Weather Forum Zero Tolerance Policy

kindredspirit · 03-01-2012 7:18pm

Su Campu,

I've always read and studied what you have said in your posts. You stand head and shoulders above the crowd.

Enjoy your rest and pop back as soon as you can.

Respect.

KS.

.

Wild Bill · 03-01-2012 8:17pm

Thanks Su Campus - in my recent little problem you were a complete gentleman - I can speak only for myself but I'm sorry you feel the need to stop modding.

I hope you'll keep contributing.

Discodog · 03-01-2012 9:49pm

I am with MT on this one. Any decision is up to SU but there is no way that I would allow a few idiots to ruin my enjoyment or moderation of the forum especially when it is a seasonal phenomenon. What makes it worse is that it is too easy for the offensive people to see you stepping down as a victory.

You know that you have the support of 99.9% of the forum - not something many Mods could claim. This thread is a resounding vote of confidence in your Moderation. Why not take a very short sabbatical & then return refreshed & ready to resume as a Mod.

In the meantime the other Mods can simply ban the idiots & send out a message that we are a very friendly helpful lot & we expect all newcomers to be the same.

Madpaddy79 · 03-01-2012 10:31pm

Any chance of DM2 filling the vacancy?

Mothman · 03-01-2012 11:19pm

Madpaddy79 wrote: »

Any chance of DM2 filling the vacancy?

In the end its the admin's call. While I'm not at all privy to the selection of new mod(s) here, I'd be confident that by this stage that there is a short list and the process of checking etc those on the short list is well underway, though could be a few days yet.

Totofan99 · 03-01-2012 11:41pm

I don't comment much on the Weather forum, but I follow it like mad! (I think I'm addicted).

Anyway, I just wanted to say that I share the sentiments of everyone else here and I have learned so much from you, Su Campu, and from others that spend so much time keeping us updated and answering questions. It is much appreciated.

I really hope that you keep posting and sharing your knowledge.

delw · 04-01-2012 12:08am

SU Campu you will be sorely missed around here,i always thought you were a fair MOD but can understand wanting to take a back seat,please keep posting because your knowledge on this forum is just superb

Thank you

waytoowarm · 04-01-2012 12:33am

im new to posting but ive been following the threads for a while , ive learned so much from your posts su thank you... its a shame that it has come to this

nilhg · 04-01-2012 1:27am

I've been hanging around this forum for quite a while now, as a passer by, lurker and eventually a occasional contributer, and I have to say that I've always found it to be an extremely friendly place and I'd hope we wouldn't lose that here, the various mods over the years have always done superb work to keep it that way and for that I thank them.

That's not to say though that at times there haven't been problems to handle, the easy ones I suppose are the out and out trolls, they have no real contribution to make here and none of us will miss them here once their heads have rolled:D, maybe though it's not as clearcut when someone who has a genuine interest in the weather comes along but who may not, maybe for reasons of youthful exuberance and enthusiasm or an inability to properly express themselves in a forum setting like this, take kindly to being questioned or advised by the mods. People like this, if we can encourage them to calm down a little (and I don't have anyone in mind here) could in time make valuable contributions to this forum, IIRC one of our current mods was hardly the apple of the mods eye here in his younger days.;)

Again I'd like to echo what so many others have said in this thread, all the mods have been doing a great job here and it's up to the regulars to support them in their work, I do hope SU Campu's break will be a short one because his contributions to the discussions will be missed if he is gone for too long.

Mothman · 04-01-2012 12:52pm

nilhg wrote: »

IIRC one of our current mods was hardly the apple of the mods eye here in his younger days.;)

oh the memories

well in the past though

A lot of good points here and it proves the good community spirit and proves the high regard held for SU.

Zzippy · 04-01-2012 1:15pm

I don't post very often here but I lurk pretty much every day, and very much enjoy the forecast and chart analysis threads, I've learned so much from guys like Su Campu, MT, Weathercheck and others. I hope its only a temporary hiatus and you'll be back posting soon Su.

