Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Does McGuinness have any chance given the Indo's campaign against him?

  • 16-10-2011 4:52pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 386 ✭✭


    As the paper of record, the Irish Times tends to present a generally balanced view on things. The Independent, on the other hand, tends not to.

    Can McGuinness (or, indeed, any candidate) stand a chance in an election if the most widely circulated newspaper (the Irish Independent) is campaigning against him? For example, today, the website of the Independent ran some lead articles in opposition to MMcG while the Times didn't feature him in their headlines.

    2 of the Indo articles were written by Belfast Telegraph columnists - the Independent and Belfast Telegraph are owned by the same group, and, hence, often use the same journalists. Do boardsies think this is why their coverage is so one-sided?


«1345

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34,681 ✭✭✭✭NIMAN


    imho there has been a lot of media outlets guilty of anti-MMG bias, not just the Irish Independent.

    You can add RTE TV, RTE radio, TV3 .....


  • Moderators, Education Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 24,056 Mod ✭✭✭✭Sully


    Its all balanced out with the amount of shinners who come online in all shapes and disguises to talk him up.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,920 ✭✭✭Einhard


    In fairness, the Indo featured a full page spread a few weeks back where Kevin Myers wrote in opposition to MMG, and another columnist, whose name escapes me, wrote in favour of him. I don;t think this media bias is as all pervasive as SF heads like to let on. Quite a lot of it is just reporting.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 386 ✭✭The Minstrel


    Sully wrote: »
    Its all balanced out with the amount of shinners who come online in all shapes and disguises to talk him up.

    But what relevance do the musings of any boards-users (or any other online forum) have? Nobody pays any notice of what goes on in online forums. The front page of the Irish Independent is a different story.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 386 ✭✭The Minstrel


    Einhard wrote: »
    In fairness, the Indo featured a front page spread a few weeks back where Kevin Myers wrote in opposition to MMG, and another columnist, whose name escapes me, wrote in favour of him. I don;t think this media bias is as all pervasive as SF heads like to let on. Quite a lot of it is just reporting.

    Ah come on now. Look at the Irish Times coverage v Irish Independent. Is the question raised in the original post re Belfast Telegraph valid?


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    But what relevance do the musings of any boards-users (or any other online forum) have? Nobody pays any notice of what goes on in online forums. The front page of the Irish Independent is a different story.

    You think social media plays no role in forming political views and winning support for candidates? Good luck with that theory...:rolleyes:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,163 ✭✭✭✭Liam Byrne


    Are we talking daily Indo or the heap of ****e they spew out on Sundays?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,158 ✭✭✭Tayla


    Sully wrote: »
    Its all balanced out with the amount of shinners who come online in all shapes and disguises to talk him up.

    I don't agree that internet forums balance out negativity in national newspapers.

    I also don't agree that people are coming on here in disguises to talk him up, someone mentioned that in another thread on this forum and then suddenly everyone jumped on that line and started repeating it.

    Does anyone know if all the candidates will get an interview on the 6 o clock news like Sean got?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,458 ✭✭✭✭gandalf


    Martin McGuinness has serious questions to answer about his past. He has not provided truthful answers and an awful lot of people in this country want those answers. The media have every right to ask him about his past and to keep doing so because their readers want that information and it does sell papers which is their business.

    Other candidates have had rough rides from the media because of their pasts as well like Norris and Davis so throwing yourselves up on the cross and claiming media bias is getting tiresome. I think it is time that the Sinn Fein supporters concede that the candidate that they proposed was wholly inappropriate for the position of the head of state of the Republic of Ireland.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,949 ✭✭✭The Waltzing Consumer


    Ah come on now. Look at the Irish Times coverage v Irish Independent. Is the question raised in the original post re Belfast Telegraph valid?

    :P Shinners always slagged the Irish Times and called it a Unionist Protestant paper based on it's history, now they are championing it.

    No the question raised in the original point is not valid, all information is out there for anyone to find it, SF seem to be just lining up the excuses if McGuinness does not get elected and blame it on "media propaganda" :rolleyes:

    There are plenty of articles written in all papers, editorial or not, about all candidates and whilst I really do despise the "x-factor" style of examining our candidates, it will not bother me too much because I can think for myself.

    Our papers and journalists should have the freedom to question and investigate all candidates, it only seems to be McGuinness and SF who still have an air of menace to them, proven by the fact he approached the lady from RTE after the debate to give out, disgusting!

    I greatly dislike many of these guys running, but I would have zero problem talking and telling them why if they ever called to the door or if I met them on the street campaigning, I simply don't feel I can do that with SF, there is an air of menace and intimidation about them and in particular about McGuinness which is not needed for any democracy.

    So here is a better question, how is it possible that I can criticize or see journalists criticise any candidate from any party, but when it comes to SF and McGuinness, there is an air of thuggery about them so if you or a journalist criticised or delved too much into something, the mask of a modern political party slips, and you see an intimidating gang mentality there??


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 27,644 ✭✭✭✭nesf


    gandalf wrote: »
    I think it is time that the Sinn Fein supporters concede that the candidate that they proposed was wholly inappropriate for the position of the head of state of the Republic of Ireland.

    De Valera will rise from the grave to apologise for the mess he made of our Government system long before that happens.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,819 ✭✭✭Hannibal


    gandalf wrote: »
    Martin McGuinness has serious questions to answer about his past. He has not provided truthful answers and an awful lot of people in this country want those answers. The media have every right to ask him about his past and to keep doing so because their readers want that information and it does sell papers which is their business.

    Other candidates have had rough rides from the media because of their pasts as well like Norris and Davis so throwing yourselves up on the cross and claiming media bias is getting tiresome. I think it is time that the Sinn Fein supporters concede that the candidate that they proposed was wholly inappropriate for the position of the head of state of the republic of Ireland.
    He's practically head of state of northern Ireland so what's different between them and us?

