Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

PLEASE HELP, HEALER NEEDED

  • 13-02-2009 04:02PM
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 65 ✭✭


    Hey there,
    im a guy in my mid twenties and i suffer a bit with my lower back. i think its to do with my siatic nerve, sharp pain when bending awkardly, tends to be just the one side but lately its either side, sudden movement/reflexes cause pain aswell, its not a constant pain but i'm always conscious of it because its easily agrovated. My back just isn't right and i'm worried it's getting worse. I'm not over weight or anything, took a fall from a horse when i was 12 and it kind of started from there, not helped either by years of pullin' and draggin' on the farm i guess.

    I'm sure many of you heard about john liston morgan, the healer who was on the Ray D'arcy show last week. I eventually got through on the phone to be told that because of his appearence on the show, next available appointment is in October.
    Anyway, i am absolutely loathed at the idea of spinal operations, and i believe going to a GP about it is a waste of 50euro, so i'd like to try the healer option. It may be bollox, it may not, but its definately worth a go, so if anyone knows of other 'healers' around the country i d love to know.
    Thanks for reading.


«13

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,151 ✭✭✭Thomas_S_Hunterson


    Don't be silly. Stay away from the healer. You'd be better off burning the money.

    Go to your doctor.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,474 ✭✭✭jim o doom


    Try a physiotherapist, a chiropractor or even an acupuncturist (good ones do help) - but seriously, stay away from healers..


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    Christian or otherwise?
    ruxpin82 wrote: »
    Hey there,
    im a guy in my mid twenties and i suffer a bit with my lower back. i think its to do with my siatic nerve, sharp pain when bending awkardly, tends to be just the one side but lately its either side, sudden movement/reflexes cause pain aswell, its not a constant pain but i'm always conscious of it because its easily agrovated. My back just isn't right and i'm worried it's getting worse. I'm not over weight or anything, took a fall from a horse when i was 12 and it kind of started from there, not helped either by years of pullin' and draggin' on the farm i guess.

    I'm sure many of you heard about john liston morgan, the healer who was on the Ray D'arcy show last week. I eventually got through on the phone to be told that because of his appearence on the show, next available appointment is in October.
    Anyway, i am absolutely loathed at the idea of spinal operations, and i believe going to a GP about it is a waste of 50euro, so i'd like to try the healer option. It may be bollox, it may not, but its definately worth a go, so if anyone knows of other 'healers' around the country i d love to know.
    Thanks for reading.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,149 ✭✭✭ZorbaTehZ


    ruxpin82 wrote: »
    It may be bollox, it may not, but its definately worth a go, so if anyone knows of other 'healers' around the country i d love to know.

    You're worried about spending money on a GP, but not at all bothered about paying to see a healer?!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 65 ✭✭ruxpin82


    christian raised, not that that has anything to do with it, (if there was a god there would probably be no religion).
    Im not a religious person, im just looking to be fixed.

    i think that GP's wouldn't be able to help and would only refer me to other people and a long drawn out process involving x-rays, specialist,more referals, months of waiting and money would result. the way the health service is run does'nt inspire me with confidence.
    I know im looking for an easy fix, but if half a day given over to see one of these guys got a result, wouldn't it be worth it??

    i accept that chiropracter/physio is one route which i should explore and probably will, but they're not cheap either, i just want to give myself some options.

    thanks for your replys.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    I meant the healer, not you....

    :)

    And you need faith whatever you choose, be it drs or healers.

    Faith in whoever you turn to.

    Blessings this night..


    ruxpin82 wrote: »
    christian raised, not that that has anything to do with it, (if there was a god there would probably be no religion).
    Im not a religious person, im just looking to be fixed.

    i think that GP's wouldn't be able to help and would only refer me to other people and a long drawn out process involving x-rays, specialist,more referals, months of waiting and money would result. the way the health service is run does'nt inspire me with confidence.
    I know im looking for an easy fix, but if half a day given over to see one of these guys got a result, wouldn't it be worth it??

    i accept that chiropracter/physio is one route which i should explore and probably will, but they're not cheap either, i just want to give myself some options.

    thanks for your replys.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,226 ✭✭✭taram


    ruxpin82 wrote: »
    christian raised, not that that has anything to do with it, (if there was a god there would probably be no religion).
    Im not a religious person, im just looking to be fixed.

    i think that GP's wouldn't be able to help and would only refer me to other people and a long drawn out process involving x-rays, specialist,more referals, months of waiting and money would result. the way the health service is run does'nt inspire me with confidence.
    I know im looking for an easy fix, but if half a day given over to see one of these guys got a result, wouldn't it be worth it??

    i accept that chiropracter/physio is one route which i should explore and probably will, but they're not cheap either, i just want to give myself some options.

    thanks for your replys.

