2006 diesel - A3, 1-series, or Civic?

JHMEG · 30-07-2009 04:33PM #1

Motor tax is NOT an issue as the car will be in NI.

The contenders are:
A3 1.9 TDI
BMW 120d
Civic 2.2 iCTDi

What and why?

Magown3 · 30-07-2009 04:56PM

Civic is an awesome car. Get the Type S model, it looks the ****!

.Longshanks. · 30-07-2009 04:59PM

The A3 is an overpriced golf with a tractor engine. IMO you need bad eye sight to appreciate the bmw's looks (and although not an issue for me) the leg room in rear is a bit of a joke.

None of the above applies to the civic. I'd say its the cheapest too

Bluefoam · 30-07-2009 05:38PM

Alfa 147 1.9jtd preferably the 170bhp ducati special. The civic looks ****e, the a3 is an overpriced seat, the BMW will be poverty spec and have no go...

JHMEG · 30-07-2009 05:44PM

The options are the three above only.

Sqaull20 · 30-07-2009 05:50PM

Out of those the Civic, but you should really look around.

My choice for a diesel hatch with go would be the Leon Cupra.

http://atsearch.autotrader.co.uk/ni/cars_popup.jsp?searchform=&modelexact=1&lid=search_used_cars_full&photo=1&state=block&sort=3&hassearched=Y&make=SEAT&min_pr=75&source=0&model=LEON&max_pr=&miles=1500&agerange=5&mileage=&postcode=m52ty&variant=cupra&bodyid=0&trim=&fuelid=2&colour=&transmissionid=0&keywords=&ukcarsearch_full.x=0&ukcarsearch_full.y=0&start=1&distance=3&adcategory=CARS&channel=CARS&id=200930338356886

Eoin · 30-07-2009 06:21PM

Civic for me. No real technical reasons, just think it's a cracking car. Neither the Audi or the BMW do much for me.

EPM · 30-07-2009 08:01PM

While i actually dont mind the VAG 1.9 as much bs a lot of people do its not a patch on the other two engines here. I test drove a civic diesel not too long ago and the engine is excellent. Really loved a lot about that car but i couldn't live with the noisy suspension or the road noise. It felt like there was no sound insulation in it. Radio would fix it but it suprised me that they missed something relatively simple. Based on that i'd go for the 120d which has at least as good an engine, is nicer to drive but i bit small in the back due to its rear drive layout

Stephen · 30-07-2009 09:14PM

the Civic. I've had a petrol one for 2 years now. They're generally very well specced (except for the 1.4s). Like EPM said, they're noisy at speed but you have the benefit of massive rear legroom (I'm 6ft 1in and I can set behind the drivers' seat when its in my usual position without putting my knees in my face) and rear seats that fold totally flat. Well they do in the 5 door ones anyway, not sure about the Type-S.

I'd go and buy a spare wheel for it if it doesn't have one, as they weren't standard and the electric compressor + bottle of gunk solution sucks.

maidhc · 30-07-2009 09:20PM

JHMEG wrote: »

.

The contenders are:
TDI
d
iCTDi

Are you feeling OK? Need a lie down or anything??

Civic all the way I reckon. Nicest looking and most technically superior, and probably the most reliable by a long ways.

Johnny Utah · 30-07-2009 11:51PM

I'd go for the BMW tbf.

JHMEG · 31-07-2009 12:09AM

maidhc wrote: »

Are you feeling OK? Need a lie down or anything??

LOL! Not for me I'm afraid.

cashmni1 · 31-07-2009 12:18AM

I don't like the Civic, I think it looks awful.
I quite like the 1 series BMW. 120D would be quick and a smart handler.
The A3....sorry, old hat.
My2c

Biro · 31-07-2009 11:22AM

120d would be the best handler no question, but it looks so terrible and is poor value in every other respect that I'd have to rule it out. So Civic for me. The interior is the best part! And get one in black.

Bluefoam · 31-07-2009 11:33AM

None of the above

Number Nine · 31-07-2009 12:28PM

A3 TDI 90 bhp will get you 55/60 mpg , good resale value , cheap to service and is a good all round car .

sk8board · 31-07-2009 01:08PM

Number Nine wrote: »

A3 TDI 90 bhp will get you 55/60 mpg , good resale value , cheap to service and is a good all round car .

well yes and no. Its like asking which shade of beige do you want to paint your kitchen.

I can't imagine anything I'd rather less than the spec you mention above.

mpg: you're right
good all round car: yep, sure

as for the good resale, its only a myth; the sellers have completely over-inflated idea of what their A3 is worth, moreso than any other car on the planet.

I'm in the market for a car, and while I would consider an A3, it would only be the 2.0, purely so that I can get it sold on the other end. It defies belief why someone would overpay for an A3 with a 1.9 90hp, before they veer off and just pay the same price for an A4, with better resale potential

to sum up: the A3 will cost you too much for the engine you don't want, and won't have any resale value. Either of the other 2 are streets ahead, and will always find a buyer (in the 1series case, its only the 120d that will have resale value).

the civic with that engine will be easy buy & sell, with a big spec, and an inside to put a smile on your face.

JHMEG · 31-07-2009 02:00PM

sk8board wrote: »

the civic with that engine will be easy buy & sell, with a big spec, and an inside to put a smile on your face.

I would also be thinking that the Civic puts out 140bhp, which is over 50% more than the A3.

That's gonna be hugely more resposive and easier to drive, whilst still returning 55mpg combined (official).

.Longshanks. · 31-07-2009 02:29PM

Number Nine wrote: »

A3 TDI 90 bhp will get you 55/60 mpg , good resale value , cheap to service and is a good all round car .

Almost positive the base 1.9 TDI A3 comes with 105 bhp as standard. But will stand corrected.....

Saab Ed · 31-07-2009 02:32PM

Longshanks100 wrote: »

Almost positive the base 1.9 TDI A3 comes with 105 bhp as standard. But will stand corrected.....

Do you know I think that just doesnt cut it anymore in a car of that so called calibre. 120 - 130 must surely be the entry level at this stage. Even boggo vans nearly have this amount of power these days.

Biro · 31-07-2009 02:41PM

Longshanks100 wrote: »

Almost positive the base 1.9 TDI A3 comes with 105 bhp as standard. But will stand corrected.....

The newer shape probably has the 1.9 with 100 and 130 options. The 105 in the newer 1.9 wasn't in too many cars, only around recently enough. I'd say brand new the options are 2 litre only, in 110, 140 and 170. The old one up to 01 at least would have been 90 and 110. Probably 100 and 130 from 02 on. Either way it's not great!

HashSlinging · 31-07-2009 02:53PM

No contest Civic 2.2 iCTDi, as car is in NI tax is not an issue..

Number Nine · 31-07-2009 04:32PM

sk8board wrote: »

well yes and no. Its like asking which shade of beige do you want to paint your kitchen.

I can't imagine anything I'd rather less than the spec you mention above.

mpg: you're right
good all round car: yep, sure

as for the good resale, its only a myth; the sellers have completely over-inflated idea of what their A3 is worth, moreso than any other car on the planet.

I'm in the market for a car, and while I would consider an A3, it would only be the 2.0, purely so that I can get it sold on the other end. It defies belief why someone would overpay for an A3 with a 1.9 90hp, before they veer off and just pay the same price for an A4, with better resale potential

to sum up: the A3 will cost you too much for the engine you don't want, and won't have any resale value. Either of the other 2 are streets ahead, and will always find a buyer (in the 1series case, its only the 120d that will have resale value).

the civic with that engine will be easy buy & sell, with a big spec, and an inside to put a smile on your face.

I had a Audi A3tdi for three years and from my experience , I can only tell you that I had no complaints and I covered 80000 miles.
The only experience I have of the civic is a test drive . I found only one big problem and that was the drivers seat dose not go far enough back . As for the BMW , overrated , overpriced and their dealership's are to expensive for regular servicing.

Stephen · 31-07-2009 04:48PM

You must be a giant or something, I have loads of room in my Civic?

larrytom · 31-07-2009 04:50PM

a3 by a mile

.Longshanks. · 31-07-2009 04:51PM

larrytom wrote: »

a3 by a mile

But the OP also wants to know why

Number Nine · 31-07-2009 04:57PM

Stephen wrote: »

You must be a giant or something, I have loads of room in my Civic?

I am no giant (6ft)
I just like the drivers seat back full .
The result is that some driver seats just do not go back far enough .

Eoin · 31-07-2009 05:09PM

Longshanks100 wrote: »

But the OP also wants to know why

I'd be interested as well!

fifth · 31-07-2009 05:11PM

Civic Civic Civic

All around, hands down. I've an Accord but know people with the Civic who are very happy with it.

R.O.R · 31-07-2009 05:22PM

The 1 Series is growing on me. 177bhp with RWD in a car that size would be pretty nice. I've driven a 118d which was very good, and from the drivers seat exactly like a 3 series. The rear leg room is a joke though, even behind me and I sit fairly close to the pedals (for "feel" like, I'm not short or anything).

I drove a Petrol Civic last year. Handled well, but I'm not a huge fan of the 2.2d engine in the Honda, just never seems as quick as it should be.

The A3 1.9Tdi is not even playing the same sport, yet alone in the same ballpark as the other 2. If it were a 2.0Tdi 170 Quattro then I'd consider it, 1.9Tdi - hell no.

groupb · 01-08-2009 11:45AM

I'd go for the BMW or Honda. Both are modern cars. The sister had a 06' A3 but she saw sense after a while and now drives a fiesta.

2006 diesel - A3, 1-series, or Civic?

Which 2006 diesel? 24 votes

Comments