Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

Baggly · 08-05-2019 11:50am

sKeith wrote: »

Okay, then say he is pocketing left right and center. I just found it odd after i had made it clear that he's pocketing everywhere, yoiu wouild then state he was pocketing you. Great detective work.

Again, i am not defending BH, i am questioning your reason. wolves tend to have difficulty coming up with reasons for calling people wolfy.

Well tbh im taking what you are saying with a pinch of salt. You may be cleared to you, but you arent to me.

sKeith · 08-05-2019 11:59am

Pter wrote: »

Well tbh im taking what you are saying with a pinch of salt. You may be cleared to you, but you arent to me.

Not going to waste my post count with you today, as you are very likely to bleed many many posts out of me, you're quite good at that and today we being counted, unlike at the weekend.

I believe you would be a good information lynch. I'd hope for wolf, but even if you flipped villa, there's lots of information to be gained.

Bounty Hunter · 08-05-2019 12:09pm

sKeith wrote: »

On Bounty Hunter, Are you serious?

I called him forty coats. (with his fifty pockets)
He's been pocketing the WHOLE thread since post #1.
You make it sound like you were singled out for pocketing, lol.
I see nothing wrong with you wolf leaning him, but the excuse is so weak its wonky. Give me another reason that does not include pocketing,

On first glance this may seem like sK defending me but the more I look at it the more dodgy I feel about it.

This is an example of someone creating a narrative. I put up a gif suggesting we all get high, then myself joked I was pocketing the whole village. As a result he dubbed me 40 coats.

Above he leaves out the context and just says I've been pocketing everyone while making sure everyone gets what 40 coats means "with his 50 pockets". He also repeats this everytime he puts up his "reads list" which is always the same post slightly edited and in doing so attempts to drill his thoughts (the thoughts of the most outspoken villager) into our heads. In the same vein he keeps repeating his Lock Clear about himself whilst of course offering nothing in return.

I said previously I don't think a wolf would play the way he is, but combining instances like this with his over eagerness to be a cleared in a game with no roles, his argumentative style and his avoiding questions and I'm really not sure if I still think that.

Baggly · 08-05-2019 12:13pm

sKeith wrote: »

Not going to waste my post count with you today, as you are very likely to bleed many many posts out of me, you're quite good at that and today we being counted, unlike at the weekend.

I believe you would be a good information lynch. I'd hope for wolf, but even if you flipped villa, there's lots of information to be gained.

Same could be said about you tbh, and would have the added bonus of you not dragging the village off course with ignoring questions and being aggressive.

Happy to ignore you as just annoying (in game, not in general - in general i think you are sound), for now. I dont think ill last long doing so, however.

Kolido · 08-05-2019 12:25pm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Whiplashy & Kolido - whips 1st post she calls Kolido a wolf for being first to post on thread. It reads like its in jest (has smiley face) but Kolido doesnt acknowledge it in any way. Later, Kolido asks whip has she caught up on thread. She thanks his post and responds that she has. End of interactions.

FFA

Kolido will be in there anyway. He completely ignored her jest post about wolf being 1st to post. Ignoring it would be something a roled player would do but seeing as there are no good roles.....

The other 2 I have decided on yet.

It was obviously a joke by Whippy so I didnt respond.

Its a flimsy reason to pick me but fair enough, no hard feelings.

08-05-2019 12:26pm

Day one votes so far

Tuesday
10:03 strawbs votes kitten
10:07 Pter votes Andy
10:18 green votes Andy
13:02 fixer voting trit or Barney with side of Keith
15:08 Andy voting green
15:26 Kolido voting tomorrow (today) for someone not throwing out accusations
16:33 Andy reiterating their vote on green
16:40 green states open to change his Andy vote
16:44 Trit thinks green and Andy interactions interesting and probably vote green out of 2
18:34 bounty will probably placeholder green or strawberry soon
20:35 clarabel votes duffman
21:45 Pter reiterating vote staying on Andy
22:26 clarabel unvotes duffman and votes crosstownk
Wednesday
01:57 Keith votes fixxxer
05:38 bounty says skunk has voted Keith think I missed skunk saying this (check ffa at 19:26 Tuesday)
07:36 Kolido votes loughc
09:45 Andy unvoting green and leaning towards Pter
09:57 strawberry unvotes kitten and votes Kolido
10:13 Qb votes for skunk
10:59 green reiterating they haven’t moved off Andy but Andy bringing them around

duffman13 · 08-05-2019 12:31pm

I've a lot of catching up to do! I did have a great weekend though. A few hundred posts to catch up on

kitten_k · 08-05-2019 12:33pm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Day one votes so far

Tuesday
10:03 strawbs votes kitten
10:07 Pter votes Andy
10:18 green votes Andy
13:02 fixer voting trit or Barney with side of Keith
15:08 Andy voting green
15:26 Kolido voting tomorrow (today) for someone not throwing out accusations
16:33 Andy reiterating their vote on green
16:40 green states open to change his Andy vote
16:44 Trit thinks green and Andy interactions interesting and probably vote green out of 2
18:34 bounty will probably placeholder green or strawberry soon
20:35 clarabel votes duffman
21:45 Pter reiterating vote staying on Andy
22:26 clarabel unvotes duffman and votes crosstownk
Wednesday
01:57 Keith votes fixxxer
05:38 bounty says skunk has voted Keith think I missed skunk saying this (check ffa at 19:26 Tuesday)
07:36 Kolido votes loughc
09:45 Andy unvoting green and leaning towards Pter
09:57 strawberry unvotes kitten and votes Kolido
10:13 Qb votes for skunk
10:59 green reiterating they haven’t moved off Andy but Andy bringing them around

I haven't voted yet but will do so before I leave work this afternoon, will post on thread once its done.

(Hope you're ok QB)

sKeith · 08-05-2019 12:37pm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Day one votes so far

Tuesday
10:03 strawbs votes kitten
10:07 Pter votes Andy
10:18 green votes Andy
13:02 fixer voting trit or Barney with side of Keith
15:08 Andy voting green
15:26 Kolido voting tomorrow (today) for someone not throwing out accusations
16:33 Andy reiterating their vote on green
16:40 green states open to change his Andy vote
16:44 Trit thinks green and Andy interactions interesting and probably vote green out of 2
18:34 bounty will probably placeholder green or strawberry soon
20:35 clarabel votes duffman
21:45 Pter reiterating vote staying on Andy
22:26 clarabel unvotes duffman and votes crosstownk
Wednesday
01:57 Keith votes fixxxer
05:38 bounty says skunk has voted Keith think I missed skunk saying this (check ffa at 19:26 Tuesday)
07:36 Kolido votes loughc
09:45 Andy unvoting green and leaning towards Pter
09:57 strawberry unvotes kitten and votes Kolido
10:13 Qb votes for skunk
10:59 green reiterating they haven’t moved off Andy but Andy bringing them around

Triceratops Ballet · 08-05-2019 12:40pm

Ok I've been doing some reading, I haven't read everyone's iso yet cos there's a lot of chaff from the weekend.

so far here are my thoughts:

Very low posters (I categorised this as anyone who's posted less than the mods!)
Digi, CTK, LoughC, Succubus
For obvious reasons I've not read on these, inclined to give the benefit of the doubt for the next day or so as RL can get in the way and there's bound to be a reason they picked a slow game to play.

I won't be voting from the v low poster group...this time

Next Level (players who've posted up to and around my level so far....spoiler alert this is as far as I've gotten)
Duffman - was very chatty all weekend kind of went a bit hard on peope "who forgot the game was starting" led us down a meta convo route with skeith, and agreed with QB that constantly changing nicknames was unfair on newbs. absent since then. could be RL could be more.

Tusk- first game trying to figure out what kind of villager they are (their words not mine) has soem interractions with other (barney and Fixxer) players wants to understand their reasoning for accusations a little. still catching up on thread.

Trit- Not loads of posts but lots of good questioning of motives of other posters, in favour of FFA and favours posters declaring their vote on thread

Ecto - again not loads of posts, but true to her word yesterday deliverd a detailed post of her thoughts on everyone yesterday

Triceratops Ballet - a majestic and graceful creature with a three horned face! She's been a little MIA so far this game but that's ok cos it was a bank holiday and this is a slow burning game and she has work to do!!!

Clarabel - also "forgot about the game" asks a lot of questions, has submitted 2 different FFA's and voted twice both times for people not on her FFA

Out of the above list so far I'm suss on Clara and Duffer, Clara can you clarify why neither of your votes were for people on your FFAs?

When I get a chunk of time again later I'll look at further posters and be back with questions, as a placeholder I'll be voting Duffer (I think)

08-05-2019 12:42pm

Don’t think Trits is a definite vote but he can clarify.

Heading for the dentist for 2:30 and will be there for 90 mins minimum. Dunno what form I’ll be in afterwards but the votes are time stamped if anyone wants to continue with them.

I have FFAs to date too should I fire them onto thread?

tusk · 08-05-2019 12:44pm

Trying to catch up a little on lunch, but random question....

Do we find out vote numbers or do we just get told who dies?

kitten_k · 08-05-2019 12:45pm

tusk wrote: »

Trying to catch up a little on lunch, but random question....

Do we find out vote numbers or do we just get told who dies?

Votes are usually published after the lynch results so we find out who voted for who

Bounty Hunter · 08-05-2019 12:49pm

You put me down as probably putting in a vote on either R&G or Stawbs and although it is odd saying this to you I can clarify that at around that time I did vote for you. Good chance I might change it today though i'l try to state on the thread if I do. Not sure if I did up an FFA again now if i'd have the same names on it at all but a lot can change perception wise in a day.

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 12:49pm

Doing a quick catchup on my lunch break.
Happy Birthday D Andy and Sully, hope they're good ones for ye both.

QB, hope you're ok and everything gets better for you soon.

I haven't voted yet and won't be til I'm home. Am currently suspecting a sKeith and G n R team which would be ballsy play but there is something off there. If not both, I do think one wolf in there.

Kitten may have moved more wolf than not.

Succubus being here is good.

Ahhh I hate playing on phone. Have my points all clear and then forget half of them as I'm typing.

fixXxer · 08-05-2019 12:52pm

I'm leaning strongly on a G&R vote at the moment after reading back. Waiting so see more information before I switch to sKieth.

I don't really like how G&R rowed back from Dandy so quickly, like he didn't expect a strong come back. Openly saying he wanted to start a bandwagon sits badly with me to. Like, what does it achieve? Everyone votes for the one person, statistically more likely to hit a villager than a wolf and now the wolves have a place to hide too.

08-05-2019 12:55pm

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

You put me down as probably putting in a vote on either R&G or Stawbs and although it is odd saying this to you I can clarify that at around that time I did vote for you. Good chance I might change it today though i'l try to state on the thread if I do. Not sure if I did up an FFA again now if i'd have the same names on it at all but a lot can change perception wise in a day.

No probs. I won’t keep adding edits/amendments one by one but I’ll change it to me when I do the next updated one. Keith, could you add it to your list anyway just Incase it gets overlooked?

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 12:56pm

Hopefully getting home early today so will get a chance to look back and see what my notes are saying.

Are we setting a time for FFAs to be done by?

Triceratops Ballet · 08-05-2019 1:01pm

I put in a placeholder of Duffer btw

sKeith · 08-05-2019 1:03pm

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

You put me down as probably putting in a vote on either R&G or Stawbs and although it is odd saying this to you I can clarify that at around that time I did vote for you. Good chance I might change it today though i'l try to state on the thread if I do. Not sure if I did up an FFA again now if i'd have the same names on it at all but a lot can change perception wise in a day.

I read it as yet to vote, which is why i didn't include in table.

There is also TBs account of voting twice which is not in timed votes post.

I can't dive back and check atm, will do later if nobdy else can double check whats correct here before then.

Green&Red · 08-05-2019 1:11pm

fixxxer wrote: »

I'm leaning strongly on a G&R vote at the moment after reading back. Waiting so see more information before I switch to sKieth.

I don't really like how G&R rowed back from Dandy so quickly, like he didn't expect a strong come back. Openly saying he wanted to start a bandwagon sits badly with me to. Like, what does it achieve? Everyone votes for the one person, statistically more likely to hit a villager than a wolf and now the wolves have a place to hide too.

Have you read my posts? I haven't vote is still there

A bandwagon can tell you stuff about who jumps on it and who doesnt
Unfortunately I'm currently the bandwagon

If you, Trit or Bounty are village then you should move off me, I'm village, have only being trying to help and now an initial vote from Dandy has been hijacked to form a bandwagon. I'm an easy target cause I've been vocal.
Of those four I've two in my FFA. Either Dandy for starting the bandwagon and then stepping off or one of the other three. Like I say if one of you three is not a wolf you should look at the other two very closely

sKeith · 08-05-2019 1:12pm

sKeith wrote: »

I read it as yet to vote, which is why i didn't include in table.

There is also TBs account of voting twice which is not in timed votes post.

I can't dive back and check atm, will do later if nobdy else can double check whats correct here before then.

No, you just blind.
20:35 clarabel votes duffman
22:26 clarabel unvotes duffman and votes crosstownk

Clarabel did vote twice and straw spotted them both. sorry.. oops.

Green&Red · 08-05-2019 1:13pm

*Have you read my posts? I haven't rowed back, vote is still there

Ecto the above also applies to you

tusk · 08-05-2019 1:15pm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Day one votes so far

Tuesday
10:03 strawbs votes kitten
10:07 Pter votes Andy
10:18 green votes Andy
13:02 fixer voting trit or Barney with side of Keith
15:08 Andy voting green
15:26 Kolido voting tomorrow (today) for someone not throwing out accusations
16:33 Andy reiterating their vote on green
16:40 green states open to change his Andy vote
16:44 Trit thinks green and Andy interactions interesting and probably vote green out of 2
18:34 bounty will probably placeholder green or strawberry soon
20:35 clarabel votes duffman
21:45 Pter reiterating vote staying on Andy
22:26 clarabel unvotes duffman and votes crosstownk
Wednesday
01:57 Keith votes fixxxer
05:38 bounty says skunk has voted Keith think I missed skunk saying this (check ffa at 19:26 Tuesday)
07:36 Kolido votes loughc
09:45 Andy unvoting green and leaning towards Pter
09:57 strawberry unvotes kitten and votes Kolido
10:13 Qb votes for skunk
10:59 green reiterating they haven’t moved off Andy but Andy bringing them around

For Transparency, I voted skunk tuesday at some point.

Bounty Hunter · 08-05-2019 1:22pm

Green&Red wrote: »

Have you read my posts? I haven't vote is still there

A bandwagon can tell you stuff about who jumps on it and who doesnt
Unfortunately I'm currently the bandwagon

If you, Trit or Bounty are village then you should move off me, I'm village, have only being trying to help and now an initial vote from Dandy has been hijacked to form a bandwagon. I'm an easy target cause I've been vocal.
Of those four I've two in my FFA. Either Dandy for starting the bandwagon and then stepping off or one of the other three. Like I say if one of you three is not a wolf you should look at the other two very closely

People get defensive when they are on FFAs but I did state my vote is currently in for Strawbs. Although that could change

Dublinandy2 · 08-05-2019 1:25pm

Nom nom nom, sadly i can't eat both for lunch I have the make the mrs one too.

Does liking meat make me a wolf? Lol some will say thus post points to that

sKeith · 08-05-2019 1:27pm

fixxxer wrote: »

Now, on Whiplashys munch.

That little interaction between Whippy and Trit over Skunkys post was interesting. Both agreeing that skunky was posting oddly and then Whippy gets murderised. Makes me suspicious of Trit more than Skunky.

Odd that Barney92 didn't mention it in his big round up of Whippys posts/

so:

Voting either Trit or Barney91 with a possible portion of sKieth to follow.

fixxxer wrote: »

I'm leaning strongly on a G&R vote at the moment after reading back. Waiting so see more information before I switch to sKieth.

I don't really like how G&R rowed back from Dandy so quickly, like he didn't expect a strong come back. Openly saying he wanted to start a bandwagon sits badly with me to. Like, what does it achieve? Everyone votes for the one person, statistically more likely to hit a villager than a wolf and now the wolves have a place to hide too.

I like where my vote is currently at.

Read that progression.

He didn't munch me because he thinks I will be mislynch material.

He doesn't want to say it outright as when I flip villa, he is not right there, He is trying to push we but trying to keep plausible deniability.

Clarabel · 08-05-2019 2:22pm

Barney92 wrote: »

So I've gone from on your list of potential wolves to one of two you are leaning good on. What did you read in the 15 minutes between those post that changed your mind?

About 20 pages

fixXxer · 08-05-2019 2:23pm

sKeith wrote: »

dandy|pter, green|2
skunk| qb, tusk|2
trit/barney| fixxxer|1
green| trit?|1
cross| calrabel|1
fixxxer| sKeith|1
loughc| kolido|1
pter| dandy|1
kolido| strawberry|1
duff|tb
straw|BH

I like where my vote is currently at.

Read that progression.

He didn't munch me because he thinks I will be mislynch material.

He doesn't want to say it outright as when I flip villa, he is not right there, He is trying to push we but trying to keep plausible deniability.

I have you on my FFA, there is no attempt at plausible deniability. Your word soup makes you a difficult read, but I'm reading wolf with what I have. Your FFA is what makes me really suspicious. LoughC on it after two posts for throwing shade, even though neither is shade. To be blunt, you're a better player than that pick indicates. So either you're a wolf padding your FFA, or possibly you're a wolf putting a little distance between and your wolfy friend in case your aggressive style gets you lynched.

Clarabel · 08-05-2019 2:23pm

Kolido wrote: »

Chances are a rather new player will be wolf number 3. What ya think Clarebel?

FFA#1

Keith
Lough
Clarebel

.

How does the maths work on that?

Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

Comments