Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Does Ireland have any Nuclear missiles? And how many fighter jets do we have left?

135

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,914 ✭✭✭danbohan


    darragh16 wrote: »
    Is it true that when the IRA were decominssioning they handed over a surface to air missile?


    yes but the nuclear warhead had been removed , they say its somewhere in cavan!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,497 ✭✭✭Poccington


    Ireland is a member of EUFOR, Norway is not. Plus, apart from having to perform NATO obligations, does it have any real external threat.

    We operated under a EUFOR mandate for the first year that we were in Chad, then switched to the MINURCAT mandate.

    You do realise that EUFOR is merely a mandate given to certain operations by the EU Military Staff and not any kind of military alliance in the same vein as NATO?

    EDIT: Sorry, didn't see your edited post. No, it has no visible external threat at the moment but it's also spends more than double it's percentage of GDP than we do and takes it's Defence spending seriously, something our Government doesn't do.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 13,992 ✭✭✭✭gurramok


    I think whats lost here is that Norway is truly a rich country unlike ours. It takes alot of dollars/euros to equip a state of the art army.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 9,300 ✭✭✭sdanseo


    2 proper combat aircraft, maybe SAAB Gripens or F-14 or similar, in Shannon and 2 in Casement would be an ideal addition to the IAC - we need to have a minimum defence. The PC9M can't chase a jet-powered aircraft and we should have the capability to intercept one in case of hijacking, etc no matter how unlikely the scenario.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,322 ✭✭✭Merch


    sdonn wrote: »
    2 proper combat aircraft, maybe SAAB Gripens or F-14 or similar, in Shannon and 2 in Casement would be an ideal addition to the IAC - we need to have a minimum defence. The PC9M can't chase a jet-powered aircraft and we should have the capability to intercept one in case of hijacking, etc no matter how unlikely the scenario.

    Hmm so who is going to fund this? wouldn't it be cheaper and simpler to put that funding into security at airports instead of funding useless, expensive military aircraft/toys.
    I'm glad your finger isn't on the button, if I was on a plane that was hijacked I'd take my chances with the hijackers, at least I might survive :)

    Other than that we don't need them, I'd rather the money went into hospitals and schools

    err oops F14 is obsolete


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,585 ✭✭✭✭Collie D


    Merch wrote: »
    Other than that we don't need them, I'd rather the money went into hospitals and schools

    Amen


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,073 ✭✭✭✭Terry


    Berty wrote: »
    We cannot even build an incinerator because of a bunch of old women living nearby and you think we have fighter jets and nuclear missiles.

    OMFG!
    That's the problem with this country.
    Any time someone wants to build something, you have the blue rinse brigade and the English upper class hippies out in force to protest against it.
    gurramok wrote: »
    I think whats lost here is that Norway is truly a rich country unlike ours. It takes alot of dollars/euros to equip a state of the art army.

    The money is there. It's just taken by our corrupt politicians.
    African dictators, while ammassing personal fortunes, also pump a lot of money into their militaries. Although, AK47's are relatively cheap.
    Our virtual monarchy just keep all the money for themselves.

    There is a plan to build a nuclear power station on the East coast. The idea is to take the nuclear waste in the Irish sea and use it to heat water and create steam powered generators.

    As for our own military; they do a great job as peace keeping troops around the world. We don't need a huge military. We are not an aggressive nation, unlike those to the East and West of us.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,382 ✭✭✭Motley Crue


    It has one nuclear missile. In my pants.

    Ah no, I kid


    ....I emigrated, so no, none left


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,518 ✭✭✭OS119


    What international conflicts are we not neutral to (apart from northern Ireland).

    Afghanistan - Ireland voted for the UNSC resolutions, vocally supported the US's rights to undertake military action in response to attacks on its soil, and contributes troops (7) to ISAF.

    Kosovo - Ireland voted for the UNSC resolutions under-pinning KFOR and the authority of the UN to run Kosovo in defiance of Serbian/Yugoslav claims to Kosovo as it territory. Ireland contrubuted Troops to KFOR, one of who's purposes to to repel any Serb/Yugoslav invasion of that territory.

