Straight Razors

Amalgam

Is it time for a dedicated Straight Razor thread?

---

I just caught B&B member LarryAndro promoting the following link:

http://www.whippeddog.com/

Some of the 'Poor Man' supplies look ok, no idea what P&P to Ireland would be though.

I am thinking of buying a cheap straight soon.

Shaving.ie

Amalgam wrote: »

Is it time for a dedicated Straight Razor thread?

Yes it is.:)

I think it could get interesting in here as it looks like a few people are just picking it up. It would be great to keep track of the progress and share any useful tips. The more I have read about straight razors over the last few months the more interested I have become in taking it up myself.

Morf

As if a DE Razor habit wasn't expensive enough!

Gran Hermano

Morf wrote: »

As if a DE Razor habit wasn't expensive enough!

You posted that seconds before I was about to type the same!

Sean Quagmire

\o/ I was gonna do this a while back.

The one thing about straight shaving with me was before I bought it I was watching a lot of videos and reading instructions. I said to myself "Im gonna hack the bloody face off myself"

You do have to be carefull but if the razor is sharp and smooth, it is not hard to use at all.

MediaTank

Great idea Amalgam. I've been at it for a week now, and I now that I started off on the wrong foot with advice from badgerandblade.com here http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthread.php?t=28547. This information is great but very technical and not much about the shave itself. He also advocates changing hands and doing a full shave - trust me, baaad idea! I found much better information here http://www.straightrazorplace.com/forums/beginners/38137-first-straight-razor-shave-read-first.html. It's a lot easier on you face and the information is more about the shave.

As for suppliers it's hard to beat theinvisibleedge.co.uk for advice and products. All razors are checked for shave readyness before dispatch and his starter kits are hard to beat value wise.

At the moment I'm trying to hook up with a professional barber for a one on one lesson. Anyone else (in Dublin) interested in this?

MT

MediaTank

Here's a book about how to shave with a straight written in 1905. http://ia360619.us.archive.org/2/items/shavingmadeeasyw0020th/shavingmadeeasyw0020th.pdf

Amalgam

MediaTank wrote: »

Here's a book about how to shave with a straight written in 1905. http://ia360619.us.archive.org/2/items/shavingmadeeasyw0020th/shavingmadeeasyw0020th.pdf

I love the wording. ' What the Man who Shaves Ought to Know '

Really nice find, it answers the questions you'd be scared to ask. The physical aspects and terms for the razor are answered very clearly.

MediaTank

Amalgam wrote: »

I love the wording. ' What the Man who Shaves Ought to Know '

Really nice find, it answers the questions you'd be scared to ask. The physical aspects and terms for the razor are answered very clearly.

Yes, still as valid today as 105 years ago.

Sean Quagmire

Great find indeed, the wording is fantastic.

Very few men seem to think they can hone their own razors. How this impression became current, it is difficult to say. We venture to assert, however, that honing a razor is at least as easy as stropping it. In this case as in many others, the difficulty arises from suposing there is a difficulty

Makes me want to read more articles from that time. Just brilliant.

Wood

I just logged into boards and this was the first thread in the list at the front, which i thought was fitting as i've just had a shave with a straight razor here in work.

Two passes, finished. Once you get proficient you will never go back.

And you look really cool whiile doing it.

Damo649

Are there any shops around Ireland that sell the straight razors, or do ye all buy them online?

MediaTank

Damo649 wrote: »

Are there any shops around Ireland that sell the straight razors, or do ye all buy them online?

shaving.ie sells them online. The Waldorf Barbers on Westmoreland St. sell them too.

Amalgam

The Grooming Rooms on South William Street (Dublin) sell them. Knights Barbers in the St Stephens Green Shopping Center sometimes have them. The hairdresser and barber stock supplier opposite Easons on Middle Abbey Street had the following in their window a few weeks back.

fergalr

I shaved with a straight razor there for a while (maybe a month or 2), 2 or 3 years ago.

I know that it takes a bit of time and practice to learn how to do it, how to care for the blade (strop it, look after it, etc). I spent this time, and got pretty good at it.

But here's the thing I found - at the end of the day, I found it simply gives a less close, less good, shave than something like mach3.

Now, I should say, I've met a lot of men that have much less facial hair growth than me. I get stubbly very fast, will typically be quite stubbly in the evening after a close shave in the morning - in contrast with some guys who only need to shave every few days. So I'm quite sensitive to having a close shave, to the extent that electric razors (and I've tired several, including modern wet-shave ones that use foam, and that get very well reviewed) are actually pretty ineffective.

