Here I am, there you are

Frank Bullitt

Finding myself in the midst of a existential crisis a bit here, so bear with me on this one.

Been living abroad for the past 8 years now, have had plenty of trips home over that with each trip feeling a bit different etc. As it was for everyone, the past 18 months or so have been tough. Travel was restricted and as a result, this was the longest stretch I went without getting home to see family or friends.

A lot has happened in that timeframe. Last year, my uncle passed away so I got one of those dreaded texts from home, one that I always feared. I was very close to him, he was my godfather so not being here to support my folks was ultra tough. Fast forward again, and I get the news that I chap I worked with during college also passed away, again very sad and even though I wasn't super close, the isolation I felt while away was tough.

I have since gotten back for a long overdue trip. I booked it last minute and I am beyond happy right now as I sit in the house with the folks, working while I am here, and just readjusting to life in Ireland after being away for so long.

I am in a 2.5 year relationship abroad, we are both not from the city that we live in, and it seems that recently this has become an issue for us. We talk about the future and where we could go etc, she visited her folks earlier this summer and I came over. I gave her a lot of space while she was there but that hasn't really been the case while I am here. Quite a lot of texting, questions, wanting video calls, and it has been interrupting my trip to the point of it almost being ruined. During my trip, my anxiety was really high as the days counted down to me going back to Canada. I contacted Expedia and I was able to change my flight, at no extra cost, to stay until next Wednesday. This really was something that made me happy and I felt a huge relief lift. The GF didn't take too kindly to it, as I will not be there for her birthday next week, but I explained clearly that I felt I needed to stay and be with family, and going back on the original date wouldn't have done me much good for my emotions. I was really clear and wrote everything out so I wouldn't trip over my words or say something wrong or off. That didn't seem to do much good, and I got the "this will take a long time for me to get over" and "I would never do this to you", there were a few other comments that implied a guilt trip for a while also.

Our relationship hasn't been the best for the past few months. My homesickness has gotten in the way of us progressing in her eyes, and it has boiled over into arguments about moving in, getting a dog, marriage and leaving the city we are in. Her reaction to me staying a while longer has left a bit of a dark shadow on how I feel right now about the relationship and her, I have told a few friends what she said and all responded with "that is a red flag mate, do you think moving in would be the best idea".

I am trying to unpack what I am asking here. I now feel really drawn home, I compare what I do in Canada and here, and there is very little difference now. I mainly do CrossFit, box and ride my motorbike, all of which i can do here. My career is now at a point where there is opportunity here and all over Europe for me, my current job is fully remote with staff here, so that is something i can benefit from.

I love my GF, but this trip and her actions and words have really left a mark. I am already dreading the cross examination I will get form her when I get back about who I was hanging out with etc, her insecurities really don't make for great conversations and that generally leads into an argument about the future and so forth. I have actually posted in here before anonymously about this, and all said to get out of that. The bad is offset by the good at times, but this trip home, the draw home, my career and so forth, it feels like I am at a crossroads. She has also said she wants to move back to her hometown next year, which I am really not sure as I know no one there, and I would be quite isolated in terms of friends and things I can do on my own.

I don't think it is the right time for me to commit to moving home to Ireland right now, this is my first trip back and I just want to enjoy it as best as I can. I can't, however, ignore the feelings I am getting while I am here.

Thanks for reading, you can find me in the spot between a rock and a hard place anytime.

Baybay

Many of us have evaluated relationships, family etc over the past eighteen months or so. Some are strengthened, some not. Some things come to an end, sad as that makes us feel, it may be for the best.

If a move to her hometown was to be a thing, would the cross fit, boxing & motorcycling that you could do here & in your current city be enough to sustain you while you settle in, get to know her friends?

Is her job or holiday entitlement enough for her to come here for a bit more than a holiday to evaluate what her life might be like in Ireland?

Only you know if either of those might be worth the effort. If not, maybe it’s time to call a halt. Heartbreaking & sad as that might be, would it be for your best, hers, both or neither?

