Buskers; purveyors of bohemianism or beggars with instruments?

spider guardian · 04-09-2011 08:06PM #1

Down through the years there has been some good buskers that went on to find fame. Rodrigo y Gabriel are one example. Pretty sure there was a crowd that played on Pat Kenny that were picked from the streets but later fell into obscurity. Oasis even used buskers to promote 'Dig Out Your Soul'.

I suppose there are some buskers that add to the atmosphere in a town or city on a shopping day. At night-time they can come in useful when you pinch an instrument off them and try to impress girls in the vicinity with your flawless rendition of Pink Floyd's 'Wish You Were Here'.

But should they be paid for this? Some 'buskers' clearly have came across their instruments in a public bin and only pluck or blow into these acquired instruments in the hope some do-gooder will drop some spare change into the worn cap in front of them. The racket they make and the guilt they induce puts them slightly above chuggers. Even if this isn't the case the skinny jeans and air of smugness can be off-putting.

So in short, buskers, yay or nay?

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 08:08PM

I busk. So yes.

Captain_Generic · 04-09-2011 08:09PM

Bipolar Joe wrote: »

I busk. So yes.

Boards doesn't do Paypal

WindSock · 04-09-2011 08:09PM

They aren't beggars as they are doing something other than simply asking for money.

Give them money if you appreciate the music and it has lifted your spirits.

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 08:10PM

Captain_Generic wrote: »

Boards doesn't do Paypal

OK?

.

John Doe1 · 04-09-2011 08:10PM

A public nuisance. Most do sub standard covers or sound like ****ing newton faulkner

rockmongrel · 04-09-2011 08:11PM

Very much yay. Imagine walking down Grafton St. with no buskers, no noise but the ****ty music coming from HMV and the clothes stores and the noise of all the people. Terrible thought, plus many if not most buskers you see (around Dublin at least) are really quite great.

Princess Consuela Bananahammock · 04-09-2011 08:26PM

spider guardian wrote: »

Down through the years there has been some good buskers that went on to find fame. Rodrigo y Gabriel are one example. Pretty sure there was a crowd that played on Pat Kenny that were picked from the streets but later fell into obscurity. Oasis even used buskers to promote 'Dig Out Your Soul'.

I suppose there are some buskers that add to the atmosphere in a town or city on a shopping day. At night-time they can come in useful when you pinch an instrument off them and try to impress girls in the vicinity with your flawless rendition of Pink Floyd's 'Wish You Were Here'.

But should they be paid for this? Some 'buskers' clearly have came across their instruments in a public bin and only pluck or blow into these acquired instruments in the hope some do-gooder will drop some spare change into the worn cap in front of them. The racket they make and the guilt they induce puts them slightly above chuggers. Even if this isn't the case the skinny jeans and air of smugness can be off-putting.

So in short, buskers, yay or nay?

Absolutely. What's next - just ban art if it's not in a gallery? Ban any entrepuener if they don't work in an office?

Bad buskers tend not to stay in business long when they don't get paid. Where are you getting the air of smugness from? That's a first.

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 08:31PM

Buskers provide free entertainment. If you don't like what they're doing, that's fair enough, no harm no foul. Generally, there's not much of an expectation for people to throw us a couple of pennies. Busking is nearly as much an art form as playing the damn music is.

spider guardian · 04-09-2011 08:33PM

Ikky Poo2 wrote: »

Absolutely. What's next - just ban art if it's not in a gallery? Ban any entrepuener if they don't work in an office?

Bad buskers tend not to stay in business long when they don't get paid. Where are you getting the air of smugness from? That's a first.

Calling it art is stretching it (some of the time). And as for comparing them to entrepreneurs and mentioning how the bad ones "tend not to stay in business long", are you saying that they only do it as a business venture? They should be taxed in that case.

The air of smugness comes from them thinking they are all great and arty.

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 08:34PM

Jealous of our musical talent?

spider guardian · 04-09-2011 08:35PM

Bipolar Joe wrote: »

Jealous of our musical talent?

