Relaxation of Restrictions, Part V - **Read OP for Mod Warnings**

Ginger n Lemon

FintanMcluskey wrote: »

Is there a correlation between mask wearing and low case numbers?

No.

The more mask wearing, the more new cases we get. Simple stuff. People dont socially distance when wearing the mask. They also dont tend to wash it daily or change it daily.

And then protesters get called "loons" lol.

ThunbergsAreGo

_Kaiser_ wrote: »

It's pretty obvious why this is Jac - the Government/HSE have squandered the time bought in the late spring/summer by falling numbers that they should have been using to build up capacity in the system for the autumn/winter.

Instead, the healthcare system is the same shambles it is every winter and so they're panicking that they won't be able to handler even a modest CV-19 demand on top of the usual winter demands.

Thus, better to blame students, people gathering at home, protesters.. anyone except themselves!

100% - this is in the HSE. Almost 20% of our budget (pre-covid), overruns every year and poor capacity.

Flatten the curve, give our healthcare system time (to do absolutely nothing)!

BobMc

_Kaiser_ wrote: »

Pat Kenny seems to be mad keen for fines and sanctioning people here on NT today. I think maybe he feels a bit vulnerable himself? His current guest (Jim O'Callaghan) at least trying to talk sense.

the guards cant seem to issue fines etc. for some serious traffic offences at the best of times, where will they get time or want to enforce Covid Reg. even
if fines issued will they just be ingnored and chased after, pointless unless its going to be a detterent

drunkmonkey

FintanMcluskey wrote: »

Is there a correlation between mask wearing and low case numbers?

Oh Jesus don't start, masks went on numbers went up even before the schools opened, we were warned by Government experts it could happen and it did.
Even Tony was worried about it, they've extended the masks on public transport until November they haven't extended the one in retail yet it expired today. We can free breathe for a few hours.

_Kaiser_

BobMc wrote: »

the guards cant seem to issue fines etc. for some serious traffic offences at the best of times, where will they get time or want to enforce Covid Reg. even
if fines issued will they just be ingnored and chased after, pointless unless its going to be a detterent

The Gardai (rightly in my view) don't want more enforcement powers on this one per Drew Harris recently. I have to say he's turning out to be a great appointment, especially after his 2 predecessors!

As I said above, the real issue here is that the public are being blamed for the incompetence/waste in the HSE

average_runner

NPHET are just trying to frighten the people, at the moment we are not doing enough to stop the spread and its starting to get into the community, eventually it will spread into the vulnerable sections of society.

So I believe we have a month to get numbers down or then there will be a lockdown.

Its in our hands

average_runner

drunkmonkey wrote: »

Oh Jesus don't start, masks went on numbers went up even before the schools opened, we were warned by Government experts it could happen and it did.
Even Tony was worried about it, they've extended the masks on public transport until November they haven't extended the one in retail yet it expired today. We can free breathe for a few hours.

Shops can force you to wear masks today though.

Ginger n Lemon

average_runner wrote: »

NPHET are just trying to frighten the people, at the moment we are not doing enough to stop the spread and its starting to get into the community, eventually it will spread into the vulnerable sections of society.

So I believe we have a month to get numbers down or then there will be a lockdown.

Its in our hands

Uve been saying that for over 6 weeks now.... :rolleyes:

Ginger n Lemon

Ginger n Lemon wrote: »

The Irish National Teachers Organisation (INTO) has demanded an immediate review of whether is it safe for Ireland's schools to stay open.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40059548.html

What an embarrassment. Why do they "demand" that? Are schools closed in any other EU countries?

They are of course correct to call for this.

Its obvious we need immediate a strong action and the move to level 5 is the sensible move however the schools staying open is the elephant in the room, they should all be closed from tomorrow morning if we are serious about fighting back against this virus spread.

_Kaiser_

_Kaiser_ wrote: »

Neither Level 5 (point whatever!) nor fines are needed to sanction the overwhelming majority of people who are not at any real risk from this thing.

Those who are need to protect themselves, up to and including cocooning if their own situation warrants it. The rest of the population need to be let get on with things with as little interference as possible.

The damage to the economy, personal circumstances, mental health and indeed society as a whole (given the divisive impact this topic is having) is already bad enough without making things worse because those in charge are covering their mistakes or fearful because they (or those close to them) are in that most vulnerable group.

Exactly !

Ginger n Lemon

Grant Billions Bifocals wrote: »

They are of course correct to call for this.

Its obvious we need immediate a strong action and the move to level 5 is the sensible move however the schools staying open is the elephant in the room, they should all be closed from tomorrow morning if we are serious about fighting back against this virus spread.

Noxy I ve told you before this is not kung fu panda. You do not "fight the spread". You do not see the virus either.

You want social beings to become unsocial. Cuckoo land

average_runner

Ginger n Lemon wrote: »

Uve been saying that for over 6 weeks now.... :rolleyes:

Well NPHET has just said it now!! Lets hope I am right and they are bluffing.




I have been saying it but people are still stupid enough not to help stop the spread

average_runner

Ginger n Lemon wrote: »

Noxy I ve told you before this is not kung fu panda. You do not "fight the spread". You do not see the virus either.

You want social beings to become unsocial. Cuckoo land

Well pubs would be open if we had done more to stop the spread in Dublin

Ginger n Lemon

average_runner wrote: »

Well pubs would be open if we had done more to stop the spread in Dublin

New cases in July were in single digits.

Why didnt we reopen them pubs back then?

