Boardsies Decide... TV's Greatest Action Kick Ass Crime Fighting Star Character

Necro

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger - my nom
Raylan Givens Justified
Batman Batman The Animated Series - my nom

That be it from me this round

Tauriel

Dylan Reinhart Instinct

Veronica Mars Veronica Mars

Erin Lindsay Chicago P.D.

John Watson Sherlock

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo

Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo

Abstaining from the others as I've never watched those shows

the purple tin

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse

Root Person of Interest

Matt Murdock Daredevil

Batman Batman The Animated Series

John Watson Sherlock

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo

Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo

Stella Gibson The Fall

Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

rainbowtrout

Round 3


Veronica Mars Veronica Mars Vs. Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse

Hercule Poirot Poirot Vs. Matt Murdock Daredevil


Oliver Queen Arrow Vs. John Watson Sherlock


Ben Matlock Matlock Vs. Lieutenant Columbo Columbo


Saga Norén The Bridge Vs. Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo


Stella Gibson The Fall Vs. Grace Hanadarko Saving Grace


Andri Olafsson Trapped Vs. Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

JP Liz V1

Round 2 Results Through

Vic Mackey The Shield

David Rossi Criminal Minds

Elliot Stabler Law and Order SVU

Sherlock Holmes Sherlock

Jessica Fletcher Murder She Wrote

Thomas Magnum Magnum, P.I.

Ted Hastings Line of Duty

Emma Peel The Avengers

Gil Grissom CSI

Joan Watson Elementary

Zaph

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse

John Watson Sherlock

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo

Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo (I never knew she had a surname)

Alfred Borden

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse
Root Person of Interest
Matt Murdock Daredevil
Batman Batman The Animated Series
Oliver Queen Arrow
Lieutenant Columbo Columbo
Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo
Stella Gibson The Fall

Round 3


Dylan Reinhart Instinct

Vs.

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger



Raylan Givens Justified

Vs.

Root Person of Interest



Ben Matlock Matlock

Vs.

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo



Andri Olafsson Trapped

Vs.

Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

quickbeam

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger - like a lot so far, I've never seen it, but know it's iconic enough to warrant going through
Veronica Mars Veronica Mars - meant to be good
Root Person of Interest - never seen Justified, but it's on my to watch list and I hate voting against Timothy Olyphant, but Root is just too good.
Hercule Poirot Poirot - David Suchet's version, I presume? The little grey cells tell me I should vote here
Pass
John Watson Sherlock - the hobbit is pretty good in this
Lieutenant Columbo Columbo - iconic (I think his name was Columbo Columbo there for a second!)
Saga Norén The Bridge - my nom, great show, great detective
Pass
Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes - never saw AtA. LoM was a bit overrated, but worth a first round vote at least.

pc7

Round 3

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger
Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse
Raylan Givens Justified
Hercule Poirot Poirot
John Watson Sherlock
Lieutenant Columbo Columbo
Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo

sKeith

Round 3


Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger


Veronica Mars Veronica Mars


Root Person of Interest


Matt Murdock Daredevil


Batman Batman The Animated Series


Oliver Queen Arrow


Lieutenant Columbo Columbo


Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo

duffman13

Round 3


Dylan Reinhart Instinct

Vs.

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger


Veronica Mars Veronica Mars

Vs.

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse


Raylan Givens Justified

Vs.

Root Person of Interest


Hercule Poirot Poirot

Vs.

Matt Murdock Daredevil







Ben Matlock Matlock

Vs.

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo




Andri Olafsson Trapped

Vs.

Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

Sawduck

Round 3
Veronica Mars Veronica Mars
Raylan Givens Justified
Matt Murdock Daredevil
Batman Batman The Animated Series
John Watson Sherlock
Lieutenant Columbo Columbo
Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo
Stella Gibson The Fall
Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

y0ssar1an22

Dylan Reinhart Instinct

Vs.

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger


Veronica Mars Veronica Mars

Vs.

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse


Raylan Givens Justified

Vs.

Root Person of Interest


Hercule Poirot Poirot

Vs.

Matt Murdock Daredevil


Batman Batman The Animated Series

Vs.

Erin Lindsay Chicago P.D.


Oliver Queen Arrow

Vs.

John Watson Sherlock


Ben Matlock Matlock

Vs.

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo


Saga Norén The Bridge

Vs.

Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo


Stella Gibson The Fall

Vs.

Grace Hanadarko Saving Grace


Andri Olafsson Trapped

Vs.

Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

few abstentions, cos ive seen neither

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger


Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse


Root Person of Interest


Hercule Poirot Poirot


John Watson Sherlock


Lieutenant Columbo Columbo

____________________________________________________________


I actually nominated Raylan Givens but I have to give Root the nod, brilliant character.

Capt'n Midnight

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse

Hercule Poirot Poirot

Batman Batman The Animated Series

John Watson Sherlock

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo

Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo

Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

JP Liz V1

Round 4


Frank Castle The Punisher

Vs.

