Car insurance - tell us your quotes/renewals

passatman86 · 22-05-2021 10:46AM

Just renewed, not happy but didn't expect much.
Rang around and current insurers was cheapest

2010 avensis "own nearly 6 years"
Full licence male 35 y/o
10 + years no claims
Fully comprehensive
€710
Parked driveway, 10-12k kilometres a year
Was getting quotes of €800 plus elsewhere

Hear others getting €500 or so with similar details but not for me it seems

on_the_roots · 23-05-2021 12:20PM

mankteln wrote: »

Renewal coming up next month and AA are offering €950 so been shopping around, cheapest I've found so far is its4women at €711. They don't offer any no claims bonus protection which I have at the moment(and having started off with no no claims bonus I know that's worth it's weight in gold!) so not keen to switch to them. AXA (who I was with previously) are offering €840 and they have some protection (it's step back so you lose a year), anyone know what other companies offer NCB protection at this stage (lots tend not to offer it until you're full/5+ years)

Sorry for my ignorance, but what is the point with NCB Protection? I never understood this.

If you have a claim it will be registered on your name and every quote that asks for claims on last 5 years will definitely put up prices for you anyway, no matter how many years you have left on your NCB certificate.

Can you help me understand what is the advantage of having this protection?

CoBo55 · 23-05-2021 02:39PM

on_the_roots wrote: »

Sorry for my ignorance, but what is the point with NCB Protection? I never understood this.

If you have a claim it will be registered on your name and every quote that asks for claims on last 5 years will definitely put up prices for you anyway, no matter how many years you have left on your NCB certificate.

Can you help me understand what is the advantage of having this protection?

You don't go back to zero years. I made a claim in 2017 which put me back to having 3 years NCB on my cert, this is my last year being penalised (€22) for making that claim. If I hadn't had NCB protection I would have another 3 years to go.

on_the_roots · 23-05-2021 04:11PM

CoBo55 wrote: »

You don't go back to zero years. I made a claim in 2017 which put me back to having 3 years NCB on my cert, this is my last year being penalised (€22) for making that claim. If I hadn't had NCB protection I would have another 3 years to go.

In your case, this claim penalized you by only €22/year during 3 years?

wotzgoingon · 23-05-2021 04:27PM

on_the_roots wrote: »

In your case, this claim penalized you by only €22/year during 3 years?

Don't you worry both me and you were punished though for his claim. :eek:

CoBo55 · 23-05-2021 06:31PM

on_the_roots wrote: »

In your case, this claim penalized you by only €22/year during 3 years?

No, the loading for this year's renewal was only €22 according to the breakdown of the premium.

CoBo55 · 23-05-2021 06:34PM

wotzgoingon wrote: »

Don't you worry both me and you were punished though for his claim. :eek:

What do you mean by that smart arse?
My 6 week old car was vandalised to the tune of more than €3000. I claimed on my own insurance. It was probably done by someone with the same mindset as yourself.

Wheety · 27-05-2021 11:31AM

Male and female: Both 40
Dublin
Hyundai i30

AIG 397.43
Liberty 440.09
123.ie 475.76
AXA 610.55 Supervalu same price
FBD 519.38
Zurich (OneBigSwitch) 400
Zurich 387
Its4women 359

Here's what I have so far. I know it's not an exact comparison as there are different levels of cover and excess etc.

Think I'll go with Its4women. That's with €0 voluntary excess and the 'Premier Plus' added which includes compulsory excess reduced from €450 to €300 and roadside assistance with homestart. I'm sure some people sign up not realising that they have a compulsory and voluntary excess. As standard without changing anything it would be €750. I'm currently with them and renewal is €405 :rolleyes:

Interesting that the Zurich through OneBigSwitch is actually dearer despite meant to be having a bigger discount.

The SuperValu comment is there because AXA are the actual insurers. You get SuperValu rewards through it but as you can see it's a lot more expensive than the others so you're paying for those 'rewards'. Also, the €30 of rewards they give is 2 x €10 off a €40 spend and 1000 points. We wouldn't spend €40 in one go in SuperValu really so not much use to me.

Any others I should try before going ahead? I'm going to buy today.

Just tried AIG again and it's €371. Due for renewal on 1st June. Does it get cheaper the closer you get?

Wheety · 29-05-2021 02:07PM

I went with Aviva in the end €348

I'm never sure if I should purchase no claims protection or what level to choose. Went with step back this time. Was around €330 with no protection and over €360 with full protection.

