Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
If we do not hit our goal we will be forced to close the site.

Current status: https://keepboardsalive.com/

Annual subs are best for most impact. If you are still undecided on going Ad Free - you can also donate using the Paypal Donate option. All contribution helps. Thank you.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

"Significant" numbers of babies remains actually found

1272830323364

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,456 ✭✭✭The high horse brigade


    Mr.Wemmick wrote: »
    smurgen wrote: »
    I genuinely thing the church is a law unto itself in the country and the operate in a parralel society.take for example the refusal of some or the religious orders to contribute toward compensation for abuse victims. The state should seize the assets of these organisation until they pay the compensation due by them to survivors if their abuse.http://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/editorial/shortfall-in-contribution-to-compensation-scheme-damages-catholic-church-s-authority-1.2813775


    Amazing at how powerful they are that they can evade the law to this extent. Astonishing, nothing short of an unelected corporate powerhouse pulling the strings in front of the state's nose and can do and say whatever they please - sickening to the extreme..

    It seems to me, the laws of the land need urgent reform to function correctly to make them accountable, allowing no wriggle room otherwise there will be no justice for the victims of these horrors.

    You would need to start by removing the traditional Dail prayer and re writing the constitution.


  • Posts: 5,094 ✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    kbannon wrote: »
    We were told by the nuns that the relevant documentation was given over.
    Given the reluctance of the RCC to hand over anything willingly, I would doubt that it was *all* of the documentation.
    Do we really believe that complete details of all infant deaths and adoptions was given to the county council?

    Reminded me of Brian Ó Nualláin's famous limerick following the deaths of 35 children and 1 adult in an orphanage run by nuns in Cavan in February 1943:

    "In Cavan there was a great fire,
    Judge McCarthy was sent to inquire,
    It would be a shame, if the nuns were to blame,
    So it had to be caused by a wire."


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,183 ✭✭✭✭Grayson


    smurgen wrote: »
    I genuinely thing the church is a law unto itself in the country and the operate in a parralel society.take for example the refusal of some or the religious orders to contribute toward compensation for abuse victims. The state should seize the assets of these organisation until they pay the compensation due by them to survivors if their abuse.http://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/editorial/shortfall-in-contribution-to-compensation-scheme-damages-catholic-church-s-authority-1.2813775


    This is just a snippet from a far longer article. It's really interesting and I'd advise everyone to read it.
    http://www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/the-baby-black-market-1.1847804
    There were both legal and illegal adoptions. During the 1950s up to 15 per cent of all illegitimate Irish children born in mother-and-baby homes each year were taken to the United States with the full knowledge of the State. In total more than 2,000 illegitimate children were removed from the country in this way. Most were adopted by wealthy American Catholics.
    But it seems that hundreds, if not thousands, more children were taken from the country without sanction or public record-keeping. Many were handed to foreigners. On October 8th, 1951, The Irish Times reported that in the previous year “almost 500 babies were flown from Shannon for adoption”, a number that the paper said “is believed to have been exceeded” during the first nine months of 1951. In the first week of October alone, it reported, 18 “parties” of children departed from the airport.
    These figures far exceed the number of official “adoption passports” issued to let adoptive parents take children out of Ireland. In the whole of 1951 only 122 such passports were issued, a fraction of the number of children actually taken from the State.
    Some children were handed over to men travelling alone, as when a US businessman left, after a brief visit to Ireland in 1949, with two toddlers from the Braemar home in Cork. The New York Times called it “a surprise for the wife”. The same year a US airman was given two children to take home by the Sacred Heart nuns at Manor House mother-and-baby home, in Castlepollard. This was reported in three US newspapers.
    On February 2nd, 1955, one American newspaper, the New Haven Register, carried a startling story under the headline “50 American couples buy Irish babies through international adoption ring”. Claiming a senior garda as its source, the article said the Americans paid between $600 and $2,000 per child. The children had reportedly come from private nursing homes around Ireland, including five in Dublin.

