25-10-2016, 15:00   #31
pippip
Registered User

Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 2,011
Quote:
 Originally Posted by Sam Kade I buy coal and logs from Dairygold as I have a boiler stove as the only heat source. To keep the stove going for 12 hours a day costs roughly €8.5 and the house is still comfortably warm in the morning until the stove is lit at 1pm. The last fill is 9pm and it lasts until 1am. If I were to get the same heat from oil even with an efficient modern burner I would use 3L/hour @ 58c/L that would cost €20.88/day. So how do you come to the conclusion that oil is cheaper?
Your calculations are way off, I know plenty of people with oil heating and would be nowhere near what your saying it costs. Your calculations on the oil leave out so many variables.

25-10-2016, 15:06   #32
Registered User

Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 11,777
Quote:
 Originally Posted by pippip Your calculations are way off, I know plenty of people with oil heating and would be nowhere near what your saying it costs. Your calculations on the oil leave out so many variables.
Any efficient boiler will use 3L/hour, to have constant heat for 12 hours you need to have the boiler running for 12 hours so can you explain how I'm way off?

25-10-2016, 15:06   #33

Join Date: Jul 2015
Posts: 998
Quote:
 Originally Posted by Sam Kade I buy coal and logs from Dairygold as I have a boiler stove as the only heat source. To keep the stove going for 12 hours a day costs roughly €8.5 and the house is still comfortably warm in the morning until the stove is lit at 1pm. The last fill is 9pm and it lasts until 1am. If I were to get the same heat from oil even with an efficient modern burner I would use 3L/hour @ 58c/L that would cost €20.88/day. So how do you come to the conclusion that oil is cheaper?
Its nowhere near double the cost for the same heat, thats not to say you wouldn't burn twice as much fuel, people with oil/gas boilers tend to put significantly more heat into their home, partly dues to the convenience, running heating for longer periods,being too lazy to turnoff radiators program zones and in general heating the entire house - you wouldn't find many people with boiler stoves heating the utility room or empty guest bedrooms.

At current prices the coal probably just about pips the kerosene. Its not so long ago the kerosene was 90+c a liter though at which time coal was saving several hundred euro a year versus oil for the average house.

Kerosene = 9.8kwh per liter 58c / 9.8 = 5.9c/ kwh

Assuming 85% efficiency for a real world condensing boiler with appropriately sized radiators, flow rate etc.

5.9c/kwh / 0.85 = 6.94c/kwh

Hiqh quality Bituminous coal = 8.5kwh /kg = 4.7c/kwh (assuming €16 per bag bought in bulk from coop - in Dublin probably more like €20 per bag)

Quoted solid fuel stove efficiencies are derived from an unrealistic test, real world efficiency of a modern boiler stove burning coal is probably 75% at best with dry fueld, appropriate loading, riddling, water circulation, draught adjustment, etc.

4.7c/kwh / 0.75 = 6.27c/kwh @75% efficiency

Last edited by crabbypaddy; 25-10-2016 at 15:12.

25-10-2016, 15:09   #34
pippip
Registered User

Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 2,011
Quote:
 Originally Posted by Sam Kade Any efficient boiler will use 3L/hour, to have constant heat for 12 hours you need to have the boiler running for 12 hours so can you explain how I'm way off?
For a start the boiler won't be constantly on for 12 hrs, it will turn on and off as needed. Along with the fact that if you're not in your home (assuming you don't spend 24hrs a day in your home) then oil can just be switched off.

25-10-2016, 15:09   #35
Registered User

Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 11,777
Quote:
 Originally Posted by Esteban Huge Firefight I was really talking about wood on its own and going by the few blocks you'd get in a trailer for â‚¬ 60 to â‚¬ 80 and to generate the same heat. I reckon it would be cheaper to burn oil You're doing well to heat the house for twelve hours a day for under â‚¬ 60 a week. How many bags of coal do you burn. It's â‚¬ 19 euro for a bag of coal in the Co Op near me and I don't know how much the logs are.
Coal @ €17.49/bag and logs €3/bag. I use 1/3 bag of coal a day and less than a bag of logs.

25-10-2016, 15:15   #36
Registered User

Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 11,777
Quote:
 Originally Posted by pippip For a start the boiler won't be constantly on for 12 hrs, it will turn on and off as needed. Along with the fact that if you're not in your home (assuming you don't spend 24hrs a day in your home) then oil can just be switched off.
The 3L/hour includes the boiler cutting in and out. Trying to compare oil with solid fuel and saying the oil will only be turned on for a few hours isn't comparing like with like.

25-10-2016, 15:16   #37

Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 590
Quote:
 Originally Posted by Sam Kade Coal @ â‚¬17.49/bag and logs â‚¬3/bag. I use 1/3 bag of coal a day and less than a bag of logs.
I'm not doubting you but that seems very low usage for a boiler stove burning for 12 hours a day.

 25-10-2016, 15:46 #38 ablelocks Registered User   Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 2,753 jaysus, how about we stick to actual bargains and do the cost/benefit/efficiency analysis in another thread. or better yet, forum
 (4) thanks from:
25-10-2016, 17:39   #39
vicwatson
Registered User

Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 26,230
Quote:
 Originally Posted by ablelocks jaysus, how about we stick to actual bargains and do the cost/benefit/efficiency analysis in another thread. or better yet, forum
Its getting worse in Bargain Alerts, the amount of off topic chat

25-10-2016, 20:52   #40
Registered User

Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 11,777
Quote:
 Originally Posted by Esteban Huge Firefight I'm not doubting you but that seems very low usage for a boiler stove burning for 12 hours a day.
That's what I use no reason to lie, a fill will last 3-4 hours.

25-10-2016, 20:54   #41
Registered User

Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 11,777
Quote:
 Originally Posted by ablelocks jaysus, how about we stick to actual bargains and do the cost/benefit/efficiency analysis in another thread. or better yet, forum
Quote:
 Originally Posted by vicwatson Its getting worse in Bargain Alerts, the amount of off topic chat
Would you consider minimal efficient usage a bargain?

 28-10-2016, 21:29 #42 Join Date: May 2016 Posts: 52 Not sure if this is a bargain? Got a leaflet through the door today from Eco Firewood Baldoyle D13. (Can't post website link - maybe because I am a new user - ecofirewood dot eu) At checkout these codes can be used: 'eco20' for 20 euro off a 1m3 crate of kiln dried firewood or 'eco40' for 40 euro off a 2m3 crate. Online it seems the norm for a 2m3 crate of ash is around 360 euro - which is the same here. With the coupon it's 320 euro including nationwide delivery. Last season I got a 1.5m3 crate of ash from my local Topline for 270 euro including delivery. Has anyone used Eco Firewood before?
 Thanks from:
 28-10-2016, 21:38 #43 vicwatson Registered User   Join Date: Feb 2011 Posts: 26,230 Isn't all firewood "eco"?
28-10-2016, 22:56   #44

Join Date: May 2016
Posts: 52
Quote:
 Originally Posted by vicwatson Isn't all firewood "eco"?

I suppose so.

Just wondering about the business itself, quality of wood, delivery, etc. Never dealt with them before.

Whether it's worth taking a punt for 40 euro.

 Thanks from:
 28-10-2016, 23:52 #45 2forjoy Registered User     Join Date: Oct 2015 Posts: 338 Just seen this website and prices look ok http://surefirewood.com/firewood/