So, what I'm wondering, whats the experience of other people who usually have quite thick stubble, that have shaved with straight razors? Do you also find that at the end of the day, the shave just isn't as fine as something like Mach3?

Because I'd really rather use something that wasn't disposable, if I could (from the point of view of saving money, and wasting less) but I've honestly not found anything that gives as close a shave.

Unfortunately, I suspect a lot of what I read is either people wanting a straight razor to give them a better shave, and deciding it does, or people that don't actually have a huge amount of hair growth - and I suspect that, contrary to what I might like, the reason mach3 etc have become dominant is that they are actually just rather good at what they do, rather than slick marketing.

Whats other peoples experience?

Cabaal

fergalr wrote: »

So, what I'm wondering, whats the experience of other people who usually have quite thick stubble, that have shaved with straight razors? Do you also find that at the end of the day, the shave just isn't as fine as something like Mach3?

I wouldn't use a Mach3 or Fusion as the "marker" to gage other shavers against as honestly a DE will do a much much better job in comparison.

Obviously you've tried a straight and you mention electric and Mach3's and you want to use something re-usable have you compared all of the above to a DE?

I'm still debating getting a straight to try it out I've been exceedingly happy with my results with a progress over the past 12 months but want to see can I either do a better job with a straight or can I just learn a new "shaving skill" as it were

Amalgam

I would go along with Cabaal, I am very happy with a safety razor, relative to how my skin would be after a shave with a disposable. I would get a straight on the understanding that it would just be 'another skill', rather than a better replacement.

Cabaal

Amalgam wrote: »

I would get a straight on the understanding that it would just be 'another skill', rather than a better replacement.

It really would be just another skill because as it is it takes approx 10 min to do a shaver in the morning with a DE, this includes two passes.

Howevr I think with a straight between the looking after it and all that before and after the shave its bound to take me longer then 10min which I could do without in the mornings

opinion guy

fergalr wrote: »

I shaved with a straight razor there for a while (maybe a month or 2), 2 or 3 years ago.

....snip....

Unfortunately, I suspect a lot of what I read is either people wanting a straight razor to give them a better shave, and deciding it does, or people that don't actually have a huge amount of hair growth - and I suspect that, contrary to what I might like, the reason mach3 etc have become dominant is that they are actually just rather good at what they do, rather than slick marketing.

Whats other peoples experience?

I have similar stubble growth too yourself. Just the once I went to a proper barber and had a striaght razor shave with the hot towels and everything. Must say I was rather underwhelmed. I also felt it wasn't much different to a mach3 or a fusion

MediaTank

fergalr wrote: »

Whats other peoples experience?

I'm new to shaving with a straight, so it's a bit early for me to say. However, I'm enjoying the learning process and that's why I decided to try it out - to learn something new. I've been shaving for years with a DE and find it difficult to believe that a straight could be any better. Only time will tell.

As regards Mach 3 etc. I found that the hysteresis effect was destroying my face, no such problems with a DE. Why not try a DE and see if that works for you.

MT

MediaTank

By way of contrast with the book from 1905, here's one from 2005 http://www.shavemyface.com/downloads/The-Straight-Razor-Shave.pdf Written by Chris Moss - he of the Moss scuttle fame.

Sean Quagmire

In my experience, it takes time to get perfect results from a straight.

I'm using mine 3 months solid with shaves every 2nd day. Results are very close to DE results. The difference comes down to my skill of using it.

What I really love about the Straight above everything else is that there is no clog ever. You'd be surprised how it feels. Really improves comfort.

If you stick with it you will have a more comfortable shave and match results you get from a DE.

The big let down for me with safety razors is the varience of blade Quality. Some brands (BIC yellows and Green 7'oclocks) gave me terrible razor burn while others were fantastic. Russian roullette.

And dont ever mention Mach 3's as even being in the same league as the two products above!!

Gran Hermano

Here's another link to a UK based honemeister

http://www.strop-shop.co.uk/category/Vintage_Straight___Open___Cut_throat_Razors,b.html?limit=200



Only sells vintage straights and new strops and any feedback I've read elsewhere is top class and you know you're getting a proper shave ready razor as opposed to just 'factory sharpened'. The vintage straights are often cheaper than the new so might be a good starting point for those looking to start.







