I'm A Celebrity Werewolf - Get Me Out Of Here!!! (February Werewolf Game)

Green&Red

sKeith wrote: »

I could have, you could have, kitten could have.


Anybody who you thought was good before the conversion message, can now be bad.


But, bad does not become good!


So, if you thought somebody was bad before the conversion, then they can't have become good.


Your sudden trust in kitten is a change I asked for you to explain. #1254

I can't point to any one thing, a general feeling, the way she has been talking is how I think a villager should be behaving, shes open to the village's idea and seems to have the villages best interests at heart

Thats a wishy washy enough answer

More likely I think the Mods have balanced out the conversion by providing an under-strength village with two peeks

Green&Red

Trit, we'd want to get going on your peek before we need to decide on CL

tritium

OK, this is getting a bit tight I reckon

We have 10 players left.

Since we only have one wolf down, I'd guess 4 are baddies (3 wolves and 1 sk as my guess)

One baddie only got converted today

kill rate is 2/day for the baddies

we've consistently mislynched

That's the bad bits

Upside


Chances of spotting a baddie have to have increased

Baddies need to start offing each other pretty soon

Given I've a peek I'm inclined to peek cross since I think he's the best bet for a wolf. Feedback from the village would be appreciated here



Also, I'm tied up from a little after 8 tonight so will be AFK until after 9. Happy to take the CL if (I) folks want that and (ii) mods are ok with getting a slightly early notification

Green&Red

Well what are the scenarios if you peek Cross

Baddie its easy
Good - its good news but who do you evict tonite?
Me I'd presume?

I think either Barney or SK was converted but which?

sKeith

Vote for me, to evict LoughC.

I'll kill a wolf, not an NRV.

tritium

Of the remaining players

Quickbeam
Kitten K
Tritium
LoughC
Barney92
Whiplashy
Mam of 4
Green&Red
CrosstownK
Skeith

I've been peeked good - not much more I can do there so we either believe or don't, but I am good. if we assume 4 baddies in there from the remaining 9 I'd say Cross, Mam, Whip and on other. Yesterday I'd have said Green but he's looking too invested in his view to be a baddie at the moment. Still need to do some more readback but those are my current thoughts

tritium

and somehow I skimmed completely over Lough there....OK, thats my 4 I think

Green&Red

How did Whippy move across the line? I would have said she was almost definitely good yesterday

sKeith

tritium wrote: »

Of the remaining players

Quickbeam
Kitten K
Tritium
LoughC
Barney92
Whiplashy
Mam of 4
Green&Red
CrosstownK
Skeith

I've been peeked good - not much more I can do there so we either believe or don't, but I am good. if we assume 4 baddies in there from the remaining 9 I'd say Cross, Mam, Whip and on other. Yesterday I'd have said Green but he's looking too invested in his view to be a baddie at the moment. Still need to do some more readback but those are my current thoughts

Peek Cross or Kitten.

tritium

Green&Red wrote: »

How did Whippy move across the line? I would have said she was almost definitely good yesterday

Good question. Yesterday seemed legit but I think I'm trying to reframe yesterdays events in my head to make some sense of them.. not sure its quite coalesced yet

tritium

ok peeking cross unless someone really makes a case for a different choice

Lord TSC

Mod Note

I'm thinking/hoping no one noticed, but in the win conditions for the game, I forgot to put "....when the SK is dead" at the end of the wolves win conditions. The mods noticed this this afternoon, and wanted to flag it up for the remaining villagers.

Please do not read into this in a way that might make you think the game is running in any particular direction (I genuinely don't think this clarification is born from any meta data whatsoever). But we felt it important to note that the usual win conditions apply for this game. Namely, for the wolves to win, they need to read parity with the village AND THE SK MUST BE DEAD!". Those six words could potentially have become an issue due to my own inexperience writing win conditions, and so we've moved to clarify as soon as it was noticed.

So, we're editing that win condition so it lines up with the standard rule, which I think everyone was already playing under the assumption of anyway. I hope this doesn't annoy anyone, but we didn't want to edit the win condition without clarifying WHY we did.

We now resume regularly scheduled programming.

Green&Red

tritium wrote: »

ok peeking cross unless someone really makes a case for a different choice

Well?

tritium

Green&Red wrote: »

Well?

well it was only 10 minutes ago I said this. Given how quiet today has been by times I figured give it a little longer, say to 4pm

crosstownk

tritium wrote: »

ok peeking cross unless someone really makes a case for a different choice

I could make a case but I wouldn't expect to be listened to as I wouldn't listen to you if I were in your shoes.

