Match Thread: Scotland V France | Sunday 15:00 11 Feb | Murrayfield | TV3 BBC FR2

Hurrache

Stheno wrote: »

Oh dear Laidlaw

He's having a mare of a game.

Losty Dublin

Laidlaw played that one like a Scottish goalkeeper.

Mrcaramelchoc

Paul o Connell sounds like he's commentating a funeral.he's awful.

Subpopulus

Tomas player of the tournament so far

Bridge93

Finn Russell is a disgrace yet again.

LuckyGent88

Another Laidlaw implosion. 3 kicks out on the full and a bad missed tackle for the first try

Burkie1203

How did Laidlaw end up at Clermont and do Racing have a opt out clause with Russell

Oh and Monty after Hogg apparently

ScrubsfanChris

LuckyGent88 wrote: »

Another Laidlaw implosion. 3 kicks out on the full and a bad missed tackle for the first try

Do you mean Russell?

Subpopulus

Finn Oh Finn Oh Finn....

Vital Transformation

Nice line.

Stheno

This is a bit mental

LuckyGent88

Well this is fun . What an angle by Jones.

Didactic Ninja

id be fuming if i was france there. laidlaw knocked on and they got no advantage.

Burkie1203

Didactic Ninja wrote: »

id be fuming if i was france there. laidlaw knocked on and they got no advantage.

They kicked the ball 50m down field and didnt chase it

laugh

France left a massive gap there.

Losty Dublin

Why didn't France tackle like this last week? It's not fair.

Didactic Ninja

Burkie1203 wrote: »

They kicked the ball 50m down field and didnt chase it

hence no advantage

Subpopulus

Very Southern Hemisphere all this.

Burkie1203

Didactic Ninja wrote: »

hence no advantage

But if you kick the ball its advantage over. Common part of the game

Clegg

Finn Russell isn't good enough. The commentator said the wind caught the kick and sent it dead but Russell has made a habit of kicking pens dead when going for the line. I don't doubt he has great ability but every play needs to be the big one for him.

Cosmo Kramer

For all their faults and flaws Scotland have done a fine job of showing up the lack of effectiveness in our attacking game in the first 30 minutes here. We made that French defence look like world beaters. Scotlsnd showing it up to be very poor.

Subpopulus

Burkie1203 wrote: »

But if you kick the ball its advantage over. Common part of the game

Why do teams often chip ahead or do a crossfield pass as soon as they get advantage then? I've often seen that done and if that doesn't come off they come back for the penalty/scrum.

Burkie1203

Cosmo Kramer wrote: »

For all their faults and flaws Scotland have done a fine job of showing up the lack of effectiveness in our attacking game in the first 30 minutes here. We made that French defence look like world beaters. Scotlsnd showing it up to be very poor.

It was pissing rain last week. France didnt play like this with ball in hand last week either

Cosmo Kramer

Clegg wrote: »

Finn Russell isn't good enough. The commentator said the wind caught the kick and sent it dead but Russell has made a habit of kicking pens dead when going for the line. I don't doubt he has great ability but every play needs to be the big one for him.

Scotland have no other 10 that is remotely close to international standard.

Burkie1203

Subpopulus wrote: »

Why do teams often chip ahead or do a crossfield pass as soon as they get advantage then? I've often seen that done and if that doesn't come off they come back for the penalty/scrum.

There is a difference between penalty advantage and a knock on advantage

Clegg

I was wondering if we'd see a post like the above. At the start of the game when conditions were better Ireland attacked ball in hand and made a lot of metres. It was an incisive move that used forwards and backs and it stretched the French all over the pitch. It started lashing rain not long after that and any chance of expansive attacking moves stopped there. Ireland played to the conditions. When it was dry they attacked and looked decent.

Synode

French win best result for us? Keeps them interested when playing England

OldRio

Defence optional for both teams.

OldRio

Cosmo Kramer wrote: »

For all their faults and flaws Scotland have done a fine job of showing up the lack of effectiveness in our attacking game in the first 30 minutes here. We made that French defence look like world beaters. Scotlsnd showing it up to be very poor.

Oh dear. Yeah both games played in the same conditions.

Burkie1203

Synode wrote: »

French win best result for us? Keeps them interested when playing England

Yeah they have Italy next too in Paris. A win there (and if they win today) and they have a sniff of the title

Burkie1203

Synode wrote: »

French win best result for us? Keeps them interested when playing England

Yeah they have Italy next too in Paris. A win there (and if they win today) and they have a sniff of the title

ScrubsfanChris

Synode wrote: »

French win best result for us? Keeps them interested when playing England

I would say so. As you said keeps them interested with England and Wales still to play for them. If they keep on getting better game after game all good for us. Just don't be scoring many bonus points in case we don't win all our games

Bridge93

Yeah France win to keep them tuned in. Scotland will be up for England regardless of the state of play

Muligatawney

Stuart Hogg getting a bit of a pass I think. Awful effort for the first try and didn't step into the line quick enough for the second try. He's also not making much yardage with ball in hand. Huw Jones and Tommy Seymour have been Scotland's best backs for the past couple of years now.

Akrasia

Muligatawney wrote: »

Stuart Hogg getting a bit of a pass I think. Awful effort for the first try and didn't step into the line quick enough for the second try. He's also not making much yardage with ball in hand. Huw Jones and Tommy Seymour have been Scotland's best backs for the past couple of years now.

Hogg has been outstanding for Glasgow the past few season but has done feck all in the 6 nations so far

Cosmo Kramer

OldRio wrote: »

Oh dear. Yeah both games played in the same conditions.

Ya, funnily enough I noticed it was raining last Saturday. :rolleyes:

Doesn't excuse our complete lack of gameplan in the opposition 22 beyond one out passes to crash ball forwards. It'll be excused due to the weather, the French raising their game against us or whatever the latest fanboy excuse is for our poor attacking play until it costs us dearly in a big game. Some of the spaces Scotland are finding today have little to do with the weather conditions.

Bridge93

Stuart Hogg was Six Nations player of the tournament in 2016 and 2017

Faugheen

Didactic Ninja wrote: »

hence no advantage

It was only a scrum advantage. If you kick away a scrum advantage then it's called over.

It's completely different if it's a penalty advantage.

Faugheen

Akrasia wrote: »

Hogg has been outstanding for Glasgow the past few season but has done feck all in the 6 nations so far

He was player of the year for the Six Nations for the last two years...

Clegg

And Russell misses touch from a pen again.

Burkie1203

This is the dumbest 3 minutes of rugby ever

Akrasia

Faugheen wrote: »

He was player of the year for the Six Nations for the last two years...

Sorry i meant this 6 nations

Didactic Ninja

france tackle him, ref calls not held ,he goes again, gets flattened and then rucked over, then plays it off the ground.

baffling

OldRio

Cosmo Kramer wrote: »

Ya, funnily enough I noticed it was raining last Saturday. :rolleyes:

Doesn't excuse our complete lack of gameplan in the opposition 22 beyond one out passes to crash ball forwards. It'll be excused due to the weather, the French raising their game against us or whatever the latest fanboy excuse is for our poor attacking play until it costs us dearly in a big game. Some of the spaces Scotland are finding today have little to do with the weather conditions.

Fanboy? Deary me.

FrancieBrady

Cosmo Kramer wrote: »

Ya, funnily enough I noticed it was raining last Saturday. :rolleyes:

Doesn't excuse our complete lack of gameplan in the opposition 22 beyond one out passes to crash ball forwards. It'll be excused due to the weather, the French raising their game against us or whatever the latest fanboy excuse is for our poor attacking play until it costs us dearly in a big game. Some of the spaces Scotland are finding today have little to do with the weather conditions.

France are playing differently today, less defensively and more open. Hence Scotland finding space, something they couldn't do against Wales.

We play the team in front of us and can exploit if allowed,

Stheno

You'd nearly believe you were in SdF at times with the noise of the French fans

Faugheen

Cosmo Kramer wrote: »

Ya, funnily enough I noticed it was raining last Saturday. :rolleyes:

Doesn't excuse our complete lack of gameplan in the opposition 22 beyond one out passes to crash ball forwards. It'll be excused due to the weather, the French raising their game against us or whatever the latest fanboy excuse is for our poor attacking play until it costs us dearly in a big game. Some of the spaces Scotland are finding today have little to do with the weather conditions.

I like that you're complaining about a game plan that got us the win against France and would rather the one which Scotland are deploying despite the fact they're losing.

This is pure, pure entertainment. Even the crowd are entertaining. Best game of the weekend from a spectator point of view.

IngazZagni

That Scottish penalty was taken nowhere near where the original infringement occurred.

Faugheen

This is absolute carnage.