Yaris 2000-2002 or Polo same age?

renemegane

Hi all

Planning to buy my first car and am about to go mental. Looking for something old, small (up to 1.4) and reliable. Not planning to spend over 2 grand. My husband suggests to go for a Polo. I like the 2002 version, looks nice, but never drove one. Was on a passenger seat in Yaris - nice little car, same price range but seemed a bit too loud inside...

Very confused, because even at that price I find tons of different ones... Lost and don't know what to choose. Planning to have it for at least 2 years.

Maybe someone is selling my first car? We're in Meath, working in Dublin.

Please, help

colm_mcm

Yaris is a safe bet. Polo is a bit of a lottery.

renemegane

Thanks. If I go with a Polo, what especially should I pay attention to?
(Obviously, our mechanic will have a look, but I want to understand where it underperforms while the first test drive)

colm_mcm wrote: »

Yaris is a safe bet. Polo is a bit of a lottery.

Atlantic Dawn

I would go Yaris, the majority of the Polo's are poorly spec'd, most won't have electric windows. The Yaris usually demands a premium price. Yaris has a timing chain too so doesn't need the belt replaced like the Polo.

bazz26

A Yaris would be a safer bet than a Polo of that vintage. 1.0 litre Yaris is nipper, more refined and more reliable than the 1.2 Polo. A 2003 onwards Ford Fiesta 1.25 litre is worth looking at too.

renemegane

Thanks, what's the best place to look for used cars? I use donedeal, but probably it's not the right website...

bazz26 wrote: »

A Yaris would be a safer bet than a Polo of that vintage. 1.0 litre Yaris is nipper, more refined and more reliable than the 1.2 Polo. A 2003 onwards Ford Fiesta 1.25 litre is worth looking at too.

renemegane

Can't wait to try one!

Atlantic Dawn wrote: »

I would go Yaris, the majority of the Polo's are poorly spec'd, most won't have electric windows. The Yaris usually demands a premium price. Yaris has a timing chain too so doesn't need the belt replaced like the Polo.

colm_mcm

At your price level, look at donedeal private sales.

bazz26

You will pay good money for a clean tidy Yaris, the cheap ones tend to be tired dogs.

colm_mcm

We paid €2k for a 00 18 months ago.
It is a very clean one, and I reckon we'd get most if that back today.

YARIS - all the way!! Owned two of them - they have great re-sale value. They ever let me down - even the 99D reg which I only sold last year for 2.5K..... go YARIS!

renemegane

Yaris? You happy with it? Was it NCT'd and taxed then?

colm_mcm wrote: »

We paid €2k for a 00 18 months ago.

renemegane

Haha))) Thank you) Very inspiring))))

Deleted User wrote: »

YARIS - all the way!! Owned two of them - they have great re-sale value. They ever let me down - even the 99D reg which I only sold last year for 2.5K..... go YARIS!

colm_mcm

renemegane wrote: »

Yaris? You happy with it? Was it NCT'd and taxed then?

Tax is only 200 or so on them for a year, think there was a few months on it alright. Yes it was tested,

She loves it, she came from a micra.

renemegane

Haha))) Thank you) Very inspiring)))) If I bought 99, do you think I could count on 2-3 years drive?

Deleted User wrote: »

YARIS - all the way!! Owned two of them - they have great re-sale value. They ever let me down - even the 99D reg which I only sold last year for 2.5K..... go YARIS!

renemegane

One more question))) Was it an old micra? Boxy one?

colm_mcm wrote: »

Tax is only 200 or so on them for a year, think there was a few months on it alright. Yes it was tested,

She loves it, she came from a micra.

colm_mcm

It was the K11, kinda 93-02 model.

renemegane

Was looking at newer ones, they seem ok too. Thought she was not happy with 02 onwards. Thanks for the info

colm_mcm wrote: »

It was the K11, kinda 93-02 model.

colm_mcm

The newer micras aren't built as well, in my opinion.
She didn't have any trouble with hers (she had 2 1997 micras) apart from rust (which killed both of them)

Moneymaker

You'll easily get 2-3 years safe, cheap and reliable motoring.

Actually drove my sisters 05 model today. It's a nippy enough for a 1.0, easily do 120kph and it's a perfectly fine car to drive.

allthedoyles

Had a 2001 Polo , in mid '00's and it gave some trouble with warning lights every few months .

Had a crash and can say it was definately a strong car , as it took a massive impact , but little damage.

not much in front of you in a Yaris , but is definately more economical than a Polo

colm_mcm

Yaris is quite a safe car for 1999.


Polo
http://www.euroncap.com/tests/vw_polo_1997/13.aspx

Newer model polo
http://euroncap.com/tests/vw_polo_2002/114.aspx

Yaris
http://www.euroncap.com/tests/toyota_yaris_2000/74.aspx

JohnBoy26

The yaris is by far a better car than a polo. The polo despite it's quality image is not really a great car imo.

Duke O Smiley

You really cannot beat a Yaris for a first car. Just keep changing the oil every now and again and it will most probably provide years of hassle free service. They demand high prices here for a reason, so you may pay a little bit dearly for one, though for a first car it will be worth it.

OldMrBrennan83

This post has been deleted.

dhog4n

My sister has had a 2004 1.2 Polo for about 18 months. She is taking a free 1996 1.4 Polo from me shortly (the family back up car) just to get away from the constant repair bills.

It seems that engine is to be avoided. It has never run right during the 18 months. It has had two out of three coils replaced and only has full compression on one cylinder despite the repeated efforts of her mechanic.

keyboard_cat

renemegane wrote: »

Hi all

Was on a passenger seat in Yaris - nice little car, same price range but seemed a bit too loud inside...

I have a 2000 polo the engine in it is quite loud and sounds a bit like a diesel apparently this is the norm with polos but apart from that it's a great car

colm_mcm

Patww79 wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

With respect, what you're saying is nonsense. Carzone is mainly dealers, and nobody uses CBG.
The biggest selection is on donedeal, of course there are a few crap examples, but that's only because there are so many cars.

I have bought many cars from donedeal advertisers without issue, if you're suggesting that CBG or carzone have some sort of quality controls on the cars that are being sold, or that donedeal is exclusively for messers then you're miles out.

renemegane

I assume sound isolation in old Micras is far from Yaris tho

colm_mcm wrote: »

The newer micras aren't built as well, in my opinion.
She didn't have any trouble with hers (she had 2 1997 micras) apart from rust (which killed both of them)

renemegane

Have you had it for long? Any problems w/it?

keyboard_cat wrote: »

I have a 2000 polo the engine in it is quite loud and sounds a bit like a diesel apparently this is the norm with polos but apart from that it's a great car

renemegane

So if to go for a Polo then choose an older version, right?

dhog4n wrote: »

My sister has had a 2004 1.2 Polo for about 18 months. She is taking a free 1996 1.4 Polo from me shortly (the family back up car) just to get away from the constant repair bills.

It seems that engine is to be avoided. It has never run right during the 18 months. It has had two out of three coils replaced and only has full compression on one cylinder despite the repeated efforts of her mechanic.

renemegane

Wow! It really is! Thanks a mil!

colm_mcm wrote: »

Yaris is quite a safe car for 1999.

OldMrBrennan83

This post has been deleted.

renemegane

Thank you! I certainly hope so

Moneymaker wrote: »

You'll easily get 2-3 years safe, cheap and reliable motoring.

Actually drove my sisters 05 model today. It's a nippy enough for a 1.0, easily do 120kph and it's a perfectly fine car to drive.

You are not the first person I hear about hazards in Polo... And regarding the safety... colm_mcm has posted a few links, in my understanding, Yaris is safer than an old Polo.

allthedoyles wrote: »

Had a 2001 Polo , in mid '00's and it gave some trouble with warning lights every few months .

Had a crash and can say it was definately a strong car , as it took a massive impact , but little damage.

not much in front of you in a Yaris , but is definately more economical than a Polo

Thanks guys, the more I read the more I want it!)

JohnBoy26 wrote: »

The yaris is by far a better car than a polo. The polo despite it's quality image is not really a great car imo.

Duke O Smiley wrote: »

You really cannot beat a Yaris for a first car. Just keep changing the oil every now and again and it will most probably provide years of hassle free service. They demand high prices here for a reason, so you may pay a little bit dearly for one, though for a first car it will be worth it.

I thought I can't find a good car with a genuine owner on donedeal, but talked to friends, they all bought their second hand ones there. Not a problem with them.

Patww79 wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

Agree.

colm_mcm wrote: »

With respect, what you're saying is nonsense. Carzone is mainly dealers, and nobody uses CBG.
The biggest selection is on donedeal, of course there are a few crap examples, but that's only because there are so many cars.

I have bought many cars from donedeal advertisers without issue, if you're suggesting that CBG or carzone have some sort of quality controls on the cars that are being sold, or that donedeal is exclusively for messers then you're miles out.

colm_mcm

renemegane wrote: »

I assume sound isolation in old Micras is far from Yaris tho

Yeah! The micra was much noisier, engine and gearbox noise especially.

renemegane

So now your mrs is happy and that's the main thing! With your help as well as the other's I decided to go for Yaris)

colm_mcm wrote: »

Yeah! The micra was much noisier, engine and gearbox noise especially.

keyboard_cat

renemegane wrote: »

Have you had it for long? Any problems w/it?

Have not had it too long, the only other problem i can think to mention which seems to be a common fault too would be the electric windows on mine are a bit sluggish (this is apparently due to broken clips which hold the window into the motor assembly) but it can be fixed for about 10 euro to get new clips if you are handy taking apart the car door. but i would suggest going for regular crank windows if possible.
Creating an account here might be a good place to ask about what you should be aware of when getting a new one
http://www.tigerstyle.co.uk/phpBB3/index.php

renemegane

Will register there for sure!!! Thanks again for your reply!

keyboard_cat wrote: »

Have not had it too long, the only other problem i can think to mention which seems to be a common fault too would be the electric windows on mine are a bit sluggish (this is apparently due to broken clips which hold the window into the motor assembly) but it can be fixed for about 10 euro to get new clips if you are handy taking apart the car door. but i would suggest going for regular crank windows if possible.
Creating an account here might be a good place to ask about what you should be aware of when getting a new one