Eircom Fibre Vs Vodafone Fibre (Congestion)

Merry Prankster · 15-12-2014 02:42PM #1

Hi,

We're currently with Vodafone and were about to upgrade to fibre broadband with them. An Eircom salesman has just called out and claimed that Eircom offer uncongested 1:1 fibre broadband whereas Vodafone do not. Is this true?

Cheers.

Vico1612 · 15-12-2014 03:51PM

Merry Prankster wrote: »

Hi,

.. An Eircom salesman has just called out .

Cheers.

I think you've answered your question ... :-)
I'm with VF and have not seen any contention issues , can't comment if Eircom is any better.

degsie · 15-12-2014 03:59PM

I'm sure the regulator would be interested to hear of eircom dissing other isp using their own resold product!

Benster · 15-12-2014 04:14PM

Be very careful with anything those door-to-door salesmen tell you. In my experience, they have promised the Earth just to get you to sign on the spot, and some don't have a problem telling porkies about competitors.

I meant to add, I have VF broadband as well, very few, if any, problems to report.

Merry Prankster · 15-12-2014 04:35PM

Cheers for the replies lads.

I just called Vodafone and the guy would only confirm that they, obviously, all use the same network. He couldn't confirm whether it will be 1:1.

The reason I'm worried is because we currently have ADSL broadband on a 6mb line with Vodafone, but the speed goes down to less than half a meg on evenings and weekends, rendering it all but unuseable. I'd hate to commit to an 18 month contract if we're going to experience a similar type of drop with their fibre service.

I'll try posting on the VF forum and see if one of their guys can offer any further insight.

mass_debater · 15-12-2014 04:42PM

Merry Prankster wrote: »

Cheers for the replies lads.

I just called Vodafone and the guy would only confirm that they, obviously, all use the same network. He couldn't confirm whether it will be 1:1.

The reason I'm worried is because we currently have ADSL broadband on a 6mb line with Vodafone, but the speed goes down to less than half a meg on evenings and weekends, rendering it all but unuseable. I'd hate to commit to an 18 month contract if we're going to experience a similar type of drop with their fibre service.

I'll try posting on the VF forum and see if one of their guys can offer any further insight.

You can't really compare ADSL and VDSL

Merry Prankster · 15-12-2014 05:06PM

mass_debater wrote: »

You can't really compare ADSL and VDSL

True. I've just had a look over on the VF forums and one of their guys has stated that their service is non-contended. So Mr. Door-To-Door Broadband Salesman was telling porkies.

mass_debater · 15-12-2014 05:15PM

Merry Prankster wrote: »

So Mr. Door-To-Door Broadband Salesman was telling porkies.

They all do. Don't ever sign up to anything on your doorstep, no matter how good it seems

Eircom Fibre Vs Vodafone Fibre (Congestion)

Comments