Advice please - girlfriend's exes

LegacyUser · 03-10-2020 10:26am #1

Hi everyone.
I’ll try keep this as short as possible. I’m currently with my girlfriend 3 years. Most of the time we get on great and life is good. We’re both 38. The problem lies with me, or in me.
I struggle with insecurity a good bit. It has impacted our relationship and caused a lot of rows more in the past but still in the present.
My girlfriend has a lot of male friends, and she’s been with a good few of them over the years. She prides herself on being an honest person and I never think she’d cheat. It’s just not in her.
Most of the guys she’s been with that are still her friends, I have zero problem with. But one circle of friends she hangs out with there’s 2 guys out of 5-6 in it that are ex’s. They’re all friends since childhood.
Guy 1 - long term ex. Childhood sweethearts, lost virginity together etc. They broke up early 20’s, stayed in touch, got back together twice since, in the last 10 years for a couple of years each time. They’ve had a few hook ups too in between. It’s been 4 years but he’s still not comfortable around is and in my opinion not Over her.
Guy 2
My girlfriend says she is an extreme prude. Does not sleep around etc. Yet for guy 2 she broke all her rules. They didn’t have sex but they hooked up lots during her 20’s. Very good looking guy and a player. In my opinion, if you break all your rules for somebody, that makes them pretty significant. She says he wasn’t.
So far, any time she’s been out with them, we’re there as a couple. But she’s often said she wants to go out with them on her own at some stage. The thoughts of her out skulling pints with these guys makes me physically and mentally ill if I’m being honest. My stomach is in knots and my head is in a spin. She gets extremely annoyed when I say how uncomfortable that would make me. She calls it controlling and says I don’t trust her. Am I pathetic?

leggo · 03-10-2020 3:42pm

I wouldn’t consider myself insecure or jealous at all, but that wouldn’t be for me either. Now, in saying that, it doesn’t validate that you’re right and she’s wrong, more that you guys may just be incompatible at fulfilling each other’s needs.

My own preferences (I’ll say because you sound similar) with stuff like this are healthy boundaries, openness and honesty, and being with someone who I feel secure with and to have that reinforced day to day. Those are all fair things to want. There’s no specific rules attached to them, I’m not saying a girl has to do X or Y whenever they see an ex or anything like that. I just acknowledge and respect that those are my needs and someone I’ll be happy with will tick those boxes, if they don’t then I’ll be unhappy and so will they as a result.

Your girlfriend doesn’t sound like she fulfils your needs. That doesn’t mean you’re wrong and have to change yourself, or that she does either. You’re just realising that you’re chalk and cheese in this respect. And the blunt truth is that neither of you are likely to ever change, and trying will just cause resentment and a feeling of being stifled/suffocated. What you can do, though, is put this all on the table. If you can both accept that you’re different, that neither is wrong and state/accept each other’s needs, there may be a compromise that enables both of you to be happy. But if you try butt heads, make it a battle or resist/ignore this...then yeah, it’s going to end up causing huge problems because these kind of differences don’t just resolve themselves in the long term.

tara73 · 03-10-2020 6:46pm

yes OP, I think you have every right to feel uncomfortable. why does she feel the need to go out with them without you ? what's her problem with you being around? the only answer for me is she wants to mess around with them, whatever that means, maybe just flirting but that's more than a no go with ex boyfriends if you are in a serious relationship. she's disrespecting this relationship big time and messing with your head.
ask her how would she feel if you tell her you wish to meet up with your ex girlfriends you had on-off relationships for years and you explicitly don't want her around on those meet ups.

Zebrag · 04-10-2020 12:43am

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Hi everyone.
I’ll try keep this as short as possible. I’m currently with my girlfriend 3 years. Most of the time we get on great and life is good. We’re both 38. The problem lies with me, or in me.
I struggle with insecurity a good bit. It has impacted our relationship and caused a lot of rows more in the past but still in the present.
My girlfriend has a lot of male friends, and she’s been with a good few of them over the years. She prides herself on being an honest person and I never think she’d cheat. It’s just not in her.
Most of the guys she’s been with that are still her friends, I have zero problem with. But one circle of friends she hangs out with there’s 2 guys out of 5-6 in it that are ex’s. They’re all friends since childhood.
Guy 1 - long term ex. Childhood sweethearts, lost virginity together etc. They broke up early 20’s, stayed in touch, got back together twice since, in the last 10 years for a couple of years each time. They’ve had a few hook ups too in between. It’s been 4 years but he’s still not comfortable around is and in my opinion not Over her.
Guy 2
My girlfriend says she is an extreme prude. Does not sleep around etc. Yet for guy 2 she broke all her rules. They didn’t have sex but they hooked up lots during her 20’s. Very good looking guy and a player. In my opinion, if you break all your rules for somebody, that makes them pretty significant. She says he wasn’t.
So far, any time she’s been out with them, we’re there as a couple. But she’s often said she wants to go out with them on her own at some stage. The thoughts of her out skulling pints with these guys makes me physically and mentally ill if I’m being honest. My stomach is in knots and my head is in a spin. She gets extremely annoyed when I say how uncomfortable that would make me. She calls it controlling and says I don’t trust her. Am I pathetic?

