New Proposed Sheep Scheme

paddysdream · 26-09-2016 09:35PM #1

Surprised to find no one has mentioned the proposals for the new sheep scheme.Are the returns from sheep so good this year that it's slipped past everyone?

Looking at the options its hard not to feel that the thinking behind this (and many other schemes)is to give to the farmer and make him spend it on products and/or services that benefit the wider agri related industry.Kind of a green money laundering scheme.

Now in fairness the proposed options are not the most onerous but its the thinking behind them rather than the actual options themselves that I find a problem.Are many of these schemes planned to support farmers or, like the farm building grants of the celtic tiger era,mainly to benefit those that farmers buy from?

On an unrelated but similarly depressing theme,many on here finding that lamb thrive and kill out is pretty poor this year?Every single farmer that I have met over the last two months has the same complaint ie lambs not putting on flesh and/or killing out anything from one half to a full kilo under normal given similar live weight too last year.

Thats about my quota of depression for today thank you !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Mac Taylor · 26-09-2016 09:57PM

Would be inclined to agree with you, more Paperwork, more audits and checks. We only keep a few ewes so not really going to make a difference one way or the other.

paddysdream · 26-09-2016 10:43PM

Mac Taylor wrote: »

Would be inclined to agree with you, more Paperwork, more audits and checks. We only keep a few ewes so not really going to make a difference one way or the other.

To be honest the scheme at a tenner a head or so would be very worthwhile here so not complaining about that,rather the whole thrust and thinking behind such supports.

Paperwork and audits are a fact of life,whether we like it or not,and that ain't gonna change.Hard to complain about waste and overspending in other sectors and then complain about oversight on agri spending I suppose.
Its more the fact that the powers that be are almost ashamed that returns from farming,well the drystock sector to be specific,are so poor that an injection of funds is needed to sustain even a semblance of an industry ,but to admit this would mean that the cheap food policy of the past fifty years has benefited everyone bar the primary producers so each and every support package must be dependent on a fig leaf excuse of carbon footprint,water quality,greenhouse gas reduction etc etc(pick whatever is the issue of the week at any given time and if you don't like it then make up one of your own).

Bleating Lamb · 27-09-2016 07:28AM

paddysdream wrote: »

To be honest the scheme at a tenner a head or so would be very worthwhile here so not complaining about that,rather the whole thrust and thinking behind such supports.

Paperwork and audits are a fact of life,whether we like it or not,and that ain't gonna change.Hard to complain about waste and overspending in other sectors and then complain about oversight on agri spending I suppose.
Its more the fact that the powers that be are almost ashamed that returns from farming,well the drystock sector to be specific,are so poor that an injection of funds is needed to sustain even a semblance of an industry ,but to admit this would mean that the cheap food policy of the past fifty years has benefited everyone bar the primary producers so each and every support package must be dependent on a fig leaf excuse of carbon footprint,water quality,greenhouse gas reduction etc etc(pick whatever is the issue of the week at any given time and if you don't like it then make up one of your own).

Agree with your sentiments,govt( regardless of make up of it) don't want to be seen by urbanites as giving out money for nothing,so it's inevitable that there will be checks and balances attached to it.

The way I look at the scheme,it will help go some way towards the costs of keeping your individual ewes for the year re taking proper care of them with timely doses,injections etc etc.

charolais0153 · 27-09-2016 07:55AM

What are requirements or is it free money

Green farmer · 27-09-2016 09:01AM

Hope they move abit faster in getting it over the line. Anyone get start letter from dept on new discussion group ?

arctictree · 27-09-2016 11:02AM

I had a read of it in the journal and cant see that there would be much left for the farmer after all the conditions have been complied with....

ganmo · 27-09-2016 01:07PM

Haven't looked at it too closely but some of the options already common practice on a lot of farms

solerina · 27-09-2016 08:59PM

havnt looked into it yet but one of the neighbours said its like the beef scheme with 4 and 5 star rams needed..in fairness if that's the case it wont be worth getting into...is there any truth to this ?

ganmo · 27-09-2016 09:41PM

solerina wrote: »

havnt looked into it yet but one of the neighbours said its like the beef scheme with 4 and 5 star rams needed..in fairness if that's the case it wont be worth getting into...is there any truth to this ?

from what i read you had to pick 2 options of 8 which included scanning ewes, 4/5 star ram, giving lambs meal and minerals to ewes and lambs

paddysdream · 27-09-2016 10:17PM

From reading the little bit in the media so far it seems that you have to pick one option from menu A ;either mineral supplementation of ewes POST mating or a foot problem control plan (assume vet. input needed for this)
and one option from menu B;star rated ram,parasite control plan,scanning,blowfly control measure,meal feeding post weaning of hill lambs.
Think there is another option or so in menu B. but cannot think of it at the moment.
Looks like anyone selling Cobalt/B12 will see a real increase in sales whilst the scanning men will need to invest in a few more docket books.

Nothing very difficult really for the vast majority of people but its the inevitable extra paperwork and inspections that may dissuade some people from joining.Things like having a scanning docket for 500 in December and inspection finds 475 in January with sales of 22 dry ewes but no knackery dockets.
Where things like this cause problems is where you might have a "quota" of 450 based on previous census but scanner does 500 and writes docket for same and Dept will still look for this number although its not relevant to the scheme.
On any decent numbers this scheme will be worth applying for but for people with maybe 80 or less breeding ewes the money/hassle balance could tilt either way.
As far as I know a lower uptake will not mean any extra for those that do decide to participate

sea12 · 27-09-2016 10:23PM

I think it's based on an average number of ewes you had between 2014 and 2015 as returned in your census.