Indeed a possibility

Princess Consuela Bananahammock · 04-09-2011 08:39PM

spider guardian wrote: »

Calling it art is stretching it (some of the time). And as for comparing them to entrepreneurs and mentioning how the bad ones "tend not to stay in business long", are you saying that they only do it as a business venture? They should be taxed in that case.

The air of smugness comes from them thinking they are all great and arty.

Why isn't it art?

And are you sure this air of smugness isn't actually in your head rather thanb theirs?

As regards the entrepuener, it is self-promotional and earns a living. Technically they should be taxed, yes, but 1) how are you going to tax them, and 2) artists are exempt from paying tax anyway. Also, how many people do you know who get paid cash in hand actually declare it to the taxman?

westendgirlie · 04-09-2011 08:43PM

The world would be a lot sadder place with no buskers around.

4leto · 04-09-2011 08:43PM

I think buskers or any street art adds a vibrancy to a city.

Beggars piss me off.

Greentopia · 04-09-2011 08:45PM

If the quality of music being played is good-yay, otherwise it's a bit of a nuisance I think.

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 08:46PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXMuWi0dUBc

Greentopia wrote: »

If the quality of music being played is good-yay, otherwise it's a bit of a nuisance I think.

How is it a nuisance? We don't follow you around showing you a photo of a kid wired up to machines. We stand in one place and play.

Redlion · 04-09-2011 08:46PM

rockmongrel wrote: »

Very much yay. Imagine walking down Grafton St. with no buskers, no noise but the ****ty music coming from HMV and the clothes stores and the noise of all the people. Terrible thought, plus many if not most buskers you see (around Dublin at least) are really quite great.

Except that one guy on Henry Street who only ever plays the same four songs over and over for hours on end. To make it worse, he does it day in day out.

DublinWriter · 04-09-2011 08:47PM

rockmongrel wrote: »

Terrible thought, plus many if not most buskers you see (around Dublin at least) are really quite great.

I have to say, most I've seen on Grafton St. have be generally crap compared the likes of the Covent Garden buskers in London.

I remember being in Boston in 1998 and being absolutely blown away by some of the young black kids doing hip-hop and breakdancing on the streets.

In Grafton St. it tends usually to be some emo kid who knows three chords and a couple of James Blunt tunes with his mates along for moral backup.

Eric Cartman · 04-09-2011 08:49PM

nothing more than pied pipers to the tourists, spanish urchins and culchies visiting our fair city of dublin. A waste of space that cause streets to be blocked, singing or playing instuments poorly and hoping for a few more euro to hide from the tax man. If they were to be put in stephens green park or other public parks I wouldnt mind, but they should definitley be banned from temple bar, grafton street, henry street and the surrounding pedestrianized streets.

laoch na mona · 04-09-2011 08:54PM

Eric Cartman wrote: »

nothing more than pied pipers to the tourists, spanish urchins and culchies visiting our fair city of dublin. A waste of space that cause streets to be blocked, singing or playing instuments poorly and hoping for a few more euro to hide from the tax man. If they were to be put in stephens green park or other public parks I wouldnt mind, but they should definitley be banned from temple bar, grafton street, henry street and the surrounding pedestrianized streets.

whats that about culchies and you have to get a licence to busk in dublin at least i dont know about other cities

spider guardian · 04-09-2011 08:56PM

Ikky Poo2 wrote: »

Why isn't it art?

And are you sure this air of smugness isn't actually in your head rather thanb theirs?

As regards the entrepuener, it is self-promotional and earns a living. Technically they should be taxed, yes, but 1) how are you going to tax them, and 2) artists are exempt from paying tax anyway. Also, how many people do you know who get paid cash in hand actually declare it to the taxman?

It's not art when it's just some beggar blowing on a rusted tin whistle. Why we should we be guilt-tripped into giving them money? Let them do an honest day's work.

The air of smugness is definitely not in my head, I met a few buskers at house parties and they all thought they were great and artistic. Clearly they thought that just picking up oul guitars or what not conferred the artist title upon them.

As for being entrepreneurial, your definition could cover any beggar

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 08:57PM

You don't think maybe the ones you've met were dicks? I'm the least smug dude I know, bordering on self-hatred. I just do what I can to make a couple of Euro.