    East Timor - Ireland voted for, and sent forces to, the UN mandated force that secured the independence of East Timor from Indonesia.

    Bosnia - Ireland voted for, and sent troops to, UNPROFOR, the UN force that on a number of occasions decisively fought Croatian and Serb/Yugoslav forces in Bosnia. whether you paid attention or not, Ireland helped Bosnia fight Republika Serbska and Yugoslavia.

    Bosnia - Ireland voted for, and sent troops to, IFOR. Ireland participated in a force that ended Serb/Yugoslav aspirations of Serbian dominance of Bosnia.

    Neutral means not taking sides - are you suggesting that despite intervening on somebodies side, and very much against somebody else's side, in each of these conflicts, Ireland is neutral?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,369 ✭✭✭✭ejmaztec


    Ireland doesn't need nuclear weapons or jet-fighters, not when the UK is always on hand to patrol Irish air-space should the need arise.

    Politicians here like to maintain the status-quo, because it gives them more money to piss away into oblivion.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 355 ✭✭GizAGoOfYerGee


    OP, here is a proper answer:
    RobitTV wrote: »
    Does ireland have any nuclear missiles??

    In the 1970s, the Irish government wanted to build a nuclear power plant.

    This never happened due to serious political controversy involving each of the major Irish political parties and a wide range of pressure groups.

    Ireland remains nuclear-free to this day.
    RobitTV wrote: »
    how many fighter jets do we have ive heard we have 3 but two are broking i think?

    Ireland has no fighter jets.

    We have six AW139 transport helicopters that can be armed with General Purpose Machine Guns (GPMG).

    We also have seven PC-9M planes that can be armed.

    We only have two Heavy Machine Guns (HMG) with 250 round belts each, and two Rocket Pods with Fin Aerial Rockets .

    Not much, but enough for a small, neutral country that wouldn´t stand a chance against any invasion.

    http://www.military.ie/aircorps/fleet/fleet.htm


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,659 ✭✭✭Chaotic_Forces


    ejmaztec wrote: »
    Ireland doesn't need nuclear weapons or jet-fighters, not when the UK is always on hand to patrol Irish air-space should the need arise.

    Politicians here like to maintain the status-quo, because it gives them more money to piss away into oblivion.

    Actually that is a point. What are the odds the UK would defend us?

    For the sake of argument we're going with NI is still and will be (in a war) part of the UK.
    What happens if we get bombed and a piece of shrapnel lands over the border to NI? Are the UK going to go nuts or just say "fu*k it lads"?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,293 ✭✭✭✭Mint Sauce


    danbohan wrote: »
    yes but the nuclear warhead had been removed , they say its somewhere in cavan!

    or even leitrim, the inspectors will never find 'em
    ejmaztec wrote: »
    Ireland doesn't need nuclear weapons or jet-fighters, not when the UK is always on hand to patrol Irish air-space should the need arise.

    Politicians here like to maintain the status-quo, because it gives them more money to piss away into oblivion.

    dont forget the army base in shannon

    ;)


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 34,567 ✭✭✭✭Biggins


    darragh16 wrote: »
    Is it true that when the IRA were decommissioning they handed over a surface to air missile?
    According to a number of reports I've seen, yes.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,659 ✭✭✭Chaotic_Forces


    Biggins wrote: »
    According to a number of reports I've seen, yes.

    A? As in one? As far as I knew there were at least 5.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,322 ✭✭✭Merch


    Actually that is a point. What are the odds the UK would defend us?

    For the sake of argument we're going with NI is still and will be (in a war) part of the UK.
    What happens if we get bombed and a piece of shrapnel lands over the border to NI? Are the UK going to go nuts or just say "fu*k it lads"?

    Defend us against who? who is bombing us and for what?

    Bombing a country's military to soften them up before invasion suggests they have hardware to be bombed. Probably after they declined to hand over their resources too,
    I suggest we dont spend the money :) nothing to bomb
    Anyway our politicians would have signed our oil/gas away long before that happens :rolleyes:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,659 ✭✭✭Chaotic_Forces


    Merch wrote: »
    Defend us against who? who is bombing us and for what?

