Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Mobiplanet SMS scam (57976)

24

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 412 ✭✭MOTM


    SB7mobile tried to take €20 from me to despite the fact that I never signed up to the V.fitness.Guru service. The 8*€2.50 premium texts were sent to my mobile broadband number (not even my phone number). Fortunately I was able to read the texts on an app I have on my phone to monitor the broadband router and trace it back to SB7mobile.

    I complained enough to get a cheque back with a full refund. However, I have also followed up with comreg as SB7mobile have not provided me with screenshots or proof that the transaction ever happened despite the fact that I've repeatedly requested same.
    I've checked my browser history for the date in question and there is no trace of me having subscribed to this service. SB7mobile gave me is this link, which doesn't prove anything: https://mobilepaymentsupport.com/. All it indicates is that somebody signed up my number to this so called service.

    I have since blocked all premium text numbers from my mobile broadband router. As many above have said, this should be an opt-in rather than opt-out model.

    It would be great if Comreg could do something about this....but I have my doubts.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,029 ✭✭✭spaceHopper


    If this happens again, tell your mobile company that this is criminal activity and they are laundering money from them. Tell them it's not your problem network security is there. You are not accepting the charge and if they debit it form your account and hand it over to criminals you will take it further and do a DD role back with the bank. The phone companies have the power to shut these guys down but they must be making something from it too.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 412 ✭✭MOTM


    If this happens again, tell your mobile company that this is criminal activity and they are laundering money from them. Tell them it's not your problem network security is there. You are not accepting the charge and if they debit it form your account and hand it over to criminals you will take it further and do a DD role back with the bank. The phone companies have the power to shut these guys down but they must be making something from it too.

    I've already had a go at the network provider about this but may as well be talking to the wall. The only long term solution to this is legislation that looks after the consumer rather than the provider/scammer.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,759 ✭✭✭✭thesandeman


    vFit.guru took €20 off me yesterday. I sent 'Stop' after the first two texts but it sent me another six a few minutes later.
    I most certainly did not click or reply to anything to sign up to them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 412 ✭✭MOTM


    See my previous posts above and check with Comreg who the service provider is. You'll get a refund with persistence. Contact your mobile phone company to stop premium rate services from now on. See here on Comreg https://servicechecker.comreg.ie/Find/Index?q=guru&ServiceName=&PRSNumber=&ShortCode=57976&Description=

    (apart from that, contacting comreg is a waste of time. They never responded or intervened in any shape or form. Just window dressing IMHO)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,759 ✭✭✭✭thesandeman


    MOTM wrote: »
    See my previous posts above and check with Comreg who the service provider is. You'll get a refund with persistence. Contact your mobile phone company to stop premium rate services from now on. See here on Comreg https://servicechecker.comreg.ie/Find/Index?q=guru&ServiceName=&PRSNumber=&ShortCode=57976&Description=

    (apart from that, contacting comreg is a waste of time. They never responded or intervened in any shape or form. Just window dressing IMHO)

    Thanks for that. I'm getting onto the SP later.
    I'm just off chat with Three.
    In fairness to them, they gave me all the details for contacting the spammers, blocked the number, and gave me a fiver and 1000mb as a gesture of goodwill until I sort things out with the SP.
    Credit where credit is due (pun intended).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 412 ✭✭MOTM


    Thanks for that. I'm getting onto the SP later.
    I'm just off chat with Three.
    In fairness to them, they gave me all the details for contacting the spammers, blocked the number, and gave me a fiver and 1000mb as a gesture of goodwill until I sort things out with the SP.
    Credit where credit is due (pun intended).

    Good to see Three gave you something back...as I got nothing from them other than blocking the premium numbers.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,759 ✭✭✭✭thesandeman


    MOTM wrote: »
    Good to see Three gave you something back...as I got nothing from them other than blocking the premium numbers.

