Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Americans and obesity

2

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 86,683 ✭✭✭✭Overheal


    Alright as long as we're asking the question and not jumping into the racial genralities :)

    Theres a lot of factors why America is the fattest nation but like others have said they are only the first warning sign and Nobody seems to be picking up on it. Most every country is getting fatter and fatter.

    Its all down to lifestyle changes. For example if you go most places in the United States you quickly realise your fairly screwed without a car. There are paths everywhere but the distance between locations is a lot greater too: because of the popularity of cars there is no incentive to build things in congregations anymore. And depending on the weather people are more inclined to use a treadmill over walk the dog. I went to the doctor over christmas and instead of ask my mom to get off work to lift me home she freaked when I walked all of 25 minutes to get back. Nobody walks. I spent 25 minutes walking down a road populated only by cars. Never once saw another pedestrian that wasn't 15 feet from the gas pump.

    And oh god, the food. Its too cheap. If we were smart we'd tax food based on its fat content. As it is such foods tend to be ridiculously cheap. If i go down the road and around the corner I can eat at the chinese buffet for $9 ... and it aint too bad either. I can only imagine what people who were never trained on common sense and willpower would do with such things. For the same amount of food I ate that day in there I would have paid close to 50 euro here: totally worth it. Sesame Chicken is supreme. They get away with it through bulk purchase and preparation. Made to order food like here, obviously adds a fair bit of cost.
    The thing is, if youre in the states you notice almost immediately that the healthy choices almost always out-cost the unhealthy choices. Being americans: we go for the cheap choice.

    Then of course there are dozens of other factors. More and more, the things you used to go out to get and do are being brought to you so you can spend more time at home or at work. Nobody goes to the video store anymore: its all available on your sattelite dish - pay per view baby. Pizza? http://www.pizzahut.com you dont even have to pick up that 4 ounce phone anymore. Need something from best buy, wal mart, the local grocery store? They all deliver. They all have websites.

    To be honest, I just dont see how Americans that are healthy and slim are staying healthy and slim.

    The same thing will sneak in here though make no joke about it. It starts with Tesco deliveries and then The World. Next thing you know your local hospital keeps a fleet of super-heavy ambulances for those 'special needs'.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,398 ✭✭✭MIN2511


    There are a lot of factors to consider... Europeans are generally more conscious of their weight than American counterparts. We are more aware of what we eat and where it comes from, Americans couldn't care less if their burgers are from Mars. Food is also very cheap there, as Overheal said a Chinese buffet would cost you 9dollars:eek: where there hell would you get Chinese buffet in Dublin for 6euro?:mad:
    Ireland may end up like America; we seem to copy their move(except invading Iraq):D



    Generalising here, not based on facts. Feel free to disagree


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 17,895 Mod ✭✭✭✭Manic Moran


    Dudess wrote: »
    eating competitions

    The kicker is that if you look at those competetive eaters (I kid you not, it's a televised sport around these parts), they're generally not overweight. Takeru Kobayashi is 5'8" and 75kg. Sonya Thomas comes in at about 50kg.

    (Both weights are presumably starting weights, not after eating 7kg of Cheesecake in 9 minutes)

    NTM


  • Posts: 11,928 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    You can't overestimate the effect of utter laziness either.
    I've had a perfectly ablebodied American customer cause a fuss because I told her what she wanted was down stairs, and she was upset that she had walk 30 steps out of her way. She went on for five minutes! Her husband had to ask her to stop making a scene.

    I had a similar reaction when I asked a taxi driver in Ohio to help me lift my bag, he was utterly disgusted that he had to walk around the vechile.
    I had to take the cab, because I'd been waiting for it forever, he didn't shut up cribbing and moaning about the walk the whole way.

    btw anyone who think Irish obese is an anyway comparable to that in middle america hasn't the foggiest.
    Their waistlines have more in common with prize cattle than us, I never ceased to be amazed at how these people managed to function.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,256 ✭✭✭metaoblivia