I don't know OP, I'm finding it hard to believe that this is insecurity based on your personal belief rather and its insecurity knowing your girlfriend is friends with ex's and takes pride in this.

Taking pride in honesty and taking pride in being honest towards being with a couple of male friends and happily staying friends with them, tells me she likes the attention she recieves. She calls you controlling because she knows how uneasy you are towards her friendship with these guys and wants to go out with them on her own. I don't know. I'm gathering that she likes the fact she has a boyfriend but also likes the fact she gets male attention outside of the relationship. But I could be misjudging her completely.

I'm sure if the shoe was on the other foot, she wouldn't be calling you controlling, in fact you would probably be called much worst and demands would be made. She would be feeling insecure and deflated each time you went out with female friends, knowing you went out with some of them.

I don't like to tell posters to "leave their relationship" or "dump them" but I'm heading down the lines of, this doesn't sound like a healthy relationship at all and she has no boundaries. I'm all for having female and male friends. I've plenty and so does my partner but to go as far as to say they are ex's, want to be friends and to hang out with them on our own, and then claim we are being controlling because of insecurities, no I'm sorry.

OP, you're only 38. You've still plenty left to give out there and to spend another 3 years feeling the same way and eventually could lead into more mental health problems. This relationship and this girl doesn't sound worth carrying on for the long run but if you truly love her, then talk to her. Tell her that this doesn't sit well with you and you feel like maybe being friends with ex's, considering histories, that you feel she's holding onto these ex's for reasons that are not appropriate in a relationship. She might give out and call you controlling and whatever follows with that but it will go to show that she's not willing to focus on her relationship with someone who genuinely does love her.

osarusan · 04-10-2020 1:23am

Perfectly natural for you to be uncomfortable with her going out drinking with ex boyfriends, even with you present, never mind her going without you.

That she can't see your position as reasonable is the worrying element here.

Idle Passerby · 04-10-2020 5:33am

Hmm i don't think there's anything wrong per say about people remaining friends with ex's. However I can understand why this makes you uncomfortable. The fact they are ex's wouldn't bother me as much as the fact that she seems to have hooked up with both guys on a number of occasions over the years. Almost like they are both on standby. That's something other than regular friends. I would expect that if there are remaining friendships with ex's that the boundaries would be far clearer. I think it boils down to a personality clash though because it wouldn't be healthy if you were to forbid her having certain friends.

Yellow pack crisps · 04-10-2020 7:26am

All you can be is a loyal, loving and trusting partner. You can’t stop people from cheating. They will or won’t, if you think she is not the cheating kind then just enjoy the relationship. If you think she will cheat on you then your relationship is already in a bad place and tbh based on her answers to you then it probably won’t last, you can’t control who your GF hangs out, but you can control the decision to not carry on the relationship based on who she hangs out with. Nothing destroys a relationship more than one partner not trusting the other, it just hurts both of you and that’s a pointless relationship. It all comes down to respect and trust. If you respect and trust her then learn to control your insecurities.

LegacyUser · 05-10-2020 7:54am

Op here again.

Thanks for all the replies. It’s a hard one. How can I ask her not to be around her ex’s but at the same time expect her to see her friends hassle free? I can’t ask that of anyone.
I genuinely believe it’s only friendship she seeks but at the same time, why am I so uncomfortable? At a recent event maybe a month ago we were all out. It was getting late and She asked if I could go home and relieve the babysitter (as it was her time to finish) and let her stay out with her friends until closing time. The fear and panic that went through my mind was extraordinary. I don’t want to feel like this

Airyfairy12 · 05-10-2020 3:18pm

I cant speak for your ex but if it was me, I would feel like I was disrespecting my partner and the relationship by hanging out with and drinking with a group of ex's and people I slept with, what is she thinking?
Does she have many female friends or does she only hang out with these groups of men that include her ex's? Does she struggle to make or keep friends? It could be a case were she keeps them around because she doesn't have any real friends of her own.
Either that or maybe she likes the attention?
Regardless you have a right to feel insecure, any normal person would.

LegacyUser · 05-10-2020 3:50pm

I went out with someone like this before. No female friends, her best friend was her ex, all her other "friends" were guys who she had slept with before or had something going on, or guys that wanted more than friendship and had told her they loved her etc. We were in our 30s, not teenager stuff!
Some people keep exes and people who want more than friendship around them because they're more likely to do things for them and they like the attention.
It was a bit horrible really because I was supposed to be cool with all this, and if I ever brought these things up she made me feel like I was some horrible insecure person and that it was all normal on her part. Anyway I was never able to relax in that relationship, so if I were you I'd get tf out of that situation.
I'm now with a new girl who has loads of friends, nearly all female, and some male but these are normal friendships with boundaries and she doesn't have history with them. I don't feel like an anxious insecure mess because she's a good person and I trust her.