    I've had good experiences with them the two times I've needed to contact them (the first time my credit disappeared for no reason and they sorted it eventually when they had the Talk To forum here).
    They gave me a bit of leeway today because of the difficulties of getting a fresh top-up due to Coronavirus etc. It probably depends who you get.
    Time for an argument with the SP now.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 412 ✭✭MOTM


    Time for an argument with the SP now.

    From experience
    (1) go in hard, and don't take no for an answer
    (2) have your facts straight
    (3) keep a record of everything they've said...so do it all on email and insist on written answers.

    In truth, it isn't worth the €20 hassle but I was happy to spend my own time badgering them and forcing them into a U turn. Hopefully more people will read this and do similar.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,921 ✭✭✭Grab All Association


    The majority of people getting hit by this scam tend to own android devices.

    Sites like TippFM, Google, YouTube, Clare FM and MSM have these banner ads covering 50% of the page on screen in some cases. Some companies are just inputting random numbers and making you exhaust the complaints process before giving a refund. The majority of people don’t take it further and do give up.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,609 ✭✭✭amber2


    Having a similar issue with Red27 mobile games. After multiple emails they have offered a refund of €15 of the original €20 taken for 8 txt messages. They were corresponding with me through email until I requested a hard copy of opt in/sign up showing my details phone number etc, phone or device Used to sign up and IP address used at which point they have now stopped Communicating. As they are retaining €5 for a service I never signed up for or availed of I’m entitled to this info.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,962 ✭✭✭r93kaey5p2izun


    I had an issue with this last week. Same number - 57976, but it said I was signed up to something called vFit Guru. The initial text said it would be €20 at 8x2.50 messages. I then received 8 messages which are showing as €2.03 each on my bill.

    I contacted pfi.me customer support which was listed on ComReg as the owner of the number. They said they were just the billing platform and referred me to SPTwo. I contacted them asking how they got my number, for them to delete my number and seeking a refund. I received a vague response about having had to have clicked to accept their service at least twice before being signed up - that is not true. However I have received a €20 refund through PayPal.

    I'm going to ask Three to block premium services on my account now


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,449 ✭✭✭✭AndrewJRenko



    I'm going to ask Three to block premium services on my account now

    Which Three should really have done by default, and given you the chance to opt-in if you wanted, if they had their customers' interests at heart. But presumably they get some cut of the fees so...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,045 ✭✭✭silver2020


    Which Three should really have done by default, and given you the chance to opt-in if you wanted, if they had their customers' interests at heart. But presumably they get some cut of the fees so...

    Not permitted unless you request it. and why just Three?

    Imagine if they did that and you decided to use pay by text for parking and the default meant it was switched off.?

    You'd then be claiming that the mobile network was wrong for that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 553 ✭✭✭flower tattoo


    I requested refund off 57976 & 57977 - they maintain they’re different companies
    Red27 & moonlight mobile but the emails were identical and so were the amounts refunded €18.97 back to PayPal instead of €20 but it’s close enough


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,342 ✭✭✭seagull


    I requested refund off 57976 & 57977 - they maintain they’re different companies
    Red27 & moonlight mobile but the emails were identical and so were the amounts refunded €18.97 back to PayPal instead of €20 but it’s close enough

    It's not close enough. Make those poxy bastards repay you in full. If they still make a euro every time someone they scam complains, they're laughing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,449 ✭✭✭✭AndrewJRenko


    silver2020 wrote: »
    Not permitted unless you request it. and why just Three?

    Imagine if they did that and you decided to use pay by text for parking and the default meant it was switched off.?

    You'd then be claiming that the mobile network was wrong for that.

    Nope, I wouldn't. Worst case is I'd be claiming that they didn't communicate properly.

    But how often does that happen, now that people use apps for parking?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,783 ✭✭✭Joe Public


    My daughter's phone bill (on GOMO) shot up from €10pm to €17.50 last month.
    After some investigating I discovered 3 * 57976 texts @ €2.50 each. She said she didn't subscribe to anything !
    Q. Do I just block the number or what can be done?
    Who gets the money ? do GOMO pass it on to owners of 57976 ? I wonder do the phone operators get a cut of it as well !!