    “Could not truthfully be refuted”
    When the Department of External Affairs asked the special detective unit to comment on the article, the only claim it disputed was that the paper’s source was a garda.

    Higher up the legal pecking order, the secretary of the Department of Justice, Peter Berry, advised that the story “could not truthfully be refuted” because there was “some basis for the allegation in question”.
    Three years earlier a German newspaper, 8 Uhr Blatt, had carried a somewhat similar exposé headlined “1,000 children disappear from Ireland”. Many of the children, it was suspected, were destined to be sold on the United States’ thriving baby “black market”, where the going price was $3,000 a child, according to the newspaper. On this occasion the Irish chargé d’affaires in Bonn, Aedan O’Beirne, wanted to insist that the paper “publish a rebuttal of the story”, but his superiors in Dublin noted that “no action is required, especially as the article is largely correct”.
    With the authorities determined to keep the scandal under wraps, the traffickers were pursued without vigour, and the children, whose welfare seemed of little concern to the State, were abandoned to their fate.
    The scandal continued into the 1960s when a Garda investigation into another illegal adoption racket – one police believed was run by a prominent Irishman – led to the prosecution of a Dublin midwife, Mary Keating, who had also been involved in the 1950s venture. Keating was interviewed as part of a special-branch operation in the 1950s, along with birth mothers. At that time, special branch also communicated with adoptive parents in the US.
    Keating owned St Rita’s nursing home in Ranelagh, and in 1965 she was put on probation for falsifying a birth record. But behind this seemingly technical charge lay an enterprise involving private nursing homes that ran a sideline business providing “illegitimate” babies, born in their homes, to people who, for whatever reason, couldn’t or didn’t want to adopt legally. Their modus operandi was simple. Instead of registering the baby in the name of its unmarried mother, as the law required, they registered it in the name of the couple to whom the baby was given, a serious criminal offence.
    The falsification process is outlined in a letter from St Rita’s to a prospective adoptive parent in the US. It is also logged in detail in the Irish special-branch report. The New Haven Register article from 1955 describes the situation for US military personnel, who accounted for many of the adoptions. “To adopt a baby the American soldier and his wife would travel to Dublin, where the wife checked in to the nursing home as an expectant mother. An Irish woman would actually bear the child, but the birth would be registered in the name of the American.”


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators, Paid Member Posts: 28,640 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    weekday wrote: »
    forgive us our trespasses

    as we forgive those who trepass against us

    None of the people involved in causing abuse, sex abuse cover ups, selling babes, the awful treatment of these women and baby's or dumping body's into a septic tank should be forgiven.

    It's evident they had no empathy, so why have empathy for them?

    If the are dead then lets hope they rot in the hell they believe in, if they are alive they should be brought to justice.


  • Moderators, Politics Moderators, Paid Member Posts: 44,420 Mod ✭✭✭✭Seth Brundle


    Is Frankie's visit next year confirmed?
    We could have a really big mass for the kids then.

    Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/ .



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,705 ✭✭✭Mountainsandh


    Where did Catherine Corless get the death certificates from?

    Tuam and Ireland's shame: unedited interview with Catherin Corless
    It's half an hour long, but interesting. She describes how it all came about. What a simply great woman.

    She explains how she was looking for burial records, but had to go look for death certificates instead.

    https://youtu.be/Jw4UKfZqTzw


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 268 ✭✭Cdosrun


    If anyone gets they're files from these places they are redacted loads.
    Lots went missing for some reason.
    I was shown some of mine when I was young but when I got it in later years half was missing.
    No medical details at all.
    I broke my arm one day at about 2.30pm but was taken to the hospital that evening when the minibus was going that way anyway.
    No mention of anything like that as it might be checked with the hospital.
    The church will probably have better legal advice than the state or anyone else.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 346 ✭✭weirdspider


    Feeling ashamed to even be part of this country anymore. I know it's in the past but how did the RCC ever have such an influence on our people and how did such corruption go unquestioned?
    The more I think about this the more disturbing it all seems.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 724 ✭✭✭Hagar7


    ....... wrote: »
    This post has been deleted.
    Sadly,we will never know.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,705 ✭✭✭Mountainsandh


    Donal55 wrote: »
    Bol1x. They knew exactly what they were doing.
    Scum.