    Every time my mother goes to visit her parents and sister in Kansas, she always comes back amazed at how they do nothing but sit, talk, and eat. And she says they have no fruits or vegetables - just fried foods and starches.
    Some people just don't think about what they put into their bodies. They just eat whatever's easiest or cheapest. A lot of people just don't know when to stop. They go to buffets and eat and eat and eat, and I don't know how they can possibly fit so much into their stomachs.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,766 ✭✭✭Reku


    Considering the amount of people who will drive to their local newsagent or get the bus/luas for one stop, people who will never use the stairs if there is an escalator/elevator, etc... I have no doubts that we will soon be in the exact same boat as in the US.
    TBH I don't think cheap food over there is so much the issue as the availability of convenient (i.e. fast) food, there are few meals you can prepare in under 20minutes that would be unprocessed and healthy, why put in the extra effort to cook a healthy meal when you can have an unhealthy meal and use the extra time to relax?
    As Overheal has also pointed out; why go out to play soccer, chasing, etc... when you can stay in and play a virtual form of it on your games console?

    It's all down to laziness, in the general sense, IMO in that the "why take the healthier route when there's an easier one available" philosophy tends to be encroaching on all aspects of our lives. We want everything easily and readily available so we don't have to work as much to get it, as such we expend less energy getting things and because we can get food more easily we consume more energy than we used to.
    More energy intake + less energy expended in getting the energy intake = more energy to be stored as fat.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 86,683 ✭✭✭✭Overheal


    Its so unbearably true. Even when im over there im a lazy ****. Sleep late, watch TV, do the interweb. I laugh at the poor dogs sitting in the corner hoping i will get off my ass and play with them or take them for a walk in this damned heat and humidity. I dont know what it is about the place. Probably has to do with the monster TV and the leather sofa.

    Though in fairness I also dont eat anything when I'm over there. Typically I'll eat a snack item and one meal a day: it really gives you everything you need and more. Thats the only reason my family stays slim too - its coffee in the morning, **** all for lunch and a small dinner.

    But not everyone gets that. More and more some people are coming around. If you look at my family theres probably about 20% of the family that is overweight; maybe 2% you would call obese. For the most part people manage to stay slender and some still manage to be built. Only 1 or 2 kids are overweight and most of it comes from the oldies.

    Its a stupidity thing as much as everything else for those people who still think youre unhealthy if youre not eating 3 squares a day. If youre not educated on eating well you pass that onto your kids. I've used this example before: an obese woman in the all you can eat pizzeria giving out to her kids because they arent packing enough in - the kids obese too, and fair play to him he didnt want to eat anymore. Obesity should be regarded as child neglect... one guy my sister hangs out with just walks into people's houses and eats right out of their fridge: kid doesnt even have a belt, let alone clothes that fit, and - yeah its just disgusting.

    It'll come here too though - all these ready made foods: none of its really that healthy for you. Take stock in what youre eating folks and think about walking before taking the car.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 17,895 Mod ✭✭✭✭Manic Moran


    If the Good Lord intended for us to walk, he wouldn't have invented the internal combustion engine.

    NTM


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,387 ✭✭✭✭rubadub


    Overheal wrote: »
    To be honest, I just dont see how Americans that are healthy and slim are staying healthy and slim.
    By simply ingesting the calories they need.

    I have no real problem with laziness and do not equate it with being fat. I know extremely lazy skinny blokes. It all comes down to energy in and energy out. If you want to sit around all day and do nothing, fine, then lower your food intake. If you used to use 10L of petrol a week driving to the job and shops and are now in a job closer to home you simply put less petrol in the car. If you used to walk to work and are now closer put less fuel/food in your system. If you continue to eat the same amount then you are a stupid idiot, just like a lad who would have petrol pouring out the side of his car going "eh, duh, I used to put 10L in a week".
    Nobody walks
    People are stupid snobs, functional exercise is frowned up by many arseholes. They will pay a gardener, a window cleaner, a maid, a delivery man, and then pay overpriced memberships to gyms for the privelege of burning calories, and then moan all fuc king day about how crap their gym is- idiots.

    "Physical Education" is a utter farce. I know realise my PE teacher didnt have a clue about fitness, and was never taught anything about nutrition or physicality by him. My "education" was running around a field, disgraceful.

