Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Europe has been good to us?

  • 10-06-2008 11:09PM
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 562 ✭✭✭


    this is something the yes to lisbon campaign keeps telling us, my question to them is how good was europe to us in the 80s?


«13

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,510 ✭✭✭Jigsaw


    utick wrote: »
    this is something the yes to lisbon campaign keeps telling us, my question to them is how good was europe to us in the 80s?

    Very good. Ireland, until recent accession states from Eastern Europe became fully fledged member states, was a net benefactor country. Ireland as a nation has done extraordinarily well out of Europe. FACT.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 35,522 ✭✭✭✭Gordon


    How many more Lisbon treaty threads will there be? I dont remember any in the 80s.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 562 ✭✭✭utick


    Gordon wrote: »
    How many more Lisbon treaty threads will there be? I dont remember any in the 80s.


    ireland was part of the eu/ec and was in a major deppression alot of emmigration


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 641 ✭✭✭johnnyq


    Gordon wrote: »
    How many more Lisbon treaty threads will there be? I dont remember any in the 80s.
    Lol

    Indeed Ireland has done well and as a net contributor from now on, the EU's investment will be repaid, and handsomely in my view.

    Now what does that have to do with lisbon? Not much in my view, if we vote no those same EU structures which have been good to Ireland stays in place. If we vote yes then we accept other things which may be bad depending on your point of view.

    The best thing is to be informed. Referendum Commission website: www.lisbontreaty2008.ie


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 35,522 ✭✭✭✭Gordon


    utick wrote: »
    ireland was part of the eu/ec and was in a major deppression alot of immigration
    So Lisbon threads were immigrating into a depressing Ireland in the 80s? I don't remember seeing that. And I'd remember depressed Lisbon threads, it's the kind of thing I remember.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,611 ✭✭✭✭Sam Vimes


    Jigsaw wrote: »
    Very good. Ireland, until recent accession states from Eastern Europe became fully fledged member states, was a net benefactor country. Ireland as a nation has done extraordinarily well out of Europe. FACT.

    afaik we're still a net benefactor but i'm open to correction on that


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14,277 ✭✭✭✭Rb


    Europe has been good to Ireland, but I can't see it being good for Ireland in the future, particularly if a yes vote on Lisbon goes through.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,629 ✭✭✭ART6


    Ireland has been a net beneficiary true. But we also benefited from a blizzard of regulation designed to suit the mainland European countries like France and Germany rather than us. That in turn gave us water charges for schools, for example, in a country where, compared with much of Europe, water is plentiful. It gave us a common law system based upon the French model rather than the Anglo-Irish one that has stood us in good stead for hundreds of years. It gave us significantly increased food costs due to the CAP. It gave us excessive inflation because we surrendered to the ECB control of our own interest rates. It gave us a political system controlled by civil servants rather than elected representatives and thereby reduced our elected government to, very largely, a rubber stamping machine. It gave us a common currency the value of which was determined mainly by the health of the German economy rather than any of our own efforts, so that when the currency of our largest export market, the UK, slips then we are in trouble. It permitted us to give away our fisheries to France and Spain, who promptly vacuumed our fish-rich waters clean and eliminated our own industry. It gave us the proliferation of massive and visually intrusive road signs boasting how the latest scheme was part funded by the EU Development Fund. But mainly it gave us the opportunity to abandon control of our own destiny.

    Ah, but was not the Celtic Tiger phenomenon due to the EU? No. It was due to Charlie McCreevy dropping corporation taxes to 12 1/2%. It was in spite of the EU, not because of it. It happened in part because a succession of Irish and British politicians patiently worked towards peace in the Six Counties, bringing them and the Republic closer and closer together until we gained a vibrant and valuable further market, and the EU played no part in that whatever.The same effect would have occurred if we had remained members of the Common Market, which was the origin of the EU, and that would have happened without all of the endless meddling from Brussels.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 19,967 ✭✭✭✭mikemac


    ART6 wrote: »
    It gave us a common law system based upon the French model rather than the Anglo-Irish one that has stood us in good stead for hundreds of years.

    Ireland, the UK and places like Australia all have common law systems. We didn't get them from Europe, we always had it.
    Unless you want to waaaaay back to the Gaelic chiefs and Brehon law.

