Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

The Witcher Werewolf - GAMETHREAD

1…4546485051…72

Comments

  • #1412
    Holly WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,531 ✭✭✭Holly WW


    Gertrude WW wrote: »
    Okay so I'm trying to be more well rounded so I've started doing reads of all remaining players starting from the bottom up

    Holly

    - Asks questions about voting on lynch thread
    - Only people that stuck out to her are Phil and Lucy, votes Lucy
    - Has an FFA in mind but doesn’t want to post without proper reasoning, will post later
    - Says she will post FFA after omellette
    - Voted Lucy for aggressive switch, gave Phil benefit of the doubt
    - ISOs Liam, Jake and Derry
    - Thinks Liam is playing like someone clued in but also acting like noob
    - Says Jake wasn’t up to much when he flipped out, could be frustrated villager or agro wolf
    - Questions Derry BG protect
    - Can’t understand hard on for Jake
    - Notes interaction between Barbara and Phil as cosy
    - Thinks Nigel was trying to pocket Barbara and distance himself from Gabriel
    - Thinks Gabriel is Nigels team mate
    - FFAs Gabriel, Liam and Phil. Votes Gabriel
    - Questions Gabriel over interest in monster team and if role hunting Derry
    - Says she’s mentioned Nilfgards and Striga
    - Admits theory on Gabriel is unbalanced but supported her theory of Nigel/Gabriel team
    - Questions Orla being confirmed by Derry and Phil, says this could happen with non-NRV roles with two baddie teams
    - Asks Emily does Jake know her identity from the BR



    Not sure what to make of Holly, having more posts to go through would definitely help. She voted in the main wagon on Day 1 and an outlier vote on Day 2. She got heat for her vote on Lucy so could have changed tactic to an outlier. At time of voting Lucy wasn’t looking like she would turn into a wagon so maybe by the time she realised it was too late to change? She ISOs Jake and then questions if he’s a frustrated villager or agro wolf and doesn’t understand the hard on for him, this would normally stand out to me but as it’s similar to what I was thinking last night I can’t read into it too much. She was pretty strong in her efforts against Gabriel yesterday and stuck with her vote, this could be a wolf monster hunting though. I don’t understand the non-NRV thing in regard to baddies, it’s a weird way of phrasing it if she can confirm that? Questioning Orla, Phil and Derry after Derry got a wolf kill is strange, not that I’m saying they should be believed blindly but it’s looking pretty good for those three. As it stands I could see her being a potential wolf but she hasn’t got enough posts to make a solid argument so that’s something I’d like to see more of today

    Your summary of my actions were more or less accurate, but I bolded the bullet points that weren't.

    I wasn't admitting that my theory of Gabriel being on a team with Nigel was unbalanced. I was stating the Gabriels interest on thread in the Monsters team outweighed her mentions of the Nilf team. Thus supporting my theory. Honestly I haven't let go of this as of now either.
    Conor WW wrote: »
    Seriously, how are people still doubting Phil being a roled villager? He had tasks and won prizes. Peeked Orla first, poisoned Vernon (oops) second.

    Derry says Orla is DOUBLE CONFIRMED
    Gertrude WW wrote: »
    Phil done tasks and won prizes which he used on thread and there's been no counterclaim. If Orla was the black knight then Phils peek would have game back good but Derrys would have came back bad but both came back NRV

    In regards to doubting Phil, Orla and Derry, I genuinely didn't get wtf was going on with Phil. I was really speed reading and head not in the game on D1 and i think that affected my understanding of some of the things that were going on yesterday. The two posts I quoted above have more or less straightened it out.

    "Questions Orla being confirmed by Derry and Phil, says this could happen with non-NRV roles with two baddie teams"

    I was saying that just because she'd been cleared from one bad team, didn't mean she was cleared from the other. Once again, now that I get what went on with Phil, happy enough to let this bit slide.

    Think I've explained a couple times my voting patterns. But I'll give it another shot. Day 1 I was too busy and not keeping up with the game as much as I wanted, went with 2 gut reads (both wrong!) for my FFA and voted with my gut cos Lucy's aggressive post had really rubbed me the wrong way. Though to be fair I voted her early enough and didn't rally for a bandwagon.