    If the Good Lord intended for us to walk, he wouldn't have invented the internal combustion engine.
    Schwarzenegger said something like "man is was not designed to be sedentary, he was meant to run 40km a day and hunt wooly mammoth".

    Ignorance is the main cause of obesity IMO, many know exactly how much fuel and what quality of fuel to put in their car, but couldnt give a sh!te about figuring out how to fuel themselves.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 149 ✭✭SteveS


    RedPlanet wrote: »
    Then he is dumb too!
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4436638.stm
    Most the fattest states in America are all along the south

    He is also dumb if he thinks Oklahoma is part of the "South". Most people from Oklahoma consider themselves part of the West.
    To be honest, I just dont see how Americans that are healthy and slim are staying healthy and slim.

    Because some of us have some self-control. Unless you eat out all the time, it isn't really that hard to find plenty of food that is good for you.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,684 ✭✭✭FatherTed


    It's a combination of people being lazy and food being cheap. It's cheap to prepare your own food but people are lazy to do so, and end up buying the cheap fast food.

    As tempting as they are I don't frequent the buffets. But last year when I was in FL, we went to a Golden Coral. There was this one massive guy who instead of putting a small amount of food on the plate, finishing that and perhaps going up for a second, kept piling a huge amount of food on the plate, probably enough for 3 dinners. Sure enough when he finished, he was up again for more. It was one of the sickest things I've seen.


  • Posts: 11,928 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    SteveS wrote: »
    Unless you eat out all the time, it isn't really that hard to find plenty of food that is good for you.


    Not if you live in Shíthole City in Kentucky it isn't.
    Everything seems to be based on High Corn Fructose Syrup.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,740 ✭✭✭Naos


    Was in Florida on holidays last year. In some Buffet place called "Ponta Rosas".

    For 8 or 9 dollars, you go in, choose your meal (Steak & Chips/Burger & Chips etc.), they give you a plate and direct you to the buffet part saying your main meal will be served in X amount of time.

    I seen a really fat family there, going up and loading their plates, getting ice-cream etc before they had their main meal.

    They bring it on themselves.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,387 ✭✭✭✭rubadub


    Moonbaby wrote: »
    Not if you live in Shíthole City in Kentucky it isn't.
    Everything seems to be based on High Corn Fructose Syrup.

    I was going to say make your own, but I remember being in NY and I couldnt get an apple in a supermarket. Got some bread (no brown either) and went to get some cheese, all I could get was spray on cheese!
    Was a big enough supermarket too, you would konw the name, I can remember it though. I was feeling sick from all the junk but couldnt get anything I usually eat even in a supermarket.

    To be honest, I just dont see how Americans that are healthy and slim are staying healthy and slim.
    Maybe they are going to the buffets and eating the right food too. I couldnt find any buffets in NY. I like them though since I can eat only meat & some veg. I have the way many places force meals upon you. Like chineses here where chips/rice/noodles are included in the price. I dont eat them and would perfer not to be forced to pay for crap I dont want. Same in some restaurants here, you just do without them, but get no more of the food you do like.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,817 ✭✭✭✭po0k


    Corn Syrup


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 6,820 ✭✭✭Archeron


    Its well and good to blame the availability of cheap fatty foods, takeaways, car cultures and so on, which is obviously a big part of the problem in countries like the US and Ireland.

    But the highest proportion of fat people in the world come from IMO more surprising places such as Nauru, Micronesia and Samoa.
    I've never been to these countries, so I dont know, but do they have massive car cultures, highways everywhere, KFC on every corner, or do they simply just eat way too much?

    This is a list of the worlds fattiest fatties, I'm surprised Ireland is so low down at no. 103

    http://people.monstersandcritics.com/news/article_1264808.php/Forbes_annual_Worlds_Fattest_People_list

    I've no idea who that website above is by either so it could be all rubbish, I just read yesterday in an old National Geographic mag that those islands are suffering an epidemic of obesity, and mother google threw the above as the first valid link.,


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,369 ✭✭✭✭ejmaztec


    I blame Desperate Dan and all of those people who make pies:p


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 640 ✭✭✭Kernel32


    I love the little stories people tell about all the junk food in America. They obviously don't get out very much when they are visiting.