LegacyUser · 05-10-2020 4:25pm

Op again

No, she’s certainly not an attention seeker. She’s super friendly to everyone. I suppose it does irk me when I see her having the craic and being friendly with a person she’s had sex with or with in other ways. But they are her childhood friends so what am I supposed to do? Tell her not to hang out with her childhood friends. I can’t and wouldn’t do that. But it hurts like hell when she can’t grasp how it would affect me when she wants to go out with them on her own. I know she wouldn’t cheat but she doesn’t see why it’d make me uncomfortable, because if I trusted her, why would I be uncomfortable?? Btw she has plenty of female friends but probably more male. She says men are easier to get alone with whilst women in groups generally gossip or give out etc so it’s easier hang with men.

Airyfairy12 · 05-10-2020 5:50pm

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Op again

No, she’s certainly not an attention seeker. She’s super friendly to everyone. I suppose it does irk me when I see her having the craic and being friendly with a person she’s had sex with or with in other ways. But they are her childhood friends so what am I supposed to do? Tell her not to hang out with her childhood friends. I can’t and wouldn’t do that. But it hurts like hell when she can’t grasp how it would affect me when she wants to go out with them on her own. I know she wouldn’t cheat but she doesn’t see why it’d make me uncomfortable, because if I trusted her, why would I be uncomfortable?? Btw she has plenty of female friends but probably more male. She says men are easier to get alone with whilst women in groups generally gossip or give out etc so it’s easier hang with men.

I dont know, ive seen plenty of bitching and gossiping in mens friends groups. Women that dont like other women scream red flags to me.

Its one thing to be friends with exes and another to be so close that she wants nights out with them but without you.
I wonder if the tables were turned and you where best buds with your exes and women youd slept with and told your partner you wanted a night out with them and she wasnt invited. Just seems really disrespectful.
I would have no issue with a partner being friends with exes or other women but in this case, theres very few boundaries like she knows one of them is not over her, that's not a friendship, it's like he's hanging around to swoop in the minute youre off the scene. If she cant see why you have an issue she's either very naive or in total denial.

LegacyUser · 05-10-2020 5:51pm

Sorry but this is a disaster. Out drinking with ex boyfriends. Without you. Sending you home to relieve the babysitter. Seriously wtf. You couldnt make up the brass neck of her. Is she a bit thick and or are you a bit needy and knows she can play you.

Gtf out. Now. This is 100% not the way relationships are.

LegacyUser · 05-10-2020 6:00pm

Airyfairy12 wrote: »

I dont know, ive seen plenty of bitching and gossiping in mens friends groups. Women that dont like other women scream red flags to me.

Its one thing to be friends with exes and another to be so close that she wants nights out with them but without you.
I wonder if the tables were turned and you where best buds with your exes and women youd slept with and told your partner you wanted a night out with them and she wasnt invited. Just seems really disrespectful.
I would have no issue with a partner being friends with exes or other women but in this case, theres very few boundaries like she knows one of them is not over her, that's not a friendship, it's like he's hanging around to swoop in the minute youre off the scene. If she cant see why you have an issue she's either very naive or in total denial.

No, she hasn’t said he’s not over her. It’s my opinion judging his actions by his avoidance of us on nights out. He had a few few years to try won her back and he didn’t try so I doubt he’s waiting in the wings for us to separate. She wants a night out with them on her own because they are her friends and why shouldn’t she, is her opinion. She said it’s no different to going out with a bunch of girls. But my problem is that they’re men, it’s that there is ex’s. Again she says I don’t trust her because if I did I should know she’d never do anything or act disrespectfully

Dtp1979 · 06-10-2020 11:34am

It’s not about whether or not she’d do anything sinister when you’re not there. She should be considerate of your feelings and understand that any normal person would find this inconsiderate of her. It’s like she views the world through her eyes and views and nobody else’s opinions matter. She wouldn’t be for me.

Magicmatilda · 06-10-2020 12:45pm

See the thing is that if my partner was uncomfortable with me seeing my exes (which I think he would be) then I wouldn't go because I love him and I don't want to cause him pain, hurt or confusion. Its not like you feel this about all her friends its just these two and she has been hooking up with both of them on and off for years so the fact that your uncomfortable is hardly unfounded.

I assume you have a child together? If going out with these two buddies affects her family, which it does if it makes you insecure then she should put her family first as any parent, man or woman should. Protecting the integrity of the family is surely more important than having a boys night out!

Also like Airy Fairy, I'm also wary of women who don't like other women. In my experience they like the attention they get from men, they like being treated as "special" or "different" as lets face it men don't behave with women the way they do with other men. So in a group of men they are the woman and therefore special or different, whereas in a group of women there is no special treatment, they are just the same as the rest of us. That's just my own experience and I could of course be wrong.

All that said of course men and women an be friend and hang out and socialise, but these are not friends they are exes who she has gone back to more than once.

Dtp1979 · 06-10-2020 1:34pm

Magicmatilda wrote: »

See the thing is that if my partner was uncomfortable with me seeing my exes (which I think he would be) then I wouldn't go because I love him and I don't want to cause him pain, hurt or confusion. Its not like you feel this about all her friends its just these two and she has been hooking up with both of them on and off for years so the fact that your uncomfortable is hardly unfounded.