    That's the thing.
    In the case of Nazis for example, it can be claimed that a certain number may not have known of what went on.
    In this instance, it seems obvious that all nuns involved in the home knew.
    (I see the discussion veered to local people, I'm just talking about the nuns here)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,808 ✭✭✭✭Mrs OBumble


    gctest50 wrote: »
    Instead, how about ordering the timber to make crosses and nail every nun and every priest up

    Very cute.

    But its a representative of every family who put a woman in an institution, and every guard and judge and doctor and county council official who should be joining them.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,221 ✭✭✭A_Sober_Paddy


    How are the RCC tolerated in this country, this organisation has done more harm than Hitler and his Nazi party. And they are still destroying peoples life's in Ireland, Africa and the Philippines


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,473 ✭✭✭✭Esel
    Not Your Ornery Onager


    Feeling ashamed to even be part of this country anymore. I know it's in the past but how did the RCC ever have such an influence on our people and how did such corruption go unquestioned?
    The more I think about this the more disturbing it all seems.

    They had almost 2,000 years to get their act together.

    Not your ornery onager



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,188 ✭✭✭wil


    chasm wrote: »
    I wasn't arguing with you or implying anything, apologies if that's how my post came across, i was just replying to Mrs OBumble's question asking where did Catherine Corless get the death certificates from, and your response that she possibly got them from the council or the public records office.
    I am not sure if anybody realises most of these are probably now available online in the civil records. But only in the last few months.

    Ireland's historical civil records were released online towards the end of 2016.
    Births, deaths and marriages. I accidentally came across them while looking up some details for a family ancestor. They appear as scanned sheets of 10 names per sheet and are afaik the details off the death cert recorded in the local council office to register the death. The indexing is basic - name, year, age at death.

    While searching I came across a person with a similar name who died in Sean Ross Abbey in Roscrea at age 0.

    What shocked me most was there were 4 other names of under one year old infants on the same page all died in Sean Ross Abbey, all listed as son or daughter of a house servant, all different causes, all from different parts of the country, all reported by the same name, an "occupier"
    Looking at several other sheets, all the same story, 4/5/6 names per sheet.
    A search shows over 1000 infant deaths under one in the small town of Roscrea between 1930 -1950
    A search of Tuam shows exactly the same pattern.

    What I can't comprehend, among many things, is that if I can look at a list of so many infant deaths on one sheet from a civil office, signed by I presume a local council official and go "what the holy f", then where was the same reaction from the human pen pusher in these council offices dotted around the country.

    To put some context on it. Many of the other infant deaths, who died at their own home had coroner or inquest details, even back in those years. No such mention for these poor children under the so called care of nuns. I wonder did they even see a doctor before being allocated their many and various causes of death. Shocking and appalling.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 268 ✭✭Cdosrun


    Someone said they don't call around in a van to pick up kids.
    Someone else said "it was a ford car".
    Yeah they would go to where they could get kids in.
    Ford green cortina.

    As I said it was a business. .
    They got per child and after you got to old to be paid for you got put out on the street.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 724 ✭✭✭Hagar7


    How are the RCC tolerated in this country, this organisation has done more harm than Hitler and his Nazi party. And they are still destroying peoples life's in Ireland, Africa and the Philippines

    Paddy,Hitler's birthday was celebrated by the Vatican Church during WW2,the Pope blessed his and Mussolini's army.
    Josef Stalin wanted to become a priest,he later killed 7/8 million of his own people.:mad:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,188 ✭✭✭wil


    chasm wrote: »
    She got the Death Certificates from the registry office in Galway according to an article in the Journal:

    "She finally began to get the information when she contacted the registry office in Galway to try to get death certificates for every child who had died at The Home. Speaking to IrishCentral in 2014, she described how it was the first time that it became clear that a large number of children had died there:

    Corless paid €4 for each death certificate and, between 2011 and 2013, ended up with the total number: 796

    At 796 deaths, this means that one child died approximately every fortnight at The Home – a mortality rate far higher than the rate for other children in Ireland at the time.