    Very same issue without my daughter replying to their initial text, I only noticed it when the monthly bill came out. I sent stop to the service so hopefully that will stop it. They got 2 x €7.50. I also send a complaint to support@red27mobile.com and asking for the €15 back as there was no reply sent to their unsolicited text.

    I also logged into the GOMO account and attempted to bar premium SMS but it's greyed out meaning they have to do it for you. I opened a webtext screen and sent my request every half hour for 3 hours but no reply, maybe their support person didn't turn up today. I think it will bar the sending of premium SMSs but still be able to receive them so might not be a lot of use.


  • Moderators, Business & Finance Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 15,008 Mod ✭✭✭✭whiterebel


    Joe Public wrote: »
    Very same issue without my daughter replying to their initial text, I only noticed it when the monthly bill came out. I sent stop to the service so hopefully that will stop it. They got 2 x €7.50. I also send a complaint to support@red27mobile.com and asking for the €15 back as there was no reply sent to their unsolicited text.

    I also logged into the GOMO account and attempted to bar premium SMS but it's greyed out meaning they have to do it for you. I opened a webtext screen and sent my request every half hour for 3 hours but no reply, maybe their support person didn't turn up today. I think it will bar the sending of premium SMSs but still be able to receive them.

    You should stop receiving them as well. I got a text from Eir support to say the number was blocked


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,783 ✭✭✭Joe Public


    Their reply below.

    Dear .........,

    Thank you for contacting Red 27 Mobile.

    Your enquiry relates to the consumption of an online entertainment subscription service called Mobizone, providing gaming and game related applications on your mobile phone.

    The service is promoted via banner advertising often seen in applications, on Google, YouTube or related third-party publisher sites on your mobile phone. In order to activate a subscription, a consumer must follow the below steps:

    The user will find the above described banner advertising, and upon clicking,
    will be redirected to the service landing page where given the opportunity to answer a question in order to enter the competition. Upon selecting the answer, the user is shown a pop-up where to enter their phone number to verify the subscription via double opt-in.
    This page features further information relating to the service, including the content but most importantly the price, frequency and terms and conditions. To activate the service and confirm acceptance of the terms, the user must first click the “Enter” confirmation button.
    Upon confirmation, the user is sent a text message, to which they are asked to respond to in order to verify and complete the subscription process.
    Whilst I am hopeful that the above information assists in your enquiry, in case that you remain aggrieved, I would like to take the opportunity to add some additional points for your consideration:

    Maybe it is possible that someone else has access to your mobile device (friends, family or children).
    Perhaps you were not aware that it is possible to activate mobile subscription services via your mobile device.This is then billed via your mobile telephone bill.
    Perhaps you activated the free trial to access the service and simply forgot to deactivate the service prior to further billing.
    Please check your text message inbox for welcome/reminder messages from our service.
    Nonetheless, I can confirm that your subscription is now cancelled and no further billing will occur. I sincerely hope that the details above have helped to explain and alleviate any concerns you may have. However, should you remain dissatisfied with the above explanation, you are welcome to escalate your complaint via our internal escalations process. Should you wish to do this, please kindly reply to this email with the below information:

    - Your mobile phone number
    - Your reasons for complaint escalation
    - Confirmation that you are the owner or bill payer – we simply require a date of a billing transaction or a brief description of a text message received from the service (or a screenshot of a text message from our service will also suffice). Sorry, this is due to GDPR and Data Protection!

    Note: If you are not the bill payer, please provide confirmation that you have permission to discuss the transaction with the bill payer.

