Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Will there be a new generation of young Irish leaving the country?

2

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,643 ✭✭✭magpie


    Last time I left the country (between 1992 and 1997) every other funker got filthy rich buying houses before the boom. :mad:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    ionapaul wrote:
    You are right, there is a world of difference between those who have lived abroad for a few years and those who have stayed put, particularly the 'born in Dublin, bred in Dublin, never plan to leave Dublin' brigade! I certainly know who I'd rather hang out with at a party...
    Actually the people who resent living in Dublin and complain all the time about how it's a dive are the worst IMHO. Nothing worse than a bogger who wishes they didn't live here and say that things are better outside the city and in any other city. The Dublin born and bred are at least ill educated so their is some excuse. When educated people have a chip on their shoulder I find it worse. What many people fail to understand while things have changed part of the problem is people grow up and it is you who change the most first and foremost.

    Everywhere has problems and somtimes it is you who has the problem.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 65 ✭✭javelin


    I'm gonna move there, but now that you guys are speaking about it, it sounds so bad. is it really that bad living there? :)
    mostly interested in Dublin :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,643 ✭✭✭magpie


    I'm gonna move there, but now that you guys are speaking about it, it sounds so bad. is it really that bad living there?
    mostly interested in Dublin

    Don't worry you'll love it. We have

    1) The Swedish Food Company
    2) 'Totally Dublin' magazine which is run by Scandinavians
    3) That Swedish girl who used to work in the Thomas House, when it was open.

    Skoll!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    javelin wrote:
    I'm gonna move there, but now that you guys are speaking about it, it sounds so bad. is it really that bad living there? :)
    mostly interested in Dublin :)
    It's very Irish to complain :D We complain when things are good especially as we are afraid it will go bad. When things are bad we just muddle through but don't complain as much. :rolleyes:


  • Advertisement
  • Subscribers Posts: 8,325 ✭✭✭Scubadevils


    I am not complaining really about Ireland or Dublin given that its where I live, I have always wanted to live abroad and so now going to try it. There is lot I love about Ireland but equally a lot that I am sick of (for now). I'm sure when I move there will be things that annoy and faraway hills will be greener but thats life I guess! Fact still remains that life is short and there is a big world out there.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,264 ✭✭✭✭jester77


    Actually the people who resent living in Dublin and complain all the time about how it's a dive are the worst IMHO. Nothing worse than a bogger who wishes they didn't live here and say that things are better outside the city and in any other city. The Dublin born and bred are at least ill educated so their is some excuse. When educated people have a chip on their shoulder I find it worse. What many people fail to understand while things have changed part of the problem is people grow up and it is you who change the most first and foremost.

    Everywhere has problems and somtimes it is you who has the problem.

    I wouldn't say that everyone who's complaining resents living in Dublin, or anywhere in Ireland. People are fed-up with the rip off culture that has emerged from the celtic tiger. Yes there have been good things to come out of it, anyone that wants to work can now work. But at the same time prices have escalated at a ridiculous rate, far more than most people's salaries have risen. You only need to ask the majority of people who are working, there's nothing left at the end of the month. Families where there is only 1 person working are struggling to cope. The government have done a good job at getting jobs into Ireland and they have kept alot of people happy with the SSIA's and tax reductions throughout the last few years. Yet we still have a poor health system & poor public infastructure. Bus's and trains are a joke, if you live in the country and are lucky enough to be close to a train station the only place you can go is Dublin and that's on an old diesel train. Do a comparison of Ireland now and 15 years ago, health and transport facilities haven't changed much, but the prices have.
    You only need to live abroad for a while until you realise how much you are being ripped off. Insurance, groceries, clothes, communication, entertainment, etc... And the sad thing is most people are happy to accept that!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 65 ✭✭javelin


    magpie wrote:
    Don't worry you'll love it. We have

    1) The Swedish Food Company
    2) 'Totally Dublin' magazine which is run by Scandinavians
    3) That Swedish girl who used to work in the Thomas House, when it was open.

