Siemens CL75 Poppy

al. · 14-03-2006 01:25PM #1

Hi, im thinking of buying a Siemens CL75 Poppy mobile for my girlfriend. I was going to get her the Pink Razr but have heard so many complaints about it that i decided on the Siemens. The spec of the phone is not great but that does'nt bother her, she just wants a girlie phone! Has anybody bought one of these or heard anything about them? Any comments would be appreciated because i am undecided at this point.
Cheers,
Al.

link: http://www.benqmobile.com/cds/frontdoor/0,2241,hq_en_0_140543_rArNrNrNrN,00.html

chrislad · 14-03-2006 02:29PM

That's funny. You heard bad things about Motorola so you decided to go for Siemens? Better off to get her 2 cans and some string.

The Pink V3 is better than the black V3. Software is better. I HATE Motorolas, but I got one for my girlfriend and she loves it. Granted, it's only been a week, but no issues yet.

Cutie18Ireland · 14-03-2006 02:31PM

why not try the white nokia 6101... its a gr8 little phone and quite girly

TerrorFirmer · 14-03-2006 02:33PM

Cutie18Ireland wrote:

why not try the white nokia 6101... its a gr8 little phone and quite girly

The main problem I have with that phone is that its completely relying on the rare nokia flip phone feature to sell - its features are rather pathetic considering its price.

Although as a phone, price and features aside, its much more reliable then either the siemens or the v3 - both of which are very unreliable.

al. · 14-03-2006 06:11PM

Cheers for the comments, im still not convinced about the Siemens or the Razr. I had look at the Nokia 6101 and it kinda fits the bill although it seems a little pricey for what its offering. Can anybody suggest any alternatives or sugeest which phone of the three mentioned is the best bet?
Appreciate the comments,
Al.

BuffyBot · 14-03-2006 06:12PM

Siemens = bad news in my experience. SE Z520 might be a good flip option?

al. · 14-03-2006 06:38PM

BuffyBot wrote:

Siemens = bad news in my experience. SE Z520 might be a good flip option?

Yeah i jst had a look at that fone, looks really nice and the spec is pretty good aswell. I think u may have solved my problem! Cheers!!

chrislad · 14-03-2006 06:41PM

Spec on the Z520i isn't that much better than the 6101. Price wise, they are identical.

Main differences are that the Z520i has bluetooth and a slightly bigger memory, while the 6101 has a radio.

Random · 14-03-2006 06:56PM

Go for the z520i or the 6101.

Siemens and Motorola should be avoided in my opinion

Pythia · 15-03-2006 12:34AM

I'd never buy a Siemens. Hopefully BenQ will turn them around.

Siemens CL75 Poppy

Comments