    Thank you sincerely for your time and I wish you a good day.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 553 ✭✭✭flower tattoo


    Reply and tell them you’re very unhappy and have contacted comreg ( you don’t actually need to do this though)l
    They will come back with small offer - refuse this and state again you want full refund -
    I did this on 2 different companies in May - although they are different emails the generic response was identical
    Sent them copies of the bill aswell
    Although there was about 6 emails back and forward it only took an afternoon and eventually got €20 x 2 refunded to PayPal


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,783 ✭✭✭Joe Public


    I replied to them and made the mistake that I reported the incident to the Ombudsman but it didn't seem to matter :) as it looks like I'm getting the full amount back. They offered me half on the first email and full on the 2nd email. They probably operate on the assumption that most people won't go to the bother of complaining and they away with 90% or so. If they pay up it will have been painless enough. I went through similar before for €110 and got the money back by contacting Comreg but they dragged it out to the last day before Comreg could legally intervene.

    Here are my email exchanges, following the initial email, for those who want to follow up on getting a refund, maybe change "Ombudsman" to Comreg.

    Me "Thanks for your reply, I have opened a case with the ombudsman office. I will update you in due course."

    Them "Dear xxxxxxx,

    Thank you for escalating your claim via our internal complaints escalation process.

    After further investigation, I can confirm that your subscription was activated in line with the standard processes and expectations of the service flow, as hosted by our third-party payment provider.

    Nonetheless and in consideration of your unfortunate dissatisfaction, I would like to offer you a refund for the last week of your subscription, totalling €7.50, by way of full and final settlement of your complaint.

    Should this be acceptable, please respond with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may promptly process the refund.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile


    Me "Thanks for the offer but I will continue with the ombudsman until I get the full amount back."


    Them "Dear xxxxxxx,

    My director approved your full refund request for the amount of 15 euro as a gesture of goodwill and in order to move on.
    Please provide us with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may proceed.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile"



    Meanwhile GOMO have implemented barring of premium SMSs on the mobile account. Had to send them a support message as nobody was responding to the Webtext support option.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,708 ✭✭✭corks finest


    Joe Public wrote: »
    I replied to them and made the mistake that I reported the incident to the Ombudsman but it didn't seem to matter :) as it looks like I'm getting the full amount back. They offered me half on the first email and full on the 2nd email. They probably operate on the assumption that most people won't go to the bother of complaining and they away with 90% or so. If they pay up it will have been painless enough. I went through similar before for €110 and got the money back by contacting Comreg but they dragged it out to the last day before Comreg could legally intervene.

    Here are my email exchanges, following the initial email, for those who want to follow up on getting a refund, maybe change "Ombudsman" to Comreg.

    Me "Thanks for your reply, I have opened a case with the ombudsman office. I will update you in due course."

    Them "Dear xxxxxxx,

    Thank you for escalating your claim via our internal complaints escalation process.

    After further investigation, I can confirm that your subscription was activated in line with the standard processes and expectations of the service flow, as hosted by our third-party payment provider.

    Nonetheless and in consideration of your unfortunate dissatisfaction, I would like to offer you a refund for the last week of your subscription, totalling €7.50, by way of full and final settlement of your complaint.

    Should this be acceptable, please respond with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may promptly process the refund.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile


    Me "Thanks for the offer but I will continue with the ombudsman until I get the full amount back."


    Them "Dear xxxxxxx,

    My director approved your full refund request for the amount of 15 euro as a gesture of goodwill and in order to move on.
    Please provide us with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may proceed.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile"



    Meanwhile GOMO have implemented barring of premium SMSs on the mobile account. Had to send them a support message as nobody was responding to the Webtext support option.

    You'd think all the providers would ban this ****E fur once and for all


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 69,543 ✭✭✭✭L1011


    You'd think all the providers would ban this ****E fur once and for all

    They make money off it; Comreg makes money off the PRS operator licence. Neither cares to stop it.

    Lobby your TDs, particularly any vocal opposition or wobbly Green ones.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,708 ✭✭✭corks finest


    L1011 wrote: »
    They make money off it; Comreg makes money off the PRS operator licence. Neither cares to stop it.

    Lobby your TDs, particularly any vocal opposition or wobbly Green ones.