    There's been no proof issued to suggest that MMcG has not provided truthful answers to the questions posed, he hasn't provided the answers the press want from him so they just keep attacking him hoping he'll crack when he won't.

    Look at Miriam O'Callaghan where they call him a "bully boy" for being accused of murdering people on live tv, if anything he was being bullied. Miriam was offered the chance to bring a colleague with her but declined and is not happy that her line of questioning was queried. I think anybody would be pretty annoyed if they accused of something like this on tv.

    It's like a campaign of hate that's waiting for him at the school gate every day. It's not upto the media to decide if he's fit to be head of state it's upto the people who cast their votes. You would struggle to see this type of media bias in some countries where their media is state controlled.

    Sinn Fein has been backing an International Independent Truth Commission since around 2008/2009 so surely he as VP of that party supports this and will be prepared to answer any questions about his past in the proper enviroment rather than in the sensationalist headline way the papers expect. The British government also has questions to answer on it's role in Ireland and has so far refused to co-operate on a meaningful level and names anyone involved as A,B,C,D,X etc so all the blame cannot be levelled at Sinn Fein members or the IRA. MMcG has been democratically elected since the mid 90's and should be respected as such as anything else is an insult to the people who voted for him.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,163 ✭✭✭✭Liam Byrne


    Dotsey wrote: »
    He's practically head of state of northern Ireland so what's different between them and us?

    They were given the non-violent options and refused them.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Dotsey wrote: »
    He's practically head of state of northern Ireland so what's different between them and us?

    No, I think you'll find that's Queen Elizabeth 2. I can understand your confusion though... :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,819 ✭✭✭Hannibal


    Our papers and journalists should have the freedom to question and investigate all candidates, it only seems to be McGuinness and SF who still have an air of menace to them, proven by the fact he approached the lady from RTE after the debate to give out, disgusting!
    He was practically called a murderer on live tv and it's disgusting to you that he's annoyed about it? A question like that is only asked with an air of menace, he asked Miriam to bring a colleague with her into the room so he could talk to her in private and she declined even her own colleague Pat Kenny hinted that her line of questioning was wrong but wouldn't criticise her straight out.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14,670 ✭✭✭✭Wolfe Tone


    It seems to me the British media, the Guardian and what not, are actually more balanced and fair when it comes to Martin.

    I knew at the onset that there would be a campaign by the establishment to keep him out and there has been... "Move on, but not down here" seems to be the message.

    Most people besides the ardent anti republicans, seem to acknowledge this bias in the media.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,819 ✭✭✭Hannibal


    No, I think you'll find that's Queen Elizabeth 2. I can understand your confusion though... :D
    The Anglo German queen of England wasn't elected by the people, McGuinness and Peter Robinson were. That's why I said "practically"


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Dotsey wrote: »
    The Anglo German queen of England wasn't elected by the people, McGuinness and Peter Robinson were. That's why I said "practically"
    You can't be 'practically head of state' in a state that already has a head of state, unless perhaps you are just about to be sworn in. The head of state's ancestry is rather irrelevant.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Wolfe Tone wrote: »
    "Move on, but not down here" seems to be the message.

    Isn't that what Martin calls the country whose presidency he's trying to win? ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,819 ✭✭✭Hannibal


    You can't be 'practically head of state' in a state that already has a head of state, unless perhaps you are just about to be sworn in. The head of state's ancestry is rather irrelevant.
    The democratic process must be respected


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,949 ✭✭✭The Waltzing Consumer


    Dotsey wrote: »
    He was practically called a murderer on live tv and it's disgusting to you that he's annoyed about it? A question like that is only asked with an air of menace, he asked Miriam to bring a colleague with her into the room so he could talk to her in private and she declined even her own colleague Pat Kenny hinted that her line of questioning was wrong but wouldn't criticise her straight out.

    In our law, and most laws, a person is as guilty of murder even if they did not pull the trigger or press the button for the bomb themselves but planned the murder and had some hand in it.

    McGuinness rose through the ranks of the PIRA to its highest levels according to pretty much anyone. Someone at such a high level would have been privy to huge amounts of information and planning of activities such as murder and bombings.

    Do you honestly believe that McGuinness was never involved at any stage with the planning or involvement in bombings or shootings?

    He was caught with explosives and bullets in the early 70s, what was this for?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,968 ✭✭✭✭phog


    Dotsey wrote: »
    He's practically head of state of northern Ireland so what's different between them and us?

    M MG and the IRA refused to lay down arms until they had a foothold in politics in NI while "down here" we've been electing governments and president since the foundation of the state.
    It's not upto the media to decide if he's fit to be head of state it's upto the people who cast their votes.

    The media wont decide the electorate will or do you class us as being uneducated too.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Dotsey wrote: »
    The democratic process must be respected

    Indeed. And what's your point?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,949 ✭✭✭The Waltzing Consumer


    Wolfe Tone wrote: »
    It seems to me the British media, the Guardian and what not, are actually more balanced and fair when it comes to Martin.

    I knew at the onset that there would be a campaign by the establishment to keep him out and there has been... "Move on, but not down here" seems to be the message.

    Most people besides the ardent anti republicans, seem to acknowledge this bias in the media.

    So? There is bias in nearly all media. Norris has been hounded out of it with all the coverage, Mitchell has been laughed at the whole time, Dana has been the bible constitution extremist the whole time, Davis is the quango queen, Higgins is the old man.

