The Tipperary GAA (Club and Intercounty) Thread

windy shepard henderson

Xenophile wrote: »

No, he was a total failure with Wexford.

to be fair wexford were in a terrible place when he took over , we played them in one of his first games in charge of them , at the time wexford were after spiraling down 3 divisions and after losing several key players

wexford football has got worse since and to no fault of david , he was in the wrong place at the wrong time in my opinion ,

iebamm2580

Cant see it working, i know of kilsheelan lads that wouldn't play under him for his home club.

Xenophile

windy shepard henderson wrote: »

to be fair wexford were in a terrible place when he took over , we played them in one of his first games in charge of them , at the time wexford were after spiraling down 3 divisions and after losing several key players

wexford football has got worse since and to no fault of david , he was in the wrong place at the wrong time in my opinion ,

If you have the talent there is no easier place to make a good impression than with a team that is really down.

conor05

A massive step down from kearns.

Power is ego driven.

Can’t see it ending well.

Xenophile

The people who made this appointment should stand up and be counted. Probably all hurling people with no interest in football.

Xenophile

Xenophile wrote: »

No mention of a Football appointment on the Tipperary County Board website. I guess they are just not interested.

Or, you know, maybe it hasn't been officially ratified yet at a county board meeting :rolleyes:

Xenophile

Xenophile wrote: »

The people who made this appointment should stand up and be counted. Probably all hurling people with no interest in football.

I'm pretty sure there is a football board tasked with selecting the manager in Tipp and in fairness to them I would doubt there was a huge pool to pick from

willietherock

Xenophile wrote: »

The people who made this appointment should stand up and be counted. Probably all hurling people with no interest in football.

Football board appointment you hurling hating numpty.

Xenophile

willietherock wrote: »

Football board appointment you hurling hating numpty.

A Football Board recommendation has to be ratified by the County Board.

Mantis Toboggan

Xenophile wrote: »

A Football Board recommendation has to be ratified by the County Board.

He'll be ratified tomorrow night.

Xenophile

Comment from a Wexford Football supporter.

I didn't rate him at all the play was terrible and they went backwards quickly as a unit. if he's any use it's over younger players not seniors.

kilkennyboy

Cahill will be a loss.good crack next year if he comes to thurles with the blahs and does a job on ye.

Rasputin11

kilkennyboy wrote: »

Cahill will be a loss.good crack next year if he comes to thurles with the blahs and does a job on ye.

Playing them in Waterford next year.

kilkennyboy

Strange enough move.couldn't see them being a force and if it goes badly it hurts
His stock. Then if he gets them turned around he is a genius and next tipp boss.
Interesting stuff

Joe_ Public

Good luck to him if the news is true. Guess he feels he's done all he can at the under age level and isnt in the mood to wait the 2 or how ever many years it will be waiting for the next tipp senior vacancy. In a way i dont think this is bad for tipp, getting good senior experience down there will surely stand to him if it ever comes about that that vacancy then does appear at the right time for him. Has a bit of talent to work with down there, definitely wont be underestimating them next year.

The Lost Sheep

kilkennyboy wrote: »

Strange enough move.couldn't see them being a force and if it goes badly it hurts
His stock. Then if he gets them turned around he is a genius and next tipp boss.
Interesting stuff

Not really that strange. It will be a proper challenge and thats only good for his development as a coach

Joe_ Public wrote: »

Good luck to him if the news is true. Guess he feels he's done all he can at the under age level and isnt in the mood to wait the 2 or how ever many years it will be waiting for the next tipp senior vacancy. In a way i dont think this is bad for tipp, getting good senior experience down there will surely stand to him if it ever comes about that that vacancy then does appear at the right time for him. Has a bit of talent to work with down there, definitely wont be underestimating them next year.

I can only see this as a good thing. He gets senior experience at inter county level and if successful can come back to tipp role having a few years experience under his belt at inter county level...

Mantis Toboggan

Big loss for tipp if its confirmed, he was a shoe in for next tipp manager now its unlikely.

digzy

Great appointment for both sides if true
W’ford are getting a proven winner who’s gotten the best from sides of varying ability. He was probably getting the tipp job until Sheedy showed interest.

Cahill is getting the chance to manage a ‘tier 1’ side with some top players. Great experience both on and off the pitch....probably with an eye on tipp when Sheedy steps aside. Though Munster will be a dogfight ( as usual) next year.