    Bombing a country's military to soften them up before invasion suggests they have hardware to be bombed. Probably after they declined to hand over their resources too,
    I suggest we dont spend the money :) nothing to bomb
    Anyway our politicians would have signed our oil/gas away long before that happens :rolleyes:

    I just mean in general. Would the UK kind of say "we own NI"... keep the fu*k away from the land?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,653 ✭✭✭Ghandee


    RobitTV wrote: »
    just wondering Does ireland have any nuclear missiles?? and how many fighter jets do we have ive heard we have 3 but two are broking i think?

    I dare say big Biffo, lets off the odd chemical weapon a few Sunday mornings a year, thats it mate!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,444 ✭✭✭Absurdum


    This is the cutting edge technology of the Irish air 'force'.



    unfortunately the guns are currently U/S due to corrosion issues...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,322 ✭✭✭Merch


    Absurdum wrote: »
    unfortunately the guns are currently U/S due to corrosion issues...

    both of them? :D


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,444 ✭✭✭Absurdum


    Merch wrote: »
    both of them? :D

    yeah


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 88,968 ✭✭✭✭mike65




  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,322 ✭✭✭Merch


    mike65 wrote: »


    That current line up for the Air corps is almost entirely civilian aircraft, or aircraft that are not specifically designed with military use in mind, Excluding the PC-9 as an advanced trainer and even the CASA might come close as a transport/surveilance/patrol.
    Other than that most of them are utility/transport
    No armour, weapons in mind
    oh and no nukes either :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,370 ✭✭✭✭Son Of A Vidic


    stooodent wrote: »
    what would wille o dea do with ICBMs...

    He'd probably point them at ya, or the nearest camera.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,322 ✭✭✭Merch


    He'd probably point them at ya, or the nearest camera.

    and have his finger on the trigger :eek:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,370 ✭✭✭✭Son Of A Vidic


    All slagging aside, the Irish Army Ranger Wing are an excellent unit, respected around the world. They frequently train with US Delta Force, New Zealand & Australian SAS, French, German and Swedish special forces units. Someone poster mentioned they are 400 -500 strong, well I'm afraid not. I'm not too sure about unit size but I'd imagine between 120 -200 strong. Here's an interesting read below from the 2003 Indo archives.

    Army Rangers among best elite forces
    The Irish Independent
    23-Aug-2003
    Michael Lavery

    *******************************
    ARMY Rangers out-shot, out-ran and out-maneuvered dozens of special forces teams from around the world in a gruelling contest.

    The elite Irish soldiers picked up a bronze medal in the Combat Team Conference this week which tests the skills of special police and military units. Forty-one teams from 22 countries had battled it out.

    Austria's COBRA police team came first, with Italy's NOCS police second and the Army Ranger Wing (ARW) third. The Irish came in ahead of such highly skilled units as the Royal Dutch Marines, the Special Task Force from South Africa, Germany's GSG9, Sweden's Special Police Unit and GOE from Portugal.

    The competition, held every four years, was organised by Germany's GSG9 at their base near Bonn.

    Rangers had to deal with hostage situations, evade attack dogs, swim long distances in the Rhine and hit targets with their H&K MP5 sub-machine guns and 9mm SiG pistols.

    The first event involved a 2.5km run down a steep incline. "At the end of the run, the runner picked up his team of four who were roped together and they made their way back up the hill," said the Ranger team manager. "The team were stopped during the first 1km to identify five 'tangos' (hostage takers) from mug sheets that had been shown previously." Getting it wrong meant having to carry a 20kg sandbag for the rest of the run.

    "The events tested the skills that a specialist unit would need in an actual intervention, including shooting, climbing, driving, swimming, leadership and making decisions under pressure," he said.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,374 ✭✭✭Gone West


    Jaafa wrote: »
    A lot of people seem to underestimate the army. At least our special forces are one of the best in the world. Our snipers are third in the world after the US and Canada.
    How many of the Irish army snipers actually went out to conflict zones and killed people? Or are you talking about some target shooting competition?

    Likewise the Irish special forcs are one of the best in the world ....
    Are you kidding? They go out to slightly dangerous "peacekeeping" missions, which is great. Fair play, we´re up on a world stage and doing good work. They have no or little experience of actual special combat operations. Lets see them land at night from helos by the fast ropes onto ships, or kill hostage takers with their long guns from helicopters a mile away. The Americans, British, Aussies, Israelis, Russians, French all have noted special forces. The Irish (quite rightly as we are a neutral country) do not have one of the best spec ops forces in the world. They have fairly little serious real combat experience.

    Just because the newspapers will praise the Irish spec forces to no end, doesn´t actually mean that they are one of the best in the world.

    And if you think the americans or brits or germans are sending their best most experienced people to "special ops competitions" and quoting newspaper articles re:same, you are deluded.

    These guys kill people quietly, usually without recognition for a living.
    They are not going to pander to the cameras on sports day to try to beat the Irish in the egg and spoon race.
    That newspaper article is from Aug 2003, don´t you think the best guys were already deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan at that stage and were too busy to play games?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,968 ✭✭✭✭Praetorian Saighdiuir


    Fuzzy wrote: »
    How many of the Irish army snipers actually went out to conflict zones and killed people? Or are you talking about some target shooting competition?

    Likewise the Irish special forcs are one of the best in the world ....
    Are you kidding? They go out to slightly dangerous "peacekeeping" missions, which is great. Fair play, we´re up on a world stage and doing good work. They have no or little experience of actual special combat operations. Lets see them land at night from helos by the fast ropes onto ships, or kill hostage takers with their long guns from helicopters a mile away. The Americans, British, Aussies, Israelis, Russians, French all have noted special forces. The Irish (quite rightly as we are a neutral country) do not have one of the best spec ops forces in the world. They have fairly little serious real combat experience.

    Just because the newspapers will praise the Irish spec forces to no end, doesn´t actually mean that they are one of the best in the world.

    And if you think the americans or brits or germans are sending their best most experienced people to "special ops competitions" and quoting newspaper articles re:same, you are deluded.

    These guys kill people quietly, usually without recognition for a living.
    They are not going to pander to the cameras on sports day to try to beat the Irish in the egg and spoon race.
    That newspaper article is from Aug 2003, don´t you think the best guys were already deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan at that stage and were too busy to play games?




    Mods, this is going to be off topic and I apologise but I am sick to death of internet warriors with opinions on things they dont have first hand experience of.

    "How many of the Irish army snipers actually went out to conflict zones and killed people? Or are you talking about some target shooting competition?"

    Our DF snipers are very well trained. They are deployed to every troop mission undertaken by the DF. They have been called on many many times while serving overseas. The fact that they did not need to pull the trigger and take someones face off does not mean they are not good. They have competed against other snipers from around the world and held their own. In fact a few years ago, a sniper from the ARW came 1st in an international sniping competition.

    "Likewise the Irish special forcs are one of the best in the world ....
    Are you kidding?"

    The ARW are very very well trained. They are respected by other international militaries including other SF units. They are unassuming and do not advertise their work. That is all operational knowledge you need to know about the ARW.

    They go out to slightly dangerous "peacekeeping" missions, which is great. Fair play, we´re up on a world stage and doing good work.

    Have you been on a peacekeeping/peace enforcement mission?
    Do you know why we volunteer to deploy to these "slightly dangerous missions"?
    Do you actually know anything about the DF or the ARW?

    "Lets see them land at night from helos by the fast ropes onto ships, or kill hostage takers with their long guns from helicopters a mile away"

    This below is what the ARW are trained to do. Please read the list and try to comprehend what each task entails. Can you do any of them?......respect the people that can!