    I live in a small city. There are two large supermarkets within 15 minutes of me that are entirely dedicated to natural healthy and organic food. Not a bit of high fructose corn syrup in sight. Each are easily as big as any Tesco's in Ireland and offer huge variety. In the summer there is a farmers market in town every week where I can buy organically grown very reasonably priced fruit and vegetables. A lot of local organic farms here offer a service whereby you pay a flat fee, say $300 and for the entire growing season you can do a weekly pickup at the farm of whats available. We have done this before and you can get enough vegetables to feed a large family every week.

    I'm not saying that there aren't a lot of over weight Americans. I am saying the stories about lack of availability of good food is complete BS.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 86,683 ✭✭✭✭Overheal


    Archeron wrote: »
    Its well and good to blame the availability of cheap fatty foods, takeaways, car cultures and so on, which is obviously a big part of the problem in countries like the US and Ireland.

    But the highest proportion of fat people in the world come from IMO more surprising places such as Nauru, Micronesia and Samoa.
    I've never been to these countries, so I dont know, but do they have massive car cultures, highways everywhere, KFC on every corner, or do they simply just eat way too much?

    This is a list of the worlds fattiest fatties, I'm surprised Ireland is so low down at no. 103

    http://people.monstersandcritics.com/news/article_1264808.php/Forbes_annual_Worlds_Fattest_People_list

    I've no idea who that website above is by either so it could be all rubbish, I just read yesterday in an old National Geographic mag that those islands are suffering an epidemic of obesity, and mother google threw the above as the first valid link.,

    with a name like Micronesia did you even bother to wiki that? The population is close to around 100,000 anyway. Dont know what they get up to but it is crazy to think about. Still not exactly weighing in around the same magnitude of the USA; population in excess of 300 million to date.

    Also more alarmingly: 1.6 Billion People are Overweight.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 6,820 ✭✭✭Archeron


    Overheal wrote: »
    with a name like Micronesia did you even bother to wiki that? The population is close to around 100,000 anyway. Dont know what they get up to but it is crazy to think about. Still not exactly weighing in around the same magnitude of the USA; population in excess of 300 million to date.

    Also more alarmingly: 1.6 Billion People are Overweight.

    Fair point about the population size, but still, how the hell could that proportion of people be overweight in any country?
    I thought maybe the nature of the country being lots of little islands means you cant run or walk too far before you fall into the sea, so people are more stationary :rolleyes:


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,387 ✭✭✭✭rubadub


    Kernel32 wrote: »
    I love the little stories people tell about all the junk food in America. They obviously don't get out very much when they are visiting.

    I'm not saying that there aren't a lot of over weight Americans. I am saying the stories about lack of availability of good food is complete BS.
    I would have been shocked if there was not a higher selection of healthy food in the US than here. You are absolutely right I for one did not "get out very much" in NY, I was there for a short time and was mainly shopping in the centre. In dublin I can go to any number of supermarkets and get stuff, but I live here and know where to go, but I did go to a supermarket and could not get a apple or normal cheese, any centra in town has them in dublin. Porbably could have found a place if I looked.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,525 ✭✭✭vorbis


    in fairness though, Ireland doesn't have a chain of shops ike 7 elevens. Supermarkets liek shaws have good food but 7 elevens are COMPLETELY full of junk food. I was in shock when I first visited one. It is wall to wall garbage. You'd have a hard time imagining such a shop could exist.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 640 ✭✭✭Kernel32


    rubadub wrote: »
    I would have been shocked if there was not a higher selection of healthy food in the US than here. You are absolutely right I for one did not "get out very much" in NY, I was there for a short time and was mainly shopping in the centre. In dublin I can go to any number of supermarkets and get stuff, but I live here and know where to go, but I did go to a supermarket and could not get a apple or normal cheese, any centra in town has them in dublin. Porbably could have found a place if I looked.