Male (with wife added too) both 40
2015 Hyundai i30
Low mileage
Dublin

29-05-2021 04:34PM

StonedRaider wrote: »

Added a named driver ( she MIGHT even drive the car once a year) and quote reduced by about €100

Same here

Effects · 31-05-2021 04:53PM

Had been insured with 123.ie for the past few years, and usually just went with their renewal price.
Had an issue this year where the website wouldn't accept payment via card, and I tried three of them.
I wasn't in a position to call them on the phone, and their email response was terrible, so I ended up switching with chill.ie, to Allianz, for €382 on a 2008 Golf. About €100 cheaper that 123.ie.
Had about a week where the car wasn't insured, as I couldn't get in touch with 123. But it was off the street and not being driven during that period.

Wheety · 01-06-2021 08:52AM

I can't edit my post but my price with Aviva was actually €338. I know it's only a tenner but I thought it was a good price, compared to others I was getting.

AlfaZen · 01-06-2021 11:57AM

Got my Renewal notice from Aviva last weekend

Last years Premium - €432
This years renewal quote - €476

Male; 42; Full ROI License for 18 years; Zero Claims and zero Penalty points
2012 Audi A5 sportback 2.0 TDI

Other Quotes -
Aviva (as new customer) - €450
FBD - €339
Axa - €545
123.ie - €409
Allianz - €397
Zurich - €643
The AA - €590

Will probably be going with FBD this year. I'm surprised my quote from Aviva went up this year after all my mileage as dropped to practically nothing

Wheety · 01-06-2021 01:36PM

Try its4women. You have to print your own docs and be careful of the voluntary excess as there's also a compulsory one of 300. I reduced the voluntary to 0 and still got a decent quote.

02-06-2021 09:55AM

Wheety wrote: »

Try its4women. You have to print your own docs and be careful of the voluntary excess as there's also a compulsory one of 300. I reduced the voluntary to 0 and still got a decent quote.

OH had a nightmare dealing with getting insurance set up with its4women and her situation was very straightforward (no claims & all documents in order). She says it wasn't worth the effort

CoBo55 · 02-06-2021 02:34PM

Mr Hoppy wrote: »

OH had a nightmare dealing with getting insurance set up with its4women and her situation was very straightforward (no claims & all documents in order). She says it wasn't worth the effort

How? The most you need to do is send them a copy of your licence both sides and the NCB cert.

totover · 03-06-2021 04:54PM

Hey everyone.

So let me explain this.

After a 3rd attempt recently and failing at driving test for full license I'm resigned to the fact that it just won't happen anytime soon especially with covid. No serious incidents or mistakes but unlikely to pass either.

So lets leave the testing business aside as I know where I stand with that.

Re Insurance, in an ideal i would have the full license and have the pick of most situations. I'm not going to get any better value with full license as compared to the learner permit. Simple as that. We can all agree on that

Now im accepting i will be still on the permit for a while. I need either to iron out mistakes in another car or simply keep paying an instructor. Of those 2 choices a car is currently the better choice. An instructor won't spend all day going over the same issue whereas in car I can do that.

Again I know with the provisional a qualified driver needs be with you. We'll get that sorted if necessary

My main question based on what i have just told you is; I need to know what the best move for me in terms of insurance are to
"pay into the pot"so to speak and build up my insurance profile

I know the choices I have in relation to fixing my driving habits. But I'm basically thinking alongside the practice I need to start paying in to pot sooner rather than later

It's all relative. I assume if I don't pay now I will pay later so whats the odds

totover · 03-06-2021 05:26PM

Insurance or instructor

new2tri19 · 06-06-2021 09:32AM

2013 smax 40 year old €320 (20 years no claims )

Interestingly I was rear ended last month I suffered a low back soft tissue damage was fairly stiff for a few days , bumper had slight crack also so rang insurance company to inform them .
Insurance renewal came as €995 because I had reported the claim and had a claim open . I didn't claim as my back healed within a couple of days and car got a quick check over in garage and was fine .
When I rang to close off claim the woman in claims department was telling me to claim , she said they'll most likely offer you money without challenging the claim , I was disgusted with this , I told her this is why insurance is so expensive . She wasn't seen my point at all and arguing insurance is expensive through fraud not genuine claims .
Anyway as I explained to her the guy that hit me will be receiving a letter saying his insurance has gone from 320 to 900+ but she didn't get my point .