I assume you have a child together? If going out with these two buddies affects her family, which it does if it makes you insecure then she should put her family first as any parent, man or woman should. Protecting the integrity of the family is surely more important than having a boys night out!

Also like Airy Fairy, I'm also wary of women who don't like other women. In my experience they like the attention they get from men, they like being treated as "special" or "different" as lets face it men don't behave with women the way they do with other men. So in a group of men they are the woman and therefore special or different, whereas in a group of women there is no special treatment, they are just the same as the rest of us. That's just my own experience and I could of course be wrong.

All that said of course men and women an be friend and hang out and socialise, but these are not friends they are exes who she has gone back to more than once.

Like he already said, she’s not an attention seeker. They’re childhood friends.

Idle Passerby · 06-10-2020 6:14pm

Dtp1979 wrote: »

Like he already said, she’s not an attention seeker. They’re childhood friends.

Friendships with a recurring sexual element. That's a little different to simple childhood friends.

stateofflux · 07-10-2020 1:13am

This is a red flag OP, no question but I would just chill out a bit and keep alert for the next one. she knows exactly what she is doing in terms of treating you like a sucker, but if it were me i would need the major dodge behaviour to happen a couple of times before i jumped ship.

LegacyUser · 09-10-2020 4:00am

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Op here again.

Thanks for all the replies. It’s a hard one. How can I ask her not to be around her ex’s but at the same time expect her to see her friends hassle free? I can’t ask that of anyone.

People normally don't have to ask that of their partners. That's the thing.
Most other people wouldn't socialise with and definitely not go out drinking with their exes. They don't have to be asked. They naturally know not to do it out of respect to their new partner!

IAMAMORON · 09-10-2020 3:53pm

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Hi everyone.
The problem lies with me, or in me.

Guy 1 - long term ex. Childhood sweethearts, lost virginity together etc. They broke up early 20’s, stayed in touch, got back together twice since, in the last 10 years for a couple of years each time. They’ve had a few hook ups too in between. It’s been 4 years but he’s still not comfortable around is and in my opinion not Over her.

She has an large bond with this guy and you should avoid getting in between it, they will always have feelings for each other. In saying that their relationship and time together is over, but, she is no more over him as he is over her. You are stuck on this one I am afraid. It is extremely inconsiderate of her to still hang around with him, basically rubbing it in your face. I wouldn't like it, she should be moving on. Instead she is getting the best of all worlds.

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Guy 2
My girlfriend says she is an extreme prude. Does not sleep around etc. Yet for guy 2 she broke all her rules. They didn’t have sex but they hooked up lots during her 20’s. Very good looking guy and a player. In my opinion, if you break all your rules for somebody, that makes them pretty significant. She says he wasn’t.

She should not be telling you about her feelings for this guy. She was having casual hook ups with him when she was going out with Guy 1? Also girls who have good looking or attractive " friends" who they are claiming to be platonic are talking through their arse. She fancies him and the fact that she has not sealed the deal yet is telling. I don't like this one at all.

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

So far, any time she’s been out with them, we’re there as a couple. But she’s often said she wants to go out with them on her own at some stage. The thoughts of her out skulling pints with these guys makes me physically and mentally ill if I’m being honest. My stomach is in knots and my head is in a spin. She gets extremely annoyed when I say how uncomfortable that would make me. She calls it controlling and says I don’t trust her. Am I pathetic?

Does she not have a group of female friends that she can go skulling pints with? What is with the bukakke of male entourage she seems to enjoy so much time with? including 2 former lovers? FFS.

Just because you are anxious and paranoid about her hanging around and getting pissed with former lovers and boyfriends does not mean that she is not at it?

To be frank I think her behaviour towards you is deplorable. She wants her cake and she wants to eat it also. Why can't she just move on with her life? Dragging you along and rubbing your face in it and has you up to high doe in worry. She is treating you dreadfully imo, I would consider dumping her.

LegacyUser · 14-10-2020 4:41pm

Idle Passerby wrote: »

Friendships with a recurring sexual element. That's a little different to simple childhood friends.

Apologies for the late replies.
Guy 1 she’s says she’s well over but seeing as they were friends since childhood she says she’d like to stay friends.
Guy 2 is married but I wouldn’t trust him as far as I’d throw him. She hasn’t been with him in 10 year. But still.
She says my insecurities are the problem. She says if I trust her then I shouldn’t see her hanging with them as a problem. I see it differently. I honestly think that even if I get help with my insecurities I’d still see this as a problem.

One poster above claimed that she was cheating with one guy or the other back in the day. That’s not the case. She’s not a cheater or attention seeker.

bitofabind · 15-10-2020 12:32pm

Why is a 38 year old woman with a partner and young child at home prioritising going out on the piss with a bunch of exes?