    The HSE can be useless, but the people in it are excellent. Your GP is there to assess your pain, then offer a solution, it's unlikely you'd be waiting for a physio/chiro appointment more than a week. It might be something ridicously easy to sort out, more than likely some physio appointments and medical gel rather than spinal operations :) If you have health insurance you could probably go to a private physio (my dad got next day appointment) and have it mostly paid for by it.

    I admit I am hugely skeptical of healers, so that colours my comments, but I wouldn't risk my health in the hands of someone with no medical experience, you say a GP visit is a waste, but they have the knowledge of what could be wrong, the links to the medical community to cure you (if not something straight forward), and the ability if you have something seriously wrong that they can get you treated, saving you pain in the future. Seriously, what can a healer offer you?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    Healing, simply.

    What a healer can offer you, I mean.

    But attitude is everything.

    And most healers will advise a dr; they are not irresponsible. As you say of course.

    But healing is well documented.
    taram wrote: »
    The HSE can be useless, but the people in it are excellent. Your GP is there to assess your pain, then offer a solution, it's unlikely you'd be waiting for a physio/chiro appointment more than a week. It might be something ridicously easy to sort out, more than likely some physio appointments and medical gel rather than spinal operations :) If you have health insurance you could probably go to a private physio (my dad got next day appointment) and have it mostly paid for by it.

    I admit I am hugely skeptical of healers, so that colours my comments, but I wouldn't risk my health in the hands of someone with no medical experience, you say a GP visit is a waste, but they have the knowledge of what could be wrong, the links to the medical community to cure you (if not something straight forward), and the ability if you have something seriously wrong that they can get you treated, saving you pain in the future. Seriously, what can a healer offer you?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,103 ✭✭✭North_West_Art


    ruxpin82 wrote: »
    Hey there,
    im a guy in my mid twenties and i suffer a bit with my lower back. i think its to do with my siatic nerve, sharp pain when bending awkardly, tends to be just the one side but lately its either side, sudden movement/reflexes cause pain aswell, its not a constant pain but i'm always conscious of it because its easily agrovated. My back just isn't right and i'm worried it's getting worse. I'm not over weight or anything, took a fall from a horse when i was 12 and it kind of started from there, not helped either by years of pullin' and draggin' on the farm i guess.

    I'm sure many of you heard about john liston morgan, the healer who was on the Ray D'arcy show last week. I eventually got through on the phone to be told that because of his appearence on the show, next available appointment is in October.
    Anyway, i am absolutely loathed at the idea of spinal operations, and i believe going to a GP about it is a waste of 50euro, so i'd like to try the healer option. It may be bollox, it may not, but its definately worth a go, so if anyone knows of other 'healers' around the country i d love to know.
    Thanks for reading.

    You need an X-Ray... get one immediatley, then take it from there. I can give you a few numbers of top back people, but get an X-Ray first asap


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 969 ✭✭✭murrayp4


    G.P....Then physio probably...forget 'healers'. At you're age its very unlikely you'd need an op. Physio is usually €50 per. session


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,149 ✭✭✭ZorbaTehZ


    sorella wrote: »
    And you need faith whatever you choose, be it drs or healers.

    'fraid you're wrong there, doctors have this thing known as 'science' to back them up, no faith required!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 825 ✭✭✭MatthewVII


    sorella wrote: »

    But healing is well documented.

    Links/evidence? Or is the evidence anecdotal only?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    You have google.

    Abundant evidence.

    Blessings and bye!!!

    Over and out......
    MatthewVII wrote: »
    Links/evidence? Or is the evidence anecdotal only?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 219 ✭✭lisaloo


    My family are a bit sceptical about healers but when my mother was sick over 2 years ago we were told there was no chance. We heard about a healer in Monasterevin, Co Kildare. His name is Chris Talbot and i cant say enough good things about him. My mother is well today and i am positive he helped. if you are interested in meeting him send me a pm and i will give you his number. He doesnt take money!!!

