Sherlock - A game of Werewolf! FEEDBACK THREAD

WerewolfGM

Feedback to go here.

Posts from main thread pertaining to feedback moved to this thread.

• Please keep all feedback constructive.
• Please be considerate of the mods time in putting the game together and running it.
• The game is over so lets all leave any fights or disagreements from within the game just there; within the game.
• Kudos and thank you's can go here or in the game thread.

Game Thread

Game Highlights / Events





Full player list

Gertrude WW - Charles Augustus (Wolf) - Guffy
Orla WW/Winifred WW - Eurus Holmes (Wolf) - Necrominus
Abigail WW - Irene Adler (Wolf) - Bounty Hunter
Nigel WW - Jim Moriarty (Wolf) - quickbeam
Isla WW -Jeff Hope (Wolf) - Rikand

Tegan WW - Cultervon Smith (SK) - BeakerJoe

Barbara WW - Sherlock - tritium
Clodagh WW - John Watson - mitsuko045
Brendan WW - Mary Watson - Kitten K
Conor WW - Molly Hooper - Ectoplasm
Desmond WW - Mycroft - sKeith
Doris WW - Mrs Hudson - Murray TheDemonic TalkingSkull
Riona WW - D.I Lestrade - Drumpot

Oisín WW - Scotland Yard Officer - breatheme
Mary WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Jack Moore
Wendy WW - Scotland Yard Officer - fixxxer
Katie WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Y0ssar1an22
Derry WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Lord TSC
Gabriel WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Pter
Frank WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Duffman
Steve WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Uriel
Liam WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Mollyb60
Holly WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Digital Solitude
Eva WW - Scotland Yard Officer - Comic Book Guy/ stu redman sub

WerewolfGM

Full Roles

Sherlock Holmes – Consulting Detective: Each night phase Sherlock has the option to peek one individual for full role revel including hidden knowledge or alternatively can choose 3 people and learn if the group of 3 contains a bad or good player which will only give an aligned bad or aligned good response.

Foresight - Sherlock has the ability to find out if he is being targeted for a munch, this is a one time power.

Dr. John Watson – 2 bullets

Can heal one person daily which removes hospitalized status.

Shares room with Mary

Mary Watson – Bodyguard: Can protect a person each night phase. Cannot protect themselves.

Gains any bullets that our left over if John dies.

Successful protections grant 1 extra bullet to Dr Watson

D.I Lestrade – Can jail someone every night phase, jailed people lose backroom access and all powers during the night phase but cannot be killed while jailed. Can only jail the same player once.

Mrs Hudson – Can override a lynch with a person of her choosing.

Mycroft Holmes – Mycroft has a -3 lynch value meaning they need 3 votes to get to 0

Can divert the wolves kill, has the option to divert the current kill target up one letter in the alphabet or down one. One time power

Mycroft shows as align bad in investigation peeks

Molly Hooper - Molly receives any Hidden roles that the dead may have.


VILLIANS


Jim Moriarty
Moriarty has two full seer peek.

Stays in backroom after death,

Can send one message to any player every night ( anonymous sender)

Irene Adler
Irene can be sent away from the backroom. When sent way she will not be able to contact the villains but she still must act in their interest, when sent away she will be seen as Scotland yard officer to any peeks or deaths and also parity counts, she can be recalled into the backroom at any stage but this can only be done once in which she will then remain in the backroom as a villain. Recalling Irene into the backroom has a 24hr timer from request.

Charles Augustus Magnussen – Picks one player to blackmail, a pm will be then sent in which they will receive a gun with one bullet with a note attached (Magnussen writes note)

Jeff Hope
Has two pills, Jeff picks one that is poisonous and one that is harmless and names each pill, he then sends it to one player in which they have choose which pill to take. Sender will know that one pill is poisonous and harmless; they will also know that Jeff has named both pills. *Player must take one pill or they will die.

Jeff can send pills out every day but if someone picks the good pill he will have to wait an extra day until he can continue, he can kill a max of 2 times with his pills. If Moriarty dies then Jeff will lose his ability to kill with pills.

Eurus Holmes
Her speciality is reprogramming the human brain...
Eurus acts as a double parity count for the villains.

Reprogramming the human brain is her specialty; Eurus has reprogrammed the brain of a Scotland Yard officer. She is in full control of this person and can get them to say and do anything she pleases. Should Eurus die her minion will also die. Her minion is set to the same rules as any other Scotland Yard Officer regarding votes and post count, the minion also act as parity count for the citizens of London (The village)



SK

Culverton Smith – The hospital is his playground

One of the most prolific undetected serial killers in British criminal history, he can’t help boast to everyone about his kills. Can kill one person every day at any time between munches.