    The French model is a civil code system based on codes which is different to common law. So how did we replace the system we already had? :confused:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,611 ✭✭✭✭Sam Vimes


    ART6 wrote: »
    That in turn gave us water charges for schools, for example, in a country where, compared with much of Europe, water is plentiful.
    The eu had no law requiring our government to underfund schools to the point that water charges crippled them. There was nothing stopping them increasing funding to counteract the charges. But if you want to blame the eu you go right ahead
    ART6 wrote: »
    Ah, but was not the Celtic Tiger phenomenon due to the EU? No. It was due to Charlie McCreevy dropping corporation taxes to 12 1/2%. It was in spite of the EU, not because of it. It happened in part because a succession of Irish and British politicians patiently worked towards peace in the Six Counties, bringing them and the Republic closer and closer together until we gained a vibrant and valuable further market, and the EU played no part in that whatever.The same effect would have occurred if we had remained members of the Common Market, which was the origin of the EU, and that would have happened without all of the endless meddling from Brussels.
    now that is just crap and you know it. Those US companies came because of our low tax rate AND membership of the eu which gave them access to the rest of europe. Without the eu it just wouldn't have happened

    also, as micmclo said, i'm fairly sure us and the uk are the only countries in europe that have a common law system and we had it for several hundred years before the eu existed
    Posted via Mobile Device


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,291 ✭✭✭dresden8


    What's those stats?

    We received €50billion cash from the EU and gave them €100billion in fish for that.

    Net Contributor more like.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,048 ✭✭✭SimpleSam06


    Jigsaw wrote: »
    Very good. Ireland, until recent accession states from Eastern Europe became fully fledged member states, was a net benefactor country. Ireland as a nation has done extraordinarily well out of Europe. FACT.
    We also gave up the rights to our fishing grounds when we joined, earning the EU states three times more than they ever gave to us. The more I learn about EU contributions to this country, the less impressed I am.

    So tell me again, who is the net benefactor?


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators Posts: 6,391 Mod ✭✭✭✭Macha


    ART6 wrote: »
    Ireland has been a net beneficiary true. But we also benefited from a blizzard of regulation designed to suit the mainland European countries like France and Germany rather than us. That in turn gave us water charges for schools, for example, in a country where, compared with much of Europe, water is plentiful.

    Water may be plentiful in Ireland but a lot of it is polluted and it is only through being forced by the EU through the Water Framework Directive that we will resolve this. Also, we are running out of municipal reserves in the Dublin area. Have you not noticed the storm going on about bringing pipelines up from the Shannon or installing a desalination plant? With global warming, this is only going to get worse.
    ART6 wrote: »
    It gave us a common law system based upon the French model rather than the Anglo-Irish one that has stood us in good stead for hundreds of years. It gave us significantly increased food costs due to the CAP.

    CAP is not perfect but if it weren't for CAP we would have even less farmers than we do now. Plus we have never paid so little for our food. In the 60s we spent 30% of our disposible income on food, now its 10-15%. Please explain how our entire legal system has been converted over to the French model.
    ART6 wrote: »
    It gave us excessive inflation because we surrendered to the ECB control of our own interest rates. It gave us a political system controlled by civil servants rather than elected representatives and thereby reduced our elected government to, very largely, a rubber stamping machine. It gave us a common currency the value of which was determined mainly by the health of the German economy rather than any of our own efforts, so that when the currency of our largest export market, the UK, slips then we are in trouble.
    And you think that in the 1960s when we were completely economically dependent on the UK that a drop in the UK economy wouldn't have affected us? If anything, being part of the EU has given us access to new markets and thus softened any impact.
    ART6 wrote: »
    It permitted us to give away our fisheries to France and Spain, who promptly vacuumed our fish-rich waters clean and eliminated our own industry.
    We are the only ones to blame for that. We did it - no one forced us to.
    ART6 wrote: »
    It gave us the proliferation of massive and visually intrusive road signs boasting how the latest scheme was part funded by the EU Development Fund.
    I hope you enjoy driving on those lovely new roads - they wouldn't be there if it weren't for EU funding. And now you're just being ridiculous - "massive", "instrusive"? Come on - this is just petty whining.
    ART6 wrote: »
    Ah, but was not the Celtic Tiger phenomenon due to the EU? No. It was due to Charlie McCreevy dropping corporation taxes to 12 1/2%. It was in spite of the EU, not because of it. It happened in part because a succession of Irish and British politicians patiently worked towards peace in the Six Counties, bringing them and the Republic closer and closer together until we gained a vibrant and valuable further market, and the EU played no part in that whatever.The same effect would have occurred if we had remained members of the Common Market, which was the origin of the EU, and that would have happened without all of the endless meddling from Brussels.