    At the end of our time with him, he had probably spent 6 hrs with my mother.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 59 ✭✭jtbub15


    i think healers can be fantastic! I've been a couple of times myself to one guy in particular and found it absolutely amazing! Probably the "placebo effect" but what ever works to ease the pain! I also went with problems with my back (after a car crash) and he really helped ease it. Not gone completely but I dont think it ever will but it definately helped, and without the need to be off my head on very strong painkillers!

    Anywoo... what location are you in? I know of a few.:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,461 ✭✭✭DrIndy


    You should always go to a doctor first.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 67 ✭✭dorothygale


    I used to have horrible back pain, I couldn't walk some days. I went to a healer and he solved it. This was after years of goign to doctors and chiropractors who would heal me but hten It would come back every few months. I have never had that problem again, he didn't even charge me. I wish I could remember his name or where he lived exactly. I was driving with my boss on the road to Dublin from Mayo (don't work for him anymore), but I believe it was in another county... I remember he was on an oxygen tank... My boss told me he was the real deal and that he cured a lady with cancer a few years ago.

    I am an athiest, but he prayed over my back and did the sign of the cross. When I left, it stil hurt but 30 minutes later no pain and it hasn't come back.

    I dunno about healers, all i know is my back hasn't hurt since.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 67 ✭✭dorothygale


    Come to think of it, it was Co. Westmeath, maybe?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 825 ✭✭✭MatthewVII


    DrIndy wrote: »
    You should always go to a doctor first.

    Agreed, you should always make sure there's no medical reason behind things (e.g. someone I knew had back pain for ages, tried homeopathy, acupuncture etc, he then went to his doctor and it turned out he had an abdominal aortic aneurysm)

    Make sure you're looked after from a medical perspective. After that, if you think the medical profession can't help I guess you can go off in whatever direction you want. Without proper evidence for the efficacy of alternative therapy I can't really see anything in it though, medicine is the only route proven to work.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    This beautiful; thank you.

    Have had this happen to someone who was simply in the same room.
    She was going to see a chiropractor after the meeting, but instead went and dug turf on the bog for several hours.

    And many healers are "wounded healers": it does not work for us. Only through us.

    There was a lady called Jennifer Rees Larcombe; her book is called "Unexpected Healing": she had incurable dystonia and was in a wheelchair and on massive meds. Healed instantly at a prayer meeting. There was a physio there who just could hardly believe that full muscle weight and tone had returned instantly. But she saw and felt it. Jennifer picked her wheelchair up even.

    Healings at e.g Medjugorge are frequent and thoroughly authenticated; as at Lourdes. The Church is the most sceptical organisation there is.

    Many times it is, like this, in cases where the drs cannot help.

    The OP of course need to seek medical help; but the two can and often do work side by side.


    I used to have horrible back pain, I couldn't walk some days. I went to a healer and he solved it. This was after years of goign to doctors and chiropractors who would heal me but hten It would come back every few months. I have never had that problem again, he didn't even charge me. I wish I could remember his name or where he lived exactly. I was driving with my boss on the road to Dublin from Mayo (don't work for him anymore), but I believe it was in another county... I remember he was on an oxygen tank... My boss told me he was the real deal and that he cured a lady with cancer a few years ago.

    I am an athiest, but he prayed over my back and did the sign of the cross. When I left, it stil hurt but 30 minutes later no pain and it hasn't come back.

    I dunno about healers, all i know is my back hasn't hurt since.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,747 ✭✭✭mdebets


    sorella wrote: »
    Healings at e.g Medjugorge are frequent and thoroughly authenticated; as at Lourdes. The Church is the most sceptical organisation there is.

    Sorry to disappoint you, but that's not true.
    An estimate 200 Mio. people have visited Lourdes. Of them 67 have been healed (accepted healings by the Catholic Church). That's 0.0000335%.
    I think even with a placebo effect the rate should have been higher.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1 Krusti


    <sorry, we can't allow medical advice on this forum :D>


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4 Mr.X


    ****ter_ wrote: »
    Don't be silly. Stay away from the healer. You'd be better off burning the money.

    Go to your doctor.

    I agree


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    Yes it is true, given that the idea was that there are no authenticated healings, only anecdotal.

    And knowing how healing is true, nothing statistical could 'disappoint" here.

    Do you think I wrote not knowing these things? That is part of my work as a historian
    .
    "Estimated" is simply that; many who go are not ill. To escort/help the sick etc, or out of curiosity etc.

    Those who were cured were the incurables. having exhausted all medical help.

    And if you were cured, that is all that mattered; statistics are meaningless to this value.

    There were many, many more healings eg a blind baby regained sight, witnessed , but the cure could not be assessed under the rigid RC system now abolished as the baby could not testify.