Writes his own kill story

Sends up to 4 people to hospital each day, these people will be informed they have been hospitalized. They will remain hospitalized unless healed. SK can only kill players that are hospitalized. *Hospitalized is only a status and doesn’t affect any roles that the player may have.

quickbeam

OMG, those riddles. I was totally clueless. That's just not how my mind works. Fair play Lordy and Ecto for solving them. Oh, and Yoss for Googling :P

Necro

Huzzah! I'm back in my own skin

kitten_k

Isla WW wrote: »

I didn't have near enough time to play this game, squeezed in what I could and did just enough to escape most people

I seriously considered shooting you - should have stuck with my gut but waited to see how the Wini situation went.

Riona WW

2 shots in Wendy? You thought she was rolled?

Ectoplasm

Necrominus wrote: »

Huzzah! I'm back in my own skin

You disguise yourself well

kitten_k

quickbeam wrote: »

We'd a lucky peek in Barbara.

We knew Brendan was a role though didn't know which one, once he offed Tegan so quickly, and then Clodagh revealed who shot Tegan.

What gave it away I was roled?

quickbeam

Riona WW wrote: »

2 shots in Wendy? You thought she was rolled?

Somewhat yeah, we thought she was roled enough to send her the poison. But we didn't target her next time. We targeted Tegan but Mycroft sent the munch one person downwards.

Necro

Ectoplasm wrote: »

You disguise yourself well

Which one, Wini or Orla :pac:

Well played all, especially my wolf chums

Necro

kitten_k wrote: »

What gave it away I was roled?

Well MOST NRVs would shoot themselves imo rather than risk killing a roled player.

That you shot Tegan indicated you were roled.

Then when Clodagh outed and told us her wife shot Tegan we knew

quickbeam

kitten_k wrote: »

What gave it away I was roled?

Can't remember why exactly we chose you to blackmail. One of the other, cleverer wolves spotted something. You using the gun on Tegan so quickly confirmed to us that you were roled though. A NRV would have hesitated and maybe considered shooting themselves and saving a possible roled villager.

We didn't know Tegan was the SK when we gave you that choice. We thought he was roled.

beakerjoe

quickbeam wrote: »

Can't remember why exactly we chose you to blackmail. One of the other, cleverer wolves spotted something. You using the gun on Tegan so quickly confirmed to us that you were roled though. A NRV would have hesitated and maybe considered shooting themselves and saving a possible roled villager.

We didn't know Tegan was the SK when we gave you that choice. We thought he was roled.

Why poor Tegen? Why did you think I was roled

quickbeam

beakerjoe wrote: »

Why poor Tegen? Why did you think I was roled

Nice, quiet, under the radar, posting just enough to contribute. I think also (was it you?) your post quoting Abi's first post and accusing her.

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

Why poor Tegen? Why did you think I was roled

Neutral on most things, also keeping mid range. It was only a hunch tbh.

Ectoplasm

I am so, so bad at this game. It's kinda comical. Maybe I'd make a good wolf

quickbeam

Tegan WW wrote: »

Are you Culverton?

Actually should have twigged it then, shouldn't we? :P

beakerjoe

Necrominus wrote: »

Neutral on most things, also keeping mid range. It was only a hunch tbh.

I had so many plans for my notes, did you enjoy the day 1 lynch chaos?

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

I had so many plans for my notes, did you enjoy the day 1 lynch chaos?

Very much so. I was sitting back laughing in the wolf room about it :pac:

kitten_k

beakerjoe wrote: »

Why poor Tegen? Why did you think I was roled

Beaker - we still friends?? I’ll try not to shoot you again :-p

quickbeam

beakerjoe wrote: »

I had so many plans for my notes, did you enjoy the day 1 lynch chaos?

I was genuinely away for Monday and most of Tuesday so missed all the chaos. Was very clever though. Would have been interesting to see what other flavour you'd post.

Necro

The only reason we named Tegan for the blackmail is that we thought the BG protected her.

When it was actually Mycroft's powers.

Baggly

Thanks for the game mods!

TheValeyard

Oh dear God what a wipe out for the village lol


Well played wolves.


Absolute slaughter.

quickbeam

Thanks again to the mods. Superbly put together game. A fantastic amount of work put in to it. Brilliant stuff.

TheValeyard

Cheers for thr great game. Awesome fun

kitten_k

quickbeam wrote: »

Can't remember why exactly we chose you to blackmail. One of the other, cleverer wolves spotted something. You using the gun on Tegan so quickly confirmed to us that you were roled though. A NRV would have hesitated and maybe considered shooting themselves and saving a possible roled villager.

We didn't know Tegan was the SK when we gave you that choice. We thought he was roled.

Ah I see, thought you meant that you knew before sending the bullet.

quickbeam

Murray TheDemonic TalkingSkull wrote: »

Oh dear God what a wipe out for the village lol


Well played wolves.


Absolute slaughter.

I still don't understand where the Doris lynch came from!

Necro

Yeah, thanks mods for the game

Now if you could open up the backrooms and make Necro a happy bunny.... no rush, like

TheValeyard

quickbeam wrote: »

I still don't understand where the Doris lynch came from!