    SF are as bad, if not worse, then the other parties, organising all the propaganda that you guys like but then crying like little girls when it does not go your way. SF are masters of manipulation of the media and press, so stop with the whinging because they are asking more questions then you like to answer. They are not the mafia, they are meant to be an open, democratic, modern political party.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,066 ✭✭✭✭Happyman42


    It's a pity the Indo and the rest of the media wouldn't do what they are supposed to and find this 'proof' that everybody is so sure is out there.
    Too busy giving us their 'opinions'. :rolleyes:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 56 ✭✭FionnRua


    Have the Sindo said anything that is incorrect about the former terrorist?
    Or are we suffering from a complex? Isnt it terrible that they are all against us.
    Just ask Gerry McCabe and Jean McConville.
    Time for Martys supporters to grow up.
    I am sure he showed bigger balls than this when he was out fighting for Irelands freedom on all our behalf - allegedly.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,949 ✭✭✭The Waltzing Consumer


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    It's a pity the Indo and the rest of the media wouldn't do what they are supposed to and find this 'proof' that everybody is so sure is out there.
    Too busy giving us their 'opinions'. :rolleyes:

    Pretty much the standard response of all mafias.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14,670 ✭✭✭✭Wolfe Tone


    So? There is bias in nearly all media. Norris has been hounded out of it with all the coverage, Mitchell has been laughed at the whole time, Dana has been the bible constitution extremist the whole time, Davis is the quango queen, Higgins is the old man.

    SF are as bad, if not worse, then the other parties, organising all the propaganda that you guys like but then crying like little girls when it does not go your way. SF are masters of manipulation of the media and press, so stop with the whinging because they are asking more questions then you like to answer. They are not the mafia, they are meant to be an open, democratic, modern political party.
    I really don't care about what the rags say, but when it is the state broadcaster which has a professional responsibility to be impartial and unbiased when hosting a debate showing incredible bias I have an issue.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,920 ✭✭✭Einhard


    Dotsey wrote: »
    There's been no proof issued to suggest that MMcG has not provided truthful answers to the questions posed, he hasn't provided the answers the press want from him so they just keep attacking him hoping he'll crack when he won't.

    In 1994, MMG stated quite emphatically that he was never a member of the IRA. Now he claims he was, but left in 1974. He has a track record of lying about his onvolvement in that organisation.

    Apart from that, I find it odd that we are supposed to accept the word of a man who admits to having been involved at a high level with an organisation which murdered innocent civilians.

    Also, don't SF have their very own propoganda piece in An Phoblacht??


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,968 ✭✭✭✭phog


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    It's a pity the Indo and the rest of the media wouldn't do what they are supposed to and find this 'proof' that everybody is so sure is out there.
    Too busy giving us their 'opinions'. :rolleyes:

    Has Martin asked his solicitors to take a case against the media witchhunt against him, if he can prove his innocence he'll make a fortune and shut the media up once and for all.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,066 ✭✭✭✭Happyman42


    Pretty much the standard response of all mafias.

    What do you use yours for. Toilet paper? ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,210 ✭✭✭Tazz T


    Considering the Irish Times have him photoshopped onto the body of Austin Powell's arch enemy today, cat 'n' all, I don't think it's just the Indo that has it in for him.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,066 ✭✭✭✭Happyman42


    phog wrote: »
    Has Martin asked his solicitors to take a case against the media witchhunt against him, if he can prove his innocence he'll make a fortune and shut the media up once and for all.

    While the deniers down South can play with peoples lives McG doesn't have that luxury and has some responsibility to the peace, wouldn't you think?

    It's not and never has been, about the money for Adams or McG. That I admire about them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,920 ✭✭✭Einhard


    The mantra of SF over the last few weeks has been "move on, forget the dark days of the past and move towards a better future" etc etc. yet they themselves wallow in the past they exhort the rest of us to forget. This is one page from An Phoblacht's website:
    I nDíl Chuimhne
    1 October 1977: Seán Ó CONAILL, Sinn Féin (Parkhurst Prison)
    1 October 1996: Pat McGEOWN, Sinn Féin
    2 October 1971: Volunteer Terence McDERMOTT, Belfast Brigade, 1st Battalion
    2 October 1978: Volunteer Pat HARKIN, Derry Brigade
    6 October 1972: Volunteer Daniel McAREAVEY, Belfast Brigade, 2nd Battalion
    9 October 1976: Noel JENKINSON, Sinn Féin (Leicester Prison)
    9 October 1990: Volunteer Dessie GREW, Martin McCAUGHEY, Tyrone Brigade
    10 October 1972: Volunteer John DONAGHY, Volunteer Patrick MAGUIRE, Volunteer Joseph McKINNEY, Belfast Brigade, 2nd Battalion
    16 October 1972: Volunteer Hugh HERON, Volunteer John Patrick MULLAN, Tyrone Brigade
    16 October 1976: Volunteer Paul MARLOWE, Belfast Brigade, 2nd Battalion; Volunteer Frank FITZSIMMONS, Volunteer Joseph SURGENOR, Belfast Brigade, 3rd Battalion
    16 October 1992: Sheena CAMPBELL, Sinn Féin
    18 October 1974: Volunteer Michael HUGHES, Newry Brigade
    23 October 1971: Volunteer Dorothy MAGUIRE, Volunteer Maura MEEHAN, Cumann na mBan, Belfast
    23 October 1979: Volunteer Martin McKENNA, Belfast Brigade, 3rd Battalion
    23 October 1993: Volunteer Thomas BEGLEY, Belfast Brigade, 3rd Battalion
    24 October 1971: Volunteer Martin FORSYTHE, Belfast Brigade, 1st Battalion
    25 October 1982: Peter CORRIGAN, Sinn Féin
    26 October 1990: Tommy CASEY, Sinn Féin
    27 October 1970: Volunteer Peter BLAKE, Volunteer Tom McGOLDRICK, Belfast Brigade, 2nd Battalion
    28 October 1976: Máire DRUMM, Sinn Féin
    28 October 1987: Volunteer Paddy DEERY, Volunteer Eddie McSHEFFREY, Derry Brigade
    30 October 1974: Volunteer Michael MEENAN, Derry Brigade
    31 October 1975: Volunteer Seamus McCUSKER, Belfast Brigade, 3rd Battalion
    Always remembered by the Republican Movement
    Ó CONAILL, Seán (Sinn Féin). In memory of Seán Ó Conaill whose illness went undiagnosed and untreated in Parkhurst Prison, Isle of Wight, and who died in hospital on 1 October 1977, the day after removal from prison. Remembered by his friends in the Prisoners’ Aid Committee.
    QUIGLEY, Jimmy. In proud and loving memory of Volunteer Jimmy Quigley whose 39th anniversary occurs on 29th September. Always remembered by his brother Tommy and family.
    Comhbrón

