Would you risk your life?

guitarzero · 29-05-2012 11:55PM

Good man but I dont think Id have bothered, the risk would be too high. Id console my cowardice in Karma.

Amirani · 30-05-2012 12:02AM

If someone was getting attacked and they themselves were under threat then I reckon I'd intervene. Not for a purse though.

I've heard of cases where people have had their wallet/phone robbed, given chase to the thief only to find themselves confronted by a larger group in some alley where they're robbed of whatever else they have on them.

minidazzler · 30-05-2012 12:12AM

I dunno, it's kinda you gotta be there situation.

cian68 · 30-05-2012 12:18AM

Not over a handbag. She can live without a few tampons or whatever are kept in those mystery boxes. I was once punched in the face by a complete stranger waiting at the traffic lights on my way to tesco. Did nothing then either. Nothing to be gained from it.

Memory Of 98 · 30-05-2012 12:22AM

NiallSparky wrote: »

I've heard of cases where people have had their wallet/phone robbed, given chase to the thief only to find themselves confronted by a larger group in some alley where they're robbed of whatever else they have on them.

You know, looking back now and fretting at my stupidity, I didn't even think of that. I was just worried about the dangers of either being hit by a car while I was trying to dodge them, or getting stabbed by the thief.

My Girlfriend had mixed feelings, mostly worried about me getting hurt over something that was not solely consequential to me.

Doc Ruby · 30-05-2012 12:29AM

Memory Of 98 wrote: »

When I got back, the victim praised me. But just about everyone else scolded me calling me a fool and an idiot for risking my life for someone that I did not even know.

Get stabbed over a purse? Not a chance. If she was being physically assaulted I would step in though, and have in the past.

mikemac1 wrote: »

Get an actor, dress him up rough and have him collapse outside a train station, people stay walking

And I think I would do the same. Got a punch off a wino in Eyre Sq Galway once and that place was just full of winos.

Then get a smartly dressed actor, hits the ground and gets help swiftly

Police are trained not to immediately approach or touch someone collapsed on the ground in case they get a jab of a needle, verbal assistance only at first. There's more to these situations than armchair psychology.

Mr. Rager · 30-05-2012 12:29AM

I wouldn't even think about it tbh. I'd just sprint after the attacker, robber etc, thinking I could make a difference. Hate to see people get robbed or attacked.

Tommy Dillon · 30-05-2012 12:31AM

depends how hot she was really

Dan Chipowski · 30-05-2012 12:40AM

Vigilantes rock.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCnE0BfVNZE

Lionel Messy · 30-05-2012 12:42AM

I'd get another beer and pretend to care about what just happened.

donkey balls · 30-05-2012 01:49AM

Jaysus this happened to me about 15 yrs ago I was on my way into town on the bus when I caught two scumbags at the corner of my eye attacking a women draging her down a lane trying to get her handbag,I got the bus driver to stop the bus straight away hopped off and ran after the two scumers from memory one of them got a flying kick of me.
Anyway I called the Gardai on my then brick of a mobile when they arrived I headed of to meet the lads in the pub a few days later the girl called me to thank me for helping her out.
I'm getting on the wrong side of thirty now but would still do it without a blink but wether I could catch the scumbags would be another thing,I have some mates that would do the same and others who would probely freeze.

30-05-2012 02:01AM

Ares wrote: »

Can anyone remember the case last year, I think it was in Ennis where some lad attacked another lad in some public place stabbing him with about 50 people watching and not one did a single thing.

Pretty sad that its come to this.

Edit; Found it. http://www.rte.ie/news/2011/1212/clare.html

People in groups are retarded quite simply. Cowards following the herd mentality of someone else will intervene.

Persons are intelliegent, people are incredibly stupid.

The trouble is what do you do in a situation like that? You're only allowed to take "appropriate action" or whatever. Unless you've a chance to kick them in the head you're almost certainly getting stabbed, if you do kick them in the head some arsehole could have you in prison or paying massive compo.

Jesus Wept · 30-05-2012 02:11AM

Memory Of 98 wrote: »

So,

Today I found myself enjoying the lovely weather and eating at a restaurant. Half way through my meal I heard the screams of a woman from across the establishment. Looking over I saw her hanging over her table and a scumbag sprinting away with her purse in hand.

Now, there were many men there, men bigger than me. But, they did nothing, not even bat an eye lid, nor did the staff. For some stupid reason I took off in pursuit, charging down a busy street dodging fast moving traffic and nearly being ran down and killed.

When I got back, the victim praised me. But just about everyone else scolded me calling me a fool and an idiot for risking my life for someone that I did not even know.

I don`t know why I did it, but I did. I am looking back now fretting over how I was nearly killed/seriously wounded.

When did I become foolish in Ireland to be a vigilante, when did it become okay for men to not even bat an eye lid at women being assaulted?

What would anyone else have done?

Fair game if it was a man of course.

30-05-2012 02:18AM

Andy Carroll wrote: »

Fair game if it was a man of course.

Well duh, women don't do anything to deserve violence, men do.

donegal_road · 30-05-2012 02:32AM

I was in this position one time back in '94. Myself and another guy managed to pull three people from a burning car. The driver had fallen asleep and the car went off the road and landed upside down, 20 foot below into a stream. The people were disorientated from the shock, the driver was imobile because of a broken leg. We managed to haul him out of the car, and pulled the other two women up the embankment, but at that stage the flames had engulfed the car, and we couldn't reach the last person, a woman in her late 70's, who appeared unconscious and to this day I think she probably died from the initial impact, perished in the fire. We won an award for this, we were interviewed by Pat Kenny on RTE1, Marty Whelan on the morning show, and presented with holiday vouchers at a function in the Burlington Hotel. You have to make an on-the-spot descision in this cirrcumstance, I can't remember thinking of the danger until we were right beside the car. This thread has brought back many memories, Im off to bed

Wompa1 · 30-05-2012 02:42AM

Have tried to help out in a good few cases like that before. All but one were for no thanks

FouxDaFaFa · 30-05-2012 03:43AM

It's hard to know how you would react, really. I saw a girl on the street crying and trying to get away from this guy who was being really aggressive with her. I ran over with a friend (dressed as Cruella De Vil, not sure who was more scared).