Yeah. I was certain i was under no threat, except for Steve trying to kill me off.


Bad village.

Bad, bad village

Lord TSC

OH! Yes. I owe the mods an apology for the voting mess, I think. I think I accidentally voted as Gertrude, rather than Derry, out of habit from the last game. I'm guessing thats what caused the error with Gert's vote too? If so, am very sorry for causing a mess.

Will say mods, I adored the riddles. Made day 1 really interesting, especially as an NRV with nothing else to do :P

Necro

Murray TheDemonic TalkingSkull wrote: »

Yeah. I was certain i was under no threat, except for Steve trying to kill me off.


Bad village.

Bad, bad village

I was too busy having an argument with myself to notice :pac:

Ectoplasm

Terrible village, landed with a demented priest. Moar riddles, them I can do

Riona WW

Really well put together game mods. You can see the work put in and it was worth losing my family and a weeks work

I get now the Necro posting questions. I looked at the post count a bit and was surprised. We were all looking at Orla while wini was beavering alongside.... Goof game. And nice rant to compliment it.... :pac:

beakerjoe

Necrominus wrote: »

The only reason we named Tegan for the blackmail is that we thought the BG protected her.

When it was actually Mycroft's powers.

Protect me from what?

Necro

Riona WW wrote: »

Really well put together game mods. You can see the work put in and it was worth losing my family and a weeks work

I get now the Necro posting questions. I looked at the post count a bit and was surprised. We were all looking at Orla while wini was beavering alongside.... Goof game. And nice rant to compliment it.... :pac:

:mad:

FFAed for inactivity - I had a combined 400+ posts :pac:

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

Protect me from what?

No, we tried to munch you that morning, and Mycroft's power shifted down and killed Wendy instead.

But we didn't figure that, thought the vig shot Wendy and Tegan was protected.

Gabriel WW

Password reset!

quickbeam

beakerjoe wrote: »

Protect me from what?

We wanted to peek you as our first, but went last minute for Holly instead.
To make up for the disappointment of Holly just being a NRV we decided to munch you.
But Mycroft moved our munch to Wendy (edit: we didn't know this until late in the game and thought you were protected though).
So we decided to get Brendan to kill himself or you.

It was a matter of pride after missing a peek and a munch on you, I think at that stage

Riona WW

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Terrible village, landed with a demented priest. Moar riddles, them I can do

I don’t think you quite anywhere near my Phil level of crazy .. I was sweating with PTSD recall watching you go down your Gabriel rabbit hole....

Drumpot

Password is as was....

Baggly

New Werewolf forum rule: if I promise to buy you a car, I'm telling the truth.

duffman13

Pter wrote: »

New Werewolf forum rule: if I promise to buy you a car, I'm telling the truth.

You posted in the wrong account again buddy

Ectoplasm

Riona WW wrote: »

I don’t think you quite anywhere near my Phil level of crazy .. I was sweating with PTSD recall watching you go down your Gabriel rabbit hole....

I was demented at the end. I knew there was at least one wolf in the pile of note getters. I should have pursued my Wini wasn't Adler theory harder but we'd never have won anyway and I swear I'll be fired if I don't do some actual work soon. :pac:

Baggly

duffman13 wrote:

You posted in the wrong account again buddy

Can't modkill me now.

Baggly

Ectoplasm wrote:

I was demented at the end. I knew there was at least one wolf in the pile of note getters. I should have pursued my Wini wasn't Adler theory harder but we'd never have won anyway and I swear I'll be fired if I don't do some actual work soon.

It was abi who first turned me off the extra account route iirc. Well played.

Now we have had that twice, ill watch out for that every single game. Never again.

y0ssar1an22

that ended rather abruptly. well done to the wolves, and the mods. lynching me night 1 set in motion a cataclysmic sequence of events .

still mad confused. i find it a lot easier to follow when we use our real boards names

Ectoplasm

Also mods, deleted mail and I never changed the password you sent me so good to go.

And if someone wants to plan some games to coincide with school hols I'd mucho appreciate it. Can't play now for a while and while that might be good for whoever ends up with me on their team, it sucks for me.

Necro

Ectoplasm wrote: »

I was demented at the end. I knew there was at least one wolf in the pile of note getters. I should have pursued my Wini wasn't Adler theory harder but we'd never have won anyway and I swear I'll be fired if I don't do some actual work soon. :pac:

I never got a note

Baggly

The stars aligned and allowed me post stream of consciousness stuff this game. Had lots of free time this week I wasn't expecting. Sorry if it impacted the game for the village in a bad way.

andy125

Hope you all enjoyed it, was tricky enough to mod with all the different moving parts

Masterclass by the wolves and i tip my hat to you all, i don't think you were in danger once throughout the whole game. Really amazing performance guys.

Also special thanks to lord and ecto for solving the clues, i was fearful they might not be answered as the game went on

Backroom should be open to all btw