    It's a disgrace


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,708 ✭✭✭corks finest


    Joe Public wrote: »
    I replied to them and made the mistake that I reported the incident to the Ombudsman but it didn't seem to matter :) as it looks like I'm getting the full amount back. They offered me half on the first email and full on the 2nd email. They probably operate on the assumption that most people won't go to the bother of complaining and they away with 90% or so. If they pay up it will have been painless enough. I went through similar before for €110 and got the money back by contacting Comreg but they dragged it out to the last day before Comreg could legally intervene.

    Here are my email exchanges, following the initial email, for those who want to follow up on getting a refund, maybe change "Ombudsman" to Comreg.

    Me "Thanks for your reply, I have opened a case with the ombudsman office. I will update you in due course."

    Them "Dear xxxxxxx,

    Thank you for escalating your claim via our internal complaints escalation process.

    After further investigation, I can confirm that your subscription was activated in line with the standard processes and expectations of the service flow, as hosted by our third-party payment provider.

    Nonetheless and in consideration of your unfortunate dissatisfaction, I would like to offer you a refund for the last week of your subscription, totalling €7.50, by way of full and final settlement of your complaint.

    Should this be acceptable, please respond with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may promptly process the refund.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile


    Me "Thanks for the offer but I will continue with the ombudsman until I get the full amount back."


    Them "Dear xxxxxxx,

    My director approved your full refund request for the amount of 15 euro as a gesture of goodwill and in order to move on.
    Please provide us with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may proceed.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support

    Red27 Mobile"



    Meanwhile GOMO have implemented barring of premium SMSs on the mobile account. Had to send them a support message as nobody was responding to the Webtext support option.

    Fair dues boy


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,783 ✭✭✭Joe Public


    My €15 refund from Red27 Mobile Ltd. turned up in my bank account today.


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    L1011 wrote: »
    They make money off it; Comreg makes money off the PRS operator licence. Neither cares to stop it.

    Lobby your TDs, particularly any vocal opposition or wobbly Green ones.

    It seems clear to me that there is a tolerance of this kind of scamming by ComReg. On the face of it, their position and that of the network operators seems reasonable; however, both are actively encouraging these scam operators by their behaviour and lack of action.

    Network operators: “nothing to do with us, we just provide the communication infrastructure”.
    ComReg: “we regulate the services, we publish a set of regulations, service providers must register and must have a complaints procedure.”
    Service provider (aka scammer): responds to complaint with some generic nonsense, will offer a paltry “goodwill gesture” amount when pressed and only give a full refund when really, really pressed.

    Most people will either not bother to work out how to go about complaining, will complain to the wrong place and/or give up somewhere along the line.

    I was caught out when my daughter’s phone clocked up over €100 in charges on one of these services (completely innocently; she never subscribed and had been trying herself to make them stop over three months). I got a full refund, but only after multiple emails.

    It strikes me there is a fool proof opportunity for scamming people that at the moment has no prospect of being stopped:

    - Implement some type of bogus service that exploits security vulnerabilities to leak customers phone numbers as they click on certain Web sites (which is entirely possible, apparently)
    - Start sending premium rate texts to the harvested number
    - Make the required STOP message a premium one, so it never gets sent (in my daughter’s case), or just ignore them
    - Here’s the really clever bit: when the customer complains, stop sending the messages. If they persist with the complaint, offer a small amount as a goodwill gesture; if they really persist up it a bit and if necessary ultimately give them a full refund

    The clever bit is that last one: anyone approaching ComReg will be asked “Have you exhausted the provider’s compliant procedure yet?” The answer will be no, in which case they go back and ultimately get a full refund. Once they have the refund, if they then go to ComReg they are told: what are you complaining about, you have a full refund?

    It’s a brilliant scam: you can go on indefinitely with no fear of being “caught” or sanctioned. The network operators facilitate it by enabling (or refusing to fix) the leaking of mobile numbers on their network: they get their cut of the revenue. The service provider only needs a percentage of people not to go the whole road to a full refund to make it pay. And ComReg? Whose side are they on?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    My Sisters phone has been charged €22.50 by 57976 on her August bill with Gomo. She never subscribed to anything, just started getting the text messages which she thought were spam and deleted. She did text "stop" twice, these texts are also on her bill charged at 9c each.

