the eye test.

It's not all on him of course. Their o-line hasn't been playing well. They'll never win with Kirk though.

Totally agree. I'm a Redskins fan and probably saw 90% of his starts. Very frustrating QB. You'd look at his stats and see that he threw for a million yards but if you watched the game you'd see that most of the yards came from his own 20 to the opponents 20 and then the drives end with nothing or a FG.

I bet the Jets are glad he chose Minnesota over their greater offer.

Foxtrol · 31-12-2018 06:17PM

Oat23 wrote: »

The personal attack, of course. Calling him an awful waste of $84m isn't.

Never seen a QB so good at padding stats as Kirk Cousins is. He's the king of garbage time. He's not a winner. Not a big game QB. He throws bad picks at crucial times, but focus on his stats only and what do you see? 4300 yards, 30TDs and only 10 INTs. He looks solid on paper but has never passed the eye test.

It's not all on him of course. Their o-line hasn't been playing well. They'll never win with Kirk though.

I don't think he is in a top tier of QBs but he was severely hampered this year by the OL issues you mention but also by how terrible DeFilippo ran the offense.

It is hard enough to hit the ground running with a new team as a QB but much harder when the OC is new and is a complete spoofer, who got the job on the back of what others did with the Eagles offense.

If the Vikings get a decent OC I expect a lot of improvement next year from him.

Oat23 · 31-12-2018 06:32PM

https://twitter.com/RapSheet/status/1079805158115155969

If Fangio gets a HC job a lot of journalists think Todd Bowles will be a leading candidate to replace him as he & Nagy have known each other since before they got to the NFL, plus they worked together in the league in Philly.

madalig12 · 31-12-2018 10:45PM

Wile feeling the Colts will win it all this year.

kmart6 · 31-12-2018 10:49PM

madalig12 wrote: »

Wile feeling the Colts will win it all this year.

Colts fan and don't see it.

billr67 · 01-01-2019 12:01PM

Jolly Red Giant wrote: »

Broncos request permission to interview Patriots’ DC Brian Flores and Steelers’ OL coach Mike Munchak

Great the Steelers only decent coach. Nobody want Keith Butler?.....anybody?.... Guys?.....

Christy42 · 01-01-2019 12:22PM

Foxtrol wrote: »

Oat23 wrote: »

The personal attack, of course. Calling him an awful waste of $84m isn't.

Never seen a QB so good at padding stats as Kirk Cousins is. He's the king of garbage time. He's not a winner. Not a big game QB. He throws bad picks at crucial times, but focus on his stats only and what do you see? 4300 yards, 30TDs and only 10 INTs. He looks solid on paper but has never passed the eye test.

It's not all on him of course. Their o-line hasn't been playing well. They'll never win with Kirk though.

I don't think he is in a top tier of QBs but he was severely hampered this year by the OL issues you mention but also by how terrible DeFilippo ran the offense.

It is hard enough to hit the ground running with a new team as a QB but much harder when the OC is new and is a complete spoofer, who got the job on the back of what others did with the Eagles offense.

If the Vikings get a decent OC I expect a lot of improvement next year from him.

He is above average which puts him in a very small bracket of players but definitely not top tier.

I think had they Cousins last season they would have won it all. I think had the rest of the team been as good as last year they would favourites now. That is why they took the shot on Cousins.

Course now getting a team playing that well with that contract is going to be difficult.

Billy86 · 01-01-2019 01:02PM

Cousins is like Romo, lacks the additional killer instinct of Rodgers, Brady, brees, or even of Ben or Philip Rivers but that doesn't mean he's not a very, very good qb that could take the right team to the SB (and not as a game manager) . Hopefully he doesn't get made into a convenient scapegoat like cowboys fans pathetically did to Romo through his career, though I did expect a bit more from him this season.

AbusesToilets · 01-01-2019 02:58PM

Billy86 wrote: »

Cousins is like Romo, lacks the additional killer instinct of Rodgers, Brady, brees, or even of Ben or Philip Rivers but that doesn't mean he's not a very, very good qb that could take the right team to the SB (and not as a game manager) . Hopefully he doesn't get made into a convenient scapegoat like cowboys fans pathetically did to Romo through his career, though I did expect a bit more from him this season.

That's wildly ungenerous to Romo, he's legit HOF talent, without the post season success. I'd have him on the same level as Rivers. Cowboys ****ed up starting Dak over him, wasted their best shot in decades.

eagle eye · 01-01-2019 03:42PM

AbusesToilets wrote:

That's wildly ungenerous to Romo, he's legit HOF talent, without the post season success. I'd have him on the same level as Rivers. Cowboys ****ed up starting Dak over him, wasted their best shot in decades.

Romo had a much shorter career than Rivers. That assessment is very unfair to Phillip Rivers imo.

j8wk2feszrnpao · 01-01-2019 06:37PM

AbusesToilets wrote: »

That's wildly ungenerous to Romo, he's legit HOF talent, without the post season success. I'd have him on the same level as Rivers. Cowboys ****ed up starting Dak over him, wasted their best shot in decades.

I wouldn't be that high on Romo, and it was time for Dallas (and Romo with his injuries) to move on.
I do agree on Rivers. Thought he was going to be something special at the start of his career, but he's done nothing of note in the playoffs since. Both achieved in the regular season, but failure in the playoffs would rules them out of the HOF for me, esp given the QBs in the span of their own careers.