    You're having a laugh. You really think that it only happened because we dropped our corporation taxes and stabilised the north?? And what exaclty was everyone in the country going to work as for all these Farmers?? It was mostly because of the free education that was introduced in the 1960s. The EU poured huge amounts of funds into Ireland to provide this free education. Plus college education was made free in 1996 - that is a huge cost and our government does not foot the whole bill by any stretch of the imagination.

    If it weren't for the EU, we would still be tied to sterling, and hugely economically dependent on the UK. Plus as part of the EU, we were a perfect base for US TNCs to enter the European market. Yahoo, Google, Microsoft, Intel, Dell - they wouldn't be here if we weren't in the EU.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,048 ✭✭✭SimpleSam06


    taconnol wrote: »
    Water may be plentiful in Ireland but a lot of it is polluted and it is only through being forced by the EU through the Water Framework Directive that we will resolve this. Also, we are running out of municipal reserves in the Dublin area. Have you not noticed the storm going on about bringing pipelines up from the Shannon or installing a desalination plant? With global warming, this is only going to get worse.
    Thats another infrastructure problem, not a supply problem. We don't need EU regulations to sort that out.
    taconnol wrote: »
    Plus we have never paid so little for our food.
    We are getting absoloutely raped on food prices. Did you not see the headlines lately where chains in the UK were charging 50% less for food? The economics of mass distribution can in no way explain that.
    taconnol wrote: »
    If anything, being part of the EU has given us access to new markets and thus softened any impact.
    Markets we would have had access to anyway, ultimately, unless you think European countries not in the EU are locked out of the EU for some reason. Not that being part of the EU has done wonders for our international trade anyway (paid VRT lately?)
    taconnol wrote: »
    We are the only ones to blame for that. We did it - no one forced us to.
    So lets talk about what the EU owes us then. As well as the gross value of fish stocks, we have the missed opportunities in terms of employment in a national fishing industry, huge shipbuilding opportunities (we are an island state by the way) and all the industrial infrastructure that brings, processing, the list goes on.
    taconnol wrote: »
    I hope you enjoy driving on those lovely new roads - they wouldn't be there if it weren't for EU funding.
    Have you seen our lovely new roads? They ain't that lovely. Infrastructure in Ireland is a joke. This is where our government should have put the massive tax receipts of the last eight years, not into the public sector.
    taconnol wrote: »
    You're having a laugh. You really think that it only happened because we dropped our corporation taxes and stailised the north?
    Basically, yes. Thats how it got started anyway, the boom over the last decade was largely due to lower global interest rates flooding the system with cheap money. The EU had little or nothing to do with that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,727 ✭✭✭✭Sherifu


    ZZZZZZZZzzzzzzz


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 28,787 ✭✭✭✭ScumLord


    utick wrote: »
    ireland was part of the eu/ec and was in a major deppression alot of emmigration
    Wasn't there a world wide economic depression at the time?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,854 ✭✭✭zuutroy


    Sherifu wrote: »
    ZZZZZZZZzzzzzzz

    this


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,432 ✭✭✭Steve_o


    Christ... enough with the "Is Europe good for Ireland" threads... off to Politics with you.:mad:


    /walks away mumbling profanities


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 23,246 ✭✭✭✭Dyr


    taconnol wrote: »

    We are the only ones to blame for that. We did it - no one forced us to.



    Greenland had to actually leave the EEC to prevent European Fleets from fishing their waters so I find it hard to believe that "we did it" in that regard.


  • Moderators, Recreation & Hobbies Moderators Posts: 10,912 Mod ✭✭✭✭Ponster


    Steve_o wrote: »
    Christ... enough with the "Is Europe good for Ireland" threads... off to Politics with you.:mad:


    /walks away mumbling profanities


    No point. The OP IMHO probably doesn't have the skills needed to defend their point of view in the politics forum.

    These threads are getting boring.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,432 ✭✭✭Steve_o


    Ponster wrote: »
    These threads are getting boring.

    + infinity


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 14,186 ✭✭✭✭kowloon


    ART6 wrote: »
    It gave us a political system controlled by civil servants rather than elected representatives and thereby reduced our elected government to, very largely, a rubber stamping machine.

    I didn't realise that was introduced with the EU.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 328 ✭✭suspectdevice


    see its not really a politics thread, its a culture thread.

    1980's ireland. i qualified from college, did an anco course, wrote up a cv and went to a recruitment agency called headhunt. little fu'cker in there with some irish version of his name, horrible little man, told me i was useless, unemployable and that i should go abroad to get work and experience. so i went, without the intention of coming back if that was the type of wa'nker that could say whether or not my cv would be passed on to an employer. went to london got a job, after 2-3 years saw a job advertised by headhunt, same little fu'cker, in the irish newspaper with a large american software corporation that was setting up in ireland and looking for my skills. sent in my cv and got it returned saying that the employer was not interested. saw the same job advertised a couple of weeks later in the english press and the chance to apply directly, which i did and got the job. little fu'cker. anyway, thats what '80s ireland reminds me of. a very few people controlling the very many for their own interests.

    then came the corporations for the tax breaks. that gave people who were not part of the very few at the top the opportunity to enter the ruling class, the executive class, the monied class. no longer were we to be ruled by a bunch of in-bred rich fu'ckers who could hold sway over your life for their own benefit. we were the first generation to actually be able to stand tall because of the status that the large american corporations bestowed upon us, and everyone since has benefitted from our pioneering work. no longer was there the expectation of a priest, a nun, a civil servant, a bank clerk, a teacher and a homeboy to look after the folks considered to be the profile of the successful irish family. success could be down to the individual and the chance they took having been presented it by the large foreign corporations coming here to set up their operations.

    why did they come here? because of us. because of the irish people and our intelligence. the fact that we were european, spoke english but weren't fu'cking english. the fact that we could work long hours and not complain because our forefathers had a little work. but the biggest factor, the most important element of their decision was the fact the they could change the name of their company very 3-5 years to a new name registered in the caymen islands and benefit from renewed tax breaks that were afforded them. 12.5% was across the board but depending on the company and their type of business and the level of their revenue, their would be deals done.

    we should have stayed that way but we got caught on the hop and gave in to some of the eu demands. farming is fu'cked. thats not just here. collective corporate farming is killing rural communities all over europe. fishing is fu'cked. we are an island nation surrounded by rich waters and stocks that have been fleeced by spanish trawlers. we eat frozen fish from the north of england, from scotland, crab meat from fu'cking thailand. we have no real seafood culture, not any abundance or value for money.

    we have allowed companies like tesco to come in and not even require them to delcare their profits, they came in as an unlimited company. other companies have also done the same thing. recently the uk based companies, the large multiples have ceased to display their prices in sterling, the strength of the euro is something they are denying us. fair enough that europe does not have much oil but the strength of the euro should afford us better rpices than $10 a gallon. and anyway, the money we spend for fuel should be svaed on other products like food and clothing due to the stregth of the euro. is it? no. we allow multiples to import beer from spain, via the uk, ship it across the boarder from the north and sell it below cost whilst fleecing us on a our groceries bill. the people dealing with this have no approach because they have no experience, they are like the planning clerks of old telling us white walls/black slate roof to preserve the integrity of the countryside, wtf? they have not got a clue.

    then we open up our borders. what was that all about? an island nation with no natural resources, no indigenous industry, allows 100,000s of people to come here to seek work. i am not racist, i ma not even nationalist, truth be told i'd like to live in an anarchy(daydreams) but it is not long ago since we were in the state of the countries that these people come from, we show a little unsustainable growth and we take down our borders, meanwhile everywhere else on the planet is putting them up.

    infrastructure, huh. contracts handed out on foot of brown envelopes, with work phased in such a way that the contractors finish the m50 for example and start enlarging it. what a joke. but who pays? you may say the eu but you are so wrong. thats what they want you think. we have paid with our fishing grounds, we have paid with our letting down the boarders and now each and everyone of us pays whilst we are sitting in traffic for 2-3 hours per day or by paying fu'cking ridiculous prices for housing that is 2-3 miles from work - still takes half an hour to get there though.

    at the end of the day, irish people made ireland successful. the inherent good nature and hard working irish people, not the chancers but the ones who came up in hard times, nothing more, nothing less, we just didn't have the confidence to go it alone and make sure that what we had was developed for our benefit.

    i pity todays generation of 20 somethings, there are some tough times ahead. we all need to rally around a little and try and make sure we help as much as we all can. be a little bit more realistic in our expectations. take control of our future.

    i am not for or against europe but put it on the backboiler for now, until we make our politicians do their job, understand more about where we find ourselves. let them ask the question that i find fundamental - can we have a referendum to suspend our involvement in the eu until they take the time to educate us all about what it is for us to be european citizens. ask them to stop all this tribunal bullsh!t, all this distraction about trivial events in the past and spend as much time and money educating us on who we are and where we are going.

    regardless of the rant. ireland prospered because of irish people.