Regarding the M3/Fusion versus straight debate mentioned some posts above. I get my best shaves now from my safety razors, I can get a BBS shave 90% of the time when using my long-handled Progress. I'm not happy unless I can't feel any hair or stubble anywhere on the face or head!



In comparison to the shaves with my DEs, I can get a close shave with an M3 or Fusion but the shave is not as close as what I get with the Progress. It's a smooth shave but I even notice my regrowth is quicker.

Whilst the Fusion blades are also a crazy price I'd still use them if they gave me a better shave - they don't, plus my face can feel irritated after.



If I'm happy with my safety-razor shaves why you may ask do I dabble with straight razors? For the same reason I'll swap different DE razors, blades and soaps/creams into my routine - I like a bit of variety.

I can get a shave with a straight probably as good as I get with a cartridge, but not as good as I get with my safety
razors. I put this down to the fact I need more practice with the straight. Straights have a much steeper learning curve and work commitments mean I haven't had the time lately. I'll be on extended Easter break soon and hope to get back to the straight razor shaves.

I enjoy the sense of achievement I get from using a straight razor and knowing I'm mastering a new skill.

johno2

I just thought I'd add my €0.02 here. I'm a lazy shaver, usually I wait until there's some stubble worth shaving off, so maybe twice a week, sometimes less. I tried all kind of disposable shaving products for years and they all clogged on me. My solution was buying the super cheap single blade yellow bics. I removed the white plastic safety guard being very careful not to damage the blade. Sometimes the blade is bad to begin with so I just throw those away, but the ones with a smooth sharp blade are just great. They can't clog because there's nothing behind the blade to catch the hairs in. If I wipe the crud off and dry them afterwards they last a long time. They're better at getting the hairs just under my nostrils than the bulky multi-blade razors were. They probably don't give as clean a shave as a more expensive solution would, but there's gonna be growth in 3-4 hours anyway which would negate that bonus, so it doesn't bother me. I've been shaving like this for about 10 years now and I have no good reason to change to anything else. Cheap, fast, low maintenance and good enough.

DISCLAIMER: If you try this at home and kill yourself, don't blame me.

johno

Amalgam

Gran Hermano wrote: »

Here's another link to a UK based honemeister
http://www.strop-shop.co.uk/category/Vintage_Straight___Open___Cut_throat_Razors,b.html?limit=200

Lovely lovely straight razors. He sells some very nimble looking 3/8's, I am so tempted by this one.

3/8 Vintage J A Henckels Zwillingswerk Straight Razor, Solingen

Interesting description on this one.

It is a carbon steel blade made from the world-reknowned Swedish Steel, about three quarter hollow ground with an Irish (aka oblique or french) point.

fergalr

Cabaal wrote: »

I wouldn't use a Mach3 or Fusion as the "marker" to gage other shavers against as honestly a DE will do a much much better job in comparison.

Obviously you've tried a straight and you mention electric and Mach3's and you want to use something re-usable have you compared all of the above to a DE?

No - wasn't aware that they were supposed to give a better shave.

Might well invest in one and check it out, after the positive posts here.

I see the blades are disposable - are they more or less economical to use than something like gilettes? I presume they couldn't be much more expensive, anyway?

Cabaal wrote: »

I'm still debating getting a straight to try it out I've been exceedingly happy with my results with a progress over the past 12 months but want to see can I either do a better job with a straight or can I just learn a new "shaving skill" as it were

I definitely don't regret learning how to do it.
One time its extremely useful is if I don't shave for a few weeks and then need to get rid of all the hair at once.
I'm not sure there could be anything better than a straight razor for that situation.

Cabaal

fergalr wrote: »

No - wasn't aware that they were supposed to give a better shave.

Might well invest in one and check it out, after the positive posts here.

I see the blades are disposable - are they more or less economical to use than something like gilettes? I presume they couldn't be much more expensive, anyway?

Judge for yourself
13e for 100 blades (years supply for me),
http://www.shaving.ie/products/Derby-100-Double-Edge-Blades-Full-Box.html

How long you'll get out of them depends on the person and the blade you use, I use derbys as they suit me and I can get upto 5 shaves out of them (3-4 on average), mind you I shave every day

I definitely don't regret learning how to do it.
One time its extremely useful is if I don't shave for a few weeks and then need to get rid of all the hair at once.
I'm not sure there could be anything better than a straight razor for that situation.