Seriously, on reading your posts I was trying to understand how someone has this much time to spend with their friends to the point where they want to plan nights out together and then on their own, despite having a family at home. What are her priorities? Regardless of her thoughts on the issue, it doesn't seem to matter to her that your head is wrecked over the situation. She doesn't want to fix that. She just wants to maintain the same flirty status quo because she's known these people since childhood and it suits her.

You say you've suffered with insecurity issues in the past. If completely dismissing your thoughts and feelings so she can do whatever the fcuk she wants is her M.O, then it's no wonder why.

Dtp1979 · 15-10-2020 12:53pm

bitofabind wrote: »

Why is a 38 year old woman with a partner and young child at home prioritising going out on the piss with a bunch of exes?

Seriously, on reading your posts I was trying to understand how someone has this much time to spend with their friends to the point where they want to plan nights out together and then on their own, despite having a family at home. What are her priorities? Regardless of her thoughts on the issue, it doesn't seem to matter to her that your head is wrecked over the situation. She doesn't want to fix that. She just wants to maintain the same flirty status quo because she's known these people since childhood and it suits her.

You say you've suffered with insecurity issues in the past. If completely dismissing your thoughts and feelings so she can do whatever the fcuk she wants is her M.O, then it's no wonder why.

To be fair, the op doesn’t say how often she’s out with friends

IAMAMORON · 15-10-2020 1:09pm

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Apologies for the late replies.
Guy 1 she’s says she’s well over but seeing as they were friends since childhood she says she’d like to stay friends.

This sounds appalling and reflects really badly on you as a companion or partner. She is obviously not over him, while I am civil with ex partners we are certainly no longer " friends". If it is over it is over, they both need to move on.

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

Guy 2 is married but I wouldn’t trust him as far as I’d throw him. She hasn’t been with him in 10 year. But still.

In the 3rd millenium marriage is nothing more than a day out. Affairs happen all the time, you are right not to trust this guy. Furthermore he is not the problem here, the problem is your partner who insists on being "friends" with him. Don't set yourself to be a cuckold here, you deserve better.

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

She says my insecurities are the problem. She says if I trust her then I shouldn’t see her hanging with them as a problem. I see it differently. I honestly think that even if I get help with my insecurities I’d still see this as a problem.

Textbook gaslighting if you ask me. She is the one hanging out with former lovers, not you. Rubbing it in your face and telling you that you are insecure? Please believe me your insecurities are very normal. Any man in love with a women should have one eye on what she is up to, especially if she is hellbent on going on the piss with ex -boyfriends.

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

One poster above claimed that she was cheating with one guy or the other back in the day. That’s not the case. She’s not a cheater or attention seeker.

How do you know?

LegacyUser · 15-10-2020 3:56pm

I do have total faith in her that she’s never cheated in the past. Obviously I have to take her word for it.
As said above, yes she/we are not out every week or anything like it.

IAMAMORON · 15-10-2020 5:55pm

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

I do have total faith in her that she’s never cheated in the past. Obviously I have to take her word for it.
As said above, yes she/we are not out every week or anything like it.

The clincher for me is that she wants to hang with her old partners while you are not around? If she was so "over" these guys and just wants to hang out and drink pints with them, what is so wrong with you tagging along, you are her boyfriend?

I would dump her, she is treating you like an idiot and not respecting you at all. She sounds like a right piss taker.

leggo · 15-10-2020 7:56pm

Unfortunately OP, too often people become (what they identify as) attracted to people who actually exacerbate their worst fears/insecurities. It's because how they love can become warped at an early stage of development, so they don't actually identify caring behaviour as loving and instead identify being 'triggered', for lack of a better term, as love. Case in point: you have a history of feeling insecure and anxious and you're committed to and 'have total faith in' someone who could almost be accused of deliberately making you feel insecure and anxious based off what you've told us.

Pretty much everyone here has backed up your concerns that this is odd behaviour. It's certainly not the behaviour of someone who cares for you or is trying to see your side. There's no willingness to hear you out or compromise, no effort to come to solutions, and instead pushing in the opposite direction to tell you she wants to see them now WITHOUT you. That seems like the actions of someone who wants to see how far they can push you. Where exactly in all of this are you getting that she's worth this 'total faith' you have in her? Because I'm not seeing it.

LegacyUser · 15-10-2020 8:56pm

When I say she wants to go out with them without me, it’s not as if she’s asking me constantly not to go out with her. She said there will come a time when she’d like to go out with her friends, incl the 2 ex’s without me. She really sees no harm in this because she truly believes there’s nothing between them. She just doesn’t seem to get why I’d find it uncomfortable at the very least, if I really trusted her.

IAMAMORON · 15-10-2020 9:34pm

Anxiousjohn wrote: »

When I say she wants to go out with them without me, it’s not as if she’s asking me constantly not to go out with her. She said there will come a time when she’d like to go out with her friends, incl the 2 ex’s without me. She really sees no harm in this because she truly believes there’s nothing between them. She just doesn’t seem to get why I’d find it uncomfortable at the very least, if I really trusted her.

She is not being fair with you, she is taking the piss.

Get rid of her, then she can go out with her old flames whenever she likes. In fact you might even get an invite for a change once its over.

LegacyUser · 01-12-2020 12:45pm

Op here again
Things have been ok the last couple of months but that was probably due to nowhere being opened. I’ve a feeling it’ll kick off around Christmas again

LegacyUser · 02-12-2020 3:35pm

Hi OP,

why are you doing this to yourself?
can i ask you a genuine question, is your girlfriend on some kind of spectrum, seriously!

is she that oblivious to your feelings because ive never come across this kind of behavoir before, and ive had quite a few girlfriends in the past.

Youve had nearly every person in this thread saying the same thing to you. we cant all be wrong?

To me, she sounds quite selfish in her views, almost self absorbed, and clearly values nothing but own autonomy over everything, including your feelings. i dont know what to say to you except run. she wont change.
best of luck

Katgurl · 03-12-2020 10:43am

I don't agree with the other replies here at all. They are a group of childhood friends. They grew up together and share memories - parents breaking up, family tragedies etc. It's not as simple as her replacing this group with a group of girls.

She's not keeping you apart or pretending to be single. But she's right, she should be free to meet up at some stage without you. She's not blind, she knows you're tense and it must make her tense too. The night she asked you to go home, she was probably having loads of fun, didn't want the night to end and given they are her group of friends not yours it would be nice if you had let her stay out.

You haven't said anything about flirting, chemistry, suggestive remarks, mentionitis taking place. Everything you've mentioned is stuff in the past.

She's not your property. You have a child together. You sound a solid couple. Let her have a night out with her old friends and have some fun without you. Apart from anything else being with a man who knows he doesn't have to monitor you as he's confident enough to know you wouldn't stray is very very attractive.

sbsquarepants · 03-12-2020 11:05am

OP i'm with Katgurl, this is really your problem, and unfortunately it's not an easy one to get over. Things like insecurity / jealousy tend to run deep. But the long and the short of it is that your girlfriend has done nothing wrong, we all have our past and we can't change them, you'll just need to suck it up or bounce on i'm afraid.

ManOfMystery · 03-12-2020 11:22am

OP When I was younger, I used to have similar worries to yourself.

The best thing I ever did was just accept deep down that what will happen, will happen - and all the stressing and worrying in the world will only drive you insane. If she cheats on you and it's inherently in her nature to be deceitful, she doesn't deserve to be your partner and you're better off without her and knowing the truth of what she's like.

And if she doesn't cheat (which is what most people's expectation would be).................. then there's no problem.

You have to accept both these things as a positive, no matter how difficult it is.

You're stuck in this no-man's land in the middle, where there is nothing to suggest she will cheat on you but you're constantly worried it will happen. All the worrying in the world won't change the outcome either way. In fact, if anything, your behaviour could be perceived as a lack of trust in her, which will only send your relationship south and potentially end up damaging the very thing you're trying to safeguard.

IAMAMORON · 03-12-2020 11:30am

If she was genuine she would have no problem with you tagging along when she is out meeting her troupe of old lovers for a big old flirt off.... and whatever else she is up to after a bottle of Cab Sav.

Girls with no girlfriends and loads of boyfriends are attention seeking nightmares.

She is ripping the piss out of you.

Dump her.

LegacyUser · 03-12-2020 11:44am

I’ve already said she has plenty of friends. I don’t think she’d cheat. It’s about appropriateness and respect I think. I feel disrespected when I see her out having craic with people she’s been sexual with. What she sees as appropriate I see the opposite.

Katgurl · 03-12-2020 12:07pm

Is there a flirtatious vibe to their interactions? To give you another perspective -

I went on a weekend holiday with an old gang of my friends. Our baby was young so my partner stayed behind. I wasn't entirely sure who was going when I RSVPd but I felt a bit stressed when I realised one of the guys was someone I had dated prior to my partner, it hadn't worked out and we weren't ever good friends but had very good friends in common (one of whom was the organizer). He was coming with his girlfriend. Another guy was going that I had a more complicated history with - we had been good friends, had sporadically slept together and there had been feelings on both sides but never the same time so we had never been together. I have no romantic feelings.

I guess I'm a bit torn here. I told my partner and although he was sceptical I was adamant there would be nothing to worry about; no flirting, no staying up for late night chats, nothing I wouldn't do in front of him. He said I should go. I really really appreciated it and found him even more attractive because of it. I don't honestly know how I would have felt the other way around. If he had asked me not to go I would have agreed and not held it against him. After all, he was staying at home with the baby. Plenty of people on here might have told him I was taking him for a mug. I wasn't.

Apart from the romantic entanglements they share childhood history and i don't think it's fair for you to keep that from her. IME women can go back to just platonic feelings for someone quite easily and completely forget about the physical side of things. I think if there are Christmas drinks organised suggest she goes without you for once. It'll show her you trust her then she's far more likely to feel relaxed and will want you there with her the next time. It can't be fun for her feeling on edge when you're around.

IAMAMORON · 03-12-2020 12:16pm

Katgurl wrote: »

Is there a flirtatious vibe to their interactions? To give you another perspective -

I went on a weekend holiday with an old gang of my friends. Our baby was young so my partner stayed behind. I wasn't entirely sure who was going when I RSVPd but I felt a bit stressed when I realised one of the guys was someone I had dated prior to my partner, it hadn't worked out and we weren't ever good friends but had very good friends in common (one of whom was the organizer). He was coming with his girlfriend. Another guy was going that I had a more complicated history with - we had been good friends, had sporadically slept together and there had been feelings on both sides but never the same time so we had never been together. I have no romantic feelings.

I guess I'm a bit torn here. I told my partner and although he was sceptical I was adamant there would be nothing to worry about; no flirting, no staying up for late night chats, nothing I wouldn't do in front of him. He said I should go. I really really appreciated it and found him even more attractive because of it. I don't honestly know how I would have felt the other way around. If he had asked me not to go I would have agreed and not held it against him. After all, he was staying at home with the baby. Plenty of people on here might have told him I was taking him for a mug. I wasn't.

Apart from the romantic entanglements they share childhood history and i don't think it's fair for you to keep that from her. IME women can go back to just platonic feelings for someone quite easily and completely forget about the physical side of things. I think if there are Christmas drinks organised suggest she goes without you for once. It'll show her you trust her then she's far more likely to feel relaxed and will want you there with her the next time. It can't be fun for her feeling on edge when you're around.

It is different for you though because you have a baby now. You are not really on most blokes spectrum anymore, your partner is well aware of this.

In the ops scenario his girlfriend has not had any kids yet, she is still courting several potential partners.

That is the issue.

ManOfMystery · 03-12-2020 12:20pm

IAMAMORON wrote: »

It is different for you though because you have a baby now. You are not really on most blokes spectrum anymore, your partner is well aware of this.

In the ops scenario his girlfriend has not had any kids yet, she is still courting several potential partners.

That is the issue.

Wow. So much wrong with this post.

IAMAMORON · 03-12-2020 12:23pm

ManOfMystery wrote: »

Wow. So much wrong with this post.

Like what?

ManOfMystery · 03-12-2020 12:55pm

IAMAMORON wrote: »

Like what?

Well asides from being mildly insulting to the OP, it's a slightly misogynistic generalisation that once a woman has had a child, she is no longer attractive to the majority of potential suitors. I can think of numerous examples even within my own group of friends, neighbours and colleagues where this isn't the case. And you present this reasoning as the main issue with the OP's predicament?

Bearing in mind your previous post that "Girls with no girlfriends and loads of boyfriends are attention seeking nightmares" and your repeated shouts of Dump Her/She's taking the piss/Dump her, it's obvious that you're suffering from the same insecurities that the OP has - namely, unable to accept that people are able to have sexual relationships and then move into friendship without having the urge to jump each other every time they meet up.

She has been friends with these guys longer than she's been with the OP. She has the right to socialise in their company without him insisting on being present - it's called trust, and it's what most adults are able to manage.

IAMAMORON · 03-12-2020 1:05pm

ManOfMystery wrote: »

Well asides from being mildly insulting to the OP, it's a slightly misogynistic generalisation that once a woman has had a child, she is no longer attractive to the majority of potential suitors. I can think of numerous examples even within my own group of friends, neighbours and colleagues where this isn't the case. And you present this reasoning as the main issue with the OP's predicament?

Bearing in mind your previous post that "Girls with no girlfriends and loads of boyfriends are attention seeking nightmares" and your repeated shouts of Dump Her/She's taking the piss/Dump her, it's obvious that you're suffering from the same insecurities that the OP has - namely, unable to accept that people are able to have sexual relationships and then move into friendship without having the urge to jump each other every time they meet up.

She has been friends with these guys longer than she's been with the OP. She has the right to socialise in their company without him insisting on being present - it's called trust, and it's what most adults are able to manage.

I would prefer if you stayed on topic if I am being honest?

Most blokes would prefer to not start a relationship with women who already have kids, that is a fact and whilst it may be a home truth that you are not altogether comfortable with, I prefer to keep things in the real world when giving out advice.

If you are not comfortable with my opinions I suggest you report them to a moderator. But I would ask that you don't use this thread as an opportunity for you to start criticising my life please? That is not what should be happening here, keep the personal remarks to yourself. You have no idea who I am or anything about my life?

bitofabind · 03-12-2020 2:27pm

Well this took a weird turn. Women don't suddenly become unattractive or undesirable when they've had kids. Blanket statements like this don't help and don't apply either, since the OP has stated they have a child together.

This seems to be a perfect storm of the OP's insecurities combined with an OH that is determined to do what she likes and not consider her partner's needs in this relationship. I don't believe it's a simple matter of "ah they're childhood friends, there's no issue here." Katgurl, in your example, you checked in with your partner, he had no issues so off you went. In this case, the woman is going to do what she wants despite knowing the anxiety it causes her partner. This in turn provokes his anxiety even further and she couldn't give a fcuk. She may even double down and meet them on her own, send him home early from the pub so she can have more fun. Almost as if it's designed to provoke.