Green farmer · 28-09-2016 10:06AM

sea12 wrote: »

I think it's based on an average number of ewes you had between 2014 and 2015 as returned in your census.

Does that mean we'll get some payment on it before the end of year ? Or is it this time next year ?

J.O. Farmer · 28-09-2016 10:12AM

Green farmer wrote: »

Does that mean we'll get some payment on it before the end of year ? Or is it this time next year ?

No it'll be right before the next election.

The details of the scheme have to be announced and it'll be something you have to sign up to and presumably have completed certain tasks before payment so probably some time between this time next year and mid 2018.

ganmo · 28-09-2016 10:12AM

Green farmer wrote: »

Does that mean we'll get some payment on it before the end of year ? Or is it this time next year ?

No it only starts in Jan, to run for 3 years. I haven't seen any payment timeline

Green farmer · 28-09-2016 10:51AM

I suppose it'll come when it comes so, which is better then not comin at all.

BannerBarry · 12-10-2016 06:54PM

Does anyone have the specifics of the Sheep scheme announced in thr budget?
Below is as detailed as I can find.

Is "Animal Welfare" codewords for red tape and jobs for the boys?

€25m is about €4 per ewe I calculate... I can't see a rush to the marts buying over this announcement!

"Under the Rural Development Scheme, there will be increased funding of €107m, which includes €25m for a new animal welfare sheep scheme. Some 34,000 farmers are expected to participate in the scheme."

ganmo · 12-10-2016 07:30PM

BannerBarry wrote: »

Does anyone have the specifics of the Sheep scheme announced in thr budget?
Below is as detailed as I can find.

Is "Animal Welfare" codewords for red tape and jobs for the boys?

€25m is about €4 per ewe I calculate... I can't see a rush to the marts buying over this announcement!

"Under the Rural Development Scheme, there will be increased funding of €107m, which includes €25m for a new animal welfare sheep scheme. Some 34,000 farmers are expected to participate in the scheme."

It wasn't announced in the budget, it was announced in May!
Nobody is goin out buying as it's gonna be based on previous census figures and it's gonna be 10 per ewe

rangler1 · 12-10-2016 07:34PM

BannerBarry wrote: »

Does anyone have the specifics of the Sheep scheme announced in thr budget?
Below is as detailed as I can find.

Is "Animal Welfare" codewords for red tape and jobs for the boys?

€25m is about €4 per ewe I calculate... I can't see a rush to the marts buying over this announcement!

"Under the Rural Development Scheme, there will be increased funding of €107m, which includes €25m for a new animal welfare sheep scheme. Some 34,000 farmers are expected to participate in the scheme."

Supposed to be 2.5 million ewes in the country......at €10/ewe that's €25m...I'm looking forward to it

BannerBarry · 12-10-2016 09:06PM

rangler1 wrote: »

Supposed to be 2.5 million ewes in the country......at €10/ewe that's €25m...I'm looking forward to it

Great.. it might mean we don't have to dip in to the Income Averaging break year for another few years of bad losses so!
Thanks for the update.

Green farmer · 12-10-2016 09:28PM

FJ says payment is €10 and based on 14 and 15 census. Payable up to 2020 and is fixed payment so won't get any more money even if you doubled your flock .

rangler1 · 12-10-2016 10:06PM

Green farmer wrote: »

FJ says payment is €10 and based on 14 and 15 census. Payable up to 2020 and is fixed payment so won't get any more money even if you doubled your flock .

Hope you're right, wouldn't be long losing ten euros/ewe if lamb nos increased

Username John · 12-10-2016 11:01PM

Green farmer wrote: »

FJ says payment is €10 and based on 14 and 15 census. Payable up to 2020 and is fixed payment so won't get any more money even if you doubled your flock .

Do you need to maintain the same numbers as per 14 / 15 census til 2020 to continue to be paid?
(I would this to be the case, as it would seem logical)
But just wondering if anyone knew for sure...

charolais0153 · 12-10-2016 11:13PM

Typical keeping more ewes this year than last

Green farmer · 13-10-2016 06:17AM

rangler1 wrote: »

Hope you're right, wouldn't be long losing ten euros/ewe if lamb nos increased

That's what the journal says anyway.

Buford T. Justice XIX · 14-10-2016 05:00PM

https://twitter.com/NewstalkFM/status/785829314210050048

kk.man · 15-10-2016 11:05PM

Are there provisions for new entrants?

Siamsa Sessions · 21-10-2016 01:59PM

kk.man wrote: »

Are there provisions for new entrants?

I'd be interested in the answer to this too. Only started buying ewes at the end of 2015 so had very small number on census. If there's a minimum no. required, I might not qualify.

I'd ask Teagasc but I'm not renewing my subscription with them :-)

Might be more info in the Journal in the next few weeks (cheaper than Teagasc and you get very similar info from both)

ganmo · 13-12-2016 09:03PM

Will everyone be signed up to this automatically? It's meant to start this Jan and I've heard nothing about it

paddysdream · 13-12-2016 11:16PM

ganmo wrote: »

Will everyone be signed up to this automatically? It's meant to start this Jan and I've heard nothing about it

Think you will need to sign up to this as you have to commit to the measures in the scheme.Thought it wasn't gonna start till May/June as EU haven't fully signed off on it yet.
Think we are "promised" payment in calender year 2017.No commitment as to how long it will run yet either I think.

orm0nd · 19-12-2016 07:25PM

Closing date is 31st January

http://www.agriland.ie/farming-news/e25m-sheep-welfare-scheme-application-forms-to-issue-to-farmers-shortly

New Proposed Sheep Scheme

Comments