    DONNELLY. Deepest sympathies are extended to Paul, Alan and the wider Donnelly family circle on the sad loss of their father John. From the Hazlett family, Blanchardstown.
    DONNELLY. Deepest sympathies are extended to Paul and Alan Donnelly on the recent death of their father John. From all the members and supporters of the Volunteer Joe McDonnell Sinn Féin Cumann, Baile Átha Cliath Thiar.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy to Tonya and family on the recent death of Mark. From Ross Carmody.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to Tony Duncan and his family on the death of his brother Mark. From his comrades in the ODU, Dublin.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy to Tony and all of the Duncan family on the sad and untimely death of Mark. From Dublin Sinn Féin
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy to Tony and his family on the recent death of his brother Mark. From Pajo.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to Gerry O’Flaherty and family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From his comrades in the ODU, Dublin.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy to Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the recent and sudden death of Yvonne. From the National ODU.
    O’FLAHERTY. To Gerry and all the family, heart felt sympathy on the death of Yvonne.
    “All things are impermanent, with mindfulness strive on.” From Pajo and Donna Mac Aodh.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade and friend Gerry O’Flaherty and all his family on the death of Yvonne. From Peter Graves and everyone in the Sinn Féin Bookshop.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade and friend Gerry O’Flaherty and all his family on the death of Yvonne. From Dublin Sinn Féin.
    Buíochas

    The Volunteer Charlie McGlade Sinn Féin Cumann, Drimnagh, would like to thank all those who participated in our recent commemoration, especially Paddy Quinn, Dáithí Doolan, the Burns/Moley Sinn Féin Cumann from South Armagh, the Dublin colour party and the Rising Phoenix RFB.


    Notices

    CHARLIE McGLADE COMMEMORATION IN DUBLIN

    Posted by aprn On September - 30 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    BY IAN McBRIDE
    mcglade-main-p28.jpg Colour Party outside the McGlade family home

    H-BLOCKS Hunger Striker Paddy Quinn, from south Armagh, told the Volunteer Charlie McGlade Commemoration in Dublin that the best monument that could be given to Charlie McGlade, his Hunger Strike comrades and all those who have given their lives for Irish freedom is to build the Republic which they fought and died for. “This can only be given to them now by working with and popularising Sinn Féin.”
    To read the rest of this article subscribe by contacting dixie@anphoblacht.com




    Commemoration


    First Derry Volunteer to be killed by Crown forces, 1971

    Posted by aprn On September - 9 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    ÓGLACH EAMONN LAFFERTY MEMORIAL LECTURE, 40th ANNIVERSARY | BY MARTIN McGUINNESS MP, MLA

    lafferty-main.jpg A large audience turned out for the Eamonn Lafferty Memorial Lecture in Derry City

