Transfer Window Movers and Shakers

cson · 31-12-2007 06:32PM

The amount of clubs he's played for most definitely shows that his attitude is not right

PSG
Arsenal
Real Madrid
PSG
Liverpool
City
Fenerbache
Bolton

And now Chelsea.

Quite a lot of clubs for a 28 year old.

Undoubted talent, somewhat ruined by his attitude. He could have been a lot better than he was. Should have stayed at Arsenal.

Chong · 31-12-2007 06:34PM

He definately should have stayed at Arsenal, he was class there, but like all players he wanted more money and moved to Madrid.

V1llianous · 31-12-2007 06:34PM

Helix wrote: »

2 right backs, a center back, a right or left winger, and a striker will do me at the villa

I'd like to propose a creative midfielder gets added to that and also the striker should be clarified as a prolific proven goal-scorer (20+) not another Harewood.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 06:35PM

His attitude at Arsenal stank but since then he has been alright, he was very popular at Liverpool

Chong · 31-12-2007 06:36PM

Mr Alan wrote: »

His attitude at Arsenal stank but since then he has been alright, he was very popular at Liverpool

When he was at pool , he was on Loan right?

Was there an attempt at the time to sign him permanently?

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 06:37PM

Houllier decided to sign diouf instead.

Among a lot of awful decisions made during that time, it still ranks as the worst for me.

The players and fans both wanted him signed.

eirebhoy · 31-12-2007 06:40PM

cson wrote: »

Back of the Indo reports Rafa interested in buying Richard Dunne. He was excellent on Sunday and while one game isn't everything Dunne has been excellent for City for some time now.

I remember they were linked with him a good few months ago too.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 06:44PM

That would be sweet

Tusky · 31-12-2007 06:46PM

I really dont rate Hunt as highly as some on here.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 06:48PM

its only Des Tusky, dont worry!

Chong · 31-12-2007 06:49PM

Big Ron looks like he could be heading back to Brazil:

http://goal.com/en-us/Articolo.aspx?ContenutoId=531098

Zapp Brannigan · 31-12-2007 06:50PM

I don't think Dunne would be good enough to replace a fully fit Agger, so I wouldn't like to see him move to Liverpool and warm the bench.

cson · 31-12-2007 06:51PM

Tusky wrote: »

I really dont rate Hunt as highly as some on here.

+1

He's done nothing out of the ordinary thus far this season. A good mid table club player but no more. It's not like he's a teenage prodigy, he's 26 ffs. Prime of his career.

As for Anelka, his attitude was crap at Arsenal, it was crap at Madrid, it was crap at PSG and it was crap at Fener.

He's just not able to man up when things don't go his way.

Vokes · 31-12-2007 06:56PM

Would love to have Dunne at Liverpool. He's come on leaps n bounds.

He might even give Carragher a run for his money (better in the air, better passer, possibly even reads the game better).

cson · 31-12-2007 06:57PM

Zapp Brannigan wrote: »

I don't think Dunne would be good enough to replace a fully fit Agger, so I wouldn't like to see him move to Liverpool and warm the bench.

Somewhat controversially to all you Pool fans, I think he'd be good enough to replace a fully fit Carragher. Based on this seasons form.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 06:58PM

Zapp Brannigan wrote: »

I don't think Dunne would be good enough to replace a fully fit Agger, so I wouldn't like to see him move to Liverpool and warm the bench.

Agger is still developing, Rafa intends on him to be first choice like carra within a season or two alright, but not quite yet imo. He is still developing (which is frightening), Rafa wanted Heinze to play alongside him as well as Carra in order to develop him more imo. Dunne would do the same job. He wont be playing every week. But it would mean we could give Carra the occassional rest, and not have to play Agger every week.

I think Agger is more than able to be first choice for liverpool already, i think he is an amazing young player, already one of the top CBs in the league. Gonna be a future club captain. And he can only get better playing with the likes of Carra and Dunne every week.

_blank_ · 31-12-2007 07:01PM

Mr Alan wrote: »

its only Des Tusky, dont worry!

Boo to you so.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 07:05PM

ah come on des, its new years, be nice!

Helix · 31-12-2007 07:07PM

PHB wrote: »

Brown's contract is up in the summer and I'm sure if a decent bid comes in (3 million plus) United will offload him unless he signs a new one.

united wont get £3m+ for a player a club can have for free in 6 months

id say theyd be happy enough with half that

Helix · 31-12-2007 07:08PM

cson wrote: »

Unlucky to be in the same side as Vidic and Ferdinand. I rate Brown highly, a good albeit often injured CB. He'd do well at the likes of Villa/Everton/Newky/City

villa were linked with him again today, id take him anyway

Helix · 31-12-2007 07:10PM

V1llianous wrote: »

I'd like to propose a creative midfielder gets added to that and also the striker should be clarified as a prolific proven goal-scorer (20+) not another Harewood.

i think we can do without the playmaker at the moment, that can wait til summer when we'll pay a more reasonable price and theres more players available

id absolutely love to see us try for anelka, whether we get him or not i dont care, but itd be a definite signal of intention

_blank_ · 31-12-2007 07:29PM

Mr Alan wrote: »

ah come on des, its new years, be nice!

Actually, screw it.

Happy New Year Mr Alan, I'm sure there'll be many more interesting and heated debates in Twenty Oh Eight.

Have a good one mate.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 07:37PM

you too mate

irishpartyboy · 31-12-2007 07:45PM

I wouldn't get too carried away there mate, he's a good young player with alot of potential.. the key word being potential. Time will tell, like with most young players.

Mr Alan wrote: »

Agger is still developing, Rafa intends on him to be first choice like carra within a season or two alright, but not quite yet imo. He is still developing (which is frightening), Rafa wanted Heinze to play alongside him as well as Carra in order to develop him more imo. Dunne would do the same job. He wont be playing every week. But it would mean we could give Carra the occassional rest, and not have to play Agger every week.

I think Agger is more than able to be first choice for liverpool already, i think he is an amazing young player, already one of the top CBs in the league. Gonna be a future club captain. And he can only get better playing with the likes of Carra and Dunne every week.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 07:49PM

wouldnt call it carried away.

he was played nearly all last season as part of the best defence with the best record in the league. He also can score goals and play football.

He had a nightmare against Chelsea in the CL semi final first leg.

He came back and had Drogba in his pocket for the second leg as well as scoring the goal that sent us to Athens-that shows the mental strenght of the chap.

Guy is brilliant.

irishpartyboy · 31-12-2007 07:59PM

What has he won? He's got massive potential.

Mr Alan wrote: »

wouldnt call it carried away.

he was played nearly all last season as part of the best defence with the best record in the league. He also can score goals and play football.

He had a nightmare against Chelsea in the CL semi final first leg.

He came back and had Drogba in his pocket for the second leg as well as scoring the goal that sent us to Athens-that shows the mental strenght of the chap.

Guy is brilliant.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 08:01PM

Dont be stupid. He is only young and has only had one season at Liverpool.

irishpartyboy · 31-12-2007 08:07PM

I didn't realize this was the school yard. He's got potential.

Mr Alan wrote: »

Dont be stupid. He is only young and has only had one season at Liverpool.

Mr Alan · 31-12-2007 08:10PM

He has the potential to be one of the best in the world.

He is already one of the best in the league.

mike65 · 31-12-2007 08:18PM

And whats this got to do with transfers? Bah!

Mike.

Transfer Window Movers and Shakers

Comments