I wonder will sides take the tipp/limerick approach next year where qualifying for the all Ireland series is prioritized. Might give Waterford/Cahill some breathing room..

Mantis Toboggan

Mantis Toboggan wrote: »

Big loss for tipp if its confirmed, he was a shoe in for next tipp manager now its unlikely.

Hard to know. I think Cahill wants the Tipp job in the future, but he also wants to test himself at the highest level. I wish him well in any event and I genuinely think he will be a success down in Waterford. He'll bring a steely resolve to them that they have been lacking. I hope he will be a future manager for us someday. He has earned his shot at it. Hopefully the hurling gods will line things up for us sometime in the future.

digzy

digzy wrote: »

Great appointment for both sides if true
W’ford are getting a proven winner who’s gotten the best from sides of varying ability. He was probably getting the tipp job until Sheedy showed interest.

Cahill is getting the chance to manage a ‘tier 1’ side with some top players. Great experience both on and off the pitch....probably with an eye on tipp when Sheedy steps aside. Though Munster will be a dogfight ( as usual) next year.

I wonder will sides take the tipp/limerick approach next year where qualifying for the all Ireland series is prioritized. Might give Waterford/Cahill some breathing room..

Prior to Sheedy taking the Tipp job, I felt that all signs indictated that Willie Maher would land it. I heard the issue with Cahill is that he didnt have the choice of his management team. How true that is i dont know.

Mantis Toboggan

Mantis Toboggan wrote: »

Charlie McKeever, Joe Hayes -( former Clare Keeper) Micky Mcgeenan and Paddy Christie (Dub) is supposed to be the backroom team.

https://twitter.com/StephenGleeson_/status/1176604279358066691?s=19

Xenophile

Maybe it's time that Eoin Kelly started his inter county management career. Anyone agree that he should start with the minors and work towards the under 20's, I have no doubt that he will one day be a senior manager.

Xenophile

11 All Star Nominations for Tipperary.


Brian Hogan


Pádraic Maher
Ronan Maher
Cathal Barrett
Brendan Maher
Barry Heffernan


Noel McGrath


John O’Dwyer
Jason Forde
Séamus Callanan
John McGrath


PLAYER OF THE YEAR NOMINEES

1 Patrick Horgan (Cork)
2 TJ Reid (Kilkenny)
3 Séamus Callanan (Tipperary )

radharc

Think Noel not being a nominee for POTY is a good thing, 1/100 Callanan gets it now

Mantis Toboggan

Cahill stepped down from the u20 role.

Looks inevitable now.

Brave move, Waterford job has all the hallmarks of a poison chalice. He'll have a tough job to get out of Munster. If it doesn't go well for him his chances of the Tipp job will have taken a big knock.

He's a bit of a miracle man though and it's a major coup for Waterford no doubt about it.

Mantis Toboggan

radharc wrote: »

Think Noel not being a nominee for POTY is a good thing, 1/100 Callanan gets it now

Well it's a different voting system to 2016 so that farce shouldn't happen again.
Still Noel should have been nominated. He had a great year, man of the match in the semi final and final.

digzy

Mantis Toboggan wrote: »

Well it's a different voting system to 2016 so that farce shouldn't happen again.
Still Noel should have been nominated. He had a great year, man of the match in the semi final and final.

Which of the 3 would you leave out?

Mantis Toboggan

digzy wrote: »

Which of the 3 would you leave out?

Hoggie

marvin80

Mantis Toboggan wrote: »

Cahill stepped down from the u20 role.

Looks inevitable now.

Brave move, Waterford job has all the hallmarks of a poison chalice. He'll have a tough job to get out of Munster. If it doesn't go well for him his chances of the Tipp job will have taken a big knock.

He's a bit of a miracle man though and it's a major coup for Waterford no doubt about it.

+1 on this - great appointment for Waterford. Cahill has more to lose if it doesn't go well.
I'd like to see him do well there, but not too well : )

cul beag

marvin80 wrote: »

+1 on this - great appointment for Waterford. Cahill has more to lose if it doesn't go well.
I'd like to see him do well there, but not too well : )

I would be of the opposite opinion as we haven’t won a game in Munster in 2 years so any progress on that will be seen as a success. If he broadens the net he will have at least 5 more valuable additions to the squad that were cast aside by Mcgrath and that can strengthen his hand.