Darwin · 04-01-2012 1:54pm

I have to echo the sentiments of Zzippy too. I'm not a contributor either but visit the forum daily for MTs forecast and also to read the great contributions from others, and will particularly miss the great technical input from Su Campu.

tomcosgrave · 04-01-2012 10:19pm

Su, I'm a moderator outside boards.ie and have moderated elsewhere in the past.

I think you're a fine moderator and I hope you take up the reins here again before too long.

By all means have a rest if think you need it - but please do come back.

And please don't stop your posting, your experience helps to make this place what it is.

DoneDL · 04-01-2012 11:03pm

I have always found this aspect of boards of greater reliability than other weather forecasts. In extreme conditions as we have had over the last two years as well as checking MT`s forecasts I would also check what other posters were experiencing. Best of luck to Su Campu as I found the weather section to be of great value.

The Assistinator · 05-01-2012 12:24am

I have always found su to be very friendly and helpfull he brings an air of realism when forecasts get a bit exciting and go ott, i for one will miss his input i can only hope he decides to come back very soon.

dexter647 · 05-01-2012 2:09am

As it has become quite obvious Su u will be greatly missed. I for one am more of a lurker than a poster but even lurking will not be the same if the likes of yourself stop contributing. I have to admit i don't blame you for wanting to step down as a mod as imo it is a tough and thankless job and life is to short to be putting up with the crap that was regrettable rife here for some time:mad:...In saying that 99% of the time this forum is a joy and a place where the genuine weather fanatic can learn from the likes of yourself, mt, weathercheck, darkman etc..

In conclusion as a lover of weather, not an expert, keep posting as it will not be the same without your input:)

waytoowarm · 05-01-2012 9:31am

Forum Mods: trogdor, Weathercheck

i hope its not the last we hear from su,a big loss for those who are very interested in the weather..............

Hells Belle · 05-01-2012 9:49am

Thank you Su.

For the knowledge and the eye twisting charts

john mayo 10 · 05-01-2012 1:36pm

Thanks Su for all your knowledge and hopefully you will continue to post here.

Snowmaker · 05-01-2012 3:27pm

Thank you Su for parting with so much knowledge. I haven't been active here, just reading a lo,t and you have always provided an educated and level-headed approach to chart interpretation. No ramping of cold/warmth, just pure factual analysis - which is greatly appreciated. Thank you and good luck!

Spindle · 05-01-2012 3:34pm

Just to echo all other comments, I don't post here much but check in every day and it has to be one of the best forums for Weather obsessed, with great technical contributions mixed in with banter, fun and the odd Iancar storm chase

I hope you keep posting Su as learned a great deal from your posts on how to read charts and models. It is a shame that a small few would try and wreck the forum.

pauldry · 06-01-2012 10:56am

SU...dont

kwik · 06-01-2012 4:11pm

Its a great shame a great mod feels they have to leave because of the actions of a few out and out idiots. Sorry to see yo go su make sure you come back now.

ch750536 · 06-01-2012 4:35pm

Su Campu wrote: »

At my request I will be stepping down as a moderator of this forum.

I love the weather, be it warm or cold, cloudy or sunny, and this forum used to be a fun place for me, but the attitude of some posters towards me, both on and off the pitch, has increasingly generated more hassle than I am prepared to accept. I feel I have always tried to do my best towards this forum, but it has become a place I no longer enjoy, and I will be taking a break from it. It is for that reason that it would not be right to continue on as moderator.

There will be new replacement(s) taking up the reins, and I would echo Weathercheck's request that you get back to discussing the everchanging weather we have, and if a moderator has to take action, so be it - it will be for the good of the forum members and not a personal attack.

Fugs ache Su, was just looking for you for you own particular brand of expert knowledge. Stop lurking & come back.

Daisy M · 06-01-2012 8:03pm

I too am a lurker on this forum and dont contribute other than give my thanks. However this is my favourite forum and I am really disappointed that people, who have put so much time and effort into informing us novices on the upcoming weather, have been given such a hard time by a pathetic few.
Just to let all the mods and contributors past and present know you jave way more supporters than you realise, I know lots of people who are not boards members but log on to the weather forum for updates as it is so reliable.

darkman2 · 07-01-2012 4:15pm

Sad to see Su Campu leaving as a moderator. He is an excellent moderator and has not put a foot wrong on anything. His updates and knowledge are the most superb on this forum. Every post is a post we all want to read. I really hope, despite everything, he continues to post as enthusiastically as ever.