AbusesToilets · 01-01-2019 07:13PM

I'd have them both ahead of Eli and Roethlisburger, who have the rings. Both were hampered by poor teams and circumstances imo.

Knex* · 01-01-2019 07:15PM

Paully D wrote: »

Thank **** we’ll no longer have to listen to Mayock spoiling draft picks any more, although I will miss his pre-draft coverage.

Always thought that was a bit overstated tbh. I'll miss him, one of the best draft analysts out there, if not the best.

D9Male · 01-01-2019 07:25PM

eagle eye wrote: »

Just on the Jags thing with Fournette. Imo the guy is really good and the big problems is Bortles. If you had a QB who could throw the ball there would be space for Fournette to do his thing.
So you void Fournette's guarantees over a suspension but you gave Bortles a new contract at the start of the season. What on Earth is going on in Jacksonville? I know which one of those two I'd like to keep and it ain't Blake Bortles.

I couldn't disagree more on Fournette. He was a good serviceable back in his rookie season, but his value is as a volume guy.

He averaged 3.3 yards per carry in 2018, compared to YPC of 3.9 for other running backs (excluding QB's for fairness).

He was better in 2017, with 3.9 ypc, but Yeldon and Ivory (combined) had a slightly better average.

His touchdowns were valuable, but 9 in the regular season is not much more than a total of 7 across other backs from way fewer carries.

His PFF grade is above average to good both seasons, just above replacement level, and he doesn't break many tackles.

Look at the other backs selected in 2017:

Christian McCaffrey
Dalvin Cook
Joe Mixon
Alvin Kamara
Kareem Hunt

were the next 5 selected running backs.

The next two defensive players selected in 2017 draft we're Jamal Adams and Marshon Lattimore. The next two QB's were Mahomes and Watson.

I think it's crazy picking an RB that high. But if you're going to do it, you need to do A LOT better.

Big Pussy Bonpensiero · 01-01-2019 07:27PM

Apparently Antonio Brown has requested a trade. Supposedly has problems with Tomlin and Ben.
What an absolute shıtshow the Steelers are atm. Easily one of the best teams in recent memory not to make the playoffs.

Itssoeasy · 01-01-2019 07:28PM

It appears that the NFL gave a directive of sorts about not calling black Monday which is what the day after the final week of the regular season has become known as. It's meant to be new horizons Monday now. I mean Jesus Christ will everything be renamed so as not to offend people ?

adrian522 · 01-01-2019 07:41PM

So, who's creating the New Horizons Monday thread?

D9Male · 01-01-2019 08:11PM

Itssoeasy wrote: »

It appears that the NFL gave a directive of sorts about not calling black Monday which is what the day after the final week of the regular season has become known as. It's meant to be new horizons Monday now. I mean Jesus Christ will everything be renamed so as not to offend people ?

That was just a joke on the Around the NFL podcast, surely? I haven't seen that term elsewhere.

Itssoeasy · 01-01-2019 08:36PM

D9Male wrote: »

That was just a joke on the Around the NFL podcast, surely? I haven't seen that term elsewhere.

Well it didn't seem like a joke but the fact you wouldn't put it past them lot to actually change it.

D9Male · 01-01-2019 09:40PM

It seemed like a joke to me. Calling a day New Horizon Monday is clearly a mickey take.

j8wk2feszrnpao · 01-01-2019 11:25PM

AbusesToilets wrote: »

I'd have them both ahead of Eli and Roethlisburger, who have the rings. Both were hampered by poor teams and circumstances imo.

It’s not just the rings (which does help), but Eli steeped up twice in the playoffs when required. Ben in particular has reached and successed in the playoffs quite often. Not facets that you could apply to Rivers and Romo.
I’ve seen both play really well, and then lose their cool and the game in the big moments; even with good/decent teams. Rivers certainly has his chance this year.

eagle eye · 02-01-2019 12:35AM

Phillip Rivers just turned 37 and doesn't look like he is slowing down yet. There is every chance he ends up top five all time in passing yards. He will likely be top five in passing touchdowns also.
He is a certain future Hall of Fame member.

eagle eye · 02-01-2019 12:43AM

D9Male wrote:

I think it's crazy picking an RB that high. But if you're going to do it, you need to do A LOT better.

I'm not disagreeing about pick up ng a RB that high.
I'm saying that you don't know what you've got unless you have a decent QB. Like every D is stacking the box against the Jags because Bortles is so bad.
Fournette is hard to stop when he gets going so until he ends up in a situation where you can get him a little space you have no idea how good/bad he is.

D9Male · 02-01-2019 07:51AM

Yeah, that makes sense, I guess. There's a reasonable book on him now, albeit I agree he would be better with a better QB.

Knex* · 02-01-2019 11:14AM

This is a bit mad

https://twitter.com/FO_ScottKacsmar/status/1079913681004257285

D9Male · 02-01-2019 03:47PM

That is crazy. I would say if you gave me 200 guesses to name the 5 QB's in that list, I wouldn't have gotten it.

The Weird, Wacky and Awesome World of the NFL - General Banter thread V3

Comments