    After looking online I was pointed "ie.mymobiplanet.com" where a dublin number is displayed. Ringing this number I got through to a woman with a dublin accent who sounded like she was operating with a 20 year old laptop in a garden shed, very bad line and she kept saying she had to wait for the system which kept "freezing". I gave her the mobile number and she said she had stopped the messages. She then texted a message to the phone with the email address help@umelimited.com to be contacted for a refund.

    I have been emailing this address this yesterday. After several stiff emails they have finally agreed to a full refund. I am trying to find out now though if there were any charges made after the last one on the bill. €7.50 was being taken every week on the 8th, 15th and 24th august, the texts were only stopped yesterday so presumably there were 2 more charges of 7.50 taken on the 31st August and 7th September.


    Its totally disgraceful that this highway robbery is permitted by the powers that be. Comreg really need to get their finger out and do something about this.


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    king2 wrote: »
    I have been emailing this address this yesterday. After several stiff emails they have finally agreed to a full refund. I am trying to find out now though if there were any charges made after the last one on the bill. €7.50 was being taken every week on the 8th, 15th and 24th august, the texts were only stopped yesterday so presumably there were 2 more charges of 7.50 taken on the 31st August and 7th September.


    Its totally disgraceful that this highway robbery is permitted by the powers that be. Comreg really need to get their finger out and do something about this.

    GoMo seem to have a cap of €30/month on these, which limites the number every month.

    I would just assume the payments were taken in the dates you mention (assuming they don't go over the monthly cap) and just demand a full refund.

    My experience was very similar: I just jept asking for a full refund (by email) and rejected all offers until I got it.

    The refund arrived in my account within a couple of days.

    Make sure you request them to block sending you any more messages.

    You can also ask GoMo to block receipt of all premium rate messages.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    GoMo seem to have a cap of €30/month on these, which limites the number every month.

    I would just assume the payments were taken in the dates you mention (assuming they don't go over the monthly cap) and just demand a full refund.

    My experience was very similar: I just jept asking for a full refund (by email) and rejected all offers until I got it.

    The refund arrived in my account within a couple of days.

    Make sure you request them to block sending you any more messages.

    You can also ask GoMo to block receipt of all premium rate messages.

    I am trying to confirm that there were charges after the 24th with Gomo, their chat facility doesnt seem to be working at the moment. I've asked UME if there were more charges,waiting for a reply but I wouldnt be expecting the truth.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    contacted Gomo via facebook. They say they cant check if there have been more charges until next months bill is issued, hard to understand why


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    king2 wrote: »
    contacted Gomo via facebook. They say they cant check if there have been more charges until next months bill is issued, hard to understand why

    I think if I were you, I'd:

    - assume the messages did continue to be sent at the same frequency
    - work out how much they owe you if they did
    - claim for that amount
    - if they dispute the amount and claim only the ones you know about were sent, accept that amount
    - tell them you agree to that as full and final settlement for messages up to that date, but you reserve the right to claim at a future time for any received after that date

    That way you're not waiting on either party to provide further information and you can get a refund now for the ones you know about (and maybe more).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    I think if I were you, I'd:

    - assume the messages did continue to be sent at the same frequency
    - work out how much they owe you if they did
    - claim for that amount
    - if they dispute the amount and claim only the ones you know about were sent, accept that amount
    - tell them you agree to that as full and final settlement for messages up to that date, but you reserve the right to claim at a future time for any received after that date

    That way you're not waiting on either party to provide further information and you can get a refund now for the ones you know about (and maybe more).

    I did that, they are to refund by paypal, have to wait for next bill to see if there were further charges. I will be getting on to comreg about it also


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    king2 wrote: »
    I did that, they are to refund by paypal, have to wait for next bill to see if there were further charges. I will be getting on to comreg about it also

    Ah, OK: well done. I misunderstood: I thought you were waiting to get confirmation of the exact amount owed before proceeding.