    Catherine cross-referenced the list of 796 names to see if any of the children were buried in local cemeteries. A Galway County Council archivist told her that none of the names appeared in any nearby cemetery."

    http://www.thejournal.ie/catherine-corless-tuam-mother-and-baby-home-3268501-Mar2017/

    I wonder who was sitting on the records I mentioned, now online, were they sitting waiting to be scanned in some office. They could have become available 10 years or more ago under the 50 year rule?

    The same check on place of burial should now be done on all the other homes including Sean Ross Abbey Roscrea, which afaik was put up for sale in recent years.

    Edit
    The civil records I mentioned above are at irishgenealogy.ie
    Apparently formally launched in January.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 268 ✭✭Cdosrun


    I'm going to close my account here now.

    They talked my thermally ill mother into sending us kids into their care.
    They also took my mother to a different home. That was the last I seem of her.
    it is the address on her death cert.
    One of the worst places that was.

    It was business ,money ,and pay for your sins


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,537 ✭✭✭KKkitty


    I'm sure it's been said before in this thread but I'll say it again. There was a time when the Irish people feared the RCC. You dare not say a word against them no matter what they did or said. Expectant mothers whose biggest sin was getting pregnant outside of marriage had their babies ripped away from them. Young children were sent to RCC institutions to be beaten and mistreated. The RCC has a lot to answer for. The Vatican also knew everything that was going on in this country with mother and baby homes and Christian Brothers schools but yet didn't so much as excommunicate the priests or nuns that did the harm to the kids of this country. In all likelihood they moved them to another parish so no one knew them or what they did.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,549 ✭✭✭maryishere


    Hagar7 wrote: »
    Hitler's birthday was celebrated by the Vatican Church during WW2,the Pope blessed his and Mussolini's army.

    KKkitty wrote: »
    I'm sure it's been said before in this thread but I'll say it again. There was a time when the Irish people feared the RCC. You dare not say a word against them no matter what they did or said. Expectant mothers whose biggest sin was getting pregnant outside of marriage had their babies ripped away from them. Young children were sent to RCC institutions to be beaten and mistreated. The RCC has a lot to answer for. The Vatican also knew everything that was going on in this country with mother and baby homes and Christian Brothers schools but yet didn't so much as excommunicate the priests or nuns that did the harm to the kids of this country. In all likelihood they moved them to another parish so no one knew them or what they did.

    Both Hitler and Mussolini were Catholics and were not excommunicated, so you would not expect those who were responsible for the kids in this country to be excommunicated?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,800 ✭✭✭✭hatrickpatrick


    I've just read the account of the guy who was born in the Tuam home, whose sister died there and was buried in some unknown grave, who was brutally beaten in front of his mother and who after 'graduating', wasn't allowed to take her out of the home when she was in her old age.

    I've lived through many church scandals in my time but for some reason this is my tipping point. I'm seriously considering formally leaving the church. I can no longer be a part of an organisation which would pervert and corrupt the word of Christ in such an extreme and sadistic manner.

    I was just googling formal defection and apparently it was abolished in 2010, after an Irish group campaigned for it to happen en masse after the child abuse scandals of the late 2000s. This enrages me further - it's like when Boards removed the "Closed Account" tag last year to cover up how many people were quitting due to the (at that time, since rectified) appalling state of ideological censorship here. The church clearly wanted to stem the flow by force, rather than by actually admitting to having done wrong and apologising unconditionally.