  • Moderators, Recreation & Hobbies Moderators Posts: 10,912 Mod ✭✭✭✭Ponster


    regardless of the rant. ireland prospered because of irish people.

    Hmmmm...I understand what you're saying and agree. But to say that without Europe Ireland would be the same country it is today would be wrong (I don't think you think that but others could understand that).


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators Posts: 6,391 Mod ✭✭✭✭Macha


    I agree with a lot of what you're saying but you can lay the blame for our crap public transport, long commutes and high house prices at the feet of Fianna Fail and no one else.

    Believe me if the EU had their way, do you think they would have allowed Bertie to hand out his ridiculous tax incentives to developers and buyers alike? Renters get a crappy rental allowance and rents are almost the same as buying so why wouldn't you buy? Developers being allowed to throw up god-awful suburbs of ridiculously low densities so as to make public transport unviable and the car the only valid means of transport. So it due to our national policies and our own thick-headed obsession with owning a bit of garden out the back that we all sit in our cars for 4 hours a day.

    Sorry but the EU does pay for a lot of that infrastructure and whatever the government gives out, they get most of it back in tax receipts.

    The price of oil has gone up largely because of the weak dollar.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 28,787 ✭✭✭✭ScumLord


    why did they come here? because of us. because of the irish people and our intelligence. the fact that we were european, spoke english but weren't fu'cking english. the fact that we could work long hours and not complain because our forefathers had a little work.
    They came here because it was cheap, end of. Low wages, low tax, lets face it most jobs in the world are easy enough to train for even if your making computer chips your more than likely on a production line doing the same thing day in day out. Now that Ireland no longer cheap there's nothing keeping them here and they're leaving in droves.

    All the hard working Irish left years ago. I remember when I started working there was no rush on anything, monday was optional. It wasn't until the foreigners came along and started working there holes off for half the wage that we pulled our socks up.
    we should have stayed that way but we got caught on the hop and gave in to some of the eu demands. farming is fu'cked. thats not just here. collective corporate farming is killing rural communities all over europe.
    That's world wide capitolisim driving down costs not the EU.
    then we open up our borders. what was that all about? an island nation with no natural resources, no indigenous industry, allows 100,000s of people to come here to seek work.
    We begged them to come here, remember? More jobs than people.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 283 ✭✭escobar


    johnnyq wrote: »
    Lol

    Indeed Ireland has done well and as a net contributor from now on, the EU's investment will be repaid, and handsomely in my view.

    Now what does that have to do with lisbon? Not much in my view, if we vote no those same EU structures which have been good to Ireland stays in place. If we vote yes then we accept other things which may be bad depending on your point of view.

    The best thing is to be informed. Referendum Commission website: www.lisbontreaty2008.ie

    + 1

    The only argument for voting yes that i've heard is

    1.That europe has been good to us : Our sucess is because of our policies i.e. tax and our productivity etc .
    It's not as if every country who joined has been as sucessful as us.

    2.That we will be in big trouble if we vote no and all the other countries will be annoyed with us. But France and Holland voted against it last time and it was changed so why shouldn't we.

    On the no side

    We're losing half our voting power while others double and won't even have representation one third of the time

    and

    although the tax issue , as in our corporation tax is lower than other countries ,which will be pushed by the larger countries to be equalised cannot be changed except by unanimity this requirement can be voted on and changed and again we're not represented one third of the time.

    The above is enough for me to vote no. I still havn't heard agood argument to vote yes

    But I'm still completely open on the subject so all comments are welcomed


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 328 ✭✭suspectdevice


    Ponster wrote: »
    Hmmmm...I understand what you're saying and agree. But to say that without Europe Ireland would be the same country it is today would be wrong (I don't think you think that but others could understand that).

    i think it would have been better. honestly. thing is we never went down that route so we will never know what the challenges might have been and how irish people would have coped with. we do know that we are currently facing the single biggest challenge in our history and we have little or no control over it. thats a lot scarier to me than hwat would happened if we'd have remained a little more isolated.
    taconnol wrote:
    I agree with a lot of what you're saying but you can lay the blame for our crap public transport, long commutes and high house prices at the feet of Fianna Fail and no one else.