    “EAMONN LAFFERTY was the first IRA Volunteer to be killed by crown forces in Derry in the recent phase of our struggle, on 18th August 1971. Coming in the immediate aftermath of the introduction of internment and inside the perimeter of what was at that time ‘Free Derry’, it had an indelible impact on the whole community. We also remember IRA Volunteer James O’Hagan, who lost his life in a shooting in the Waterside the following day.
    It says a lot about Eamonn’s strength of character that in the IRA at that time he was identified as a leader at the young age of 18 and led from the front in many actions without fear until his untimely death following a fierce gun-battle with British forces 40 years ago today — just two months short of his 20th birthday.
    The Hunger Strike came at the end of a decade in which the British Government had employed every conceivable weapon in its substantial military and political arsenal. This included its determination to forge political alliances with the SDLP and the Irish Government in an attempt to stem the growing influence of republicans and undermine our developing peace and political strategy.
    The British aim was simple — to protect British interests and to defeat Irish republicanism and the struggle for Irish reunification and independence.
    While the foundations for the peaceful, democratic process in which we now play a major part lays in the years following the Hunger Strike, IRA Volunteers like Eamonn Lafferty continued to engage the might of the British Army.
    Senior members of the British Army conceded that they could never hope to defeat the IRA. Eventually, in the aftermath of the 1997 general election, the British Government, led by Prime Minister Tony Blair, came to the negotiating table.
    I have had many very interesting conversations with Tony Blair, the most interesting of which took place during the week leading to the Good Friday Agreement when he
    admitted that after studying Irish history that it was his view that successive British governments were as responsible as anyone from the North for the situation that partition had brought.
    Everyone needs to be clear about the type of republic we want to create: Sinn Féin wants to change the status quo on this island not join it. We are a country in transition, a country in continuous change and Sinn Féin is driving that change.
    The construction of the New Republic will require the reconciliation of Orange and Green. It will require that we reach out to unionists and engage with them to determine what accommodating them and their understanding of Britishness in a new Ireland would entail. It will necessitate us, as republicans, to think outside our comfort zone, to consider different constructs that although would be independent and sovereign, may not fit our traditional view of the Republic.
    I believe that it is generally accepted that if we are to map our way towards Irish unity we need to do so in a manner that is both economically attractive and politically sensitive to those unionists who fear change will disadvantage them. We must change our politics, our economy and our whole society for the better. But we can’t do that
    without examining a fundamental issue — the way we govern ourselves.
    We cannot expect to reach our full economic potential by maintaining two economic and political structures — two sets of currencies, tax systems, social services, laws and regulations — for a population of six million people. All the people who share this island would benefit from the creation of a vibrant, dynamic all-Ireland economy based on democratic control over Irish monetary and fiscal policies, an equitable and progressive tax regime, a harmonised VAT, income tax and corporation tax, and all-Ireland regulation of public and private sector business to ensure protection of the economic interests of the people of Ireland.
    In the course of the struggle, many challenges have been placed in our way, many decisions had to be made. We acknowledge that these challenges and decisions posed great difficulties, apprehension and pain for some people — indeed at times including myself.
    As a result, a small minority may have felt confused and disconnected from the changing strategy being adopted and an even smaller minority opposed the strategy.
    To the former, I ask that them to honestly look at how far we have travelled in the last 40 years and to ask ourselves the question, how best do we deliver our common objective of building the New Republic, reuniting Ireland, and what contribution is required of all of us to make it happen? To the latter, I say the overwhelming number of republicans who participated in the struggle support our strategy. Under no circumstances can we allow tiny, unrepresentative groups committed to violence prevail over the democratically-expressed wishes of the people of Ireland’s 32 counties in election after election.
    We are within striking distance of achieving what our fallen comrades gave their lives for. They created the circumstances for us as republicans to achieve our republican objectives. It’s up to each and every one of us who proclaim to be republican to stand shoulder to shoulder and finish the task set for us.
    Let the laughter of our children be our revenge. Let’s make sure that our children are the generation that sees Ireland reunited and free.
    We have within our grasp the opportunity to deliver the united, independent and free Ireland that Eamonn Lafferty, James O’Hagan and their comrades made the supreme sacrifice for.
    They gave their lives and we must now give the rest of our lives to finish this historic task. The most fitting monument we can build to our fallen Volunteers will be the achievement of our republican objectives.”
    » This is an edited version of the Eamonn Lafferty Memorial Lecture given by Martin McGuinness in the Creggan in Derry City on 18th August.
    Subscribe by contacting dixie@anphoblacht.com




    Commemoration News


    Death of Jack Layton, leader of Canada’s New Democratic Party

    Posted by aprn On September - 9 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    SINN FÉIN President Gerry Adams TD has expressed his sadness on learning the news of the death of Jack Layton, the leader of Canada’s New Democratic Party.
    The Sinn Féin leader extended his deepest sympathy and condolences to Mr. Layton’s family, and his many friends and colleagues.
    “I met Jack Layton in Toronto four years ago. He was a friend to the Irish Peace Process and even during difficult times he was a constant source of solidarity and encouragement.
    “His support for peace and justice in Ireland was always assured and appreciated.
    “I extend my condolences to Mr Layton’s wife, Olivia, his family, friends and colleagues.
    “Go ndéana Dia trócaire ar a anam dílis “
    Subscribe by contacting dixie@anphoblacht.com




    Obituary


    Notices

    Posted by aprn On September - 9 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    notices-main.jpg

    I nDíl Chuimhne

    1 September 1973: Volunteer Anne Marie PETTICREW, Cumann na mBan, Belfast.
    4 September 1970: Volunteer Michael KANE, Belfast Brigade, 3rd Battalion.
    9 September 1973: Volunteer Francis DODDS, Long Kesh.
    9 September 1985: Volunteer Raymond McLAUGHLIN, Donegal Brigade.
    12 September 1989: Volunteer Seamus TWOMEY, GHQ Staff.
    14 September 1986: Volunteer Jim McKERNAN, Belfast Brigade, 1st Battalion.
    16 September 1991: Bernard O’HAGAN, Sinn Féin.
    17 September 1972: Volunteer Michael QUIGLEY, Derry Brigade.
    20 September 1972: Fian Joseph McCOMISKEY, Fianna Éireann.
    22 September 1973: Volunteer James BRYSON, Belfast Brigade, 2nd Battalion.
    23 September 1996: Volunteer Diarmuid O’NEILL, England.
    29 September 1972: Volunteer Jimmy QUIGLEY, Belfast Brigade, 2nd Battalion.
    Always remembered by the Republican Movement
    CONNOLLY, Benny. Always remembered by Declan Mullen, Cabra, Dublin.
    McGLADE, Charlie. 17th September 1982. Fuair sé bas ar son soairse na hÉireann, always remembered by the Volunteer Charlie McGlade Sinn Feín Cumann, Drimnagh, Dublin.
    MARCANTONIO, Louis. In proud and loving memory of Sinn Féin activist Louis Marcantonio, who died on 20th September 1985. Remembered by his family and friends in Dublin.
    O’HAGAN, Bernard. In proud and loving memory of Councillor Bernard O’Hagan, murdered on 16th September 1991 by pro-British agents. Always remembered by the McCusker/ McMullan/ O’Hagan Sinn Féin Cumann, Swatragh, County Derry.
    O’NEILL, Diarmuid. In proud and loving memory of Volunteer Diarmuid O’Neill, who was killed on active service in London on 23rd September 1996. Always remembered by the Republican Movement in Munster.
    O’NEILL, Diarmuid. In proud and loving memory of Volunteer Diarmuid O’Neill, whose 15th anniversary occurs on the 23rd September, always remembered by Sinn Féin Cuige Mumhan; Sinn Féin Chorcaí; Cllrs Mick Nugent, Chris O’Leary, Thomas Gould, Henry Cremin & Fiona Kerins; Jonathan O’Brien TD, West Cork Sinn Féin Comhairle Ceantair; East Cork Sinn Féin Comhairle Ceantair; O’Neill/De Barra Sinn Féin Cumann, Cork City; Charlie Hurley Sinn Féin Cumann. Bandon; Ógra Shinn Féin, Chorcaí; MacCurtain/MacSwiney RFB, Corcaigh. “We must take no steps backwards, our steps must be onwards, for if we dont the martyrs who died for you, for me, for this country will haunt us for eternity” — Máire Drumm.
    O’NEILL, Diarmuid. Murdered by the London Metropolitan Police. Always remembered by friends and comrades in the West London Republican Support Group, Hammersmith.
    TREANOR, Tommy (London and Fintona, County Tyrone). Always remembered by friends and comrades in the West London Republican Support Group, Hammersmith.
    Comhbrón