    Skoll!


    in all fairness, I'm not moving from sweden to meet swedes and eat swede food :)

    SKÅL! :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,643 ✭✭✭magpie


    I'm not moving from sweden to meet swedes and eat swede food

    What, you want to meet Irish people and eat Irish food? I wouldn't recommend it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 65 ✭✭javelin


    magpie wrote:
    What, you want to meet Irish people and eat Irish food? I wouldn't recommend it.


    haha, ok. why not?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,375 ✭✭✭ionapaul


    Actually the people who resent living in Dublin and complain all the time about how it's a dive are the worst IMHO. Nothing worse than a bogger who wishes they didn't live here and say that things are better outside the city and in any other city. The Dublin born and bred are at least ill educated so their is some excuse. When educated people have a chip on their shoulder I find it worse. What many people fail to understand while things have changed part of the problem is people grow up and it is you who change the most first and foremost.

    Everywhere has problems and somtimes it is you who has the problem.
    Hey, I like living in Dublin at the moment! No, I was just saying the 'born in Dublin, bred in Dublin, never willing to leave Dublin' brigade are often less interesting and fun people to engage with than those who have lived abroad and experienced more of life...IN MY HONEST OPINION, before someone jumped down my throat :) You see the same thing in many big cities, I knew a few New Yorkers who have never lived elsewhere and physically blanch at the thought of moving away from the Big Apple, which I find fairly pathetic.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    jester77 wrote:
    I wouldn't say that everyone who's complaining resents living in Dublin, or anywhere in Ireland.
    You should look up the word resent. You resent being ripped off from everything you say. Prices have gone up but some people seem to think it is all completely unreasonable. I don't subscribe to this belief that all things have gone up in price and that it is a rip-off "culture". How is it a culture? It's a business practice at most. Irish salaries, properties, employment were all some of the lowest in the EU in the 80s things are therfore cheaper than ever before because people can buy them! THey are more expensive than every where else because wages are the highest. There is extra profit being made here but don't belive the media hype that everything is a rip off. Economies of scale is one of our problems and it is never considered. Unless you break down costs in Ireland you don't know it is a rip off you just think it is.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    ionapaul wrote:
    Hey, I like living in Dublin at the moment! No, I was just saying the 'born in Dublin, bred in Dublin, never willing to leave Dublin' brigade are often less interesting and fun people to engage with than those who have lived abroad and experienced more of life....
    I agree with you but I find I meet more country people who go on about Dublin. When people say "Dublin is a mess but when I was in Australia. Perth was so..."
    JUst boring people who want to tell you they have been away. THey are the extreme. There are a lot of people I remember in college who hated Dublin but had to come here for education and are now here for work. They hate the place. THey are basically the same crowd of "staying where they grew up" but they have to come to Dublin so are even worse.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,709 ✭✭✭BolBill


    With some luck there will be. I'm sick of not getting a seat in the boozer.....


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,643 ✭✭✭magpie


    when I was in Australia

    I'd rather eat my own flesh than go to that cultureless penal colony.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,375 ✭✭✭ionapaul


    magpie wrote:
    I'd rather eat my own flesh than go to that cultureless penal colony.
    Ha :) One year working in an Irish bar in an Irish ghetto should not be classified as living abroad! Nothing worse than going somewhere new and then trying your hardest to do the familiar...though I suppose many people need the comfort of the familiar when removed from the womb-like protection of home.

    One of the greatest things about the American college system is the importance placed on the 'year abroad', wish we had it here. That said, most of our college educated folk will live abroad for a while in their 20s, while most Americans are less willing to move abroad once their college years are over.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,264 ✭✭✭✭jester77


    You should look up the word resent. You resent being ripped off from everything you say. Prices have gone up but some people seem to think it is all completely unreasonable. I don't subscribe to this belief that all things have gone up in price and that it is a rip-off "culture". How is it a culture? It's a business practice at most. Irish salaries, properties, employment were all some of the lowest in the EU in the 80s things are therfore cheaper than ever before because people can buy them! THey are more expensive than every where else because wages are the highest. There is extra profit being made here but don't belive the media hype that everything is a rip off. Economies of scale is one of our problems and it is never considered. Unless you break down costs in Ireland you don't know it is a rip off you just think it is.