Straight blade and associated items with it I'm looking at will cost me in excess of 130e so its not a priority for me right now, but some day soon

Shaving.ie

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

I'm using mine 3 months solid with shaves every 2nd day. Results are very close to DE results. The difference comes down to my skill of using it.

Just curious, do you think you have managed to preserve the sharpness of the razor to date?

Sean Quagmire

Shaving.ie wrote: »

Just curious, do you think you have managed to preserve the sharpness of the razor to date?

I have not notice any dulling that would require honing just yet.
Every two weeks or so I would give it about 50 lap stropping, that would bring it back up to 100% sharpness.

Other than that about 10 -15 laps (About 45 seconds) before I shave is grand.

Id say in about 3 months, I'l order a 8k hone (to replenish the edge) and a 12k (to polish and smooth the blade). After honing with the 12k the blade will literally wipe away the hair i.e 'the buttery feeling'

MediaTank

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

I have not notice any dulling that would require honing just yet.
Every two weeks or so I would give it about 50 lap stropping, that would bring it back up to 100% sharpness.

Other than that about 10 -15 laps (About 45 seconds) before I shave is grand.

Id say in about 3 months, I'l order a 8k hone (to replenish the edge) and a 12k (to polish and smooth the blade). After honing with the 12k the blade will literally wipe away the hair i.e 'the buttery feeling'

I find that stropping before shaving is the key skill to learn. I don't know whether it's my tough beard or stropping technique but it is not sharp enough AFAICT to go anywhere near the chin.

When I started out I nicked the strop over and over with the razor.

Sean Quagmire

MediaTank wrote: »

I find that stropping before shaving is the key skill to learn. I don't know whether it's my tough beard or stropping technique but it is not sharp enough AFAICT to go anywhere near the chin.

When I started out I nicked the strop over and over with the razor.

Yea, stropping before you shave is the most important thing. Especially if you have a tough stubble.

I went about 3 weeks without nicking mine. Thought I was the king, but now I have many nicks on it. I bit of light sanding and forehead oil rubbed into the crack will do the trick.

MediaTank

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

Yea, stropping before you shave is the most important thing. Especially if you have a tough stubble.

I went about 3 weeks without nicking mine. Thought I was the king, but now I have many nicks on it. I bit of light sanding and forehead oil rubbed into the crack will do the trick.

Paradoxically, the shaving part is the easiest - at least on my cheeks.

Shaving.ie

I have been messing with a shavette I had lying around and I found the cheeks and neck were surprisingly okay but the chin and upper lip were a no go area for the moment.

MediaTank

Shaving.ie wrote: »

I have been messing with a shavette I had lying around and I found the cheeks and neck were surprisingly okay but the chin and upper lip were a no go area for the moment.

Same as me then.

Sean Quagmire

Honed my razor last night with terrific results. I did about 15 - 20 laps on a Belgian Blue wetstone. This stone is quiet versatile in that the more laps you do, the more slurry builds up thus increasing the grit.

Therefore you can use it as a polisher/refresher or with more laps it progresses into a cutter for older blades.

I took my time and used the instrustions from the many (many) videos and articles on the net. Followed up by a good strop, the results were fantastic. so smooth.

I'd glady polish razors you have if your interested.
I worked in a butchers for 5 years honing delicate knives and it seemed to carry over when I worked on my straight. As easy touch is key.

Shaving.ie

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

Honed my razor last night with terrific results. I did about 15 - 20 laps on a Belgian Blue wetstone. This stone is quiet versatile in that the more laps you do, the more slurry builds up thus increasing the grit.

Therefore you can use it as a polisher/refresher or with more laps it progresses into a cutter for older blades.

I took my time and used the instrustions from the many (many) videos and articles on the net. Followed up by a good strop, the results were fantastic. so smooth.

I'd glady polish razors you have if your interested.
I worked in a butchers for 5 years honing delicate knives and it seemed to carry over when I worked on my straight. As easy touch is key.

Nice one, I bought a cheap straight to practice honing with. I managed to sharpen it up quite nicely with a 4k/8k combo waterstone. I spent hours getting comfortable with the technique but it is definitely developing. After a while you start to get a feel for it which was initially absent. Moving on to a better quality razor made a world of difference also. There was much better weight, balance and feedback from the strokes.