    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade Tony and the Duncan family on the death of his brother Mark. From Sinn Féin Cúige Átha Cliath.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to Tony and the Duncan family on the death of his brother Mark. From Ann and Éamonn.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to Tony and the Duncan family on the death of his brother Mark. From Dessie and Ann Ellis.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathies are extended to Tony and the Duncan family on the death of his brother Mark, from Treasa Quinn, Tommy and Sorcha Berry.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathies to Tony Duncan on the death of his brother Mark. Our thoughts are with you. From Noeleen and Dixie.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to Tony and the Duncan family on the death of his brother Mark. From Nicola King.
    DUNCAN. Duncan. Deepest sympathy to Tony and family on the recent death of Mark. From Ross.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy from Mark McGrogan and family, Bray.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade Tony and the Duncan family on the death of his brother Mark. From the Black/Ryan Sinn Féin Cumann, Lucan; the Drumm/Doherty Sinn Féin Cumann, Clondalkin; the Terry Clarke Sinn Féin Cumann, North Clondalkin; the Markievicz/Ryan/O’Farrell Sinn Féin Cumann, Tallaght; and the Rising Phoenix RFB.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy is extended to Tony Duncan and his family on the death of his brother Mark. From his comrades in the ODU, Dublin.
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy to Tony and all of the Duncan family on the sad and untimely death of Mark. From Dublin Sinn Féin
    DUNCAN. Deepest sympathy to Tony and his family on the death of his brother Mark. From Pajo.
    GUERRINE. Deepest sympathy is extended to Peggy Guerrine and all the Guerrine family on the recent passing of Anto. From all the members and former members of the Martin Forsythe/Bob Smith Sinn Féin Cumann, Dublin South.
    O’CONNELL. Sincere sympathies are extended to Martin and all the O’Connell family on the recent death of Seamus. From Cabra Sinn Féin.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From Sinn Féin Cúige Átha Cliath.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From Ann and Éamonn.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathies are extended to Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From Treasa Quinn, Tommy and Sorcha Berry.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest condolences are offered to Gerry O’Flaherty on the death of his sister Yvonne. Our thoughts are with you. From Noeleen and Dixie.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From Dessie and Ann Ellis.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From Nicola King.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to Gerry O’Flaherty and family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From his comrades in the ODU, Dublin.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy to Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the recent and sudden death of Yvonne. From the National ODU.
    O’FLAHERTY. To Gerry and all the family, heart felt sympathy on the death of Yvonne. “All things are impermanent, with mindfulness strive on.” From Pajo and Donna Mac Aodh.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade and friend Gerry O’Flaherty and all his family on the death of Yvonne. From Peter Graves and everyone in the Sinn Féin Bookshop.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade and friend Gerry O’Flaherty and all his family on the death of Yvonne. From Dublin Sinn Féin.
    O’FLAHERTY. Deepest sympathy is extended to our comrade Gerry and the O’Flaherty family on the death of his sister Yvonne. From the Black/Ryan Cumann, Lucan; the Drumm/ Doherty Sinn Féin Cumann, Clondalkin; the Terry Clarke Sinn Féin Cumann, North Clondalkin; the Markievicz/Ryan/O’Farrell Sinn Féin Cumann, Tallaght; and the Rising Phoenix RFB.




    Notices


    Clonmel marks the Hunger Strike

    Posted by aprn On September - 9 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    clonmel-p28-main.jpg Blanket Man Jim McCann at the Clonmel Hunger Strike commemoration

    THE 30th anniversary of the 1981 Hunger Strike was marked in Clonmel, County Tipperary, on 20th August, with a march through the town centre to the Manchester Martyrs monument on the Quay, where a wreath was laid.
    To read the rest of this article subscribe by contacting dixie@anphoblacht.com




    Commemoration In Remembrance


    2011 Brian Keenan Challenge honours republican legend

    Posted by aprn On September - 9 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    keenan-challenge-main.jpg Winning team: Eamonn Nolan, Ruairí Ó Murchu, Darren O'Rourke and (not in photo) Colm Rennicks. They completed the course of 25km in 3hrs 46mins

    BRIAN KEENAN’S daughter, Chrissie, joined Bobby Storey in making the presentations at the 4th Annual Brian Keenan Mountain Challenge, a 15-mile trek over the Cooley Mountains to pay tribute to the republican legend and raise money for Sinn Féin, at the end of August. Brian’s wife, also Chrissie, was also at the event.
    IRA leader Brian Keenan passed away in 2008 and comrades initiated the Brian Keenan Challenge to honour his memory.
    More than 30 teams of 154 people from all over Ireland took part on 27th August with the intrepid but good-humoured adventurers being bolstered by local Sinn Féin activists in south Down and Louth keeping them fuelled with hot soup, rolls, fresh water and plenty of fruit.
    The winning team was Eamonn Nolan, Ruairí Ó Murchu, Darren O’Rourke and Colm Rennicks, who completed the course in 3 hours 46 minutes. The winners received the Brian Keenan Memorial Shield and a canvass portrait of the 1981 Hunger Strikers.
    The runners-up each received a copy of ‘Banjo’ Bannon’s book, ‘Ascending Heights’ (‘Banjo’, Everest climber and one of Ireland’s most celebrated mountaineers, was a safety steward at this year’s event).
    The team coming in third all received copies of the ‘Brian Keenan – Republican Legend’ book.
    Declan Murphy told An Phoblacht: “Next year will be the fifth anniversary so we will make a big effort to make it a really fitting tribute.
    “A big thanks to this year’s organisers, in particular Jane Martin, and we look forward to seeing more people next year.”
    Subscribe by contacting dixie@anphoblacht.com