Dial Hard

Setting aside the moving home thing for now, I think your priority should really be evaluating whether this relationship is right for you. The advice above of considering moving to her hometown etc. is putting the cart way before the horse, imo. Your girlfriend is insecure at best and controlling at worst. You already know you're going to be "punished" for your actions when you get home. That is not a healthy dynamic, imo. If you're questioning your relationship to the point that this is your second thread about it, I think you probably already have your answer, tbh.

Figure out what you need/want to do here first. Then worry about moving home if it's still something you think you want to pursue.

Tork

I'd break this down into two parts.

1. What to do about your relationship
2. Do you want to stay in Canada?

From what you're telling us here, your relationship sounds pretty terrible. A 2½ year relationship isn't something to throw away lightly but it doesn't seem to be bringing you much happiness. You should be looking forward to getting back to Canada to see your girlfriend, not feeling anxious and delaying a flight. You don't have much nice to say about her either and she sounds like somebody who's hard work. Added to that, you're going to be flying back fully expecting to be in the doghouse. What does that say about the sort of person she is? Basically, she is telling you who she is and I think you should listen. Are you sure you want to move in with her and all that follows.? It's going to be bloody hard to extricate yourself from this when you're living with her in her hometown. I think that comment about knowing nobody there is a red herring - you've already crossed the Atlantic and moved to a city where you didn't know anybody. I'd put more stock in what your friends are telling you, rather than strangers on the internet. I think your gut is screaming at you that this is not the relationship for you and the happiness of being at home has brought this into sharp contrast. I think she senses you have doubts and that might be feeling into her insecurity and desire to pin you down. On that, be very careful she doesn't "accidentally" become pregnant and tie you to Canada.

Homesickness also seems to be a constant in your life. This isn't just a new thing by the looks of things. Did you post a long time ago about your doubts about being in Canada, by any chance? I remember a thread by some guy who was a motorcycle enthusiast who was unsettled over there. Maybe it is time you asked yourself what it is you're gaining by being in Canada and took stock of where your life is going. Living abroad forever - which is on the cards here - isn't for everybody. Maybe you have outgrown living abroad and it is no longer a good fit for you. Even if you came back to Ireland and didn't like it, you could always go back to Canada. You are in the fortunate position of being able to live in different locations.

First though, I think you've got to get yourself out of this relationship and take your time about what to do after that.

Frank Bullitt

Thanks lads.

The waves of dread about leaving Ireland, again, are pretty severe this time and they are coming in strong as well. I think some of it might be PTSD from know that when I was here last, it was the last time I saw my uncle, and that is playing tricks on me a tad.

I have a lot to think on, my GF can be the best in the world at times, and then just say something that almost undoes it for me. I have second guessed myself a tonne as well with my actions and if I am living up to her expectations, or if it just means that we are not compatible. There is love, but sometimes you need that extra bit.

I am trying to take t day by day. My anxiety is really high, so it might be a case of seeing a counsellor when I get back to Canada.

One positive thing, I will be booking my flights at Christmas as soon as I get back.

Tork

Did you experience anxiety before you moved to Canada?

Dial Hard

OP, I'm going to say something to you that should be really obvious to everyone, but very often isn't: love isn't enough. Neither is "some" good stuff/times. They're the bare minimum. Any relationship worth talking about should be absolutely chock-full of all that good stuff, to the point where it shouldn't even be worth mentioning because it should 100% go without saying.

To *anyone* reading, if you ever find yourself in a relationship where you're using a qualifier to say that it's not all bad, then just get the fcuk out, seriously. No relationship is perfect, obviously, but there should be waaaaay more good than bad and if there's not, then honestly, you know what you need to do.

