Supernatural WW 2 - Game Thread

is anybody going to claim that crowley kill?

If you don't claim it, how is anybody supposed to counter claim it?

I wish for a gun to shoot clara

I wish for a peek to peek fritz

wasn’t me

I wish to steal those granted wishes

Any last words clara?

votes night 1 and 2:

state of play:

based on votes, i like the look of G and R for a wolf, and strawberry.

i think they are village, but it would be nice to know for sure.

I definitely should be on the discuss list based on my votes both nights.

Ah i thought it was a given.

I'd say there's a good chance G&R is well able to speak for themselves without you behaving like a angry mammy at the school gate 🤣

I don't think me saying "more likely village IMO" equates to "using this angle to frame villagers" but carry on anyway.

As I said above, those were two very poor calls (including wishing for a gun to shoot duffman) but I don't think a wolf makes those calls when they'd know 100% that they were wrong

Here's Trit's two FFAs:

Yesterday:

Wrestlemaniac: was wary of him yesterday, has done nothing today to change my mind. Spending his time shooting the breeze and not really getting us anywhere. Surfer wolf

Shane.c : Eager to please- has basically done as Neo suggest sand done nothing to share his own theories or analysis. He's just painting by numbers here with no original input. Jumped at the chance to join a wagon this afternoon and has done nothing to explore the game since. Domesticated wolf

Yossarian: In two minds here. There's been plenty of pointing to slippy posts by him, but at the same time he’s not screaming baddie. Started off well, but I got worried when he mixed up Azazrel death with village vig – felt very contrived tbh . I need to go over again, Are they scatty wolf?

Monday:

Wrestlemaniac: really hard to pin down. Everything feels like it could be spun if needed. They’re looking helpful but when you read back it’s not really going anywhere. One to keep an eye on

Neo: seems to be village grumpy old man. Not doing himself any favours with claims to have peeked players and his abrasive play. Village for the moment but might need to step things up a bit and stop fighting everyone

Shane.c : inconsistent- seems happy to slide in on the Neo wish giver train but backs away at the first challenge. Had a nice gentle spat with leg end. Are they distancing? Negative lean

Oscar: start of game I was like “holy sh!t what is this guy. I think I’ve a slightly better collar on him at this point. Granted he seems to be praying for a lynch half the time but best I can figure he’s village. He’s going to have to start helping out more soon though

Leg end: bothering me a lot. Seems to offer fluff and shade mainly. On a few occasions they seem to misrepresent things or create more confusion than they solve. Seems to have a thing for Oscar. Not getting a good lean here

Lord tsc : overall I like this look. Wants to consider what strategies might be used, doesn’t get caught in rabbit holes. Positive lean

So WM and Shane.c mentioned negatively on both days - maybe a wolf in one of these two as he'd surely mention 1 wolf in his 7 reads? Out of the two, it'd be WM for me

And Liz's FFA is this:

For me at the moment FFA are Duff (just the timing of his post around BJoe's demise) ThisIsIt (really a nothing post about gif, just a hunch lean) and maybe Clara (as no post yet I think) honestly I am conflicted about Oscar but I am leaning more village for him same also for Lord and Shane and Neo and GreenRed but will have a deeper look at the rest, I don't know what to make of Leggy, probably an overthinking villager

So maybe one wolf in This Is It and Clara - personally I'd go for This Is It but seems to be a lot going for Clarabel which I'm also okay with