    Commemoration In Remembrance


    Derry and Antrim remember Tommy Donaghy

    Posted by aprn On September - 9 - 2011 ADD COMMENTS

    donaghy-comm-main.jpgSOUTH DERRY republican Tommy Donaghy was remembered on Sunday 21st August when hundreds of republicans from across Counties Derry and Antrim marched through Kilrea and along the Drumagarner Road to his graveside at St Mary’s Chapel. They were led by a colour party from the South Derry Martyrs Band.
    Kilrea was a once-renowned bastion of staunch unionism and on the day of Tommy’s funeral, 18th August 1991, mourners were forced to run a gauntlet of physical and verbal abuse from the scores of RUC and British Army personnel who had swamped the area.
    To see our national flag flying where Union Jacks would have flown in their dozens was clearly a source of pride for those from the area who joined in the parade but this wasn’t about triumphalism – it was about equality.
    However, remembering Tommy Donaghy was the reason why we gathered in Kilrea and to recount the life of a republican activist who was cut down in his prime by pro-British death squads.
    Tommy was shot dead by members of a loyalist gun gang on 16th August 1991.
    He had just arrived at work in the Portna Fisheries on the shores of his beloved Lough Neagh when the killers struck.
    As with many of those killed by loyalists, they had been under constant surveillance and suffered harassment at the hands of the Crown forces.
    Inevitably, their security files ended up in the hands of the death squads.
    According to Tommy’s nephew, Seán Ledwidge, Tommy discovered he was being spied on by a British Army undercover unit. Said Seán in his tribute:
    “Tommy pulled back the bushes that the Brit was hiding in and asked him if he could see him okay! The startled Brit didn’t know what to do.”
    Tommy had been interned in the 1970s and was among the last of the internees to be freed in 1975.
    He reported back to the IRA and was arrested on active service in 1977.
    When sentenced to 19 years’ imprisonment he joined his comrades on the Blanket and No-Wash Protest in the H-Blocks of Long Kesh. He was released 11 years later, in July 1988.
    Immediately Tommy joined the John McGinn Sinn Féin Cumann in his local area and became a driving force in the political arena, taking a keen interest in issues relating to ongoing prison struggles.
    Tommy was the thirteenth member of the party to be killed by British forces and their loyalist allies. Four were to die in 1991. Eddie Fullerton was shot dead in his home in Buncrana, County Donegal, in May.
    Just four days prior to Tommy Donaghy’s killing, loyalist assassins shot dead Pádraig Ó Seanachain near Aghyaran, not far from Castlederg in County Tyrone.
    On the morning of Pádraig’s killing, at 8.30am on Monday 12th August, the RUC were spotted near the ambush site.
    Then, a month after Tommy was killed, on 16th September, Councillor Bernard O’Hagan was gunned down as he arrived for work at Magherafelt College.
    In his address at Tommy Donaghy’s commemoration, Francie Molloy, the main speaker on the day, reminded the crowd of the political context of the campaign of assassination directed against republicans in particular and nationalists in general.
    “In almost all of these cases, information on the victims had come from British Crown forces files.
    “The killings could not be divorced from the campaign of vilification, censorship and misrepresentation of Sinn Féin or from the multi-faceted efforts by anti-republican elements to demonise Sinn Féin.”
    These killings were taking place at a time when the foundation stones of the Peace Process were being laid and it is clear the British were attempting to terrorise republicans and weaken Sinn Féin. Clearly, their strategy has failed and failed miserably.


    I know it's long- that's the point. SF doesn't want us to move on from the past- they wantus to selectively forget the past when it's inconvenient to them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,949 ✭✭✭The Waltzing Consumer


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    While the deniers down South can play with peoples lives McG doesn't have that luxury and has some responsibility to the peace, wouldn't you think?

    It's not and never has been, about the money for Adams or McG. That I admire about them.

    You obviousily did not work in the Northern bank :P


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,920 ✭✭✭Einhard


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    While the deniers down South can play with peoples lives McG doesn't have that luxury and has some responsibility to the peace, wouldn't you think?

    Seriously...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    While the deniers down South can play with peoples lives McG doesn't have that luxury and has some responsibility to the peace, wouldn't you think?

    What has this got to do with him not suing people who say he's a murderer, or was involved in organising murders? Are you saying the Peas Process will collapse if he wins the case? :confused:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 815 ✭✭✭todolist


    McGuinness is a thug.Adams is a thug.They condoned and explained away murders.The south with their cults of Collins/Dev Valera inspired those Northern thugs.Collins and Dev Valera were murderous gunman.How can Fine Gael criticize the monster they created?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14,670 ✭✭✭✭Wolfe Tone


    Einhard wrote: »
    In 1994, MMG stated quite emphatically that he was never a member of the IRA. Now he claims he was, but left in 1974. He has a track record of lying about his onvolvement in that organisation.

    Apart from that, I find it odd that we are supposed to accept the word of a man who admits to having been involved at a high level with an organisation which murdered innocent civilians.

    Also, don't SF have their very own propoganda piece in An Phoblacht??

    Do you have a link for that? Would be interested in reading it...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,752 ✭✭✭pablomakaveli


    I've actually seen more stories about Dana than MMG in the media the last few days.

    Norris has featured heavily in the media in relation to the letters, Gallagher and his FF connections have come under scrutiny, Davis has come under fire in relation to the quangos, Dana and the recent controversies have gotten a lot of coverage, Mitchell has come under fire too.

    Thats effectively all the candidates coming under the spotlight of the media as they should be.

    This persecution complex among MMG supporters is extremely arrogant. None of the candidates should be immune and so far none of them have been.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,066 ✭✭✭✭Happyman42


    What has this got to do with him not suing people who say he's a murderer, or was involved in organising murders? Are you saying the Peas Process will collapse if he wins the case? :confused:

    Well, all you political hotshots think it through. McGuinness says he was in the IRA in the 80's;.....what comes next? Pressure to name places and trigger pullers. Off course that is gonna destabilise the peace process.
    All armies need their thug element (spend a few weekends around discos in Athlone or any barracks town) there is no telling what would begin to happen. Even if he doesn't succumb to the pressure, the fact that he might will exert it's own pressure.





    I'll start counting to see how quickly somebody comes in with 'is that a threat?':rolleyes:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    Well, all you political hotshots think it through. McGuinness says he was in the IRA in the 80's;
    No, he says he wasn't a member in the 80s, remember? I know, it's ridiculous.
    Happyman42 wrote: »
    .....what comes next? Pressure to name places and trigger pullers. Off course that is gonna destabilise the peace process.
    Why would he name who pulled the trigger if he's proving he wasn't involved in any murders or organising murders? Surely he'd be insisting he couldn't give any names? :confused:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,066 ✭✭✭✭Happyman42


    No, he says he wasn't a member in the 80s, remember? I know, it's ridiculous.

    It was ...eh.....hypothetical.....you know when someone asks you to 'think it through'? :rolleyes:

    Why would he name who pulled the trigger if he's proving he wasn't involved in any murders or organising murders? Surely he'd be insisting he couldn't give any names? :confused:

    That's what he's been saying. He wasn't involved and doesn't know.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 386 ✭✭The Minstrel


    This IS NOT a Celtic v Rangers thread!

    Please everybody can we keep this thread on topic? The subject is about the power and sway of the most widely circulated newspaper (the Irish Independent) in influencing the outcome of the election, by way of a political bias. BTW the Independent is fully entitled to take any side it wishes. It is not a state-run newspaper and has never been the "paper of record". And please...limit the inappropriate use of smiley faces.
    :P Shinners always slagged the Irish Times and called it a Unionist Protestant paper based on it's history, now they are championing it.
    You are very much mistaken:

    The Irish Independent described the 1916 Easter Rising as "insane and criminal" and famously called for the shooting of its leaders.

    I refer you to: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_Independent


    No, I think you'll find that's Queen Elizabeth 2. I can understand your confusion though... :D
    This is the real Celtic v Rangers point-scoring that I truly despise.

    The Anglo-Irish Agreement in 1985 granted Dublin an inclusive role, and the Good Friday agreement allows Northerners the freedom to claim Irish citizenship. As well you know, the role of head of state does not apply in the same way to NI as in England.
    Wolfe Tone wrote: »
    It seems to me the British media, the Guardian and what not, are actually more balanced and fair when it comes to Martin.

    Most people besides the ardent anti republicans, seem to acknowledge this bias in the media.
    There's clearly a bias. This thread was not started so as to generate a debate as to whether there is or is not a bias, it was started to generate discussion about the influence exerted on the electorate by that bias.

    FionnRua wrote: »
    Have the Sindo said anything that is incorrect about the former terrorist?
    Would you mind staying on topic please?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,920 ✭✭✭Einhard


    Wolfe Tone wrote: »
    Do you have a link for that? Would be interested in reading it...

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Martin-McGuinness-Government-Johnston-Clarke/dp/1840187255/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1318795195&sr=8-1

    No link off hand, but it's there in black and white. And before you reply, no, it;s not an anti-McGuinness spiel. It's actually quite balanced. You'd probably like it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14,670 ✭✭✭✭Wolfe Tone


    Einhard wrote: »
    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Martin-McGuinness-Government-Johnston-Clarke/dp/1840187255/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1318795195&sr=8-1

    No link off hand, but it's there in black and white. And before you reply, no, it;s not an anti-McGuinness spiel. It's actually quite balanced. You'd probably like it.
    Maybe you have no link because it didnt happen, and MMG stood up in court and said that he was a proud member of Oglaigh na hEireann?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,163 ✭✭✭✭Liam Byrne


    Wolfe Tone wrote: »
    Maybe you have no link because it didnt happen, and MMG stood up in court and said that he was a proud member of Oglaigh na hEireann?

    Maybe he meant the real one ?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,920 ✭✭✭Einhard


    Wolfe Tone wrote: »
    Maybe you have no link because it didnt happen, and MMG stood up in court and said that he was a proud member of Oglaigh na hEireann?

    I just provided you with a link...

    Not everything that has ever happened can be found with a quick google search...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,066 ✭✭✭✭Happyman42


    Einhard wrote: »
    It's actually quite balanced.

    Nice of you to acknowledge that there IS a 'balanced view' :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,455 ✭✭✭✭Monty Burnz


    Happyman42 wrote: »
    It was ...eh.....hypothetical.....you know when someone asks you to 'think it through'? :rolleyes:
    Usually, when speaking hypothetically, we indicate it is a hypothetical statement by using a word like 'if'.

    e.g.

    John says he is gay... (statement)

    If John says he is gay...(hypothetical)

    HTH :rolleyes:


  • Advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement