Manchester United Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread - Read Mod Warning in OP 7/1/15

05-03-2015 12:11PM

gosplan wrote: »

Just saw the Newcastle penalty shout there.

I'm not into some trolling idea of justice or anything. You won - move on.

But Jesus, what an AWFUL attempt at a tackle from the defender. What te he'll was he at?

That's Smalling for you, easily the worst defender that gets game time. He's never in position and is clumsy both tackling and with the ball.

TheDoc · 05-03-2015 12:14PM

gosplan wrote: »

Just saw the Newcastle penalty shout there.

I'm not into some trolling idea of justice or anything. You won - move on.

But Jesus, what an AWFUL attempt at a tackle from the defender. What te he'll was he at?

Trying to swing his leg around to get the full block, striker was quick and took the touch needed to evade the tackle. Was a stonewall penalty in fairness, but it wasn't "shocking "defending as someone are making out. 8/10 Smalling gets contact on the ball, the striker goes hurdling over his leg, and Smalling strolls out of defence with it no problems.

Two REALLY poor decisions that game, to continue the recent run of horrendous refereeing in the league.

Lack of technology aid at this point is simply gross negligence. Within five seconds of the incident we all knew it was a penalty.

Another five seconds and we see Rooney onside.

These arn't piddly arse decisions over a throw or a foul on the half way line, these are goal scoring incidents that totally change the tide of games.

Even more amazing are the dinosaurs who give it large about " technology would ruin it, football is about having the craic and debates". Cause I really enjoy talking with my mates about a ****bag referee....

05-03-2015 12:14PM

bangkok wrote: »

like I said, if we want to win the league he shouldn't be on the starting 11.

4th best team in a season that will probably go down as one of the worst premier league seasons of recent times, quality of play, ref decisions, diving, technical ability probably at an all time low

The quality was far less the last time United won the league. The quality of the league is a sweeping term that I hate but every team now is far stronger than 2 or 3 years ago where players who are in relegation teams now would have been in mid tabl. teams.

Your Airbag · 05-03-2015 12:16PM

Giggsy11 wrote: »

His articles are terrible and he doesn't even have a proper source once Moyes was gone.

TheDoc wrote: »

Yeah I know it's so weird, him and Jackson writing epicly speculative articles this season that just make no sense and have pretend sources. Such a dramatic change from their accurate, and good reporting, last season.

I imagine a big part of this is down to LVG telling the media to p1ss off and making it clear to staff that any leaks are unacceptable.

He doesn't like the media at all. His rant on them in the post match interview on BT last night was gold.

TheDoc · 05-03-2015 12:16PM

Liam O wrote: »

That's Smalling for you, easily the worst defender that gets game time. He's never in position and is clumsy both tackling and with the ball.

Behind Rojo he has been out best centre half since the turn of the year.

Van Gaal clearly has issues with Shaw, and I'm not surprised, he seriously flatters to deceive.

I'm imagine for the upcoming tough run Carrick will be playing in DM, Blind LB and Rojo in CB with Smalling.

Early days for Shaw but has definitely being a disappointment. Glimmers here and there of good stuff, but his pace seems to be covering up his defensive lapses that hopefully get sorted as he grows with experience.

Al Capwned · 05-03-2015 12:18PM

keane2097 wrote: »

Someone had a website a while ago where you put in what points you think teams will get in their remaining fixtures - anyone have a link to it?

Someone posted this one a few days ago.

Liam O wrote: »

That's Smalling for you, easily the worst defender that gets game time. He's never in position and is clumsy both tackling and with the ball.

City game aside, I think he's been ok. You're being overly harsh on him imo.

TheDoc · 05-03-2015 12:18PM

Your Airbag wrote: »

I imagine a big part of this is down to LVG telling the media to p1ss off and making it clear to staff that any leaks are unacceptable.

He doesn't like the media at all. His rant on them in the post match interview on BT last night was gold.

Yeah thats exactly what happened. Ogdon and a few lads had direct communication with both Moyes and Woodward. One of Van Gaals first things was to let management at the club know that the co operation with the media from the previous regime is totally unacceptable

bangkok · 05-03-2015 12:21PM

TheDoc wrote: »

Behind Rojo he has been out best centre half since the turn of the year.

Van Gaal clearly has issues with Shaw, and I'm not surprised, he seriously flatters to deceive.

I'm imagine for the upcoming tough run Carrick will be playing in DM, Blind LB and Rojo in CB with Smalling.

Early days for Shaw but has definitely being a disappointment. Glimmers here and there of good stuff, but his pace seems to be covering up his defensive lapses that hopefully get sorted as he grows with experience.

shaw was the best left back in England last season, playing in a better team this year and better surroundings he should be improving but looks like he has gone backwards. Cannot be helped by uniteds lack of free flowing football, not many forward passes, more side to side, cant be really helping the attacking full back.

Giggsy11 · 05-03-2015 12:23PM

Liam O wrote: »

That's Smalling for you, easily the worst defender that gets game time. He's never in position and is clumsy both tackling and with the ball.

Miles better than Evans and also our best CB with Rojo.

Al Capwned · 05-03-2015 12:24PM

Al Capwned wrote: »

Someone posted this one a few days ago.

You can select just what clubs fixtures you want to predict too - i picked current top 8, and came up with this.
Where do I pay? I'd have it in a heartbeat, though I may have been a bit optimistic....

05-03-2015 12:25PM

Al Capwned wrote: »

Someone posted this one a few days ago.

City game aside, I think he's been ok. You're being overly harsh on him imo.

I think his lack of positioning is responsible for the gaping hole in the middle of the defense when the team lose the ball and drags everyone down as the team are so imbalanced then afterwards so yeah I'm going to be harsh on him, it's things that are harder to see that he is the worst at.

As for Shaw, I think he's looked good most times I've seen him play this season. Don't think he suits a diamond midfield formation but with a winger ahead of him I think he shines.

Rayne Wooney · 05-03-2015 12:45PM

We need Swansea to get a draw and us to beat Spurs, Liverpool have all the momentum and can see them scoring a few against us, a different animal to the one that wasted chance after chance at OT, at least they'll still be behind if they beat us then

kryogen · 05-03-2015 12:46PM

gosplan wrote: »

Just saw the Newcastle penalty shout there.

I'm not into some trolling idea of justice or anything. You won - move on.

But Jesus, what an AWFUL attempt at a tackle from the defender. What te he'll was he at?

It was mistimed, by a fraction of a second. It happens to pretty much all defenders at some point.

Spazdarn · 05-03-2015 12:47PM

Smalling has improved in the last few games, he's still pants mind, but he has gotten better.

Giggsy11 · 05-03-2015 12:48PM

gosplan wrote: »

Just saw the Newcastle penalty shout there.

I'm not into some trolling idea of justice or anything. You won - move on.

But Jesus, what an AWFUL attempt at a tackle from the defender. What te he'll was he at?

TheDoc wrote: »

Trying to swing his leg around to get the full block, striker was quick and took the touch needed to evade the tackle. Was a stonewall penalty in fairness, but it wasn't "shocking "defending as someone are making out. 8/10 Smalling gets contact on the ball, the striker goes hurdling over his leg, and Smalling strolls out of defence with it no problems.
.

Every mistimed tackle in the box can be categorized as "awful attempt". It's a common mistimed tackle. We have seen Kos (just an example) making these awful tackles lot of times.

bucketybuck · 05-03-2015 12:49PM

The_Kew_Tour wrote: »

Our manager deserves lot of credit for Fellaini.

He showed great belief in him when others would have made him a scapegoat.

Don't know if I disagree, but the term "great belief" doesn't seem appropriate when the manager has only started Felliani in 2 league games this year. Our £27.5m midfielder is hardly a regular under LVG, which is surprising when you consider his performances and that we previously had Rooney playing in midfield.

Giggsy11 · 05-03-2015 12:51PM

kryogen wrote: »

It was mistimed, by a fraction of a second. It happens to pretty much all defenders at some point.

But that point goes against the agenda or whatever, that ManUtd defense is pants even though we have conceded fewer goals than Arsenal and Liverpool.

Maximus Alexander · 05-03-2015 12:53PM

Giggsy11 wrote: »

But that point goes against the agenda or whatever, that ManUtd defense is pants even though we have conceded fewer goals than Arsenal and Liverpool.

Yeah but in fairness, the team is set up to defend through possession. Most likely because the defense is pants.

kryogen · 05-03-2015 12:55PM

Al Capwned wrote: »

You can select just what clubs fixtures you want to predict too - i picked current top 8, and came up with this.
Where do I pay? I'd have it in a heartbeat, though I may have been a bit optimistic....

My current prediction has us to finish 3 points ahead of Liverpool iirc but certainly not as high a points total, think I had us down for 72 points max

Giggsy11 · 05-03-2015 12:55PM

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

Yeah but in fairness, the team is set up to defend through possession. Most likely because the defense is pants.

If the defense was great we wouldn't have played slow possession game? I don't think so.

Maximus Alexander · 05-03-2015 01:05PM

Al Capwned wrote: »

You can select just what clubs fixtures you want to predict too - i picked current top 8, and came up with this.
Where do I pay? I'd have it in a heartbeat, though I may have been a bit optimistic....

I got the following:

Chelsea	        38	35	91
Man City          38	32	83
Man Utd	        38	21	76
Arsenal	        38	23	75
Liverpool	38	12	73
Southampton	38	19	65
Tottenham	38	6	63

I didn't think I was being too optimistic but quite clearly I was. :eek:

Maximus Alexander · 05-03-2015 01:06PM

Giggsy11 wrote: »

If the defense was great we wouldn't have played slow possession game? I don't think so.

I think so.

Mitch Connor · 05-03-2015 01:14PM

kryogen wrote: »

My current prediction has us to finish 3 points ahead of Liverpool iirc but certainly not as high a points total, think I had us down for 72 points max

I have Arsenal clear in 3rd, with United pipping Liverpool on Goal difference to 4th.

I thought doing the prediction Untied would have lost out by 2 or 3 points easy to Liverpool.

Pighead · 05-03-2015 01:23PM

kryogen wrote: »

My current prediction has us to finish 3 points ahead of Liverpool iirc but certainly not as high a points total, think I had us down for 72 points max

Out of interest what result did you stick in for the away game at Liverpool?

Lord TSC · 05-03-2015 01:48PM

We're nearing 10000 posts, so I'm going to knock off this thread now and open the new one

Manchester United Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread - Read Mod Warning in OP 7/1/15

Comments