Su, with respect, you have done nothing wrong and have modded excellently and sensibly and I am far from the only one (earlier posts) who think you should seriously reconsider.

I have to say it's bizarre, given the subject matter of the forum, that a few choose to act silly and spoil it for contributors and lurkers.

bb1234567 · 11-01-2012 6:01pm

Thats sad, I really liked su's posts. Is he gone for good like will he even post anymore, and could he become a mod again or was he fired or just chose to leave himself?Whos mod instead? Sorry for all the questions Im just a bit confused, I only heard su had even left just today.

Speak Now · 11-01-2012 6:07pm

bb1234567 wrote: »

Thats sad, I really liked su's posts. Is he gone for good like will he even post anymore, and could he become a mod again or was he fired or just chose to leave himself?Whos mod instead? Sorry for all the questions Im just a bit confused, I only heard su had even left just today.

Why dont you read the thread?

bb1234567 · 11-01-2012 6:17pm

Jerry Seinfeld wrote: »

Why dont you read the thread?

Ye I just did:o I take my post back, everythings cleared up now, I didnt think the thread would be about su but it sort of is, so now I understand. Really bad su is gone:(

cyclops999 · 11-01-2012 6:22pm

The Mods on here along with most of the other contributers give a great insight into the weather patterns that vist our Island. As a pure observer for the last 6 months I have learnt a great deal on weather keep up the good work and Su come back always looked forward to your postings.

nacho libre · 14-01-2012 4:48pm

Su Campu will be back. His passion for all things weather wise will see to that. The great thing about Su is, just when I thought I might be getting a handle on this weather lark, he'd disabuse you of that notion fairly quickly.

M.T. Cranium · 15-01-2012 8:05am

I've noticed that the weather forum has also lost a couple of other valued members in addition to Su Campu, at least it seems that way ... Deep Easterly and "thetonynator" have not been posting recently.

I hope there wasn't a related set of issues for all three of them. Some trolling can include off-forum personal messages and stalking, as well as impersonations. I've had to deal with this on other forums (not all weather related) where I've been a moderator. If any of these missing guys happen to look in and read this, please review any such correspondence and verify the source.

It's too bad that one or two infrequent posters can create this sort of havoc, or even potentially if more active members take up trolling under assumed names. However, this is more or less an unfortunate "given" of the internet world and we have to work around it, taking whatever action we can to eliminate the sources. We also need to be vigilant about possible harassment of female and younger members. I'm sure that boards.ie in general must have policies about this kind of activity so the weather forum would be no different there.

jimmy.d · 15-01-2012 11:46am

M.T. Cranium wrote: »

I've noticed that the weather forum has also lost a couple of other valued members in addition to Su Campu, at least it seems that way ... Deep Easterly and "thetonynator" have not been posting recently.

I hope there wasn't a related set of issues for all three of them. Some trolling can include off-forum personal messages and stalking, as well as impersonations. I've had to deal with this on other forums (not all weather related) where I've been a moderator. If any of these missing guys happen to look in and read this, please review any such correspondence and verify the source.

It's too bad that one or two infrequent posters can create this sort of havoc, or even potentially if more active members take up trolling under assumed names. However, this is more or less an unfortunate "given" of the internet world and we have to work around it, taking whatever action we can to eliminate the sources. We also need to be vigilant about possible harassment of female and younger members. I'm sure that boards.ie in general must have policies about this kind of activity so the weather forum would be no different there.

ya could always find out who they are by their ip address check it before they are let become a member that way you would know if they were trolling on here before

Redsunset · 15-01-2012 12:52pm

Last I checked, Tony's (thetonynator) account is now closed. Shame really, but yeah atmosphere in here went to sh1t recently. I need not say anything else on the matter. Onwards and upwards I say.

thetonynator
Closed Account

Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 4,938
Adverts | Friends

Su Campu · 15-01-2012 6:47pm

Hi guys, I've logged on to the forum again and am overwhelmed at the number of kind replies I got in this thread. I guess maybe I was letting a few bad apples cloud (get it?) my thoughts a while back and the huge majority of people on here are here to share their passion for weather, and nothing else.

