Kilkenny GAA Thread Part 2 MOD NOTE POST 1*

kkclubhurling · 15-01-2017 09:21PM

Richie has spoken before about his frustration about how few games an Inter County hurler gets to play in the past so let them at it I say. Let's be honest, they are grown men, if they felt they were at risk of an injury or needed another few weeks off they would have told the management. Kilkenny are just back from the holiday and I'm sure the lads were delighted with the opportunity to blow the cobwebs off on the field of play rather than under lights or in the gym.

brookville · 15-01-2017 09:39PM

Credit to antrim today while being totally outplayed and well bet not a dirty stroke

kk.man · 15-01-2017 10:49PM

Village87 wrote: »

Padraig Walsh is an exceptional hurler for Kilkenny, good in the air, aggressive, great striker both sides. Kilkennys best back by a long way.
Kilkenny need him in the backs but a great option in the forwards, wrists to match the best forwards in the country such as bubbles, R Hogan, TJ, Joe Canning, not sure can we afford to do this though.
Apart from Riche and TJ Kilkenny lack natural forwards. Walter Walsh, Colin Fennelly, Liam Blanchfield, Jonjo Farrell are not big scorers, they are great athletes and workers and every forward line needs two of these but players like Riche Hogan, TJ,Bubbles can make the ball sing and these players get the big scores in the big games, IMO Padraig Walsh can provide this

+1 ...I thought this after last year's all Ireland forwards are harder to come by than backs in leaner times.

JimboJones99 · 16-01-2017 11:53AM

Doesn't look too encouraging for Michael Walsh. Hope he hasn't done serious damage again.

PaulKK · 17-01-2017 10:42PM

Senior captain announced:

http://www.oloughlingaels.gaa.ie/senior-mens-match-reports/mark-bergin-gets-the-nod

brookville · 17-01-2017 11:40PM

PaulKK wrote: »

Senior captain announced:

http://www.oloughlingaels.gaa.ie/senior-mens-match-reports/mark-bergin-gets-the-nod

Best of luck to mark his a sound fella.

PáircLife · 18-01-2017 02:59PM

This time last year he wasn't even on the panel. Unbelievable achievement from Mark Bergin in fairness.

Having said that, our way of choosing a captain is definitely outdated and the sooner it's changed the better. I wouldn't expect Mark Bergin to be starting this year, captaincy should drive him on this year but every team needs a captain who is a leader and a main player.

minty81 · 18-01-2017 03:14PM

Best of luck to Mark and sincerely hope we see him lifting silverware this year.

However i can't understand why a club hasn't put forward a motion to change the rule so that the county managers get to pick the captains. (Maybe they have but not aware of it ever put forward)
The odd year it works out where an experienced man gets the job (Brian Hogan 11, Larkin 12, Shefflin 07)
Often in our case a player got it early in their career and went onto be great leaders afterwards (jackie in 06, mick fennelly 09, reid 10)
But in other cases fringe players have gotten the job and i think it actually puts unnecessary pressure on them.
Well overdue a rule change here

citykat · 18-01-2017 05:42PM

PáircLife wrote: »

Having said that, our way of choosing a captain is definitely outdated and the sooner it's changed the better. I wouldn't expect Mark Bergin to be starting this year, captaincy should drive him on this year but every team needs a captain who is a leader and a main player.

There's plenty of leaders on that team, lads with multiple AIs. Non playing captains haven't held us back in the past. Its a reward for the club champions but is really only an honorary position at this stage. Leave it as is.

Charlie69 · 18-01-2017 05:47PM

Maybe the County champions should also nominate a vice-captain that could take on the role of Captain should the man they nominate not make the team or is otherwise unavailable.

Michael Kavanagh · 18-01-2017 07:42PM

Cornerback1 wrote: »

Still they a break would do them no harm.

I suppose the way Cody looks at it there all playing for places look at T Walsh a couple of years ago.

brookville · 21-01-2017 01:17PM

O loughlins have nominated richie hogan as vice captain.Best of luck to both.realistically it's unlikely mark will be in the top 18 if all players get back from injury and the likes of alyward and maher returning and hopefully blanchfield and kevin kelly kick on and hopefully the likes of leahy,walsh or chris bolger make the breakthrough.
With kilkenny almost guaranteed a walsh cup semi final spot I'd like to see few more u21 lads getting gametime tomorrow although it's unlikely.I know players want to be playing and the panel is small at the moment with college commitments but playing 8 of last year's team against antrim is madness to me.surely there's enough good club hurlers or lads not in college good enough to be competing in this competition.

citykat · 21-01-2017 04:28PM

brookville wrote: »

O loughlins have nominated richie hogan as vice captain.

Have they? I've seen where Danesfort have proposed him. Didn't think OLG had any say in the matter tbh. It's Codys decision afaia.

brookville · 21-01-2017 04:50PM

citykat wrote: »

Have they? I've seen where Danesfort have proposed him. Didn't think OLG had any say in the matter tbh. It's Codys decision afaia.