    I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for any response from ComReg, other than something along the lines that if you've been refunded the case is closed in their eyes and you've no further claim.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    Ah, OK: well done. I misunderstood: I thought you were waiting to get confirmation of the exact amount owed before proceeding.

    I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for any response from ComReg, other than something along the lines that if you've been refunded the case is closed in their eyes and you've no further claim.

    Comreg are not doing their job if thats the attitude they take. UME limited are robbing people and probably getting away with it in the majority of cases. Its not acceptable that they do nothing about it


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    king2 wrote: »
    Comreg are not doing their job if thats the attitude they take. UME limited are robbing people and probably getting away with it in the majority of cases. Its not acceptable that they do nothing about it

    That's exactly the point I was making in post #79 above.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    That's exactly the point I was making in post #79 above.

    Did you try complaining to any TDs?!! So the scam starts if you just click on a link and they get your mobile number through security vulnerabilities. Are these vulnerabilities the responsibility of the network provider? Is the link you click on an ad for the Company running the scam or ad for something else?


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    king2 wrote: »
    Did you try complaining to any TDs?!! So the scam starts if you just click on a link and they get your mobile number through security vulnerabilities. Are these vulnerabilities the responsibility of the network provider? Is the link you click on an ad for the Company running the scam or ad for something else?

    No, I havent had the chance to take it any further.

    I can't answer your other questions, other than to guess that the network providers deny any liability.

    It might be worth your while reading the ComReg Code of Practice for these services if you haven't already:

    http://www.comreg.ie/csv/downloads/ComReg1445.pdf


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 65,709 ✭✭✭✭unkel
    Chauffe, Marcel, chauffe!


    Most people will either not bother to work out how to go about complaining, will complain to the wrong place and/or give up somewhere along the line.

    I was caught out when my daughter’s phone clocked up over €100 in charges on one of these services (completely innocently; she never subscribed and had been trying herself to make them stop over three months). I got a full refund, but only after multiple emails.

    Same. I just hope people in this situation will google it and some will end up reading this. You will get all your money back if you persist!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 404 ✭✭king2


    unkel wrote: »
    Same. I just hope people in this situation will google it and some will end up reading this. You will get all your money back if you persist!

    I got a full refund from the UME Limited crooks. It was not easy though. emails back and forth for about 24hrs. They initially offered 30% then 50% and finally 100%. Dirty operators these companies, something really needs to be done about them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,670 ✭✭✭✭fritzelly


    I've posted a similarly veined thread today
    https://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2058115484

    Did anyone when contacting their operator find they couldn't tell you where the credit was going?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,921 ✭✭✭Grab All Association


    :confused:

    A Nokia 5110 from 1998 with no internet access. SIM card is an old o2 sim still in use.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,851 ✭✭✭Ten Pin


    Why would it need internet access? It's all done via SMS as that's where this whole "industry" started out...buying ringtones and games over GSM.

    The excuse that red27 and others were using was/is that somehow clicking on an ad is considered giving consent when that doesn't comply with the code of practice at all.

    Have charges actually been applied or is it possibly a phishing text to trick the recipient into calling them and confirming that the number exists after which they start charging for fresh air. That phone number isn't the one given as contact on Comregs website.


  • Registered Users Posts: 51 ✭✭User Steve


    Hi All,


    Just realised i've been paying mobiplanet about €300 per month since January! Almost €300 in total. Encouraging to hear some are getting refunds. Would love to know how much 'service providers' like Virgin Media are getting out of this scam. The Irish state also collects VAT on this! Anyway, about to lodge complaint with Commreg. Will post up anything relevant that hasn't already been said. Thanks very much to previous posters.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 51 ✭✭User Steve


    First response from help@umelimited.com below :-)

    Dear Steve,

    Thank you for escalating your claim via our internal complaints escalation process.