Sam Waters Profiler


Cal Lightman Lie To Me

Vs.

Brenda Leigh Johnson The Closer


Theo Kojak Kojak

Vs.

Sterling Malory Archer aka Duchess Archer


Javier Peña Narcos

Vs.

Dean Winchester Supernatural


Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Vs.

Sharon Raydor Major Crimes


Laure Berthaud Spiral

Vs.

Kurt Wallander Wallander


Stephanie (Steve) Oskowski Father Dowling Mysteries

Vs.

Tom Mathias Hinterland


Lennie Briscoe Law & Order

Vs.

Vivian (Viv) Johnson Without a Trace


Lilly Rush Cold Case

Vs.

Agatino Catarella Inspector Montalbano


Lucas Hood Banshee

Vs.

Billy Butcher The Boys


John Luther Luther

Vs.

Seeley Booth Bones

Tauriel

Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Seeley Booth Bones

Alfred Borden

Frank Castle The Punisher
Javier Peña Narcos
Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Lennie Briscoe Law & Order
Lilly Rush Cold Case
Billy Butcher The Boys
John Luther Luther

Kojak - we still love ya baby !!!

Zaph

Theo Kojak Kojak

Javier Peña Narcos

Billy Butcher The Boys

the purple tin

Frank Castle The Punisher

Brenda Leigh Johnson The Closer

Theo Kojak Kojak

Dean Winchester Supernatural

Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Kurt Wallander Wallander

Stephanie (Steve) Oskowski Father Dowling Mysteries

Lennie Briscoe Law & Order

Agatino Catarella Inspector Montalbano

Lucas Hood Banshee

Seeley Booth Bones

Zaph

Zaph wrote: »

Theo Kojak Kojak

I love ya baby

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Frank Castle

Cal Lightman

Sterling Archer

Dean Winchester

Buffy Summers

Lennie Briscoe

Billy Butcher

Seeley Booth

***passing on the other ones as don't know either character***

Necro

Dean Winchester Supernatural - My nom
Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer - My nom
Lennie Briscoe Law & Order

JP Liz V1

Round 3 Results Through

Cordell Walker Walker Texas Ranger

Endeavour Morse Inspector Morse

Root Person of Interest

Hercule Poirot Poirot

Batman Batman The Animated Series

John Watson Sherlock

Lieutenant Columbo Columbo

Velma Dinkley Scooby Doo

Stella Gibson The Fall

Gene Hunt Life on Mars / Ashes to Ashes

Capt'n Midnight

Frank Castle The Punisher

Theo Kojak Kojak

Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Kurt Wallander Wallander

Stephanie (Steve) Oskowski Father Dowling Mysteries

Lennie Briscoe Law & Order

Agatino Catarella Inspector Montalbano

rainbowtrout

Round 4


Theo Kojak Kojak

Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Laure Berthaud Spiral

Tom Mathias Hinterland

John Luther Luther

Kojak

Buffy

pc7

Round 4
Dean Winchester Supernatural

Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slaye

Lucas Hood Banshee

(Can’t believe he was against Billy! But have to go for Lucas)

Necro

Missed Lucas Hood. Also voting him

quickbeam

Frank Castle The Punisher - never seen it, but the film is a guilty pleasure
Cal Lightman Lie To Me - because there's just something about Kyra Sedgwick that I don't like
Theo Kojak Kojak - because he's Kojak
Dean Winchester Supernatural - not seen either but this show is the one I'm more likely to enjoy, I think
Sharon Raydor Major Crimes - anyone but Buffy, but I know it's a futile effort
Kurt Wallander Wallander - not seen it, but I like Nordic noir
Tom Mathias Hinterland - an anti-nun vote
Pass
Lilly Rush Cold Case - enjoyed this show
Pass
John Luther Luther - enjoyed this show and Elba is good, and he's not a fupping pretty boy vampire either.

Round 4

Theo Kojak - Kojak

Lennie Briscoe - Law & Order

John Luther - Luther

sKeith

Round 4


Frank Castle The Punisher


Cal Lightman Lie To Me


Theo Kojak Kojak


Dean Winchester Supernatural


Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer


Stephanie (Steve) Oskowski Father Dowling Mysteries


Seeley Booth Bones

Kojak
Buffy
Lily from cold case


Only ones I’ve seen

Kojak- great dialogue - can cut you in half with a few words

Dean Winchester, Supernatural

Buffy Summers, Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Kurt Wallander, Wallander

Seeley Booth. Bones


Don't know the others.

JP Liz V1

Round 5


Vera Stanhope Vera

Vs.

Hannibal Smith The A-Team


Harry Bosch Bosch

Vs.

Jane Tennison Prime Suspect


Angus MacGyver MacGyver

Vs.

Carrie Wells Unforgettable


Jethro Gibbs NCIS

Vs.

