Supernatural WW 2 - Game Thread

I didn't get my wish

posting what I’ve done so far cos I’ve got to have dinner and walk the dog. I’ll do FFA at 7

FRITZELLY - 3 posts on the opening evening, general chat and engaging with others. Next post late Sunday afternoon and it’s another jokey post. There had been posts by many others regarding the game but they didn’t join in to any conversations. Posted again but to no one in particular after the Samuel flavour death . Joins the conversation Sunday night regarding wishes. That was their last post. 

Aside from their Saturday evening posts, nobody has engaged with Fritzelly, myself included. They’re not pushing themselves to be heard either. I can’t decide what way they lean yet. 

Update: they posted again saying same thing as before. Lots of players responded and now they’ve disappeared again! Wolfy lean

OSCARMILDE - Chatting to anyone and everyone. Not afraid to get stuck into conversations that lead to them being the subject of the conversation. Leaning Village

GREEN&RED - First post straight into the game and in a good way too as it was bringing some clarity to what the bad team consists of. I liked their 2nd post too as it was all about helping the village. Straight into the game and its mechanics again this afternoon. I don’t see anything false in the way they’re posting. Leaning Village

LEGENDREJECT - Not afraid to question everything and throw shade around. Puts them on the radar. Would a wolf want to be the centre of attention? Or is that the play?Leaning village for now. 

ELECTRIC NITWIT - tells us he’ll be posting less and reading more this game. Next post 

Doing the numbers. Asking about Alpha and reincarnated one. Banter chat. Tongue in cheek calling leg or Lord a wolf. Filler post. Filler post. Lots of filler posts. Is the first one to do a reads list just after lunch. Everyone is either neutral or village lean on it. Says leggy is nearest to a wolf lean even though they also class them as a try hard villager. Then in there next post to neo says his lean for neo (or ShaneC) to slight village but they were already that on his reads list. Few lists this afternoon.

To summarise I think EN is getting the posts in without really saying anything of substance. There’s no suspicion on anyone in any post. No tree shaking. Wolfy Lean. 

NEOWISE - straight out of the stalls and went with a wish. Knowing now that the Samuel death was just flavour has reduced my suspicions. It was strange not seeing overnight neo posts and holiday mode neo has a chilled out (for neo) posting style.  Gonna stick with a neutral read for now. 

MACDANGER - when Kolido death announced said “nice one”. Filler post and tagged the non posters and says yoss “genied” to it but yoss had previously been tagged. Wishes for a peek at 2.30ish (a wish has been granted just before 6). Has a little dig at Lorcan. Leggy joins in shading Lorcan. This is before the 3 thing which Lorcan implicated in. BJ dead so Mac going to investigate. Comes back and lists those who BJ interacted with but somehow forgets my exchange with BJ. Tells leggy her 3 theory is an interesting spot. The more I type here the more I see a gameplay setup between Mac and Leggy. I’m leaning wolf and will reevaluate Leggy if need be. 

Sorry folks RL has put me into a bit of catch up here. I don’t have reads on everyone yet but here’s my thinking so far on read back( boards functionality is going to break me btw)

Wrestlemaniac: really hard to pin down. Everything feels like it could be spun if needed. They’re looking helpful but when you read back it’s not really going anywhere. One to keep an eye on

Oscar: start of game I was like “holy sh!t what is this guy. I think I’ve a slightly better collar on him at this point. Granted he seems to be praying for a lynch half the time but best I can figure he’s village. He’s going to have to start helping out more soon though

Leg end: bothering me a lot. Seems to offer fluff and shade mainly. On a few occasions they seem to misrepresent things or create more confusion than they solve. Seems to have a thing for Oscar. Not getting a good lean here

Neo: seems to be village grumpy old man. Not doing himself any favours with claims to have peeked players and his abrasive play. Village for the moment but might need to step things up a bit and stop fighting everyone

Shane.c : inconsistent- seems happy to slide in on the Neo wish giver train but backs away at the first challenge. Had a nice gentle spat with leg end. Are they distancing? Negative lean

Lord tsc : overall I like this look. Wants to consider what strategies might be used, doesn’t get caught in rabbit holes. Positive lean

Wrestlemaniac is hard to pin down?