I'm not a wolf and as a villager I feel the peek would be better used on another player. I'm not suggesting anyone because they'll probably say the same as me.

sKeith

Lord TSC wrote: »

Mod Note

I'm thinking/hoping no one noticed, but in the win conditions for the game, I forgot to put "....when the SK is dead" at the end of the wolves win conditions. The mods noticed this this afternoon, and wanted to flag it up for the remaining villagers.

Please do not read into this in a way that might make you think the game is running in any particular direction (I genuinely don't think this clarification is born from any meta data whatsoever). But we felt it important to note that the usual win conditions apply for this game. Namely, for the wolves to win, they need to read parity with the village AND THE SK MUST BE DEAD!". Those six words could potentially have become an issue due to my own inexperience writing win conditions, and so we've moved to clarify as soon as it was noticed.

So, we're editing that win condition so it lines up with the standard rule, which I think everyone was already playing under the assumption of anyway. I hope this doesn't annoy anyone, but we didn't want to edit the win condition without clarifying WHY we did.

We now resume regularly scheduled programming.

A wolf team wins by gaining parity with the village, after the sk is dead (i.e. there is the same number of people on their team as there are villagers left).

No mention of wolves having to kill another wolf team to win.



My take on that is that there is only 1 wolf team.

Loughc

crosstownk wrote: »

I could make a case but I wouldn't expect to be listened to as I wouldn't listen to you if I were in your shoes.

I'm not a wolf and as a villager I feel the peek would be better used on another player. I'm not suggesting anyone because they'll probably say the same as me.

This is weak sauce defence. Peek Cross. He’s definitely a baddie.

What you worried about Crossy? A good peek clears your ass.

tritium

crosstownk wrote: »

I could make a case but I wouldn't expect to be listened to as I wouldn't listen to you if I were in your shoes.

I'm not a wolf and as a villager I feel the peek would be better used on another player. I'm not suggesting anyone because they'll probably say the same as me.

Can you make it anyway, especially any suspicions you have - if you are a villager then pooling what we have is important at this point

crosstownk

sKeith wrote: »

No mention of wolves having to kill another wolf team to win.



My take on that is that there is only 1 wolf team.

It's be game over if it was two teams of 3. 3 v 3 v 3 v 1

quickbeam

Nearly three hours with Virgin Media!! Haven't got to do third ISO. Will attempt one now.

crosstownk

tritium wrote: »

Can you make it anyway, especially any suspicions you have - if you are a villager then pooling what we have is important at this point

OK - If you really insist.

I'd like to know the alignment of GNR and sKeith - in that order.

quickbeam

sKeith wrote: »

My take on that is that there is only 1 wolf team.

That was my take since yesterday morning when we've only had two kills each morning.

sKeith

crosstownk wrote: »

It's be game over if it was two teams of 3. 3 v 3 v 3 v 1

If it were multiballed, it would not be game over. all the teams would have to kill each other. a wolf is dead. so multiball with 2x2 and sk with 1 wolf dead = 5v2v1v1.

Green&Red

Ya, a villager is delighted to be peeked

Barney92

sKeith wrote: »

No mention of wolves having to kill another wolf team to win.



My take on that is that there is only 1 wolf team.

quickbeam wrote: »

That was my take since yesterday morning when we've only had two kills each morning.

Yes, but it's almost confirmation of it I suppose. So 3 wolves left and an SK, do you reckon?

Mam of 4

If you peeked at Quickbeam say for instance , and she was a wolf , then what ?

tritium

Mam of 4 wrote: »

If you peeked at Quickbeam say for instance , and she was a wolf , then what ?

well, find a wolf kill a wolf is the general rule - if we peek a wolf they have to be evicted

Mam of 4

tritium wrote: »

well, find a wolf kill a wolf is the general rule - if we peek a wolf they have to be evicted

That's what I thought , just wanted it clarified ,thank you .

Barney92

Green&Red wrote: »

Ya, a villager is delighted to be peeked

Why? It's more valuable to peek a wolf. That's what a villager would be delighted with.

Say I'm peeked good, why would that make me happy? It doesn't really make it more likely that the village will win. I mean everyone else would know I'm good but the wolves can just kill me off and not much good has been done for the village.

quickbeam

ISO on Kitten done. Not a whole lot jumping out at me. Very little fluff, all game related.

Very first post was a greeting to a known wolf (Sully)
Agreeing with Lough re reason for wolves going for Bounty
Assumes one wolf team and one SK (Monday 10am, after just one munch)
Gives examples of why a CL might not follow the WOTP
Missed CL vote
Scrap with sKeith re his confirming Sully as villager before she died
Volunteers to be shot to avoid SK getting prize
Won peek (11:08); announced win (11:25)
Puts peek choice to the village
Peeked Tritium (14:34)

Village lean for me.