    Day two, I did ISOs, formed theories, voted in accordance. And honestly I still think my reasoning on Gabby can stand. If I had to vote right this second, I'd vote for her again, but I suppose much can happen during the day


  • #1413
    Ewan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 2,568 ✭✭✭Ewan WW


    Angus WW wrote: »
    I’ll expand on that

    Their voting patterns

    Conor is on the same counter wagon both nites. Strange on two accounts
    Eva is away from any kind of a wagon both nites, fair enough D1 but D2 she’s just avoiding trouble

    Ewan for his shifting votes, obviously I did similar but I know I’m good

    So you want to string me up for something you did the exact same on both nights?

    Late votes on Lucy and Jake.

    Earlier you said I wasnt a wolf so which is it Angus, you seem to spinning a narrative that keeps me at the forefront and your own opinions dont actually matter


  • #1414
    Ewan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 2,568 ✭✭✭Ewan WW


    And Conor, your lack of interest in actually reading my posts is infuriating me.

    I'm gonna go back and quote every single post I mentioned Phil in from when I came online Monday.


  • #1415
    Holly WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,531 ✭✭✭Holly WW


    Emily WW wrote: »
    Oh, I take it backrooms don't look like boards then? If not, then perhaps I was too definite in my condemnation of Vernon so I'll suspend that until everyone has posted for today

    I don't like this. Butter wouldn't melt!


  • #1416
    Ewan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 2,568 ✭✭✭Ewan WW


    For the attention of lazy Conor

    Ewan WW wrote: »
    tenor.gif


    Gosh I'm sooooo sorry folks I got snowed under till now. Have read up a bit on the thread.

    Frank munched - seems a pure role hunt there, the loon was posting Geralt gifs.

    Phil is acting a bit manic, really stands out which is exactly NOT what a wolf does imo.

    Gabby very defensive this morning towards Franky but I've liked their responses to Babs tbf.

    That's all I've kinda got for now, aside from Conor being a chatty Kathy
    Ewan WW wrote: »
    I dunno, I think the tendency a lot is to suspect the highest posters simply because they say more than anyone else. Meanwhile the lower and mid-range posters just skate by for days because nobody is paying any attention to them*.


    *I'm aware I'm in that echelon currently but I've been busy. Will be more active from now.
    Ewan WW wrote: »
    Why are we lynching Phil again? Is he not claiming the bard? Does that not completely tie into his posts all day like?
    Ewan WW wrote: »
    He's quoted mistruths all day though:



    I think it adds up tbh.
    Ewan WW wrote: »
    If the bard is tasking on thread he probably has no choice tbh.

    Which means we might have other taskers in play


  • Advertisement
  • #1417
    Conor WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 5,361 ✭✭✭Conor WW


    Ewan WW wrote: »
    And Conor, your lack of interest in actually reading my posts is infuriating me.

    I'm gonna go back and quote every single post I mentioned Phil in from when I came online Monday.

    I’m doing it I’m doing it!

    Would you go and eat another snickers, please!


  • #1418
    Gabriel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,635 ✭✭✭Gabriel WW


    Angus:

    Defends Phil early on.
    Says there's nothing to suggest a task for N0 kill.
    N1 20.48 says he's voting for one of the people on 2 votes. At this stage there are 2 votes on me, Conor, Liam and Lucy. Votes for Lucy at 20.59. Doesn't really give any reason for voting for Lucy only that he didn't want to vote for Phil or Barbara. Gives no reason for not even considering voting for me, conor or liam though. Convenient that he picks the person that gets lynched.
    Has engaged with Barbara on thread and supported.
    Brings up and discusses Derry's protect from the Striga bite. I didn't want to discuss this on the thread as I had copped that she was Yennefer. Didn't like this from Angus at all. Acting like the Kikimora who was unhappy his teammates bite got deflected.
    Yesterday at 19.42 he says he doesn't believe Phil but won't vote for him? Votes for me at 20.24 but switches late to Jake again.
    I just don't think there's a great look about him so I think he's a good candidate for a lynch tonight.


  • #1419
    Phil WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,145 ✭✭✭Phil WW


    Holly WW wrote: »
    I don't like this. Butter wouldn't melt!

    Didn't Emily claim to be a new player?