    And of course Medjugorje is not at this time recognised by the Church so there are no statistics.
    mdebets wrote: »
    Sorry to disappoint you, but that's not true.
    An estimate 200 Mio. people have visited Lourdes. Of them 67 have been healed (accepted healings by the Catholic Church). That's 0.0000335%.
    I think even with a placebo effect the rate should have been higher.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 106 ✭✭ttilting


    hI op

    i SUFFERED WITH chronic sciatica down m left leg/ bum/back. . . barlely able o get in and out of the car.

    spent fortunes on all sorts and was due to have serious surgery on my bulging disk. (it was pressing on a nerve!)

    Went to a guy called Mark Cleary in Ballyfermot (dublin 12). . . He was excellent. Took a good few sessions, , , cost a good few quid . . . but havn't had a problem in over 14 months and i can now play sport etc . . .

    The consultant who recommended surery was amazed at my progress . . .

    Anyway, , , If you want is number PM me ... but I remember he is difficult to get an appointment with, , , , and im only assuming he's still there.

    good luck with your back pain, , , Its the most debilitating thing I've ever had wrong with me!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,747 ✭✭✭mdebets


    Sorella, could you please make up your mind.
    First you said
    sorella wrote:
    Healings at e.g Medjugorge are frequent and thoroughly authenticated; as at Lourdes. The Church is the most sceptical organisation there is.

    then you said
    sorella wrote: »
    Yes it is true, given that the idea was that there are no authenticated healings, only anecdotal.

    What is it, are these healings frequently authenticated or not?
    sorella wrote: »
    And knowing how healing is true, nothing statistical could 'disappoint" here.

    Do you think I wrote not knowing these things? That is part of my work as a historian
    .
    "Estimated" is simply that; many who go are not ill. To escort/help the sick etc, or out of curiosity etc.

    Let's have a look at the figures again and do another conservative estimate.
    Let's assume that the number was totally overestimate and only 1% of these people were really there. That would make 2Mio visitors. Now assume that for every genuine sick person 9 non-sick person were there. Now we have 200.000 sick people having visited Lourdes. Now do your maths, still only 0.03 %.
    Let's ask a doctor here, how this numbers relate to healing in hospitals? I would say they are much higher.
    Now you're going to say, that not all healings are recorded or acknowledged by the Church. You have to think however that the Church has a vested interest in Lourdes. Do you honestly think, that they would undercount healings? No, they are going to count as much healings as possible. Therefore it is more likely that there were actually less then 67 healings.
    sorella wrote: »
    Those who were cured were the incurables. having exhausted all medical help.

    And if you were cured, that is all that mattered; statistics are meaningless to this value.

    There were many, many more healings eg a blind baby regained sight, witnessed , but the cure could not be assessed under the rigid RC system now abolished as the baby could not testify.

    And of course Medjugorje is not at this time recognised by the Church so there are no statistics.

    Statistics are not meaningless. A absence of a statistic says quite a lot.
    If there were so many healing, as you claim, there would have been a statistic long ago, showing exactly this, the many many people that were healed. That this statistic doesn't exist tells you that the healings don't exist.

    Another thing you should ask yourself is, why does Lourdes needs a hospital, if the people could just be healed?

    Healers and Healing places have existed since antiquity. But they never removed the need for conventional doctors. Surely at least one of them should have been so good that there was no need for doctors anymore.

    Another question is as to why none of the many healers ever did a publicity act, like going to the local hospital and healing all the people in there, his success afterwards would be immense.

    At the very least, why does non of these healers did a large study, to show that their patients were really healed. After all, that would be very easy to have a before and after examination by an independent doctor.

    On a personal note, I must really say I'm disappointed when a Christian (especcially a nun) falls for this sort of mambo-jambo, as I really think it cheapens the Christian faith (and I'm saying this as a Christian).
    Do I believe God heals: yes; does he need a human medium or a place for it: no, why would he; would I ever advice someone to go and see a faith healer: never, but I would pray that he would be healed, by a doctor or God, but not by a healer


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,888 ✭✭✭AtomicHorror


    sorella wrote: »
    Healing, simply.

    What a healer can offer you, I mean.

    But attitude is everything.

    And most healers will advise a dr; they are not irresponsible. As you say of course.

    But healing is well documented.