    After further investigation, I can confirm that your subscription was activated in line with the standard processes and expectations of the service flow, as hosted by our third-party payment provider.

    Nonetheless and in consideration of your unfortunate dissatisfaction, I would like to offer you a refund for the last week of your subscription, totalling €7.50, by way of full and final settlement of your complaint.

    Should this be acceptable, please respond with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may promptly process the refund.

    Best regards,

    Liliana

    Customer service UME

    help@umelimited.com


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    I think that’s exactly what my first repose was. Just say you reject the offer and repeat the original complaint.

    By the way, it’s pointless going to ComReg, as they’ll just send you back to keep going until resolution.


  • Registered Users Posts: 51 ✭✭User Steve


    Thanks PickYourName

    Ya, it's actually the 2nd email i got back this morning ...the first was so long and well written that there was no way 'Lilliana' knocked it out in 30mins :-)

    I'll keep going back to them.
    will keep the thread posted .


  • Registered Users Posts: 412 ✭✭PickYourName


    User Steve wrote: »
    Thanks PickYourName

    Ya, it's actually the 2nd email i got back this morning ...the first was so long and well written that there was no way 'Lilliana' knocked it out in 30mins :-)

    I'll keep going back to them.
    will keep the thread posted .

    Just to warn you, it'll take a while, though once engaged they do seem to respond fairly rapidly.

    For the craic, I went back to check, and here's how it panned out for me:

    Offer #1:
    “Nonetheless and in consideration of your unfortunate dissatisfaction, I would like to offer you a refund for the last week of your subscription, totalling €7.50, by way of full and final settlement of your complaint.”

    Offer #2:
    “Having looked further at your complaint and escalated this matter to my supervisor, I have authority to process a €20 refund”

    Offer #3:
    “Thank you once again for your response in relation to your open complaint. It is never ideal to see an unhappy customer. Therefore, in order to resolve the problem and move-on we are willing to proceed with a €40 goodwill refund.”

    Offer #4:
    “Thank you once again for your response in relation to your open complaint.
    Despite opt-in being explicit and final, and of course you have received entries into all draws as per the terms of service, since you are unhappy with the service I am happy to arrange a goodwill refund of €55 as a gesture of good will and in order to move on. Sadly, that is all I am permitted to offer in the circumstances.”

    Offer #5:
    “My director approved your full refund request as a gesture of goodwill and in order to move on.
    Please provide us with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may proceed.”


  • Registered Users Posts: 51 ✭✭User Steve


    I think that’s exactly what my first repose was. Just say you reject the offer and repeat the original complaint.

    By the way, it’s pointless going to ComReg, as they’ll just send you back to keep going until resolution.
    Just to warn you, it'll take a while, though once engaged they do seem to respond fairly rapidly.

    For the craic, I went back to check, and here's how it panned out for me:

    Offer #1:
    “Nonetheless and in consideration of your unfortunate dissatisfaction, I would like to offer you a refund for the last week of your subscription, totalling €7.50, by way of full and final settlement of your complaint.”

    Offer #2:
    “Having looked further at your complaint and escalated this matter to my supervisor, I have authority to process a €20 refund”

    Offer #3:
    “Thank you once again for your response in relation to your open complaint. It is never ideal to see an unhappy customer. Therefore, in order to resolve the problem and move-on we are willing to proceed with a €40 goodwill refund.”

    Offer #4:
    “Thank you once again for your response in relation to your open complaint.
    Despite opt-in being explicit and final, and of course you have received entries into all draws as per the terms of service, since you are unhappy with the service I am happy to arrange a goodwill refund of €55 as a gesture of good will and in order to move on. Sadly, that is all I am permitted to offer in the circumstances.”

    Offer #5:
    “My director approved your full refund request as a gesture of goodwill and in order to move on.
    Please provide us with your Paypal address or bank details (IBAN + SWIFT written correctly), so we may proceed.”






    :-) I'm on Offer#2 now - The €20 Level


  • Advertisement
Advertisement