    Believe me if the EU had their way, do you think they would have allowed Bertie to hand out his ridiculous tax incentives to developers and buyers alike? Renters get a crappy rental allowance and rents are almost the same as buying so why wouldn't you buy? Developers being allowed to throw up god-awful suburbs of ridiculously low densities so as to make public transport unviable and the car the only valid means of transport. So it due to our national policies and our own thick-headed obsession with owning a bit of garden out the back that we all sit in our cars for 4 hours a day.

    Sorry but the EU does pay for a lot of that infrastructure and whatever the government gives out, they get most of it back in tax receipts.

    The price of oil has gone up largely because of the weak dollar.
    agreed, fianna fail, solicitors, developers, councillors, tds. they all had a hand in the massive exploitation of the land banks in ireland.

    the eu pays for infrastructure to a certain extent but we have paid all the way along personally. we have been a bunch of lab rats for the expansion of the eu for a long time. they have colonised ireland, turned us into the model country, and are now resetting expectations for the medium to long term. they will now move on and do the same to the other, equally unadvanced, members. poland and the like have a lot to be wary of as they are colonised.

    oil has gone up because of profiteering, massive profiteering by everyone in the supplychain


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators Posts: 6,391 Mod ✭✭✭✭Macha


    Ok how about this: At the moment, legislation is written, discussed and adopted in the EU in a way that does not involve our national governments. They really have no say, apart from through the commissioner and the few MEPs.

    Once the legislation is passed at EU level, it is totally binding for national governments to implement it. In the case of directives, the goal of the legislation is the main thing & so we're allowed a bit of leeway to implement it as we see fit. If the Lisbon Treaty is passed, national governments will have a greater say in EU legislative procedures and will have 8 weeks to look at the legislation & go back to the EU with it. If 1/3 of national governments object, the legislation will have to be reviewed.

    ALSO, Irish people don't seem to realise how screwed we are when it comes to energy. We import over 90% of our energy (98% when it comes to transport - remember all those miles we're driving in our beloved cars?) We are on the end of a VERY long gas pipline from Russia & if they switch off the gas, we will be the first and worst hit. It is only as part of the EU and part of a new EU common energy policy that we will be able to have any influence over Russia.

    That's just two reasons to vote yes. I've yet to hear any good reasons for voting no, or at least any that outweigh the yes vote.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 328 ✭✭suspectdevice


    ScumLord wrote: »
    They came here because it was cheap, end of. Low wages, low tax, lets face it most jobs in the world are easy enough to train for even if your making computer chips your more than likely on a production line doing the same thing day in day out. Now that Ireland no longer cheap there's nothing keeping them here and they're leaving in droves.
    no they did not. they came here for the well educated workforce who were prepared to work an honest day for an honest pay. and long term renewable low taxes.

    i was in meetings with the ida and companies thinking about coming here and i saw the sales pitch. show cases were made of certain compnaies who had already good experiences in ireland with regard to workforce and taxes, directly attributable to ireland. this was not as simple as assembly lines. they were looking for some manfacturing skills but they had their plan set to land their revenue here and support all their sales operations in europe, africa, the middle east, indian sub continent, eastern europe out of here. the germans would think it was a german company, the french would think it french, inside every little irish worker was an american dying to get out. or at least thats the way they saw it.

    they are moving on because we have been modernised. we must now compete on a level playing field. they have moved on to colonise elsewhere.

    ScumLord wrote:
    All the hard working Irish left years ago.
    thats just plain silly
    ScumLord wrote:
    I remember when I started working there was no rush on anything, monday was optional. It wasn't until the foreigners came along and started working there holes off for half the wage that we pulled our socks up.
    never heard of it in industries that contributed to the bottow line. must have been in the trades or service industries but then they are the ones who will pay the price of all this first. we still haven't pulled our socks up. no one has worked here for half the wage of anyone else in a long time. we have the strictest and most well enforced and the most generous minimum wage system in europe, holidays included. people from other countries came here to take up jobs on minimum wage, break their bo!lox for two years and go home and buy out their mortgage. others got assimulated and are a part of our society. paddy hasn't pulled his socks up in the last while.
    ScumLord wrote:
    That's world wide capitolisim driving down costs not the EU.
    costs are going up
    ScumLord wrote:
    We begged them to come here, remember? More jobs than people.
    we just dropped our borders, i still can't for the life of me think why when hardly anyone else did
    [/quote]
    overall, we are obviously talking about different timelines


Advertisement
Advertisement