Eggs For Dinner · 06-06-2021 03:28PM

From your own description, your car was damaged and you suffered soft tissue injury as a result of negligence by another motorist. Why are you so offended by the advice your insurer gave you to claim for a legitimate loss? That's what insurance is for and bears no relation to fraud

Anyway, I hope your injuries don't come back at you later, can't have been nice

new2tri19 · 06-06-2021 08:05PM

Eggs For Dinner wrote: »

From your own description, your car was damaged and you suffered soft tissue injury as a result of negligence by another motorist. Why are you so offended by the advice your insurer gave you to claim for a legitimate loss? That's what insurance is for and bears no relation to fraud

Anyway, I hope your injuries don't come back at you later, can't have been nice

There was a small crack in the bumper which would have been a massive over reaction to change . You had to get a magnifying glass to see it .
I was fine after a couple of days so when renewal quote came a few weeks later I was healed 100% , so there's no need for any compensation I'm uninjured and car is in perfect working order , but the insurance claims department where encouraging me to claim on the basis that the other party had admitted liability it will likely be an uncontested offer . I just don't see why someone in that situation should be actively encouraged to claim . The whole claim culture is gone crazy , to a man everyone I spoke to that day recalling what happened said " claim , you'll get thousands " .

Eggs For Dinner · 07-06-2021 07:07AM

You suffered damage and a soft tissue injury. If you don't want to claim for that, that's your own decision. My point is that you seem to have taken offence to the correct options given to you by your insurers

djan · 09-06-2021 02:23PM

Coming up to my renewal so shopping around. Only have one year's policy holder NCB now compared to 4yrs named driver when I got my own policy last year. Some quotes are actually coming in as more due to having less years NCB even if they were named driver.

Surely with an additional NCB it should go down? If anyone has any recommendations for brokers etc please let me know. Thank you!

DeKing · 09-06-2021 05:16PM

djan wrote:

Coming up to my renewal so shopping around. Only have one year's policy holder NCB now compared to 4yrs named driver when I got my own policy last year. Some quotes are actually coming in as more due to having less years NCB even if they were named driver.

djan wrote:

Surely with an additional NCB it should go down? If anyone has any recommendations for brokers etc please let me know. Thank you!

Did you try AXA they take both your NCB and named driver into account.

djan · 10-06-2021 01:57PM

DeKing wrote: »

Did you try AXA they take both your NCB and named driver into account.

Thanks, tried that and managed to get 75 eur less. Noot too bad but honestly was expecting a bit more of a discount for a year worth of main NCB. Swear I could type up my details for a quote blind but will keep at it :cool:

gussieg · 11-06-2021 10:32AM

has anyone noticed fluctuation in quotes depending on day of the week and time ? weekends seem to go up, as do any out of hours .tuesdays seems to be a good day about 11am

New Home · 14-06-2021 11:25PM

The AA have quoted me €200 more than last year, despite my having done fewer kms than foreseen (what with the whole working from home and all) and having one extra year no claims bonus. I've made it clear last year that I did not want to get any further communications from them (I opted out of everything available on their privacy settings and I confirmed this over the phone) - despite this, I got 3 texts, 3 emails and one phone call in the space of a week. I'm not impressed in the least.

scudzilla · 14-06-2021 11:32PM

Bit of a mad one here

Last year i paid 575, fully comp, mcb protected for my wife and i driving a 2010 megane, got my renewal at 540, got quotes from chill/123 and they came in at 436/437, so i ring Allianz
Gave them my reg and they said 7 seater Grand Scenic, told them it was a megane and had to supply copy of logbook.
They rang me back today, said they'd change vehicle on system and new quote is cheaper due to car, came in at 470, asked them could they match others, within 20 seconds it was 430
Also, they said i've been over paying due to their error for last 3yrs so will be getting a refund

New Home · 20-06-2021 08:18PM

If anyone needs it, FBD have a discount code, too: SAVE50.

So far, the best quote I got was a little over €500 with AIG, the worst was the guts of €1200 but I can't even remember who it was that rang because the price was just ridiculous.

Pekarirska · 20-06-2021 08:34PM

2006 Corolla Verso 1.6
45 years old with 10 years NCB and no points.

Renewal from AIG €350 fully comp, new AIG quote €450. Chill came very close, the rest of the gang €500 plus.

Car insurance - tell us your quotes/renewals

Comments