    OK, maybe resent was the wrong word to use there. I love Ireland, great place, great people and great fun. But while living there I was on what was considered the "average" salary and I was scraping by at the end of the month and it wasn't like I was living the high life. Just rent, transport, bills, food, few drinks at the weekend. I'm now on the same wage here, doing the same things and I have alot extra cash at the end of the month. I don't read into the media hype, I just see it as it is!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    jester77 wrote:
    I'm now on the same wage here, doing the same things and I have alot extra cash at the end of the month. I don't read into the media hype, I just see it as it is!
    Well it proabably isn't the average wage there but a higher wage in relationship to there. The average wage in Ireland is different from the average wage in Dublin. Not every country has such a city divide but where it does it needs to be considered.
    If you "see it as it is" and don't examine it you might miss something. You should never just look at the surface. High minimum wage makes things expensive but more people benifit. I hear people go on about how good life is in the US. What people miss is the people at the bottom. Here we have automatic machines to issue tickets into car parks. In the use they use people! Why? It is cheaper to hire somebody than buy the machine. THe person working there probably works 3 or 4 jobs to survive. I have never seen poverty like I saw in the US in any other western country.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,264 ✭✭✭✭jester77


    Well it proabably isn't the average wage there but a higher wage in relationship to there. The average wage in Ireland is different from the average wage in Dublin. Not every country has such a city divide but where it does it needs to be considered.
    If you "see it as it is" and don't examine it you might miss something. You should never just look at the surface. High minimum wage makes things expensive but more people benifit. I hear people go on about how good life is in the US. What people miss is the people at the bottom. Here we have automatic machines to issue tickets into car parks. In the use they use people! Why? It is cheaper to hire somebody than buy the machine. THe person working there probably works 3 or 4 jobs to survive. I have never seen poverty like I saw in the US in any other western country.

    I'm not sure what the average wage here is but I don't think I am far off. Maybe I am missing something but here in Germany everyone can get by. They have a ridiculous welfare system, in that it is too generous. I know it's a bigger country so has more tax to pay for good infrastructure, health, etc. But I still think Ireland is being ripped off for things like insurance, groceries, entertainment, etc. I read just last week a magazine here that was talking about all the major festivals in Europe and gave prices for them. Oxygen was the most expensive by a good bit, even though some of the other festivals were over 3 days with big acts as well. That's just 1 example that came to me. But people will still pay! The first time any friend or family member visits me, they always without fail comment on how cheap they find things!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,942 ✭✭✭Mac daddy


    I'm leaving next year ( thank god )

    Reason cost of living

    The cost of rent,

    Can earn more money abroad for the same work that i'm doing,

    Crap public transport - lived in holland for 14 years then moved to ireland what a joke......


  • Advertisement
  • Subscribers Posts: 8,325 ✭✭✭Scubadevils


    Ireland is without doubt a lot more expensive for many things. One example that springs to mind (it may not be the best example but anyway) is a bottle of Jameson whiskey - Bought a bottle in Lanzarote last year and it was 13 euro, back here in Tesco the same bottle was 29! Thats a drink made here and sent all the way over there. I know the Canary Islands are tax free but that is a hell of a difference in price.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 25,000 ✭✭✭✭Sleepy


    Personally I'd love to move and will probably do so for a couple of years whenever I can get my finances sorted out enough to do so...

    We are ripped off in many ways in Ireland and most of it is state-sponsored. It's the corruption and culture of a "nod and a wink" that has things like insurance, house prices criminally high. Other things like restaraunts, bars etc are expensive due to minimum wage levels and then others (cinemas etc) are just expensive because we're so used to being ripped off that we don't think twice about spending a tenner to go see a new movie.


  • Subscribers Posts: 8,325 ✭✭✭Scubadevils


    Sleepy wrote:
    (cinemas etc) are just expensive because we're so used to being ripped off that we don't think twice about spending a tenner to go see a new movie.

    Yeah, and another tenner on popcorn and a drink!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    jester77 wrote:
    I read just last week a magazine here that was talking about all the major festivals in Europe and gave prices for them. Oxygen was the most expensive by a good bit, even though some of the other festivals were over 3 days with big acts as well. That's just 1 example that came to me. But people will still pay! The first time any friend or family member visits me, they always without fail comment on how cheap they find things!
    Geramny has a huge unemployment problem and we don't!!!! Give everybody a job in Germany and prices will go up. It's relative price!!! The example of a luxury like a music festival to indicate how great life is else where ignores many things. Germany for example has a small population of people with heraditorytory disabilities because they were sterilised by Hitler. Germany also got to design it's cities and country from scartch something we didn't do. You need to learn some economics and read some history. Once you have done that I suggest you look at the true nature of your society . I really don't want to be preachy but you are showing a real lack of applied knowledge to apply a life view on.
    Felixdhc wrote:
    Thats a drink made here and sent all the way over there. I know the Canary Islands are tax free but that is a hell of a difference in price.

