Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Can someone make me a bionic arm?

  • 01-10-2021 12:08pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    I lost use of arm in accident 7 years ago.

    Finally, after a long time agonising, I am moving towards amputation and fitting of a bionic arm, to be carried out in Vienna.

    Prior to that I would like to practice on an arm if I could.

    I visited the hospital in Vienna in 2019, they connected me to an arm and I could close the hand but not open it, as the signal from the opening muscle was quite weak.

    The plan is to move a muscle from my leg to my arm to do that job. However, if I was able to practice I might theoretically be able to strengthen the signal I have already and hopefully / potentially avoid surgery and massive cost associated with it.


    There are instructables etc available on line.

    Now, if I had the use of two hands I could do this but unfortunately for me everything takes much longer / is more difficult with one hand, I don't have the space, time etc - also I'm sure plenty of people here are experienced, have the tools, setup etc.


    I'm thinking of a basic 3d printed arm, with two sensors - one to close the hand the other to open it.


    I have a video of myself using the arm when I visited Vienna which I can show you.

    I will of course pay for your time & materials.


    This is serious, I need to get this done.

    Please don't mess me around, I was involved with two different people already but nothing came of it, and I'm running out of time.


    Dublin based but can travel within reason.

    Can anyone help? Even point me to right group for this type of thing.



«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 812 ✭✭✭CreadanLady


    Sorry to hear of your struggle but is good you are getting it sorted soon.

    However, I think you very seriously underestimate the significance of the task you are asking. This is not something that could be reasonably done by someone as a nixer over a few weekends. And the cost of custom making something like this would be quite significant. This stuff costs major money because of all the R&D and certification that goes along with it. There is also the issue of liability for whoever makes it for you. If, for whatever reason, you ended up getting hurt somehow through the use of whatever they make you, whatever engineer did it would be liable unless they had the item certified and had all the insurances etc.

    Basically, you would be asking someone to put their professional reputation at stake for the sake of a nixer. Medical devices and prosthetics are not a nixer type activity.

    Plus, anyone who works in that industry is probably very well paid. They don't need to do side nixers on showstring budgets.

    You are in the care of your medical team. Follow their advice.

    The MFV Creadan Lady is a mussel dredger from Dunmore East.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    You misunderstand what I'm asking for, my fault for not explaining better.

    I do not want a finished product that is as good as the one that I am potentially getting fitted.

    I'm just looking for a training device that is arm shaped, has two sensors to attach to muscles close to the elbow, and can open and close. Doesn't even have to be an arm, just a hand would be fine.

    My medical team said it would be good if I could get a training device - as mentioned to strengthen the muscles there in advance of three operations over the next year or so.

    I guess I picked the wrong forum - its probably more for electronics / hobbyists. As I mentioned there are instructables etc on line - while I work in IT and understand technology. I cannot complete such a project for reasons outlined previously.

    Thanks for the input.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    I realise the headline was a bit sensational so again my fault.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,896 ✭✭✭✭28064212


    Your medical team recommended a training device, but didn't give you any advice on where to get one? Surely your first port of call is to them?

    Boardsie Enhancement Suite - a browser extension to make using Boards on desktop a better experience (includes full-width display, keyboard shortcuts, dark mode, and more). Now available through your browser's extension store.

    Firefox: https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/boardsie-enhancement-suite/

    Chrome/Edge/Opera: https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/boardsie-enhancement-suit/bbgnmnfagihoohjkofdnofcfmkpdmmce



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    They did not recommend one, one of the doctors had me hooked up to a sensor on a pc which showed muscle activity, and then connected me to an arm.

    She said it would be useful if you could get something similar, it would help you, just said that its possible to get them from the internet.

    And I suppose they are not my medical team as such, I went abroad, got an assessment and left it at that.

    It was in Vienna so maybe misunderstanding on my part.

    I really just thought it would be easy for someone to print something off on a 3D printer, put in a couple of electrodes / sensors to open and close and that would be it.

    There are plans on line, but as I said I'm not geared up for it, and its easier to pay someone who has the capabilities than going on a steep learning curve myself.

    Maybe its not that easy. Ans I suppose I'm in the wrong forum but cannot locate an electronics type one.

    Ill google it and see if I can get someone to make one.

    So apologies for wasting people's time.



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,488 ✭✭✭Ryath


    Would just a sensor and light be a start to train the muscle?

    From a quick google

    https://shop.pimoroni.com/products/myoware-muscle-sensor

    https://shop.pimoroni.com/products/myoware-led-shield



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 23,686 ✭✭✭✭mickdw


    I don't think you need an arm for a start point.

    As said above, surely, a sensor similar to the official one in terms of sensitivity would be needed and then just something simple to confirm activation.

    The suggestion of a light above might not be ideal in terms of automatic brain training re looking at something that you want to control but I'd imagine sensor connected to a simple scissor type device would be ideal. The device wouldn't need to be strong enough to lift or grip anything, just some basic plastic hinged object to help muscle control while also brain training the open and close.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 812 ✭✭✭CreadanLady


    It doesn't matter if it is just a basic training device. You would be asking someone to put their career on the line by doing a nixer like this, even if it is just a cobbled together sensor and some basic electronics. You are missing the point that, nomatter how simple a device, it is still a medical device and whoever makes it and gives it to you is liable for it and any harm it might potentially cause inadvertently.

    If I was a medical device engineer or technician, I wouldn't touch this sort of nixer type work with a barge pole. It would end your career if it got out that you were even dabbling on the side, not to mind any potential case taken against you. And as I said, anyone competent in this field is already making big bucks money - they don't need to take on mickey mouse nixers at the weekend.

    Why do you even need a device to train the muscle? Can you not just excercise and contract the muscles on their own? The sensor is just sensor, it won't make anything stronger or cause the signal to strenthen. A sensor is just a passive device detecting a signal, much like a microphone or camera passively detects sound and light.

    you need to talk to your doctors about this and ask them for advice.

    The MFV Creadan Lady is a mussel dredger from Dunmore East.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    These are the type of things that could be useful alright. Someone was making me similar but it never worked / got finished.

    I guess Ill start here and see where I go after that.

    I was hoping to get a 3rd arm to do rudimentary things like picking up light objects, holding a plug while I rewire it etc etc - again it would not have to be a space age, titanium carbon fibre terminator type arm, just a 3d printed plastic one.


    Sure look, thanks for all the input, I'll keep going.

    And if I do get anything, I'll post it ...

    I'll be back ....



  • Posts: 1,263 ✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    If there are resources online, could you send the files to a 3D printing place and they would print it for you? That would get you part of the way there.



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    Jesus, you are going way too deep into this. I don't need a lecture, I need a bit of help.

    I hereby absolve whoever I deal with of any malpractice, malfeasance whatever as a result of making me a device.

    I'm asking someone to make something, not put their career on the line, were not building a bridge here.

    As I said its probably the wrong forum.

    Transition year students could probably do this.


    Why do I need this? Because I have a very weak signal in the muscle that opens the hand and a strong signal in the muscle that closes it.

    I had a catastrophic injury and had some nerve transfers which have allowed these muscles to work slightly.

    I'm facing an operation to move a muscle from my leg to replace the opening muscle, and if I could spend a few months training with an opening and closing type device I could hopefully get that muscle working and bypass the need for surgery - its a big operation, it costs a lot and I have to spend a month in Vienna. If I'm connected to something with a gauge / measurement I would be able to see progress.

    Look thanks for all the suggestions, I'll look elsewhere.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    Yeh I m gonna do that, there's lads in India, China etc who could do this.

    I just thought I'd ask locally first.

    Forgive my angst, I'm basically at the end of my tether living life with one hand and carrying around a useless uncomfortable hunk of flesh and bone.



  • Posts: 1,263 ✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Nothing to apologise for! There's a 3D printing forum on here. Hopefully, an Irish 3D printing place would print it for you.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 812 ✭✭✭CreadanLady


    I understand your frustration, but I think you massively underestimate the significance of the task you are asking someone to do as a nixer.

    Transition year students? Seriously?

    I understand the type of device you are seeking and why you are seeking it, but you are misguided in seeking medical advice/services it from randomers on an internet forum.

    You really need to discuss this matter with your doctors or whoever is managing your care for the upcoming procedures. It is they who should be advising you on this, not you going off behind their backs seeking back-street DIY medical devices from randomers on an internet forum. And to be honest, you should have the bit of cop on to realise that.

    And for what it's worth, you need to cool the jets a bit. There are people far worse off. There are people who would kill to have one working arm. So I am sorry for the pain you have endured, but you need to count your blessings in this life, not your burdens.

    The MFV Creadan Lady is a mussel dredger from Dunmore East.



  • Posts: 11,614 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    @Finnrocco

    The hackerspace, Tog, in Dublin should have everything you need. I know some of the guys involved in it and am checking with them if they could print it for you. I'll post back when I hear from them.

    I was searching for a link I read a while back about another hackerspace who were making prosthetic arms for kids but found this: https://www.generationunlimited.org/stories/teenagers-develop-3d-printed-bionic-arm-30-times-cheaper-existing-prosthetics

    Is this the site you got the assembly instructions from: https://ebionics.org/faq/ ?

    I'll let you know when I hear back.

    I understand the type of device you are seeking and why you are seeking it, but you are misguided in seeking medical advice/services it from randomers on an internet forum.

    He didn't ask for any medical advice. He just needs someone to 3d print it, and possibly a small bit of soldering. I happily volunteer to do the latter. I just don't currently have access to a 3D printer.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    Ok apologies for me massively underestimating this job.

    Back street medical devices? Its a thing that sits external of my body, strapped to my working arm, and opening and closing. A piece of plastic with a few wires in it, hinge maybe, not a full blown 50,000 dollar device. Maybe my choice of title was wrong.

    I'm not going behind their backs, they said if you can manage to get a training device let us know how its going

    Cool my jets? you don't get to tell me how to feel. I'm allowed feel the way I feel.

    People far worse off? I absolutely totally understand that, and no matter how bad things are its always worse for someone else. There's also people far better off than me. And there's nothing wrong with wanting to be better. Also this is the only thing wrong in my life but it is still a burden.

    It doesn't achieve much I accept that but that's they way I feel, sometimes up, sometimes down. I just didn't expect a lecture / put down here .. I need a bit of help, yeh I can help, no I can't help - that's it, is that not what the internet is good for - ideas, advice etc?

    Look, were obviously not going to agree on this, we both seem to have different ideas on my situation and my needs.

    So I guess mods close this thread and I'll move on.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    Thank you.

    Ill look up Tog.

    I have just seen a few sites, someone wanted a couple of hundred dollars for plans, I don't mind paying if I can get it printed and working and usable for training.



  • Posts: 11,614 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Do me one small favour and just ignore that poster. She seems to be under the impression you're asking for a mates rates kidney transplant, not a 3-d printed project.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 812 ✭✭✭CreadanLady


    Fair enough.


    But on the practical side, I don't understand why it needs to be 3D printed. Why is that? If it is just a training device and not intented to be of any practical use to hold or manipulate things then what is the point of complicating it by printing compotents.

    Wouldn't a very simple actuator device, with some sort of binary indicator flag attached, or even 2 leds mounted on a hold be sufficient to indicate the notional "open" and "closed" positions in response to the signal from the muscle. Any a sensor(s) could be attached to the skin with a velcro strap around the limb. The indicator actuator or even the leds and any supporting circuitry and battery could be mounted in a compact desktop case, linked to the sensor velco srtap with a cable. Or even, then whole arrangement could be made compact enough to be attached to velcro strap with the sensors and entirely worn on the arm .

    For an simple indicator training device rather than a functional device, 3D printing seems to be over complicating things adding unecessary cost and time input. Are we talking 3D printing simply because it is a buzzword and seems to fit with the whole direction prosthetics manufacturing is going, (which it is)?

    Number one rule of engineering is identify the desired fuction and purpose, and then find the simplest and most straightforward method of achiving the desired purpose. KISS. Keep it simple stupid.

    The MFV Creadan Lady is a mussel dredger from Dunmore East.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 224 ✭✭SunnySundays


    Have you spoken with 3D Assist in Tallaght?

    They might be apply to help you. They produce assist limbs but not sure it's exactly what you are looking for?



  • Advertisement


  • This indeed seems like a very good place to contact as they are a university which teaches students under due expertise and guidance:

    CreadanLady may be absolutely technically correct (guess she is a professional engineer) but OP is probably trying to get the full psychological feel of the future functioning arm on board to maximise his input into the practice of its operation,

    If OP can use the stimulus in his muscle to practice actuating the opening/closing of a hand-type device in any way up until this mammoth surgery, that is indeed the “operand” goal, but to see it in a device attached to his real arm is the icing on the cake and perhaps the real stimulus to a achieving his goal.

    Just be wary, OP, not all “promises” are practically delivered in spite of someone’s fully genuine intentions. I think you have found out about this already. Enthusiasm to deliver is something I’ve seen which has been failed to be delivered, if you know what I mean.

    Things are a bit too serious with you for you to be messed around with, don’t let this happen.