    My question is:

    Have any of ye done this? Formally left the Catholic Church? If you have, did you join a different Christian denomination and which one? Do you have any fears or hangups regarding the church's (in hindsight, increasingly moronic) teaching that nobody other than Catholics can get in to heaven, etc?

    Words cannot describe my raw fury right now. :mad:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,452 ✭✭✭✭The_Valeyard


    I've just read the account of the guy who was born in the Tuam home, whose sister died there and was buried in some unknown grave, who was brutally beaten in front of his mother and who after 'graduating', wasn't allowed to take her out of the home when she was in her old age.

    I've lived through many church scandals in my time but for some reason this is my tipping point. I'm seriously considering formally leaving the church. I can no longer be a part of an organisation which would pervert and corrupt the word of Christ in such an extreme and sadistic manner.

    I was just googling formal defection and apparently it was abolished in 2010, after an Irish group campaigned for it to happen en masse after the child abuse scandals of the late 2000s. This enrages me further - it's like when Boards removed the "Closed Account" tag last year to cover up how many people were quitting due to the (at that time, since rectified) appalling state of ideological censorship here. The church clearly wanted to stem the flow by force, rather than by actually admitting to having done wrong and apologising unconditionally.

    My question is:

    Have any of ye done this? Formally left the Catholic Church? If you have, did you join a different Christian denomination and which one? Do you have any fears or hangups regarding the church's (in hindsight, increasingly moronic) teaching that nobody other than Catholics can get in to heaven, etc?

    Words cannot describe my raw fury right now. :mad:

    Did you really just compare the horrors of the Tuam homes and dead babies to that of a banned or closed account tag line????


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,169 ✭✭✭chasm


    wil wrote: »
    I am not sure if anybody realises most of these are probably now available online in the civil records. But only in the last few months.

    Ireland's historical civil records were released online towards the end of 2016.
    Births, deaths and marriages. I accidentally came across them while looking up some details for a family ancestor. They appear as scanned sheets of 10 names per sheet and are afaik the details off the death cert recorded in the local council office to register the death. The indexing is basic - name, year, age at death.

    While searching I came across a person with a similar name who died in Sean Ross Abbey in Roscrea at age 0.

    What shocked me most was there were 4 other names of under one year old infants on the same page all died in Sean Ross Abbey, all listed as son or daughter of a house servant, all different causes, all from different parts of the country, all reported by the same name, an "occupier"
    Looking at several other sheets, all the same story, 4/5/6 names per sheet.
    A search shows over 1000 infant deaths under one in the small town of Roscrea between 1930 -1950
    A search of Tuam shows exactly the same pattern.

    What I can't comprehend, among many things, is that if I can look at a list of so many infant deaths on one sheet from a civil office, signed by I presume a local council official and go "what the holy f", then where was the same reaction from the human pen pusher in these council offices dotted around the country.

    To put some context on it. Many of the other infant deaths, who died at their own home had coroner or inquest details, even back in those years. No such mention for these poor children under the so called care of nuns. I wonder did they even see a doctor before being allocated their many and various causes of death. Shocking and appalling.

    I know the site you are refering to as i have used it many times whilst doing my own genealogy.
    I looked up the tuam area myself earlier, most of the deaths were not registered until 2-3 months later, one, 5 months later. I picked a random page of results to review and i'm unsure whether "The Bon Secours Home" is the same as the Bon Secours Mother and Baby home as there were a few deaths registered to elderly people as well? That page listed 5 children all under 11 days old, and 5 adults aged between 48 and 80 years.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,183 ✭✭✭✭Grayson


    KKkitty wrote: »
    I'm sure it's been said before in this thread but I'll say it again. There was a time when the Irish people feared the RCC. You dare not say a word against them no matter what they did or said. Expectant mothers whose biggest sin was getting pregnant outside of marriage had their babies ripped away from them. Young children were sent to RCC institutions to be beaten and mistreated. The RCC has a lot to answer for. The Vatican also knew everything that was going on in this country with mother and baby homes and Christian Brothers schools but yet didn't so much as excommunicate the priests or nuns that did the harm to the kids of this country. In all likelihood they moved them to another parish so no one knew them or what they did.