    Yes the differnce of high insurance, high wages and an actual tax. What is the minimum wage there? What is insurance like? If you had been injured in the shop would you have been suitably renumerated? What is the percentage of the price of wiskey with relationship to the average wage.

    I really wonder if people understand how anything works if they can't figure out some basic economics. I really don't want to be preachy but we are talking very simple basic principles that our lives are based on.


  • Subscribers Posts: 8,325 ✭✭✭Scubadevils


    Yes the differnce of high insurance, high wages and an actual tax. What is the minimum wage there? What is insurance like? If you had been injured in the shop would you have been suitably renumerated? What is the percentage of the price of wiskey with relationship to the average wage.

    I really wonder if people understand how anything works if they can't figure out some basic economics. I really don't want to be preachy but we are talking very simple basic principles that our lives are based on.

    Minimum wage there is about 5 - 6 euro per hour from memory. Spain have some of the best employment laws and conditions in Europe. Insurance equally is always a big consideration in any tourist resort. I don't know what insurance costs are like there but I would be confident that they give the same cover as here.

    As for basic economics, I work in buying and selling electronics and my job involves suggested selling prices of the same products in the Irish market. I stress suggested as thats the law here. These products are bought mainly from the far east and cost the same to import to Ireland as any other EU country - Import duties are standard all over Europe. Shipping costs are also the same with any international shipping company. These same products end up costing in some cases over 20% more here than they do in another European country. There is no justifcation for a 20% difference in price regardless of insurance or minimum wage differences. In a lot of cases its simply down to greed.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,375 ✭✭✭ionapaul


    I'm actually waiting on my application for permanent residency in Canada to be processed, its been sitting in London since November and I probably won't hear a thing until next year! Crazy delays on these things, though I am fairly confident about being approved. Once I know for definite, then I need to make my decision, which obviously will be difficult. When I came back from the States a few years ago (under duress, my many many visas had run out :)) I really wanted to get out of Ireland ASAP, but over the past two years I'm no longer certain of this. Ireland has so many great things going for it, I really love Galway and Dublin. But I'd have about 50% of the purchase price of an ideal property in Canada should I move next year, which would really improve my quality of life going forward. Very tough decision.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,264 ✭✭✭✭jester77


    OK, Germany has a high unemployment, but the majority of those are unskilled people. Plus with the social welfare system being the way it is, anyone who was a high earner in their previous job will get more social aid than if they were to take the jobs that are available. Ridiculous system. The Irish government has done an excellent job with education, no one can deny that and that is the foundation to our low unemployment. The concert prices was just something that was fresh in mind from reading it last week, there are so many more examples. Felixhdc pointed out the price of Jameson in the Canarys. I can buy 2 1L bottles in my supermarket here for €28, less than price of 1 bottle at home. I could last year purchase a Dell PC (made in Ireland and shipped over) for less than in Ireland and that is taking the tax difference into account. I don't see why an exported Irish product is cheaper than at home!
    Yes, Germany were able to build from scratch after the war. But look at Ireland before the boom took off. There weren't as many houses and estates around, but people have been let build houses and estates anywhere with ease without any thought for roads or rail. This was greed on everyone's part. Roads and rail links could have been built during the boom of the 90's. Now we are at a stage where building a road costs way over what it should, greedy farmers, people against the roads because of where there houses are located, greedy companies, etc. Look at the Luas, how did it cost so much. The Australians were able to put a track from the north to the south through the outback for the same price.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    Felixdhc wrote:
    Minimum wage there is about 5 - 6 euro per hour from memory. Spain have some of the best employment laws and conditions in Europe. Insurance equally is always a big consideration in any tourist resort. I don't know what insurance costs are like there but I would be confident that they give the same cover as here.

    As for basic economics, I work in buying and selling electronics and my job involves suggested selling prices of the same products in the Irish market.