    On the flip side we spent nearly a month back in Ireland last year. We shopped at Tesco's and SuperQuinn many times and couldn't get anywhere near the variety in fresh food we get here. I think overall the quality was pretty good but we missed the fact that over here all the local supermarkets have a large section that is purely natural products, like a supermarket within a supermarket. I was surprized it hasn't caught on in Ireland yet but in time it probably will. The success of the chain natural food stores like Whole Foods and Wild Oats in the states has forced the large main stream supermarkets to stock more and more natural products. I think Whole Foods is opening in England now too, it's probably only a matter of time when it comes to Dublin.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 17,895 Mod ✭✭✭✭Manic Moran


    I think Samoans are just genetically massive. There are quite a few over my neck of the woods, I see no reason to believe they're eating any more or less than anyone else. Just seems to be the way they're built. I guess they might have been selectively bred to play Rugby?

    NTM


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 149 ✭✭SteveS


    Moonbaby wrote: »
    Not if you live in Shíthole City in Kentucky it isn't.
    Everything seems to be based on High Corn Fructose Syrup.

    Never been to ****hole City, but I used to live in Bumfart, Wisconsin. Despite all the large people, there is a fairly high demand for 'lite' food and low fat stuff. I live in a small town now that has a huge produce section and you can get healthy food if you avoid the prepackaged and processed stuff.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 6,820 ✭✭✭Archeron


    I think Samoans are just genetically massive. There are quite a few over my neck of the woods, I see no reason to believe they're eating any more or less than anyone else. Just seems to be the way they're built. I guess they might have been selectively bred to play Rugby?

    NTM

    LOL. Whats the Nauru'ans excuse? (more important, what are people from Nauru called?).

    Could a part of the problem be misleading packaging though? This probably seems like a cheap blaming act, but I often see larger people at the till, and a lot of the stuff they buy is diet this and low fat that.

    I was surprised recently to see a comparison on biscuits, (aptly enough) and the low fat version of a particular biscuit had more calories than the regular ones. I know nothing about nutrition, so really don't understand the mechanics of how that is, but it does show that some people might be just getting conned into buying particular products, hoping for a store bought miracle answer to their weight, but instead getting lumbered with even more calories. Of course, less pies would also be good, but I'm sure the real reasons for this are more complicated than everybody just being greedy monsters.

    I am seeing more and more people in Ireland who are beyond fat, and are really at "holy God" stage though, and I actually feel quite sad when I see somebody dealing with the very obvious physical limitations they endure due to something that in most cases can be dealt with. Its a tragic way for society to go.


  • Posts: 11,928 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Kernel32 wrote: »
    On the flip side we spent nearly a month back in Ireland last year. We shopped at Tesco's and SuperQuinn many times and couldn't get anywhere near the variety in fresh food we get here. I think overall the quality was pretty good but we missed the fact that over here all the local supermarkets have a large section that is purely natural products, like a supermarket within a supermarket. I was surprized it hasn't caught on in Ireland yet but in time it probably will. The success of the chain natural food stores like Whole Foods and Wild Oats in the states has forced the large main stream supermarkets to stock more and more natural products. I think Whole Foods is opening in England now too, it's probably only a matter of time when it comes to Dublin.


    I used to frequent one of these stores in NYC. Vegetarian heaven.
    Believe it or not, the range of fruit and vegetables available in Ireland has exploded over the last three years, thanks to immigration. Traditionally vegetables do not agree with Paddy.

    I have travelled the extensively through 3 of the top 10 states on the obesity scale, and there are plenty of "cities" where the identikit fast food parks and if they were lucky truck stop multipurpose stores seem to be the only source of sustenance.

    Diet foods are indicative of a problem and not a solution to me.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,398 ✭✭✭MIN2511


    Is it just me or does it cost more to eat healthy?
    My typical shopping list for a week cost me 45euro or more... :mad:
    Before xmas i wasn't bothered and shopping list for a week cost me 24euro:D
    Fruits are expensive! How the hell are we supposed to eat apples when it's cheaper and tastier to eat sausages...:confused:


    I live alone btw, although i have some rats(friends) over most times so i shop for them as well-fat bastards!:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 20,099 ✭✭✭✭WhiteWashMan


    49% of australians are overweight.

    to work off a can of full fat coke, you need to walk 3km.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,845 ✭✭✭2Scoops


    to work off a can of full fat coke, you need to walk 3km.

    Or, sit very still for an hour and a half. :rolleyes:


Advertisement
Advertisement