Is this how we behave when we love someone? I would hope not. I hate seeing my partner upset, it's even worse when it's something I've caused. If he had an issue with some similar situation, I'd probably be a little annoyed, but wouldn't be doubling down. I'd be talking about it and doing what I can to make him feel secure. "These are my friends, I'm going to see them, what can I do to make you feel ok about this?" None of that going on here.

IAMAMORON · 03-12-2020 2:39pm

Apologies OP, my hands up here, I was not aware that you already had a child together. It was only when I re-read your post about her sending you home early to relieve the babysitter whilst she stayed out flirting with her ex partners that I realised my misinterpretation.

Neyite · 03-12-2020 2:47pm

Mod note:
Can we stop with the generalisations of women and the assumptions please.

Stick to giving the OP helpful advice.

Thanks

Katgurl · 03-12-2020 2:51pm

IAMAMORON wrote: »

It is different for you though because you have a baby now. You are not really on most blokes spectrum anymore, your partner is well aware of this.

In the ops scenario his girlfriend has not had any kids yet, she is still courting several potential partners.

That is the issue.

What a ridiculous not to mention offensive post. How would you know if I'm on most blokes' spectrum? Have I said anything about whether I get propositioned or not? The point is they are not on mine so it doesn't matter, not because of the baby but because I love my partner and would never cheat or disrespect him behind his back.

ETA - whoops sorry just spotted the mod warning. I was so annoyed by that post I responded before finishing the thread. Back on topic

Katgurl · 03-12-2020 3:06pm

@bitofabind yes valid points and I do agree with you. But is she actually saying "the hell with your feelings and I'm going out anyway"? Or maybe she's frustrated and saying "look you've been out with us all as a group, there is nothing to worry about, there may be a time when I'm there without you and there will still be nothing to worry about". She is possibly opening up the conversation as she wants him to be ok with it. It doesn't necessarily follow she's going to plough on regardless.

And as for staying late on the night out to flirt - the OP hasn't said there was flirting. The drink and laughs were probably flowing, the friends could have begged her to stay out and she just suggested it spontaneously. Maybe that is even what opened up this conversation topic.

I'm not saying everybody else here is wrong, that OP's girlfriend isn't enjoying the attention and trying to have the best of both worlds, I'm saying it's not a definite. I certainly wasn't courting attention or flirting but it was nice to let my hair down and have a bit of a blow out while knowing my partner was fine with it. I did have a possessive partner in the past (not calling op that) which drained my joy, self confidence so I may have a skewed view.

Also, this is only my perspective but that is what people come to RI for - a very good friend of mine has a gang of guys she was very close with since childhood. In the group there were three girls and about twelve guys. They all lived very close to each other. Despite everyone growing up, getting married, emigrating etc they have a really close bond and will amalgamate for occasions. Herself and the other two girls have some growing up experimenting history with the guys but there is zero chance of anything like that going on now. They are more like cousins tbh - a shared history. One of the guys got married to a woman who didn't allow him hang out with my friend or the other women without her and honestly I thought it was such a shame. If she had really looked at the dynamics of the group she could have made some new female friends herself.

LegacyUser · 03-12-2020 3:06pm

Katgurl,
You sound a lot like my girlfriend tbh.

You asked about flirting. Well no, but she is very much one of the lads and having craic + drink + late hours snd a history is a dangerous mix.
I dunno, I’d never in a million years ask my partner to go home. But any time we go out now it’ll probably play on my mind that I may be asked to go home if there’s a babysitter. I’d never ask that of anybody and was so surprised she asked it of me.

As for being off the radar, absolutely not. She’s very attractive and guy 2 (married guy) would try it on in a heartbeat. She says he’s so not her type yet she repeatedly went for him in years past. Not saying she would again. I hate feeling like this.

IAMAMORON · 03-12-2020 3:17pm

Katgurl wrote: »

What a ridiculous not to mention offensive post. How would you know if I'm on most blokes' spectrum? Have I said anything about whether I get propositioned or not? The point is they are not on mine so it doesn't matter, not because of the baby but because I love my partner and would never cheat or disrespect him behind his back.

ETA - whoops sorry just spotted the mod warning. I was so annoyed by that post I responded before finishing the thread. Back on topic

To be honest I never meant to cause you any offense?

I think we all know the truth and despite a moderator having to intervene in the discussion there is not really any reason to get cat on the matter. I don't think I said anything that everyone doesn't accept is true in the first place? It may be a bit blunt... and a tough read, but I live in the real world.

Either way my original thoughts were completely unfounded as it turns out that they already have a child together. So essentially my bad, but it does not take away from the truth of how men think, it is not an " assumption" either.

sbsquarepants · 03-12-2020 3:19pm

IAMAMORON wrote: »

Either way my original thoughts were completely unfounded as it turns out that they already have a child together. So essentially my bad, but it does not take away from the truth of how men think, it is not an " assumption" either.

I'm a man, i don't think that way!

Advice please - girlfriend's exes

Comments