Hi OP, I met my last boyfriend overseas. He is not from Ireland and we were in a third country. We spent a year and a half together there. I was very happy there, not so homesick, but he would be very sad when he came back from his home country. He had a lot more family and responsibility there then I do here. Anyway, the point is, I knew how he felt. I would do everything I could to help him, make him feel better, take his mind of things etc. If he needed to stay home for extra days, I understood completely.

I never ever felt jealous or insecure, I never once questioned him about what he was doing! We had normal conversations and if he or I were too busy or had something on, we talked the next day.

I think this is how it should be. You shouldn't feel anxious about telling your girlfriend something and you should support each other. I really could not deal with an interrogation from the person who is supposed to be on your side.

I think the question about living in Canada and your relationship are two different questions you need to sort out.

Tork

Also OP, a lot of your relationship has been lived under unnatural conditions. I don't know what restrictions were like in Canada but I'm sure you spent quite a lot of it being 'locked up' to a certain extent. So in other words, there weren't many opportunities for you to be away from your girlfriend for long. When you got the chance to finally see your family again, you got to see this unpleasant part of her personality in a big way. It has always been there but it was manageable or you ignored it.

Your uncle's death has obviously hit you hard but I fear you are using the aftermath of those grief to paper over the cracks of what is really going on here. My guess is that your gut is screaming at you that you're flying back to something you don't want. You just don't want to admit it because of what it will unleash. You should break up with your girlfriend ASAP but I'm not convinced you will. You are making up excuses and talking yourself into staying. I hope for your sake that the therapist you talk to in Canada challenges you on this and teases it out. If you're someone with a tendency to be anxious, then she's an even worse partner to have. She's not helping or understanding it. Instead, she's making it worse.

Frank Bullitt

Thanks for the comments.

A lot of them are ringing true to me, as painful as they are.

@Tork It was indeed me a few years ago that posted in here. I did actually try to move back to Ireland for a stint, but I moved back to Canada after 8 months. On reflection, I moved back on a whim and without a real plan, I also moved at Christmas which was a big mistake when I look back at it.

On this current trip, I am back 2 weeks, i leave on Wednesday but honestly, this trip has been eye opening. Other than the over-the-top drinking that comes after a long time without good Guinness, I have been dong what I would be doing over in Canada. My lifestyle is very middle of the road in that I don't have exclusive pastimes in Canada like snowboarding, crazy outdoor adventure and so on. I will say also, my move back to Canada 3 years ago sent my career in a great direction and I am reaping the rewards for that now.

On the relationship note, I can't shift the dread of some reactions that may or may not happen, I guess even thinking like that isn't a good sign though...I really find myself in a tough spot, but then there is a 3rd person view that I get that says "she probably knows, in her heart of hearts, that we are on the rocks".

It does sound like I have 2 big hills to climb for my life right now, the relationship hill and the life hill. You never really get prepared for how different your life looks once you are away for a certain amount of time, but here I am (probably in a relatively good position) but I am not 100% happy at all.

I appreciate the honesty in here too, I am only giving a snapshot of what is going on but you all seem to be on the ball with it.

Tork

In the position you're in, you can move or not move at any time. There is no set timetable or deadline for it really. That is something you can process later and make a decision on. Far more urgent is your relationship. Your girlfriend is pressing hard for commitment and I think that's cranking up the anxiety in you. She has a future all mapped out and that entails moving back to her locality and settling down. If that isn't what you want, then you've got to bail out before it gets hard to walk away. Before you get attached to the dog or get even more worried about breaking her heart. Or worse still, she has your child. I think the latter is a very real threat by the way.

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117932707#Comment_117932707

You aren't the first to say this to me...😕

Frank Bullitt

Just as a note of interest, I was meant to fly back to Canada but I delayed it until Wednesday. The ol anxiety is up today big time

Tork

If your were to split from your girlfriend would you be lonely?

Is there anybody you can talk to today or in the next few days? A family member or friend? Or someone from your job's employee assistance program (if they have one). Perhaps you could organise something over Zoom?

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117933532#Comment_117933532

There are, I have one friend who I have been talking with who has been very supportive in all of this, I should talk to them more often.

Tork

You should. You're obviously very stressed and confused at the moment. Talking this out with someone will calm some of those thoughts that are bouncing around in your brain at the moment.

Jim2007

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117930244#Comment_117930244

After eight years if you still call Ireland home and consoling yourself with the thought of booking at 'trip home' at Christmas, perhaps it is time to go home! If you have not made a life for yourself there and feel at home there, what has been stopping you? Eight years in a transient state is too long, it's impacting your happiness and your relationships.

For me, I will always maintain contacts with Ireland, nice to visit from time to time etc, but it is not home, it has not been for a very long time now. After the second week in Ireland, I'm happy to be going home and landing at Zurich airport always makes me feel I'm coming home. When I'm abroad if I hear someone speaking Swiss-German, that reminds me of home, not an Irish accent. And that is as it needs to be if you are going to make a live for yourself outside Ireland.

I've seen it before with people, they spend their entire time in some kind of suspended state - not making a life for themselves where they are, while at the same time seeing their old Irish live slowly disappear with the passing of time. And in the end they are not happy in either place.... You need to make a commitment to one or the other and go with it. Otherwise I don't think you will be happy.

And I can understand your partners position, it is very hard to build a stable relationship with some who is not even committed to the country where they live. And if she was my daughter I'd be telling her to cut you loose - if you don't know what you want after eight years......

You can't go on living as you are in some kind of suspended state and expect her to continue putting up with it. You need to decide what you want and then commit to it.

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117934334#Comment_117934334

Thanks for this.

My original plan was for 1 year in Canada, and that has turned into 8 years now.

My partner as well, after her trip home recently, her tone seems to be very similar to mine now that I have enjoyed some time in Ireland. It may well be the case that we both just want something different for our lives. Even today, my Ma asked "so...what do you actually have in common", not that you need to be doing the same thing all the time, but there are gaps of course.

You are right that my happiness has been on been impacted a lot. Outside of the home stuff, there has been other stuff that has had us arguing, so I think this trip home has made me reflect on some of our conversations more recently. When I told her I was staying longer, she responded with "I would never do that to you" followed by "It will take me some time to get over this". Those comments felt a bit red flag to me.

Tork

For what it's worth - and this is all guesswork - I think you've reached the point in your life where you want to come home for good. You're muddying the waters because you have a girlfriend there and Canada seems to have been good for your career. You possibly have built some of your status around being an Irishman in Canada. But to me, you don't sound like somebody who wants to settle there permanently. Coming back to Ireland won't solve all your problems but I think you're making yourself extra miserable by staying away. You really need to get to the bottom of why you're so anxious about going back to Canada. You haven't figured it out yet but there is something very wrong with your current life. Is it your self-imposed exile in Canada? Is it your girlfriend? Do you miss your family when you travel back? My suspicion is that aside from the problems in this relationship, your girlfriend is the personification of something you don't want. Permanent settlement in Canada, with the return to Ireland option off the menu.

I agree with a lot of what Jim2007 said above about not fully committing to your home abroad and the transient existence but I've been putting more emphasis on your relationship. I think that is the first thing that needs to be dealt with, and soon. I consider it to be a ticking timebomb and you need to think very long and hard about where that is going. Aside from that risk of her "accidentally" becoming pregnant and making your mind up for you, you're wasting her time. Maybe setting her free and giving her the chance to meet somebody better suited to her is the kindest thing to do for you both.

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117938287#Comment_117938287

Thanks again.

Have taken the last few days to think on a lot, and met some friends to chat as well.

Plenty to digest, and it is very tough when you consider all of what is going on.

rainbowtrout

If she decided to bite the bullet (no pun intended!) and rang you tonight and said 'It's not working, I want to end the relationship' how would you feel? Sad? Lonely? Regret? Relief?

As most posters have said, there are two issues: the return (or not) to Ireland and the relationship with your girlfriend:

Can you see yourself being happy in the longterm with your girlfriend whether that be in Canada or Ireland?