ThewhiteJesus

when are the pubs going to reopen in dublin ?

ThewhiteJesus

average_runner wrote: »

Well pubs would be open if we had done more to stop the spread in Dublin

i'm not so sure about that, but look we as a country are not very bright, look at the support for Sinn fein as an example, and if pubs are closed people have big house parties with no social distance so i think the pubs should be open personally and managed

Loafing Oaf

ThewhiteJesus wrote: »

when are the pubs going to reopen in dublin ?

Wouldn't be holding my breath.

Except if you've got the virus and you're a few inches away from somebody else's face...

Tenzor07

average_runner wrote: »

Well pubs would be open if we had done more to stop the spread in Dublin

Would they? Maybe we should have shut them down since March, all stayed at home for a couple of months so they could open....?



Oh wait... We all did...


The Pubs stayed shut!?!

Tenzor07

ThewhiteJesus wrote: »

i'm not so sure about that, but look we as a country are not very bright, look at the support for Sinn fein as an example, and if pubs are closed people have big house parties with no social distance so i think the pubs should be open personally and managed

but look we as a country are not very bright, look at the support for Fianna Fail as an example, the party that brought us multiple scandals, brought the Troika to Ireland and almost bankrupted the state out of existence... Now they are back in charge of the Covid response and Brexit!! :eek:

average_runner

Ginger n Lemon wrote: »

New cases in July were in single digits.

Why didnt we reopen them pubs back then?

Why aren't they open now in Dublin?

average_runner

Tenzor07 wrote: »

but look we as a country are not very bright, look at the support for Fianna Fail as an example, the party that brought us multiple scandals, brought the Troika to Ireland and almost bankrupted the state out of existence... Now they are back in charge of the Covid response and Brexit!! :eek:

Yep i agree, we aren't a very bright country. If we were we could do a Sweden

Ginger n Lemon

average_runner wrote: »

Why aren't they open now in Dublin?

Because of NPHET. And spineless MM

average_runner

Tenzor07 wrote: »

Would they? Maybe we should have shut them down since March, all stayed at home for a couple of months so they could open....?



Oh wait... We all did...


The Pubs stayed shut!?!

Not all pubs stayed shut, most were open in Dublin pretending to serve food.


Uncle Tom's, The Goat, PennyHill and Dropping Well are open now also.



And they opened up in all other counties.

average_runner

Ginger n Lemon wrote: »

Because of NPHET. And spineless MM

Nothing do with how the general public is behaving at all?


Everyone else fault except our own?

Ginger n Lemon

average_runner wrote: »

Nothing do with how the general public is behaving at all?


Everyone else fault except our own?

I am not sure if you follow.

In July new cases were in single digits.

Public was behaving.

Dublin pubs, in fact wet pubs across whole country DID NOT reopen.

Do you have a question about above? Or you thought public behaving well is the equivalent of 0 new cases daily for a period of X months before we consider re opening wet pubs?

Tenzor07

average_runner wrote: »

Why aren't they open now in Dublin?

I've been to Belgium, Luxembourg, Malta, all with Case rates higher than Ireland, possibly double...
...the pubs are open, you don't need to buy a €9 protection meal... We never opened ours in Dublin... if some stretched the rules by opening without having a kitchen then I'm sure the authorities were notified and took action.

robfowler78

[Deleted User] wrote: »

For whatever reasons, the government and NPHET clearly don’t want to give us the full picture.

We’ve had cases rising and rising since late July. How many people are actually sick though? Only 134 in hospital and 21 in ICU. Death rate is tiny.

People need to stop thinking that a positive swab = a sick person. Most have either no symptoms at all or extremely mild.

I don’t buy into conspiracies. I don’t believe the government or NPHET have any kind of motive. They are just inept and super conservative. Easier to just crash the country and blame Covid than actually do something.

If we put the politicians and NPHET on 300 a week, we’d quickly see how severe Covid really is. I imagine it would quickly become very easy for them to share how many people have no symptoms at all.

Spot on no one in the government or NPHET remotely effected by covid economic problems. We need some other voices to at least balance the debate. Is NPHET just medical people or are there any economists or buisness people involved. Also with all due respect to Tony he is a GP should someone more experienced with virus not be in charge?. I mean Dr Feeny had to resign because he disagreed with the government approach but if he is as equally qualified to give his opinion.

average_runner

Ginger n Lemon wrote: »

I am not sure if you follow.

In July new cases were in single digits.

Public was behaving.

Dublin pubs, in fact wet pubs across whole country DID NOT reopen.

Do you have a question about above? Or you thought public behaving well is the equivalent of 0 new cases daily for a period of X months before we consider re opening wet pubs?

Not sure you followed, my question was about now not July

awec

robfowler78 wrote: »

Spot on no one in the government or NPHET remotely effected by covid economic problems. We need some other voices to at least balance the debate. Is NPHET just medical people or are there any economists or buisness people involved. Also with all due respect to Tony he is a GP should someone more experienced with virus not be in charge?. I mean Dr Feeny had to resign because he disagreed with the government approach but if he is as equally qualified to give his opinion.

NPHET is just medical.

average_runner

Tenzor07 wrote: »

I've been to Belgium, Luxembourg, Malta, all with Case rates higher than Ireland, possibly double...
...the pubs are open, you don't need to buy a €9 protection meal... We never opened ours in Dublin... if some stretched the rules by opening without having a kitchen then I'm sure the authorities were notified and took action.

But most of the people in those countries don't behave like us with drink in us.