    Post edited by [Deleted User] on


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,638 ✭✭✭Turbulent Bill


    OP, very sorry to hear about your injury; your frustration is obvious and understandable.

    Any direction on training aids should come from your medical team and be clear, same as any other aspect of the treatment programme. I've no experience in your scenario, but if a training regime would simplify your treatment, surely the medical team would specify exactly how to do this (and what tools you need)?

    I work in medical devices, but this really looks like a medical query (can I simplify the surgery?) rather than an engineering one. Your understandable urge to get things moving, and people's understandable urge to help, could end up giving you false hope if this doesn't align with the medical reality. Best of luck.





  • Consulting with a chartered physiotherapist who has specialist knowledge in this area could be helpful. They would not necessarily need a specific referral, would be be qualified to provide guidance in how the muscle could be best developed in preparation for the surgery and ultimate placement of device. It’s too serious an issue for random advice without the additional input of a suitably qualified person. In my own experience preparing for and recovering from orthopaedic surgery, physiotherapists offer very good bang for your buck. Physios tend to be very practical people too, and would advise in conjunction with engineering solutions that folk might come up with.




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 604 ✭✭✭Finnrocco


    Ok everybody thanks for all your input


    Ill get in touch with a few of the mentioned people or organisations.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,888 ✭✭✭ozmo



    Its a great idea.

    Do consider the above again - the muscle sensor will show the level of the muscle - you can do without the led shield - but you will need an arduino (10 euros from adverts.ie and a laptop) and spare skin stickie pads.

    eg. see this on youtube:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wlx8JndAgs

    the 3d printing would take longer to manufacture(takes days to print large items) and maybe multiple versions required to get a fit; its not just printing but there are motors, moving parts and fastners etc to deal with -

    so if you can get just the training lights/graph above working you can add the mechanics as a second part of the project after you have proven you can get the sensors to work. The graph may even be enough.


    you will need to be sure you are training the correct muscles, and what levels they need to be - but Im sure you know that part.

    Best of luck.

    “Roll it back”



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,125 ✭✭✭kirving


    It looks like 3D Assist would be a good starting point. They look to have similar experience in this area which is absolutely vital.


    As any doctor would abide by the "first do no harm" mantra, a professional engineer will do the very same.

    With the best will in the world, anyone who suggests that it's just a bit of soldering and some code downloaded to an Arduino is simply naive. I'm a mechanical engineer, working in electronics, and deal with automation equipment every day. I've also had a number of orthopaedic surgeries over the past 2 years or so, and happy to say that I don't know what I don't know about orthopaedics, physio or the nervous system.

    There are also risks for even the most rudimentary of devices. These could range from simply slowing your recovery due to to training the wrong muscles, right up to say dropping a pot of boiling water on a child because the arm broke in half. You can't realistically expect an engineer you find online to assume that responsibility and liability. A post on a forum isn't going to cut it when you realise someone has lead you astray and caused injury to a third party.

    I do hope you find something which is of help, genuinely. It is extremely off putting though, for professionals who might want to get involved, when you and others on the thread are repeatedly underestimating the amount of work involved.



  • Moderators, Recreation & Hobbies Moderators, Social & Fun Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 6,914 Mod ✭✭✭✭shesty


    I have a Masters in Bioengineering, - you don't knock this type of thing together over a weekend.

    That being said can I also suggest you try contacting Universities, as they may have some ideas/suggestions or resources that might help.UCD, UCG and Trinity I know all have very good programmes in Bioengineering so that could be a start.DCU have an excellent mechatronic programme also I think, might be worth a look.They may have research ongoing or facilities they might allow you to check out that might be useful, or be able to put you in touch with a company or individual that can assist.





  • This has brought to mind an air accident report I read (the avgeek I am) about an experienced BE Captain who had an artificial arm, and, as pilot flying, was landing his aircraft in very gusty conditions. His left bionic arm became dislodged just prior to touchdown and was left detached “holding” the control stick whilst his right hand grappled to adjust the throttle in response to a sudden change in wind vector. As a result the aircraft touched down extremely hard and bounced a number of times, causing more embarrassment that damage. It took some re-engineering to find a more fail-safe mechanism to ensure his arm remained attached for all future flights. If it hadn’t been gusting his right hand would have adequately controlled the aircraft and the First Officer would have stepped in to assist, but all happened so suddenly. People can do all sorts of things with various limb impairments, but it has to be got just right if safety is at stake.



  • Posts: 11,614 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    So OP, don't be signing up as a pilot with Ryanair, or carrying around pots of boiling water with your new DIY arm.


    This thread is absolutely ridiculous.



  • Advertisement


  • I guess you know my concern is that the OP doesn’t get let down yet again, there’s way too much at stake for him in this scenario. If he can really be assisted, I would say to anyone who can do it, please do and follow through.

    I’ve had personal radical surgery which you’ve seen for yourself, if someone had offered a device that ended up not fitting me after I would have been absolutely devastated. But the thread is about the OP.

    Post edited by [Deleted User] on


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,125 ✭✭✭kirving


    It's a completely reasonable scenario to expect, I don't see what's ridiculous in the slightest.

    There's a very good reason why prosthetic limbs cost what they do, and it's not all just profiteering by their manufacturers. I think it's borderline disingenuous, and giving false hope to the OP by boiling an incredibly complicated project down to "a small bit of soldering".

    Even the most basic of sensors and indicator light contraptions need to be guided by medical advice, so as not to risk prolonging the OP's recovery. I might sound negative, but I have enough experience of people thinking they can hack together solutions to problems which have real consequences to both businesses and people.

    As I said "you don't know what you don't know", and I squarely include myself in that. There is potential to make the OP's situation worse rather than better.





  • In fairness to denartha, who is well-meaning, the OP really just wants something very simple as a “practice device”, something denartha believes he may be able to help source or even help create and he is very good at electronic stuff.

    As others have said, simplicity is the key, so it need not necessarily be elaborate. Something for OP to demonstrate to himself the potential within his muscle, and to develop It as much as possible ahead of radical surgery.

    I just think a physio, who won’t charge more than about €70 per consultation, might be able to give one or two pointers as to what kind of thing to go for and above all what to avoid, to avoid disappointment.

    it is entirely possible that eventually OP may come to achieve more than he imagined, hence my example of the Belfast pilot. During its existence, FLYBE, an airline with a perfect safety record had a policy of employing able pilots “with a disability”, and in my own days of hobby flying I personally knew a pilot who was without use of a limb. There’s a paraplegic ex military pilot in Britain who flies himself around in his Piper Cub with wheelchair in back. Many more examples. People with apparent limitations can potentially achieve a heck of a lot.

    OP suffered what can only be described as a catastrophic life event; that’s enough cr@p in anyone’s life. People, with all the goodwill in the world, really need to go the full 9 yards to follow-through with any practical offers of help. My experience in life is that people have made many pledges that are not fulfilled and one can end up feeling seriously let down. Not good for the mental health.

    Post edited by [Deleted User] on


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 259 ✭✭pummice


    there is a small company n cork that make limbs for doctors, maybe they could point you in the right direction?





  • I’m guessing the limbs you speak of here are ones to practice administering needles into etc. Such would not be suitable. They are available on Amazon etc.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 259 ✭✭pummice


    kennedy prosthetic and orthodaedic. Maybe they could help or point you in the right direction



  • Advertisement


  • An interesting article from The Examiner about someone who was fundraising for an advanced bionic arm.


    Ottobock is the clinic mentioned in the article which supplies those devices.

    A Gofundme route might be a way to go if OP considered it.






  • Came across an article possibly relating to OP’s, hopefully forthcoming surgery in Vienna. It’s quite technical, but interestingly elaborates on the electrode placement, nerves, rehabilitation. It demonstrates the complexity of the subject which requires a collaboration of medical, engineering & rehabilitation expertise. Therefore I think if a temporary practice device is to be created it would have to be at least guided by notes from a physiotherapist who would know what might be helpful and what would be a complete waste of time. There’s be some better basis to work from.




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,275 ✭✭✭✭banie01


    @Finnrocco

    1st off sorry to read about your injury, but very inspired to see how you are approaching it.

    I have a Wanhao D9 MK2 with a 400mm³ build volume. I'd be happy to place it at your disposal to print off any G-code or .STL you come up with?

    Have a range of filament available too. There is no charge whatsoever, for time or materials. If I can help you out just drop me a PM.

    I cant help with design, for 2 reasons. I'm crap at it 😉 and time is a pressure for me.

    If you are in the Limerick area? I'd be happy to meet up and even have you over to manage your prints yourself.

    If I can help? Drop me a PM and let's get to it.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 812 ✭✭✭CreadanLady


    Can an MOD lock this thread. It is just rediculous.

    We have an exasperated and desperate OP coming on here looking for someone to knock him up a "basic" prothetic limb as a nixer or pro-bono. And people are entertaining it by discussing it saying go here, go there, contact this crowd and that crowd and possibly getting his hopes up only to be disappointed. This is nonsese. Any engineer here worth their salt should not touch this or even get drawn into discussion on it. It is not ethical to entertain this sort of thing.


    At the end of the day, a random stangers on an internet forum is not the place to be procuring DIY style medical devices or prosthetics.

    THE OPS NEEDS TO DISCUSS THEIR TREATMENT WITH HIS GP AND WHATEVER MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS ARE TREATING HIM.

    And I have come to the conclusion that if the OP were actually serious about it, they would be doing the above and not pissing about with strangers on a forum.

    <\THREAD>

    The MFV Creadan Lady is a mussel dredger from Dunmore East.



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 812 ✭✭✭CreadanLady


    If you are a professional engineer then you are on very thin ice if anything goes wrong. Check yourself before you wreck your career mate.

    The MFV Creadan Lady is a mussel dredger from Dunmore East.





  • I imagine he has, for some reason, fallen between two non-communicating medical teams, one in Dublin, the other in Vienna, and at the end of his tether. A neighbour suffered loss of the use of his arm many decades ago in an accident and has been living with it in a sling ever since. I suspect we are not yet great at offering orthopaedic solutions for such cases in this country, so in desperation the OP sought expertise abroad. Unfortunately teams in these scenarios sometimes have minimum cooperation, the exceptions having been transplants prior to Ireland offering most transplant surgeries here.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,125 ✭✭✭kirving


    Your offer, while well intentioned, is I'll advised to say the least. To be blunt, you are wholly unqualified to be offering a medical device to a stranger on the internet.

    Are you prepared to assume full liability if the 3D printed arm , which you haven't designed, breaks while the OP is holding a cup of coffee next to a toddler?

    Are you prepared to compensate the OP if the 3D printed arm, which you haven't designed, causes excessive pressure on a nerve and slows their recovery?


    In my experience, the least experienced engineers tend to let their own ego get the better of them and believe that they can solve all of the worlds problems. The issue is that they don't even know what they don't know about a particular subject. The mode experienced engineers know when to stop and are brave enough to hand over to a professional in that specific area.

    You can't just hack together a half solution to a serious medical problem.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,275 ✭✭✭✭banie01


    Point out where I've offered medical advice or a device?

    Further no design or engineering assistance was offered, indeed it was specifically excluded.

    I offered to provide a printer for the OP to use, anything he prints or has printed is his call.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,125 ✭✭✭kirving


    You're offering a tool to build a medical device. Like it or not, it's your responsibility to ensure that it has the capability to build to a the required specification (which we don't have).

    I'm genuinely not trying to be a smart arse here. If you were to offer your printer to build a medical device, you are leaving yourself open to the consequences if it goes wrong.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,495 ✭✭✭Markus Antonius


    I'm a medical device engineer and this is complete b*llox. Don't listen to him/her OP. Your job/reputation is only at stake if you are doing the task using company equipment or doing the work under the pretense that it is on the company's behalf.

    Anything you do outside the 9-5 is none of anyone's business.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 23,686 ✭✭✭✭mickdw


    Well to be fair, if a medical device professional did a nixer in producing a professional medical device that was defective, it is reasonable to hold them liable and they would be.

    This is a different scenario.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,495 ✭✭✭Markus Antonius


    That goes for anything though. If you got your car serviced by a lad down the road would you sue him if you crashed? If you got your neighbor to hang a mirror and fell smashed and cut your foot, would you sue your neighbor?

    As someone said above, we're not medical professionals doing black market kidney transplants on the side.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,495 ✭✭✭Markus Antonius


    I suggest getting in contact with your nearest university and ask them if a final year/masters engineering student would be interested in creating a bionic arm for the purposes of training as part of their final year project. This would be a great project for any engineering student.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,488 ✭✭✭Ryath


    Is everybody missing the point he won't be wearing this arm? He still has his arm he just has no use of it. There's no danger of him dropping pots of hot water on babies with it! Unless someone is offering to perform the amputation too!

    It's a training device for him to visually see a hand closing and opening and try and get some control of a particular muscle. He hasn't had use if his arm for several years, muscles are wasted and trying to contract a particular muscle when you can't use your hand would be very hard. The only parts connecting with your body I assume Fionn will be the electrodes stuck your on your arm where you still have some muscle function.

    I am surprised though you haven't got more support through your GP and Hospitals here though.

    Post edited by Ryath on


  • Advertisement
Advertisement