If the relationship does come to an end, would you stay in Canada?

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117946859#Comment_117946859

Well, after the last few days, I think relief would be the feeling.

Things have really taken a turn during my trip home, and through talking to friends here (as recommended by a few posters here), a few have said I am in an abusive relationship.

Now, not for one minute did I think i was in one, but the last day or so has shown that to be maybe the case. I won't go into the extreme details, but she was upset about me not calling, began to tell me never had intention to (I did, and did call later that evening), it escalated to some verbal abuse, anger, blaming me and so on, then turned to excuses as to why etc, and has no settled into the calmer phase. This was pointed out to me as being the cycle of abuse.

I also was more open with my folks about it over dinner last night, and after explaining a few details of some incidents over the past few months, my mother said "Ah no, son, you have to look after yourself here". I almost cried hearing that.

So now, I am checked into my flight back tomorrow, sitting in panic, confusion, anger, sadness, all of it. I have a tough time ahead of me I think...

Still stihl waters 3

To be blunt, get rid, go back to Canada with the intention to move back home within a time frame comfortable for yourself, good luck with whatever do

Baybay

A tough time indeed. But better now than later.

Once the decision is made, you’re free to decide what’s for you going forward. Whether that’s booking another flight home for as soon as you’ve packed your stuff up or apartment hunting etc. And it’ll have downsides too no doubt. Maybe regrets but I think you saw the writing on the wall when you first posted. Telling your family was a big step towards realisation, I think.

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117949651#Comment_117949651

Already looking at flights.

There is a wedding coming up as well, so I probably have to act fast on that front. I legit feel terrible for even having these thoughts, but I can't get over how I have felt over the last few days.

Tell me how

If the conversation with your GF touches on what your thought process was and what made you change your mind etc. I'd go easy with the part about a lot of people on the internet advising you to do this. ;)

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117949945#Comment_117949945

I will probably skip over that part, just to be safe.

Tork

Frank, if you think you're in an abusive relationship and decide to leave it, be very careful what you say to your girlfriend. Do the groundwork for your split in the background and don't give her a heads up that you're thinking of leaving. That'll give her too much scope to escalate things, manipulate you or "forget" to take the pill. She really doesn't need to know that you've been talking to people on boards or your friends or your mum. That'll just open up the lines of communication and make it harder for you to leave. You need to present the break-up as a done deal and something that's non-negotiable.

rainbowtrout

Also, no decisions have to be made instantly. I guess the first thing is that it is likely from the sounds of it that you will get a frosty reception on your return. How things pan out with your girlfriend after that is your decision. It's not something to be passive about and just go along with for a quiet life. Assess how you feel about her and the relationship and if you decide to stay with her how things might pan out in the future.

If things do go pear shaped and you break up with her, then you can take time to assess the staying in Canada/move to Ireland and how it leaves you work wise which will probably be the biggest change in all of it. It will be easier to make decisions when there is an end goal in sight.

bitofabind

Hey OP. I went to Canada "for a year" too, stayed for four. After that I went to London "for a while", I recently returned home after seven years.

My body was screaming at me after a few years abroad. Huge emotions and sadness on flights back, dreams of home, "home" never became anywhere but Ireland and that was loud and clear in how I lived my life. Renting instead of buying in the UK, despite great financial success and surpassing the age where friends were settling down and buying their own homes. Every moment of joy in my life was tied to a family wedding or event back in Ireland. But I lied to myself about how "happy" I was because - great exciting job, great income, living in a lovely part of the city, sure doesn't everyone think I'm great. It's similar to what Jim said upthread - there's a real impact on your health and happiness when you're this transient and not progressing similarly to those around you, who have put roots down and gotten on with their lives.