Sean Quagmire

Chris, was that the norton 4/8k? I was looking at them myself.
Its hard to get a defined grit level for the one im using because its a natural stone. some poeple estimate them at about 9-12k so not much chance of 'over honing' the blade, which I like.

Shaving.ie

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

Chris, was that the norton 4/8k? I was looking at them myself.
Its hard to get a defined grit level for the one im using because its a natural stone. some poeple estimate them at about 9-12k so not much chance of 'over honing' the blade, which I like.

Yes its the Norton. Seems to be a nice stone to learn with plus this video helped me with some pointers. I don't think I would pass the hanging hair test just yet though.. :pac:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tTYbj9ARhk

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tTYbj9ARhk&feature=related

Sean Quagmire

Funny my razor doesnt pass the hanging hair test but It litterally wipes 4 day stubble off my face with ease.

I wouldnt base everything on that test method.. Even when I got the razor from one of the UK's top honemeisters it didnt pass it.

MediaTank

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

I'd glady polish razors you have if your interested.
I worked in a butchers for 5 years honing delicate knives and it seemed to carry over when I worked on my straight. As easy touch is key.

I'm interested where do I sign up

Sean Quagmire

MediaTank wrote: »

I'm interested where do I sign up

I'l pm you my address and you can post it over

MediaTank

Sean Quagmire wrote: »

I'l pm you my address and you can post it over

Great. Thanks.

MT

MediaTank

I think I'm finally getting the hang of this I made a first attempt at the chin area this morning. Stretch, stretch is the only way.

I've also acquired a Thiers Issard straight and a paddle strop. This type of strop is much easier to use and the razor is fantastic.

I also took SeanQuagmire up on his honing offer and he did a great job. Thanks Sean.

Sean Quagmire

No bother.

Ooo got any pics of the Thiers Issard straight, they are beautiful. seen one on youtube before and it was like an axe

Old'n'Cranky

So what is the best way to preserve a straight?
What would you use or could you use to prevent the blade from oxidising?
I mean could you even use WD40?

MediaTank

OldnCranky wrote: »

So what is the best way to preserve a straight?
What would you use or could you use to prevent the blade from oxidising?
I mean could you even use WD40?

3 In 1 Oil, or yes even WD40.

Old'n'Cranky

MediaTank wrote: »

3 In 1 Oil, or yes even WD40.

WD40 it is so, cheers!

Dramatik

Recently made the switch from a DE to straight razor. Shaving with a straight's so much fun and I think it's safe to say I've a healthy obsession with them now I've only used my DE once since I started using the straight and that was only to compare the shaves of the two. I can get really close to the closeness of my DE but not 100% I've no problems with the shave itself, just getting quicker each time. With a straight you defo don't want to rush it. It does take me longer to shave with it but I've just started shaving with it the night before rather than in the morning.

Just got a F.W. Engels "Leader" razor the other week :cool: It's a lovely shaver. I also have a Thiers Issard "Sparticus" razor too . My next purchase has gotta be a Dubl Duck "Goldedge" they're beautiful, they seem to be in pretty big demand at the moment so I think I'll wait a bit and see if I can get one cheap.

I was thinking of maybe starting a thread for people to put up pictures of their straights but I'm not sure if there's enough demand. What do you's think?

Also for those who are starting or thinking of starting I found this guy's videos a great help: http://www.youtube.com/user/geofatboy
He also does DE videos as well so there's something there for you guys as well

Amalgam

The Irish Independent have a picture of candidate Conor Lenihan going for a traditional shave..



---


A close shave
Conor Lenihan gets a shave from John O'Loughlin at Johnny's Traditional Barber Shop, Tallaght, Dublin
Credit: Brian McEvoy Date: February 24, 2011

---

http://photos.independent.ie/gallery/The_campaign_trail/slideshow/Conor_Lenihan_gets_a_shave_from_John_O%27Loughlin_at_Johnny%27s_Traditional_Barber_Shop%2C_Tallaght%2C_Dubli/07UJeNtcCn7dr

Amalgam

Taken from dad.ie. Dan and his Japanese straight, pinky extended..

MadsL

Here's the image tags for the straight razor version of the shaving boardsie below if anyone wants....stand up all you 'straight' guys...kudos to Amalgam for the orginal artwork!!

Just put the http bits into

http://i317.photobucket.com/albums/mm394/SmithfieldResi/shave.png