He was surprised enough to let her go and she ran off.

The bystander effect is fascinating, the murder of Kitty Genovese was one of the saddest things I've ever heard about.

Nothingbetter2d · 30-05-2012 10:17AM

Memory Of 98 wrote: »

So,

Today I found myself enjoying the lovely weather and eating at a restaurant. Half way through my meal I heard the screams of a woman from across the establishment. Looking over I saw her hanging over her table and a scumbag sprinting away with her purse in hand.

Now, there were many men there, men bigger than me. But, they did nothing, not even bat an eye lid, nor did the staff. For some stupid reason I took off in pursuit, charging down a busy street dodging fast moving traffic and nearly being ran down and killed.

When I got back, the victim praised me. But just about everyone else scolded me calling me a fool and an idiot for risking my life for someone that I did not even know.

I don`t know why I did it, but I did. I am looking back now fretting over how I was nearly killed/seriously wounded.

When did I become foolish in Ireland to be a vigilante, when did it become okay for men to not even bat an eye lid at women being assaulted?

What would anyone else have done?

also if this old lady could foil a jewellery store robbery anything can be done

did u catch the scumbag and get back her handbag?

CL7 · 30-05-2012 10:31AM

I would jump in if someone was being assaulted, yes. Would I run down the street in pursuit of some scumbag for a purse? You've got to be fuking kidding me.

JohnMarston · 30-05-2012 10:47AM

Reminds me of this scene from the excellent show Black Books

smash · 30-05-2012 10:50AM

Memory Of 98 wrote: »

Half way through my meal I heard the screams of a woman from across the establishment. Looking over I saw her hanging over her table and a scumbag sprinting away with her purse in hand.

Was she hot?

mongdesade · 30-05-2012 11:05AM

I had a friend who intervened when he witnessed a male skanger outside Amiens Street Dart station physically attack a female he was with...
As he was restraining the male, the female reached into her pocket, produced a nail file & slashed his face requiring over 40 stitches...go figure !

Liam90 · 30-05-2012 11:05AM

Its called the fight or flight reaction and your brain decided to fight. I think thats a good thing.

RedXIV · 30-05-2012 11:15AM

I remember years and years ago, when I would have been about 14 or 15 and walking towards croke park when a scumbag ran up and stole my cousin's novelty hat. I was already running after him without thinking until my older cousin caught my arm and said it'd be a stupid thing to get into a fight for.

Since then I seem to have calmed down but I like to think I'd get involved in something that needed my help

Jester252 · 30-05-2012 11:42AM

Sure more people will come to help if its a fire then a rape

Cee-Jay-Cee · 30-05-2012 11:52AM

I'd judge it on the size of the scumbag, if i thought i could take him then yes i'd go after him but if he was much bigger than i am i probably wouldnt risk it.

I once was in freebird records at the back of the central bank and a scum bag came in and started arranging t-shirts into a neat pile, i seen what he and walked outside the door and stood partially blocking it, next thing he came running out and i tripped him. He fell in a heap at the door and the fella from behind the counter came out and jumped on him. Another scum bag came along and tried to get the shop assistant of him and i grabbed him around the neck and fúcked him on to his back as hard as i could. I seen two guards coming walking along and walked over to them and told them that i think the shop owner was in bother and simply walked away into the crowd.

Enkidu · 30-05-2012 12:00PM

LordSmeg wrote: »

Personally I think I'd risk my life as long as I was sure I wouldnt embarrass myself. Nothing worse than making a show of yourself in public. So I wouldnt be chasing anyone but may or may not jump in front of a bus to save a pretty lady.

:eek: I think risking my life would be worse than public embarrassment.

Hande hoche! · 30-05-2012 12:01PM

CJC999 wrote: »

I'd judge it on the size of the scumbag, if i thought i could take him then yes i'd go after him but if he was much bigger than i am i probably wouldnt risk it.

I once was in freebird records at the back of the central bank and a scum bag came in and started arranging t-shirts into a neat pile, i seen what he and walked outside the door and stood partially blocking it, next thing he came running out and i tripped him. He fell in a heap at the door and the fella from behind the counter came out and jumped on him. Another scum bag came along and tried to get the shop assistant of him and i grabbed him around the neck and fúcked him on to his back as hard as i could. I seen two guards coming walking along and walked over to them and told them that i think the shop owner was in bother and simply walked away into the crowd.

Fair play.

Plazaman · 30-05-2012 12:23PM

Probably wouldn't get involved (I can't run for shít would probably be the main excuse).

However I could be of service with the after incident commentry between bystanders and a victim. I can "tut" at the rate of six per second so could be very beneficial with my verbal inputs.

Combining "thats disgraceful", "fecking scumbags these days" and "thieving bastárds" with my 6 TPS, I think would be more of a help than getting stabbed for a Penneys purse whilst hyperventilating from running.

Nothingbetter2d · 30-05-2012 12:28PM

Plazaman wrote: »

I can "tut" at the rate of six per second so could be very beneficial with my verbal inputs.

soundcloud link or gtfo

Would you risk your life?

Comments