And there's a real impact on the people in your life too. To any man I met, I presented uncertainty, almost unavailability in a way. Because they knew I'd drop it all to be "at home" in the morning if I needed to. For all your girlfriend's issues, this is probably the trait in you that is provoking her the most. Your non-committal, indecisive, not-knowing-what-you-want vibe is ratcheting up the insecurities in her. Because she knows that you don't want to be there, she's just refusing to acknowledge that consciously because it will mean a breakup. Having a relationship with someone who doesn't know what they want is the loneliest place to be.

It's time to sit down and make some hard decisions, OP. Think about your uncle. Life is short. You don't get to re-do all of this. And doing nothing - is very much a choice. And I'll tell you from the other side - "coming home" is not easy, not for one second. I've mostly lived abroad as an adult and have had to learn a new social code, a new way of interaction, a new jobs market, I've had to deal with a lot of mixed emotions and uncertainty. Because change is hard. But the difference is - this time i feel connected to the country I live in, I identify it as "home", and I know that every hard decision is leading me to a beautiful new life in my true home.

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/117954549#Comment_117954549

I can relate to a lot of this.

There is no real chance of me ever buying in Canada due to the insane prices. I am in Vancouver, you are all free to get a laugh out of the prices here. But I get what you are getting at.

I do find I have less friends here now, there has been a lot of leaving lately of people I have known since I have lived here, some back to Ireland, and some to other parts of Canada and the province. That has had an impact on me lately, and I can see it more and more.

You are probably right as well with the traits my GF has/is displaying. There is that mixed with just how I am, she has made comments about me not being sentimental enough, or lovey dovey enough etc, I am who I am but those passing comments make me second guess who I am or who I should be a lot of the time.

The time for hard decisions seems to be right here now, and I can't say I am looking forward to it in the slightest.

miamee

Hi Frank, it's a hard place to be alright. Maybe if you look at things from a slightly different perspective, it will help you to make a decision. She wants certain things, a lovely dovey man who is sentimental and who misses her desperately when not together, enough to be messaging her or video calling all the time. She deserves to have all of those things that she wants. But if being 'lovey dovey' or overly sentimental doesn't come naturally to you then you are not the right person for her. She deserves someone else who will give her all of those things.

And it goes without saying that equally you deserve a woman who suits you too and brings what you need to a relationship.

PoisonIvyBelle

I remember your posts a few years ago, I'm sorry to hear you're still feeling confused about it all.

I'd be inclined to go easy on your GF, from another POV.

My thoughts on it are:

• You've been with your GF over 2 years, so I'd assume she hasn't been abusive (emotionally?) since day 1? Do you know what changed that started that behaviour? Is anything going on with her that could be causing the change in attitude?
• Is she actually being abusive when you think about it yourself as someone who is with her daily, and not your friends or your Ma who hear about it second-hand?
• Is it possible that she is anxious about you delaying your flight back because she gets the vibe off you that you're not happy there and is guessing you don't want to come back?

In terms of whether you should come back to Ireland, I think you should if you're still thinking about it years later. However, it would seem the natural and fair thing to include your GF in that thought process and make a plan with her, e.g. does she come back with you, do you break up, what are the options? The fact that you're not doing that says alot. I think you've really already decided she isn't "it" for you and she's feeling that from you, hence the behaviour.

Tell me how

Just as an aside, I think the perception that the OP's girlfriend is abusive is going a bit too far. Wanting to know where you stand 2.5 years in to a relationship or being upset because your partner changed their return flight meaning that they wouldn't be around for your birthday don't sound excessive or abusive to me.

She's not likely to be reading this, but still.

Tork

To be fair, it's the OP himself who brought up the possibility that he might be in an abusive relationship. It didn't come from anybody here - it came from conversations he had with his own friends. None of us can say for sure if the relationship is that bad because we're only going on what he has told us. Having said that, to our knowledge he has now started two threads about this relationship in recent times. Is the girlfriend abusive? Who knows? What seems to be clear is that it isn't a good relationship for either of them and it's making them both anxious in different ways. When a relationship is hard work like this, you've got to ask is it worth it?

Frank Bullitt

Well...here I am, again.

It has only been 2 months or so since I last posted in here, there has been some change but also not.

Both myself and the OH have had some serious conversations over the past while, but the circle of things seems to be still there. There will be tension, it will spill over, we talk about and then there is a honeymoon period. Rinse and repeat.

I have now had more close friends tell me they are worried about it, and I can't tell you how hard it is to hear that, especially from people who you just wouldn't expect it from too.

More recently, I have been to another counsellor and he specialises in my kind of situation. I openly asked him if moving in together would help solve some of the issue and he flat out said no, it would only make it worse. I have another booked for when I get back as well.

I sit here in Dublin, and the other big issue now is how covid is causing havoc across everyones life and Xmas plans. It has hit me hard again, thinking that it might be another stint after this before I can come home. This has, again, got me thinking about moving home fully to Ireland. I do now really see a life for me here, my hobbies and career are all readily available here for me now, and with the relationship being how it is, it is really hard to just not want to do it next year.

Not really sure what I am posting this for, it is an awful update of sorts, but I find it is worthy to vent a little bit here.

Big Bag of Chips

It really sounds like you are trying to convince everyone else that coming back is the right decision for you. You don't need to convince anyone of anything. You just have to make the right decision for yourself. Your gf, if you break up, will be fine. She had a life before you, she will survive after you. Being considerate of others and taking other's feelings, circumstances and situations into account is a noble thing. But sometimes it is ok to be completely selfish and to make the decision that is best for you.

Can you see yourself married, living together, raising a family and retiring happily in old age together? What you have with her now is what you will still have in 20 years time - only add in extra life stresses, mortgage, bills, responsibilities, ill health, children, teenagers etc. If you're not a strong unit now then you either won't last the distance, or you will just make the journey miserable for everyone you bring along on it with you.

I think it's decision time.

Family > Girlfriend

Honestly, reading your post it sounds like you want to come home. Do what's best for you.

LilacNails

Op, you sound way too good for this person. Read over the thread again, and again after that and ask yourself what advice would you give to your best friend.

I feel you need to move on, she does not to appreciate or listen to you.

Its a crap time of year for a break up, but when is there a good time? You need a fresh clean break, and sounds as though you need to be around your family and friends more, they have your back and by the sounds of it your gf does not.

Tork

Frank, nobody can make this decision for you but you're going to have to decide on something soon for everybody's sake. I'd say you're driving everyone in your life up the walls and frustrating some. You're long on talk and short on decision making. You're going to have to piss or get off the pot at some stage. The question is, how long have you been on the pot now? I'm not really sure how much advice you are actually taking on board either. I'm starting to wonder are you doing all this talking as a way of pushing away the decisions you have to make.

Months ago, people on this thread told you much what your therapist did - do not move in with your girlfriend. I'm sure people around you have been giving you similar advice. Yet still you went along to that therapist as if none of this advice had been given before, still believing that moving in with your girlfriend will magic away the obvious problems you're having. Looking back over this thread, I don't think there is much more that can be added to the advice already given. You're stuck and dithering. I'm not sure how much progress you have made since you started this thread.

While I'm not a fan of your girlfriend, going by what you've written, I have some sympathy for her. It's infuriating to be with somebody who has one eye on the door. She has her life plans and you're not fully on board with them. If you don't see a long-term future with her, staying together is wasting everybody's time. Especially hers if she wants to have a family.

It's your decision to make, of course, but I think there is something to be read into your track record. Despite being in Canada for several years, you have never broken your ties with home in the way that somebody living abroad needs to do. Apart from your girlfriend, what's keeping you there? At a guess, a lot of your self-identity and self-worth is built around being Mr Successful over in Canada and you don't want to lose that status. Is it your ego that's keeping you in Canada? You don't sound like somebody who's at peace with settling there permanently. So what, apart from your girlfriend, is keeping you there?

You can have a good life in lots of countries if you put your mind to it. Problem is, you've plonked yourself firmly on the fence. You're keeping your options open, making no decisions and driving yourself crazy. This has already been covered very effectively upthread by BitofaBind and Jim2007. You should read and re-read what they wrote because they've hit a lot of nails on the head regarding the experience of an Irish person person abroad.

What makes you think that continuing with this troubled relationship or living in Canada will bring you peace? Neither have brought you peace so far, have they? You've started numerous threads on both and both are tormenting you in different ways. Do you really think that things will change? If something doesn't happen easily or naturally, how do you see that changing into the future? You're in a relationship that's turbulent, and that's before complications like mortgages or kids or other issues come along. You're very attached to home and seem to think a lot about when you can come back again. If you had a friend telling you this story, what would you tell them?

You still have two big decisions to make and have conflated the two in your mind. If you decide to split from your girlfriend, it doesn't mean you have to take the next plane home. You can still stay in Canada and decide on where you want to settle at any time. But sort that relationship issue of yours sooner rather than later.

Frank Bullitt

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/118351663#Comment_118351663

You’re right.

Being on the fence isn’t right, and I’ve attached an awful lot of my identity on being abroad. I’ve built a strong career and so on in Canada, now that’s changed with the current situation of covid and my career is really global.

Me not wanting to hurt someone does actually hurt them, putting it off does nothing to help anyone, and it’s high time I realise that.

I appreciate all the feedback and help.

You won’t hear from me from here on out unless I have real news.

Tork

Frank, don't let my comments put you off posting here ☺️ You're clearly suffering horribly with these huge decisions you have to make and if posting here helps, keep doing that. Only you can know if this thread is helping or has become a way of avoiding big decisions.

bitofabind

Hey Frank. I can see both sides of this. The complexities and emotionally difficulties of the big life decisions you need to make. And the "sh1t or get off the pot" side of it too. This isn't a new problem that you have. You've been talking about it and making excuses to not take action for years.

The way I see it: life is hard. Change comes with a lot of discomfort, instability, loss and grief. We humans hate the unknown, so even though it's "home", coming back to Ireland would carry some risk with it too. Your brain can't compute that and you're getting paralysis by analysis. Maybe it's better the devil you know. But what's harder than that, is ignoring your own gut instincts. That comes with consequences. BIG consequences, for you and the people you love. Not acting now, spells out greater loss, regret and grief in the longer term.

I'm speaking as someone who made the big life decision six months ago, when I moved home to Ireland. It's been hard, between all the admin type stuff (setting up a bank account, huge tax issues, car insurance, new job and all the hardship that comes with getting onboarded, shipment delayed by Covid) and the emotional stuff (goodbye to my closest friends, and a job that was my life for a long time, getting used to no longer living abroad, the "new identity" stuff). I've gone through a period of grief and loss too, and I still get upset sometimes when I get the memories of my life abroad, the good times, the opportunities, the friendships, the incredible privilege of it all.

But the reckoning, for me, came during the pandemic, when I was 6 months into therapy and realising that this "great life abroad" stuff was coming at the cost of my own happiness, peace of mind, my family relationships, my closest friendships, my own personal values of freedom and integrity and at the cost of me feeling like I was actually living life on my own terms, as opposed to passively going along with things and "I've made my bed and now I'll lie in it" about my life overseas.

You get to choose your own life. And in this case, you also have to choose which version of "hard" you want to have. For me, knowing what I know now, I'd do it all again in the morning. Because I want the version of hardship that puts me in the driver seat of my own life, where I can feel like I'm making an active choice in my future, and if it doesn't work out - well, at least I've answered a few questions that would've plagued me for a lifetime. This decision is reversible. But time isn't. Time doesn't stop while you ponder these things - and it just makes the decision harder, ultimately.

So the question you might need to ask yourself and discuss with your therapist is: what do you need to be able to move forward here? What does life look like, if you don't take action?