Reading through the current threads it's refreshing to see the atmosphere that's returned to the forum, with the usual good-humoured banter replacing the mould that had been forming. Of course some things never change, with the hunt continuing for the elusive cold spell this winter!

It's also strange to see the threads without all the moderator gadgetry that I had become accustomed to, but I hope the process of recruiting new moderators has come on and we'll see some new blood helping out weathercheck and trogdor. We'll all help make things easy for them and for everyone.

Thanks again guys

Tom Cruises Left Nut · 15-01-2012 6:49pm

Welcome back Su !

Now get into the threads and give us some cold hope ! haha :pac:

bb1234567 · 15-01-2012 6:55pm

Su Campu wrote: »

Hi guys, I've logged on to the forum again and am overwhelmed at the number of kind replies I got in this thread. I guess maybe I was letting a few bad apples cloud (get it?) my thoughts a while back and the huge majority of people on here are here to share their passion for weather, and nothing else. Reading through the current threads it's refreshing to see the atmosphere that's returned to the forum, with the usual good-humoured banter replacing the mould that had been forming. Of course some things never change, with the hunt continuing for the elusive cold spell this winter!

It's also strange to see the threads without all the moderator gadgetry that I had become accustomed to, but I hope the process of recruiting new moderators has come on and we'll see some new blood helping out weathercheck and trogdor. We'll all help make things easy for them and for everyone.

Thanks again guys

Glad youre back

. The weather forum just isnt the same without su campu !

bb1234567 · 15-01-2012 6:57pm

M.T. Cranium wrote: »

I've noticed that the weather forum has also lost a couple of other valued members in addition to Su Campu, at least it seems that way ... Deep Easterly and "thetonynator" have not been posting recently.

I hope there wasn't a related set of issues for all three of them. Some trolling can include off-forum personal messages and stalking, as well as impersonations. I've had to deal with this on other forums (not all weather related) where I've been a moderator. If any of these missing guys happen to look in and read this, please review any such correspondence and verify the source.

It's too bad that one or two infrequent posters can create this sort of havoc, or even potentially if more active members take up trolling under assumed names. However, this is more or less an unfortunate "given" of the internet world and we have to work around it, taking whatever action we can to eliminate the sources. We also need to be vigilant about possible harassment of female and younger members. I'm sure that boards.ie in general must have policies about this kind of activity so the weather forum would be no different there.

I checked Deep Easterly and his account is still open and his last post was only 3 days ago so im sure hell be back soon. But tonynators account is closed unfortunately...

M.T. Cranium · 15-01-2012 8:50pm

I'm aware of the IP address tool, but from moderator experience elsewhere I could mention that some persistent trolls set up duplicate accounts from remote posting sites (workplaces, internet cafes) and go about their business while their "public" handle remains dormant. I've even seen cases where this has been done on political commentary threads to set up material for lawsuits against target posters and forums. A few years ago there was a case where poster A (male in U.K.) created a second account for poster B (female in USA) and engaged in flirty chat on-line that turned into a marriage proposal.

No kidding!! :eek: The guy asked himself to get married in public.

Obviously this could be passed off as a joke, but the same person was also engaging in multiple off-line interactions with forum members, none of them very helpful to those people, and it led to a forum banning in that case.

We had a case in Canada where a political activist posted a very inflammatory message designed to look like the work of a political adversary and meant to influence the outcome of a vote in parliament on an important issue. This is still being hassled out in the courts. The internet is a bit of a wild west jungle at times.