    Offensive Operations behind enemy lines :
    Securing of vital objectives
    Long Range Patrolling - Raids - Ambushes - Sabotage
    Capture of key personnel
    Diversionary Operations
    Intelligence Gathering

    Defensive Operations
    VIP Protection
    Counter insurgency
    Training in and conduct of specialist operations
    Delay Operations

    Aid to the Civil Power (Anti-Terrorist Tasks)
    Anti-Hijack Operations - aircraft, ferry, ship, bus, train.
    Hostage Rescue Operations.
    Airborne and Seaborne Interventions.
    Search Operations - Difficult or dangerous specialist tasks on land or at sea.
    Pursuit Operations over any terrain.
    Recapture of terrorist-held objectives - Vital Installations, Embassies, Airports, Gas & Oil Rigs, Summit venues, Broadcasting and Government facilities.
    VIP Security Operations/Close Protection of VIPs.
    Contingency Planning to Counter Terrorist/Subversive Threat

    Among others:
    Physical Training.
    Advanced Shooting and Marksmanship.
    Long Range Patrolling - Survival Training and Rough terrain navigation.
    Hostage Rescue Tactics - House, Aircraft, Bus, Train and Ship assaults. Parachuting
    Boat Handling
    Combat Diving
    Advanced Navigation
    Sniping
    Explosives Intervention
    Communications
    Medical

    "just because the newspapers will praise the Irish spec forces to no end, doesn´t actually mean that they are one of the best in the world."

    Just because you dont know what they do or have done does not mean they are not one of the best in the world. However, they are one of the best TRAINED in the world.

    We have a minimal defence budget which limits our size, equipment and training, nevertheless we are very well trained and well equipt. Our DF is sufficient for our current needs. Our tasks at home are varied but we are mainly known for our ATCP roles but we excel on overseas deployments.

    Despite our size and our "combat experience", the UN continuously requests Irish peacekeepers to deploy to conflict zones. We have 50 years experience serving on peacekeeping/peace enforcement missions around the world, given that we are a small country thats less than 100 years old, this is a great feat.

    We have served and unfortunately some have died in these "slightly dangerous missions". El Salvador, Haiti, Honduras, Kosovo, Georgia, Bosnia, Cyprus, Yugoslavia, Western Sahara, Chad, Ivory Coast, Sudan, Congo, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Rwanda, Somalia, Angola, Namibia, South Africa, Liberia, Lebanon, Syria, Georgia, Israel, Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, New Guinea, India, Pakistan, East Timor and Sri Lanka. We are not sent to these places for a suntan or a holiday. These are/were very hostile places where people were being murdered. There was genocide and ethnic cleansing happening.

    I personally have served in Lebanon, Liberia and Chad. Id like to think that my presence in these countries was worthwhile and maybe helped stabilise them and provide a better future for their people. I have never killed anyone, even though I am well trained and capable of doing so. There have been situations where force was needed but diplomacy and a cool head wins out in the long run. I know for a fact the my presence has stopped men, women and children being kidnapped, raped, mutilated and murdered.

    Some say we are not needed. Some say we are a waste of money and a burden on the taxpayer. I hope to God we are never needed in our own country, but if we are, Il be there, along with the rest of our well trained DF by my side.

    I will continue to serve my country with pride no matter what BS is said about us. I will continue to be well trained and I will continue to serve overseas in "slightly dangerous places".

    We have no nuclear weapons at all. We dont have the money and we dont need them. We dont have any fighter jets, we dont have the money plus our air space and land mass doesnt warrant it.


    Sorry for the rant:P


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,497 ✭✭✭Poccington


    Fuzzy wrote: »

    Likewise the Irish special forcs are one of the best in the world ....
    Are you kidding? They go out to slightly dangerous "peacekeeping" missions, which is great. Fair play, we´re up on a world stage and doing good work. They have no or little experience of actual special combat operations. Lets see them land at night from helos by the fast ropes onto ships, or kill hostage takers with their long guns from helicopters a mile away. The Americans, British, Aussies, Israelis, Russians, French all have noted special forces. The Irish (quite rightly as we are a neutral country) do not have one of the best spec ops forces in the world. They have fairly little serious real combat experience.

    Of the countries you just listed as having the best SOF in the world, the ARW have worked with more than half of those countries SOF Units either on Ops or training.

    So, if the ARW are obviously good enough to work and train with the best SOF personnel in the world... They're surely doing something right?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,369 ✭✭✭✭ejmaztec


    I've only ever heard of the ARW training in Hereford (which probably pisses off a few Boardsies) and Fort Bragg (which might piss off less than a few), so the unit can't possibly be regarded as a bunch of Boy-Scout amateurs.


Advertisement
Advertisement