Greentopia · 04-09-2011 08:58PM

Bipolar Joe wrote: »

How is it a nuisance? We don't follow you around showing you a photo of a kid wired up to machines. We stand in one place and play.

I said it's a nuisance if it's not played well. I was thinking of the likes of some Romanian kids who stand there with an accordian who don't even play a proper tune but just seem to randomly press buttons and this cacophany of noise comes out. Dreadful aural assault.

I have a lot of time -and respect- for people who have musical ability and can play an instrument or sing well on out streets. I often stop and listen and give some money if I find them particularly good.

dirtypanties · 04-09-2011 08:58PM

Gotta love buskers.

Even the bad ones..

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 09:00PM

Greentopia wrote: »

I said it's a nuisance if it's not played well. I was thinking of the likes of some Romanian kids who stand there with an accordian who don't even play a proper song but just seem to randomly press buttons and this cacophany of noise comes out. Dreadful aural assault.

I have a lot of time -and respect- for people who have musical ability and can play an instrument or sing well on out streets. I often stop and listen and give some money if I find them particularly good.

I practice constantly. Trust me when I say, the ones who are clearly crap don't last long. I'm not exactly a maestro, but I can make enough to buy milk and a few bits.

jluv · 04-09-2011 09:01PM

My son busks on a frequent basis and makes more money than me:mad: but as he is good business's actually pay him to busk outside their premises so that people will stop there. 4 hours work for him = 120 euro=30 euro an hour.I'm in management. Wish I could make this much

Greentopia · 04-09-2011 09:05PM

Bipolar Joe wrote: »

I practice constantly. Trust me when I say, the ones who are clearly crap don't last long. I'm not exactly a maestro, but I can make enough to buy milk and a few bits.

What instrument do you play if you don't mind me asking?
I'd love to be able to play the piano but never got around to learning

I'm thinking of getting a ukulele as I love the sound and it seems like an easy enough instrument to get into and I have someone who could show me how to play it.
Before you say it-I'm not a hipster!

westendgirlie · 04-09-2011 09:06PM

I don't get why people are saying they are a nuisance. The busker is stationery on the street, the public are walking along the street. So if you don't like em, well, you're away from the noise a few seconds later ????

And if you do like the entertainment they are providing then stop, and show your appreciation by giving em a few bob

Bipolar Joe · 04-09-2011 09:09PM

Greentopia wrote: »

What instrument do you play if you don't mind me asking?
I'd love to be able to play the piano but never got around to learning
I'm thinking of getting a ukulele as I love the sound and it seems like an easy enough instrument to get into and I have someone who could show me how to play it.
Before you say it-I'm not a hipster!

I started off playing the guitar when busking, but I get more money when I play on the ukulele. I always recommend people learn at least the basics of piano before taking up an instrument, the linearity of it makes picking up another one so much easier. I always seem to get the most money when I play "Airplanes" by B.O.B and that sort of thing. If you have tiny baby hands like I do then I recommend the ukulele, just don't get a crappy Argos one, an remember that good strings make a world of difference.

Princess Consuela Bananahammock · 04-09-2011 09:12PM

spider guardian wrote: »

It's not art when it's just some beggar blowing on a rusted tin whistle. Why we should we be guilt-tripped into giving them money? Let them do an honest day's work.

The air of smugness is definitely not in my head, I met a few buskers at house parties and they all thought they were great and artistic. Clearly they thought that just picking up oul guitars or what not conferred the artist title upon them.

As for being entrepreneurial, your definition could cover any beggar

True, no it isn't, but then the majority of buskers have some talent.

The problem here is that you seem to think that all buskers are beggars on some level. Perhaps your rant would be better aimed at beggars pretending to be buskers rather than actual buskers.

Why do you feel guilt-tripped into it? No one is putting a gun to your head. Do you feel guild tripped into paying you TV license?

I still think the air of smugness is in your head. I know plenty of buskers who just do it because they enjoy doing it. Nothing elitist about it. Perhaps you just came across one or two arrogant musicians and decided that they're all like that? Or perhaps, as someone pointed out, it's jealousy?

Buskers; purveyors of bohemianism or beggars with instruments?

Comments