By the way, the search for snow looks promising on the latest ECM.

cyclops999 · 15-01-2012 9:09pm

Su Campu wrote: »

Hi guys, I've logged on to the forum again and am overwhelmed at the number of kind replies I got in this thread. I guess maybe I was letting a few bad apples cloud (get it?) my thoughts a while back and the huge majority of people on here are here to share their passion for weather, and nothing else. Reading through the current threads it's refreshing to see the atmosphere that's returned to the forum, with the usual good-humoured banter replacing the mould that had been forming. Of course some things never change, with the hunt continuing for the elusive cold spell this winter!

It's also strange to see the threads without all the moderator gadgetry that I had become accustomed to, but I hope the process of recruiting new moderators has come on and we'll see some new blood helping out weathercheck and trogdor. We'll all help make things easy for them and for everyone.

Thanks again guys

Now that your back I hope you brought all the ingredients for some of the white fluffy stuff.:D

TURRICAN · 15-01-2012 9:17pm

I'm always reading the posts but don't have much to contribute as it's all very technical.
I enjoy it tho and read every day.
It's good to see su campu back again and I hope any other members who left come back.
Just ignore people who troll.
I could rant here but il stay whissht.
Thanks.

bb1234567 · 15-01-2012 9:29pm

TURRICAN wrote: »

I'm always reading the posts but don't have much to contribute as it's all very technical.
I enjoy it tho and read every day.
It's good to see su campu back again and I hope any other members who left come back.
Just ignore people who troll.
I could rant here but il stay whissht.
Thanks.

I dont know much,doesnt stop me from posting though:p but that mightnt necessarily be a good thing...:o

TURRICAN · 15-01-2012 9:55pm

bb1234567 wrote: »

TURRICAN wrote: »

I'm always reading the posts but don't have much to contribute as it's all very technical.
I enjoy it tho and read every day.
It's good to see su campu back again and I hope any other members who left come back.
Just ignore people who troll.
I could rant here but il stay whissht.
Thanks.

I dont know much,doesnt stop me from posting though:p but that mightnt necessarily be a good thing...:o

That's why I don't ðŸ˜„

thomasj · 17-01-2012 2:39pm

bb1234567 wrote: »

M.T. Cranium wrote: »

I've noticed that the weather forum has also lost a couple of other valued members in addition to Su Campu, at least it seems that way ... Deep Easterly and "thetonynator" have not been posting recently.

I hope there wasn't a related set of issues for all three of them. Some trolling can include off-forum personal messages and stalking, as well as impersonations. I've had to deal with this on other forums (not all weather related) where I've been a moderator. If any of these missing guys happen to look in and read this, please review any such correspondence and verify the source.

It's too bad that one or two infrequent posters can create this sort of havoc, or even potentially if more active members take up trolling under assumed names. However, this is more or less an unfortunate "given" of the internet world and we have to work around it, taking whatever action we can to eliminate the sources. We also need to be vigilant about possible harassment of female and younger members. I'm sure that boards.ie in general must have policies about this kind of activity so the weather forum would be no different there.

I checked Deep Easterly and his account is still open and his last post was only 3 days ago so im sure hell be back soon. But tonynators account is closed unfortunately...

Looks like we've lost wolfeire though..........

Tom Cruises Left Nut · 17-01-2012 3:00pm

thomasj wrote: »

Looks like we've lost wolfeire though..........

Ah for the sake of jaysus ! Whats going on ??

John mac · 17-01-2012 5:48pm

Looks like we've lost wolfeire though

New weather site coming online perhaps ?

He's still tweeting though.;)

pistolpetes11 · 17-01-2012 8:42pm

Even when setting up IWO he still maintained a presence here ,

Looks like his account is closed , was on this morning and is gone now .

Wonder whats going on lately , loosing a lot of good people

DOCARCH · 17-01-2012 8:52pm

That's bizzare!

redsteveireland · 17-01-2012 9:03pm

DOCARCH wrote: »

That's bizzare!

New mod account being set up?

Wild Bill · 17-01-2012 9:29pm

Well, to be fair, nothing much has happened in the way of unpleasantness in the past week to account for Wolfie leaving!

Must be for a completely different reason?

Weather Forum Zero Tolerance Policy

Comments