    There are still plenty of catholic organisations running "rogue" family planning organisations here. They peddle lies like abortion causes breast cancer or that women who have an abortion will beat any kids they have in the future. And their fall back has always been that they can put the baby up for adoption.

    The church still runs most schools in the country too. We have the angelus on TV.

    The church still has a very tight hold on this country.

    However it is lessening. Besides the fact that atheism is growing fast there is also a marked decrease in the devotion Catholics have to their religion. Over the last 10 years the numbers attending mass has dropped in every age group except the elderly.
    http://www.catholicbishops.ie/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Practice-and-Belief-among-Catholics-in-the-Republic-of-Ireland.pdf

    What we need now is for the government to form a commission which can investigate issues like the Tuam graves. They need carte blanche to be able to investigate as thoroughly as they need and assign blame. As people get older and older we are going to lose the testimony of witnesses and people will die without knowing what happened to their loved ones.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,800 ✭✭✭✭hatrickpatrick


    Did you really just compare the horrors of the Tuam homes and dead babies to that of a banned or closed account tag line????

    Not at all, that was in relation to the church's artificial attempt to control bad optics and unwittingly making their PR situation worse.

    Ironically enough, I was still halfway undecided about leaving the church until I read just a little while ago that they had essentially blocked people from formally leaving in order to stave off the inevitable PR disaster which would have resulted in 2010 had the defection campaign taken off - absolutely sickening. They should have publicly hung their heads in shame and begged for forgiveness rather than smugly cutting off the one effective avenue people had to protest.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,808 ✭✭✭✭Mrs OBumble


    Cdosrun wrote: »
    As I said it was a business. .
    They got per child and after you got to old to be paid for you got put out on the street.

    Pretty much the same as happens to kids who get too old for the state care system now ...

    Nothing's changed folks.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 790 ✭✭✭LaChatteGitane





    My question is:

    Have any of ye done this? Formally left the Catholic Church? If you have, did you join a different Christian denomination and which one? Do you have any fears or hangups regarding the church's (in hindsight, increasingly moronic) teaching that nobody other than Catholics can get in to heaven, etc?

    Words cannot describe my raw fury right now. :mad:

    I did when I was 18 (am 54 now). Even though I was brought up atheist my parents had me christened as a baby. Why ? I will never know, since my brother, who is 7 yrs my junior, wasn't.

    As a blowin' I am truly shocked at what the RCC has gotten away with (and still is) here in Ireland. It's like being send back to the dark ages. The grip they still have on the day to day lives of everyone is incredible. And that politics and church are so interwoven to this day, in a modern country, baffles me.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,537 ✭✭✭KKkitty


    maryishere wrote: »
    Both Hitler and Mussolini were Catholics and were not excommunicated, so you would not expect those who were responsible for the kids in this country to be excommunicated?

    They were leaders of their respective countries so why would they be excommunicated? The RCC didn't denounce world leaders only the vulnerable in society after all. All as bad as each other IMO.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,537 ✭✭✭KKkitty


    Grayson the RCC can try what they like now but my generation, the next and so on will not be duped by their indoctrination. The wool over the proverbial eyes is being lifted more and more while another generation is being born. We won't be taken in by imaginary objects in the sky thankfully.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,336 ✭✭✭Mr.Micro


    I did when I was 18 (am 54 now). Even though I was brought up atheist my parents had me christened as a baby. Why ? I will never know, since my brother, who is 7 yrs my junior, wasn't.

    As a blowin' I am truly shocked at what the RCC has gotten away with (and still is) here in Ireland. It's like being send back to the dark ages. The grip they still have on the day to day lives of everyone is incredible. And that politics and church are so interwoven to this day, in a modern country, baffles me.

    Well said. All hypocrites. They go to church as an insurance policy and try and validate their lives, rather than just accept people live and die, that is it.


Advertisement