    I work on retail systems accross Europe and see the costs daily. 15% price increase in Ireland is easily explainable. There is extra profit being made here it's just not as high as people think. As you are also fully aware much of the stock that enters the country comes via english businesses or agenets that charge. Charges accross Europe for delivery may be standard in your field but over all they are different. It costs more to ship to Ireland for everything I am looking at right now so I don't know how electric companies operate (foods and general FMCG is my focus).
    Irish insurance payout is the highest in Europe so cover is not the same. Spain is cheaper because less people are employed and paid less.
    Due to property increases all new businesses have to charge more to get started too.
    Have a look at this and compare countries to understand we aren't anyway a bad country to live in. Whiskey is cheap enough for people to afford it's that simple

    http://www.nationmaster.com/index.php


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    jester77 wrote:
    OK, Germany has a high unemployment, but the majority of those are unskilled people.
    JUst because somebody is unskilled doesn't mean they aren't less human are deserving of a job.
    jester77 wrote:
    Plus with the social welfare system being the way it is, anyone who was a high earner in their previous job will get more social aid than if they were to take the jobs that are available. Ridiculous system.
    Worse than you think they are getting the whole country into debit.
    jester77 wrote:
    I could last year purchase a Dell PC (made in Ireland and shipped over) for less than in Ireland and that is taking the tax difference into account. I don't see why an exported Irish product is cheaper than at home!
    It's actually impossible. You just don't know how the bonded warehouse system works and have not considered Irish taxes applied prior to the finished product. THe germans may charge absolutely no tax on every part where we charge it on the parts and then the fixed product. Economies of scale too.
    jester77 wrote:
    Yes, Germany were able to build from scratch after the war. But look at Ireland before the boom took off. There weren't as many houses and estates around, but people have been let build houses and estates anywhere with ease without any thought for roads or rail.
    Every country with a huge increase in the economy suffers this. THe good comes with the bad. Greece is having worse problems.
    jester77 wrote:
    This was greed on everyone's part. Roads and rail links could have been built during the boom of the 90's. Now we are at a stage where building a road costs way over what it should, greedy farmers, people against the roads because of where there houses are located, greedy companies, etc. Look at the Luas, how did it cost so much. The Australians were able to put a track from the north to the south through the outback for the same price.
    That is just media hype you may think you have't listened to but how did you know there was trouble or expense. How did the farmer decide the price? They didn't government decided the price. (Claim corruption if you want). Greed was nothing to do with road protest quite the opposite. Better planning is always possible but at that speed it is difficult. Australia again paid all it's workers less money so it cost less. A lot of the land is not agricultural like here so it cost less. How long were they planning before they did it.
    I bitch and moan about Ireland too but try to balance the view by seeing what it is like everywhere.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,264 ✭✭✭✭jester77


    JUst because somebody is unskilled doesn't mean they aren't less human are deserving of a job.

    Yes, they are deserving, but alot of the jobs here require some form of skill. It's difficult for them to find work.
    Worse than you think they are getting the whole country into debit.
    Yes, it's getting serious. The upcoming elections will be very interesting. The Socialists want to increase VAT but people here won't accept that. The Germans complain about how bad the economy is yet they are not willing to make any compromises. I think the CDP will get into power this Autumn.
    It's actually impossible. You just don't know how the bonded warehouse system works and have not considered Irish taxes applied prior to the finished product. THe germans may charge absolutely no tax on every part where we charge it on the parts and then the fixed product. Economies of scale too.
    Was not aware of this, so it's sort of like VRT where you get done for double tax?
    That is just media hype you may think you have't listened to but how did you know there was trouble or expense. How did the farmer decide the price?
    I know from when I was living at home. They wanted to build a bypass around my local town, farmers were made an offer. Some took it, some didn't. The whole project got held up and in the end the farmers got a much larger price. Far more than they would ever have gotten if there land was bought for housing. I'm sure the situation is not much different in other parts of the country.

    I bitch and moan alot as well. But Ireland is in a better position than most countries. I just don't like the way alot of things are handled. Ireland could be a much better country than it is. One of my biggest concern is the amont of debt accumulated by everyone. I don't get the obsession Irish people have with property. Hope it doesn't come back to bite when interest rates increase.


Advertisement
Advertisement