Sam Winchester Supernatural


Jane Rizzoli Rizzoli & Isles

Vs.

Peter Boyd Waking the Dead


Jim Longworth The Glades

Vs.

Jim Taggart Taggart


DI Jack Frost A Touch of Frost

Vs.

Daniel Pierce Perception


Robert Goren Law & Order Criminal Intent

Vs.

Oscar Vega Motive


Edward Fitzgerald (Fitz) Cracker

Vs.

Walt Longmire Longmire


Rust Cohle True Detective

Vs.

Sarah MacKenzie (Mac) JAG


Clarke Griffin The 100

Vs.

Mike Torello Crime Story


Nikita Mears Nikita

Vs.

Harold Finch Person of Interest

Hannibal Smith, The A-Team

Harry Bosch, Bosch

Sam Winchester, Supernatural

Jim Longworth, The Glades

Robert Goren. Law & Order Criminal Intent

Walt Longmire, Longmire

Rusty Cohle, True Detective


Not familiar with the others.

Tauriel

Hannibal Smith The A-Team

Carrie Wells Unforgettable

Jethro Gibbs NCIS

Jane Rizzoli Rizzoli & Isles

Sarah MacKenzie (Mac) JAG

Nikita Mears Nikita

Necro

JP Liz V1 wrote:

Hannibal Smith The A-Team

JP Liz V1 wrote:

Sam Winchester Supernatural

JP Liz V1 wrote:

Rust Cohle True Detective

JP Liz V1 wrote:

Clarke Griffin The 100

JP Liz V1 wrote:

Harold Finch Person of Interest

Votes above. Abstain on the rest

JP Liz V1

Round 4 Results Through

Frank Castle The Punisher

Cal Lightman Lie To Me

Theo Kojak Kojak

Dean Winchester Supernatural

Buffy Summers Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Kurt Wallander Wallander

Stephanie (Steve) Oskowski Father Dowling Mysteries

Lennie Briscoe Law & Order

Lilly Rush Cold Case

Billy Butcher The Boys

Seeley Booth Bones

Zaph

Jane Tennison Prime Suspect

Edward Fitzgerald (Fitz) Cracker

Never seen any of the others

sKeith

Round 5

Hannibal Smith The A-Team

Angus MacGyver MacGyver (didn't know that was his first name!)

Jethro Gibbs NCIS

Jane Rizzoli Rizzoli & Isles

Clarke Griffin The 100 (not sure how this is crime fighting, but, go clarke)

Nikita Mears Nikita

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Hannibal Smith

Angus MacGyver

Sam Winchester

Robert Goren

Clarke Griffin

Harold Finch

Round 5

Hannibal Smith - The A-Team

Angus MacGyver - MacGyver

Jethro Gibbs - NCIS

Jim Taggart - Taggart

Edward Fitzgerald (Fitz) - Cracker

Rust Cohle - True Detective

quickbeam

Hannibal Smith The A-Team - because he can chew a cigar better than any one else
Jane Tennison Prime Suspect - I've not seen either, but I read a Bosch novel once and didn't like it
Angus MacGyver MacGyver - because he's awesome
Sam Winchester Supernatural - I like NCIS
Pass
Jim Taggart Taggart - classic, I guess
DI Jack Frost A Touch of Frost - another classic
Pass
Edward Fitzgerald (Fitz) Cracker - classic
Sarah MacKenzie (Mac) JAG - anti McConaughey vote
Pass
Harold Finch Person of Interest - great character, great show

the purple tin

Round 5

Hannibal Smith The A-Team - He's on the jazz


Harry Bosch Bosch - never seen the show but the books are excellent.


Angus MacGyver MacGyver

Sam Winchester Supernatural

Jim Taggart Taggart - there's been a murrrder

DI Jack Frost A Touch of Frost

Edward Fitzgerald (Fitz) Cracker

Harold Finch Person of Interest- a member of the oft-forgotten hard-working nerd brigade of crime-fighters

pc7

Round 5

Hannibal Smith The A-Team

Harry Bosch Bosch

Angus MacGuyver

Sam Winchester Supernatural

DI Jack Frost A Touch of Frost

Sarah MacKenzie (Mac) JAG

Harold Finch Person of Interest

sKeith

quickbeam wrote: »

Hannibal Smith The A-Team - because he can chew a cigar better than any one else
Jane Tennison Prime Suspect - I've not seen either, but I read a Bosch novel once and didn't like it
Angus MacGyver MacGyver - because he's awesome
Sam Winchester Supernatural - I like NCIS
Pass
Jim Taggart Taggart - classic, I guess
DI Jack Frost A Touch of Frost - another classic
Pass
Edward Fitzgerald (Fitz) Cracker - classic
Sarah MacKenzie (Mac) JAG - anti McConaughey vote
Pass
Harold Finch Person of Interest - great character, great show

you like ncis, yet vote sam over jethro?