    Faith healing is indeed well-documented and demonstrated not to work, beyond a placebo effect. The Cochrane library did a systematic review of randomised controlled trials on intercessory prayer and found that while some small studies found vague positive effects, when analysed all together (covering some 7000 or more cases) there was basically nothing happening at all.

    You can read the for free study here:

    http://mrw.interscience.wiley.com/cochrane/clsysrev/articles/CD000368/pdf_fs.html

    OP, go to a doctor.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 106 ✭✭ttilting


    OP go to a doctor for a 4 minute waste of time & 50euro . .. . .

    While ''faith'' healing is mot for everyone . . .

    At very least consider alternative medicine. . .

    Western medicine =will lead to a surgical operation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,888 ✭✭✭AtomicHorror


    ttilting wrote: »
    OP go to a doctor for a 4 minute waste of time & 50euro . .. . .

    Oh spare us please. Yes GPs are not perfect, but if you're really ill a real doctor is never a waste of time or money.
    ttilting wrote: »
    While ''faith'' healing is mot for everyone . . .

    At very least consider alternative medicine. . .

    There's medicine that is known to work based on evidence from carefully controlled trials and there is medicine that is not. "Alternative" is a blanket term typically applied to the latter to create the illusion that the distinction lies elsewhere, that they're providing an effective alternative to those mean old pharmaceuticals companies and the medical establishment. There are plenty of cases where both sides are actually being run by the same company or are as big and bad as each other. But aside from that, they are not at all equals. Look at the trials, the evidence. The rest is irrelevant.

    That evidence says faith healing does not work.
    ttilting wrote: »
    Western medicine =will lead to a surgical operation.

    Funny. I've used western medicine every day for over 25 years without surgery. I've gone to my GP perhaps 70-80 times during my life. No surgery.

    The evidence says ttilting's Law doesn't work.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 923 ✭✭✭sorella


    Well, you know, we hear all this so often.

    That is your take on it; ours is very different.

    And to us it is not "mumbo jumbo"

    So let us agree to disagree on this.

    We do not assess Jesus by statistics, but by love, simply and power.

    And by deep humility before Him and beforfe Him only. And deep thankfulness for His healing.

    The OP asked re healers; we responded as others have with our faith and our skill and experience.

    That is the end of it for us.

    If you have problems with that; tough...

    We respect your right to hold your views, but we do not agree with them - period.

    We KNOW healing is real; by faith, by prayer... as Jesus wills it.
    Statistics are meaningless in this area.

    And we are most certainly not being drawn into arguments on this; far too busy working to feed our babies!!

    Over and out.

    Blessings this day
    mdebets wrote: »
    Sorella, could you please make up your mind.
    First you said



    then you said



    What is it, are these healings frequently authenticated or not?



    Let's have a look at the figures again and do another conservative estimate.
    Let's assume that the number was totally overestimate and only 1% of these people were really there. That would make 2Mio visitors. Now assume that for every genuine sick person 9 non-sick person were there. Now we have 200.000 sick people having visited Lourdes. Now do your maths, still only 0.03 %.
    Let's ask a doctor here, how this numbers relate to healing in hospitals? I would say they are much higher.
    Now you're going to say, that not all healings are recorded or acknowledged by the Church. You have to think however that the Church has a vested interest in Lourdes. Do you honestly think, that they would undercount healings? No, they are going to count as much healings as possible. Therefore it is more likely that there were actually less then 67 healings.



    Statistics are not meaningless. A absence of a statistic says quite a lot.
    If there were so many healing, as you claim, there would have been a statistic long ago, showing exactly this, the many many people that were healed. That this statistic doesn't exist tells you that the healings don't exist.

    Another thing you should ask yourself is, why does Lourdes needs a hospital, if the people could just be healed?

    Healers and Healing places have existed since antiquity. But they never removed the need for conventional doctors. Surely at least one of them should have been so good that there was no need for doctors anymore.

    Another question is as to why none of the many healers ever did a publicity act, like going to the local hospital and healing all the people in there, his success afterwards would be immense.

    At the very least, why does non of these healers did a large study, to show that their patients were really healed. After all, that would be very easy to have a before and after examination by an independent doctor.

    On a personal note, I must really say I'm disappointed when a Christian (especcially a nun) falls for this sort of mambo-jambo, as I really think it cheapens the Christian faith (and I'm saying this as a Christian).
    Do I believe God heals: yes; does he need a human medium or a place for it: no, why would he; would I ever advice someone to go and see a faith healer: never, but I would pray that he would be healed, by a doctor or God, but not by a healer


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement