Mayo GAA Discussion - Part 3

EICVD · 21-09-2017 11:25AM

blinding wrote: »

Hopefully Alan Costello won’t be playing but you never know what kind of stunt the Dubs would pull:D:eek:

Alan? Is he Cormacs older or younger brother?.....

Oldtree · 21-09-2017 11:32AM

BENDYBINN wrote: »

Common sense!
Is there a rule that says no buses can be parked in large parallelogram?
Sweet mother of god!

What have buses to do with rules on the field of play?

So that's 3 of ye that don't know the rules. Any more with nonsence to spout?

The Talking Bread · 21-09-2017 11:35AM

BENDYBINN wrote: »

Oldtree wrote: »

What rule are You referring to?

Common sense!
Is there a rule that says no buses can be parked in large parallelogram?
d!

Many a team has parked the bus on Croke Park pitch the last decade in fairness

21-09-2017 11:39AM

djPSB wrote: »

Have Mayo much of a chance?

If Cora Staunton is on form, I'll always give them a chance!

blinding · 21-09-2017 11:41AM

EICVD wrote: »

Alan? Is he Cormacs older or younger brother?.....

Cormac would be too obvious somebody would notice...

Alan has a more feminine side ..

My bad, sorry .

djPSB · 21-09-2017 11:43AM

Shurimgreat wrote: »

If a player can steal and throw away the opposing goalkeepers tees, what's to stop one of the coaching staff doing the same when delivering instructions to their own players. Where does the stealing of tees stop?

I hope the GAA make an example of Costello. On a par with the Keegan incident imo. Sportsmanship like this should have no part in the game. The GAA need to send out a strong message.

This is all very childish. Both were wrong. Trying to claim moral victories over who was 'wronger' is silly.

Two wrongs don't make a right. Punish both and move on.

djPSB · 21-09-2017 11:44AM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

If Cora Staunton is on form, I'll always give them a chance!

That's what I thought.

3/1 on Mayo seems generous.

Hammer Archer · 21-09-2017 11:46AM

BENDYBINN wrote: »

Common sense!
Is there a rule that says no buses can be parked in large parallelogram?
Sweet mother of god!

That's a pretty ridiculous analogy to be fair.
Just admit Costello was trying to slow the kickout down. Was it unsportsmanlike? Yes. Was what Keegan did unsportsmanlike? Yes. Most Mayo fans will admit that I feel. Is either issue a big deal? No.
You'd swear Keegan threw a severed head at Rock the way some Dublin "pundits" and posters are going on.

blinding · 21-09-2017 11:53AM

He might even have missed it had Keegan not thrown the GPS.....

Keegan may have inadvertently corrected some terrible miscalculation that Rock was about to make.....

Keegan’s GPS may have won the All-Ireland for Dublin .

MayoAreMagic · 21-09-2017 11:53AM

djPSB wrote: »

This is all very childish. Both were wrong. Trying to claim moral victories over who was 'wronger' is silly.

Two wrongs don't make a right. Punish both and move on.

Agreed.
Personally, I think the EOG thing is worse than both. If a player bumped into him while he had his finger in boyles eye he could have done permanent damage.

Shurimgreat · 21-09-2017 11:54AM

djPSB wrote: »

This is all very childish. Both were wrong. Trying to claim moral victories over who was 'wronger' is silly.

Two wrongs don't make a right. Punish both and move on.

Laughable!

Dubliners all over the media and on here all week saying Keegan should be harshly punished.
When the Costello incident is pointed out, suddenly they back track and say both should be treated lightly, its childish to say one was worse than the other, etc etc.

At least people are backing off on Keegan now which is good to see.

Yes its time to move on, I've argued that already. Let the CCCC deal with both players. Both were on an equal footing in my book.

Bonniedog · 21-09-2017 02:05PM

Poor Lee. There is an old expression "Don't throw other peoples' snowballs."

And if are going to be hard man, maybe not cry like a little girl at the end of it all.

irishgeo · 21-09-2017 02:13PM

Why didn't mayo get a free for the kilkenny black card. Surely they were fouling the players.

Secondly where was the extra man for mayo after Dublin got the black card.

Ballstein · 21-09-2017 02:26PM

Bonniedog wrote: »

Poor Lee. There is an old expression "Don't throw other peoples' snowballs."

And if are going to be hard man, maybe not cry like a little girl at the end of it all.

Man, I've seen it all now. One of the best games of modern times, played by two of the best teams and some keyboard warrior slags a player cause he cried after losing his 4th All Ireland.
Your beyond contempt. Is winning 3 in a row not enough for you that you've to sink to that? You wouldn't lace the 3rd eyelet of his left boot and I don't care who you are behind the keyboard, because I know that 100% true. Your a horrible, nasty person.

ArielAtom · 21-09-2017 02:52PM

km79 wrote: »

PARlance wrote: »

Brady wants all 3 of our FF line to get yellows for kicking the ball away as Cluxton is about to kick it out...

I've been thinking about this a bit
We should do what cork did to us
Have someone throw an extra ball on
Will get away with it for the first few minutes

And then if we are winning coming due the stretch do EVERYTHING we need to
Kick balls of the tee
Kick balls into the stand to prevent quick frees

Obviously not if there is only a point in it and free is brought into kicking range
But in there half slow it all down
Rick
Pull
Foul

Too nice for too long

Kilkenny/Costelloe must have been reading this thread!!!!

Donal55 · 21-09-2017 02:57PM

MayoAreMagic wrote: »

Agreed.
Personally, I think the EOG thing is worse than both. If a player bumped into him while he had his finger in boyles eye he could have done permanent damage.

Was it not Boyle's gob he had his fingers in?

Billy Mays · 21-09-2017 03:12PM

Donal55 wrote: »

Was it not Boyle's gob he had his fingers in?

It was but some people have decided to go with the eye gouge angle instead.

Not condoning O'Gara sticking his finger in Boyle's mouth by the way.

Audioslaven · 21-09-2017 03:16PM

Bonniedog wrote: »

Poor Lee. There is an old expression "Don't throw other peoples' snowballs."

And if are going to be hard man, maybe not cry like a little girl at the end of it all.

This is passion and Keegan has everything (skill, drive, commitment, power, pace, team player, leadership etc) in abundance.. clearly you know nothing about any of this!!

The Talking Bread · 21-09-2017 03:20PM

Anyway, on a more positive note, apparently Kim Jong Un went to a Mayo gaeltacht in his early years and since then has informed his people every September that Mayo have won every single All Ireland since by 50 points.

PARlance · 21-09-2017 03:53PM

Bonniedog wrote: »

Poor Lee. There is an old expression "Don't throw other peoples' snowballs."

And if are going to be hard man, maybe not cry like a little girl at the end of it all.

You could wash that bulls1t down with some yellow snow. Were you the hard man calling him names?

seligehgit · 21-09-2017 05:00PM

Poor Lee. There is an old expression "Don't throw other peoples' snowballs."

And if are going to be hard man, maybe not cry like a little girl at the end of it all.
Man, I've seen it all now. One of the best games of modern times, played by two of the best teams and some keyboard warrior slags a player cause he cried after losing his 4th All Ireland.
Your beyond contempt. Is winning 3 in a row not enough for you that you've to sink to that? You wouldn't lace the 3rd eyelet of his left boot and I don't care who you are behind the keyboard, because I know that 100% true. Your a horrible, nasty person.

Poor form Bonnie,I have always considered you a very reasoned poster.

thesultan · 21-09-2017 05:21PM

Of the mayo subs how many would start next year? Have one orvtwo experienced on the bench?

boosabum · 21-09-2017 05:30PM

For 2018, retirement permitting, Andy, Boyler & SOS should be guys who start on the bench and provide the impetus that's needed to close out a game.
The AI to my mind was lost because the squad depth wasn't reinforced through the year and that's a real concern. Nally, Boland & Regan to mention a few must not have made the improvement required to push for starting places. These guys as well as the other extended squad members should be afforded as much game time in 2018 to see if they have what it takes.

PARlance · 21-09-2017 05:40PM

thesultan wrote: »

Of the mayo subs how many would start next year? Have one orvtwo experienced on the bench?

You could have a similar team next year with

Diarmuid on, Boyle impact
Coen on, Seamie or Vaughan impact
Loftus on, Andy impact.

I would be comfortable enough with the first two but Loftus would need to step up a fair bit.

Westernyelp · 21-09-2017 07:22PM

This place really goes to Sh!t this time of year....

charlie14 · 21-09-2017 07:45PM

PARlance wrote: »

You could have a similar team next year with

Diarmuid on, Boyle impact
Coen on, Seamie or Vaughan impact
Loftus on, Andy impact.

I would be comfortable enough with the first two but Loftus would need to step up a fair bit.

Colm Boyle has been playing inter-county now for the guts of 10 years faik, and while for whatever reason wasn`t deemed by management fit to play more than 55 mins in any game this years.
When on the pitch I thought him one of Mayo`s most consistent performers with Mayo`s preformances often dipping when he was called ashore.
Along with what he brings to Mayo going forward, he is a teak tough centre back who tackles hard without conceding frees.
I just do not see Diarmuid O Connor having what is needed for centre back.
If it was me, I would be more inclined to sort whatever problems Boyle may have, give him plenty of rest, and have him at his best for the championship

Stoner · 21-09-2017 08:56PM

boosabum wrote:

For 2018, retirement permitting, Andy, Boyler & SOS should be guys who start on the bench and provide the impetus that's needed to close out a game. .

Andy has to start surely, player of the year aside this year must have confirmed that he is a starter not a sub and that he is definitely Mayo's best forward.

Martina1991 · 21-09-2017 09:35PM

charlie14 wrote:

Colm Boyle has been playing inter-county now for the guts of 10 years faik, and while for whatever reason wasn`t deemed by management fit to play more than 55 mins in any game this years.

I just do not see Diarmuid O Connor having what is needed for centre back. If it was me, I would be more inclined to sort whatever problems Boyle may have, give him plenty of rest, and have him at his best for the championship

Boyle couldn't finish games due to health issues. I doubt he or management could have helped that.

O Connor is a forward. Coen is more likely to fill in at half back in the next few years.

charlie14 · 21-09-2017 09:44PM

Martina1991 wrote: »

Boyle couldn't finish games due to health issues. I doubt he or management could have helped that.

O Connor is a forward. Coen is more likely to fill in at half back in the next few years.

It appeared obvious that Boyle had health problems this year, but if I was Mayo management I would make every effort possible to sort them prior to next years championship.
As I said earlier, I just cannot see O Connor filling the centre-back position with anything like the same authority that Boyle brings.

PARlance · 21-09-2017 09:48PM

charlie14 wrote: »

Colm Boyle has been playing inter-county now for the guts of 10 years faik, and while for whatever reason wasn`t deemed by management fit to play more than 55 mins in any game this years.
When on the pitch I thought him one of Mayo`s most consistent performers with Mayo`s preformances often dipping when he was called ashore.
Along with what he brings to Mayo going forward, he is a teak tough centre back who tackles hard without conceding frees.
I just do not see Diarmuid O Connor having what is needed for centre back.
If it was me, I would be more inclined to sort whatever problems Boyle may have, give him plenty of rest, and have him at his best for the championship

We broke away from our norm and played 7 defenders (Durcan coming in for DO'C) against Dublin. So that switch of Boyle to DO'C sees DO'C as wing forward not CB.

He was one of our best performers this year but I think we'll have to have faith in the management when they say he can only do X km..minutes... It's on medical device afaik.

The reality is that if he's struggling this year, and at his age, he probably won't bounce back next year. It's likely he'll could deteriorate. I would save him and get another year or two out of him as an impact sub if that was the case.

(I'm not calling for him to be dropped btw. A question was asked: who from the bench could start next year and who might they replace)

Mayo GAA Discussion - Part 3

Comments