I was told he was vice captain during the week but came across this today http://www.irishexaminer.com/sport/gaa/hurling/oloughlin-gaels-gesture-could-see-a-danesfort-captain-for-kilkenny-439768.html

Rasputin11 · 21-01-2017 09:50PM

John Mulhall going hurling with Kildare, he looked a nice prospect in his youth. Why didn't he push on with Kilkenny?

Realt Dearg Sec · 21-01-2017 10:46PM

Rasputin11 wrote: »

John Mulhall going hurling with Kildare, he looked a nice prospect in his youth. Why didn't he push on with Kilkenny?

Let's just say he didn't have the right attitude for the Cody regime.

Comerman · 22-01-2017 12:47PM

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

Let's just say he didn't have the right attitude for the Cody regime.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exBnHWJfCVw

dastardly00 · 22-01-2017 02:45PM

KK team vs Westmeath:

https://twitter.com/KilkennyCLG/status/823163454240473088

It's going to be a tough day for the Westmeath full-back line... having to mark TJ, Richie Hogan and Wally.

Good to see Michael Walsh starting after going off with what looked like a bad injury last week.

Cornerback1 · 22-01-2017 03:35PM

Going well but Richie Hogan has gone off after 5 mins. Not sure if he's injured. Just following Twitter. 3-10 to Westmeath's 0-7 nearing half-time.

Realt Dearg Sec · 22-01-2017 04:29PM

You would have to wonder what the benefit is of playing our best and most established players and dishing out these hammerings. We haven't much to learn about Richie at this stage, what is the reason for risking him? There must be a few hurlers around Kilkenny that it would be worth seeing if they could contribute anything to the extended squad for the year.

Topcat32 · 22-01-2017 04:32PM

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

You would have to wonder what the benefit is of playing our best and most established players and dishing out these hammerings. We haven't much to learn about Richie at this stage, what is the reason for risking him? There must be a few hurlers around Kilkenny that it would be worth seeing if they could contribute anything to the extended squad for the year.

Richie didnt start, was named to start tho

brookville · 22-01-2017 04:35PM

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

You would have to wonder what the benefit is of playing our best and most established players and dishing out these hammerings. We haven't much to learn about Richie at this stage, what is the reason for risking him? There must be a few hurlers around Kilkenny that it would be worth seeing if they could contribute anything to the extended squad for the year.

I said the same yesterday it's madness playing richie and tj today and last week.it was a convincing enough win but westmeath battled hard in the 2nd half to their credit.John joe and wally the pick up front

Realt Dearg Sec · 22-01-2017 04:37PM

Topcat32 wrote: »

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

You would have to wonder what the benefit is of playing our best and most established players and dishing out these hammerings. We haven't much to learn about Richie at this stage, what is the reason for risking him? There must be a few hurlers around Kilkenny that it would be worth seeing if they could contribute anything to the extended squad for the year.

Richie didnt start, was named to start tho

Fair enough, I stand corrected on that. The general point still stands though. I'd have Richie hogan at home warming his feet at the fire with a nice cup of tea on Sundays until February to be honest!

Topcat32 · 22-01-2017 04:52PM

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

Fair enough, I stand corrected on that. The general point still stands though. I'd have Richie hogan at home warming his feet at the fire with a nice cup of tea on Sundays until February to be honest!

Yeah totally agree, I think the selection policy is being effectd by a lot of the players in collages being ineligible until the semi final tho

brookville · 22-01-2017 05:06PM

I think tj came off near the end with a injury.it's good to see pat lyng hurling well.he got 3 points from play.

dubcat51 · 22-01-2017 10:08PM

Who got rhe goals and who played well.

brookville · 22-01-2017 10:27PM

dubcat51 wrote: »

Who got rhe goals and who played well.

Two each for jj and wally.Pat lyng and tj also hurled well.
Might be worth noting joey being tried at no 2 in these matches and paul murphy and fogarty on the hb line in both matches

citykat · 22-01-2017 10:43PM

dubcat51 wrote: »

Who got rhe goals and who played well.

http://www.kilkennypeople.ie/news/sport/231876/kilkenny-ease-into-walsh-cup-semis.html?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter

minty81 · 23-01-2017 12:05PM

Richie was named both on the programme and on the tannoy to start so must've pulled out very late.
Though i didn't see him in the warm up.
Wally looked very sharp i thought. TJ won endless ball and the forwards were throwing it around nicely in the first half.
Not sure was the substitution of michael walsh a result of injury but i thought he was the best of the full back line. Rob Lennon looked sluggish enough and full back back line in second half was holden, lennon and pender which wouldn't inspire you.
Pat Lyng the best of the newcomers, took his scores well and worked very hard.
Big test next week for the newcomers away to wexford

Topcat32 · 24-01-2017 03:58PM

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

Let's just say he didn't have the right attitude for the Cody regime.

From what I know Cody liked him and he was a popular member of the panel, he went through a spell of games in the league where he totally lost confidence and then there was a relatively minor breach of disipline which led him to be dropped from the panel, the door was open and I dont think there was much bad will at all on either side but his club form never justified a recall.

Kilkenny GAA Thread Part 2 **MOD NOTE POST 1***

Comments

Kilkenny GAA Thread Part 2 MOD NOTE POST 1*