  • #1420
    Conor WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 5,361 ✭✭✭Conor WW


    Conor WW wrote: »
    #IFIMDEADREADTHIS

    If Phil is lynched or munched and returns village. Please read all posts prior to this one and go through who was both being subtle and/or direct in wanting him lynched tonight.

    If Phil returns evil. Don’t waste your time reading anymore of my hashtag posts :D
    Ewan WW wrote: »
    tenor.gif


    Gosh I'm sooooo sorry folks I got snowed under till now. Have read up a bit on the thread.

    Frank munched - seems a pure role hunt there, the loon was posting Geralt gifs.

    Phil is acting a bit manic, really stands out which is exactly NOT what a wolf does imo.

    Gabby very defensive this morning towards Franky but I've liked their responses to Babs tbf.

    That's all I've kinda got for now, aside from Conor being a chatty Kathy

    Yes, Ewan. You piped up and started to post on thread AFTER Phil had to a good as spell it out to players what he’d being doing. My post was before yours so I have nothing to apologise for.

    Whilst your possible team mate or mates were sowing seeds of doubt on Phil, you could watch from the sidelines and say nothing. They were doing the work and you could show you wasn’t involved in the possible Phil lynch. Distancing at its finest.


  • #1421
    Phil WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,145 ✭✭✭Phil WW


    I think Angus is Kikimora.

    He has posted nothing but drivel and seems to be just having the craic because he realises that it's a long road to victory without his buddy.


  • Advertisement
  • #1422
    Orla WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,233 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    How wolfy did I look to be peeked twice! Jaysis :(


  • #1423
    Ewan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 2,568 ✭✭✭Ewan WW


    Conor WW wrote: »
    Yes, Ewan. You piped up and started to post on thread AFTER Phil had to a good as spell it out to players what he’d being doing. My post was before yours so I have nothing to apologise for.

    Whilst your possible team mate or mates were sowing seeds of doubt on Phil, you could watch from the sidelines and say nothing. They were doing the work and you could show you wasn’t involved in the possible Phil lynch. Distancing at its finest.

    I HADN'T POSTED AT ALL

    What is your malfunction, would you like a print out of my call stats for Monday as proof or something


    Your post is nonsense and the SEER even states you were hedging with it so using it as some sort of smoking gun is terrible evidence against ANYONE

    Take your distancing and shove it, I couldn't get online till after work on Monday

    Child minding all day Sunday and spending time with them as I worked 6 days last week

    Work from 8.30 to 5pm Monday.


    Grand for some of you who get to work from home and have time to make stupid idiotic rules about when someone posted or didnt.


    Go ahead and lynch me over it, I'm done responding to you Conor and your stupid arrogance


  • #1424
    Orla WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,233 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    Phil WW wrote: »
    I think Angus is Kikimora.

    He has posted nothing but drivel and seems to be just having the craic because he realises that it's a long road to victory without his buddy.


    You know what Phil, I am somewhat on board with Angus being bad myself!


  • #1425
    Angus WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,977 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Phil WW wrote: »
    I think Angus is Kikimora.

    He has posted nothing but drivel and seems to be just having the craic because he realises that it's a long road to victory without his buddy.


    Well you've been spot on with your reads so far, peeked an NRV and poisoned Ciri


  • #1426
    Conor WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 5,361 ✭✭✭Conor WW


    giphy.gif?cid=4d1e4f299fb9a83b31e14c263870665f8d3aaf7fd2b99d45&rid=giphy.gif


  • #1427
    Orla WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,233 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    Holly WW wrote: »
    Okay been through Nidge's posts looking for anything useful about his teammate



    Accusing Babs of pocketing Gabby.





    Backtrack?



    Throws a little shade at Babs, backtracks, bows out.



    This is in relation to Conor's suggestion for the hashtags. I read this as pockety. Sure, there's room for jokes, but its not "not a bad idea" its a horrific idea, we have FFAs which're nice and organised, as opposed to everyone tagging with "all my posts are important". So... That seems pockety to me.



    I'm wondering if the back and forth with Babs might've been to pokcer her and throwing Gabs in there was for distance.



    Concerned?



    Hard defence of Phil



    So after being cosy with Babs, he votes for her. Sticks to his word, throws Gabs in 2nd on FFA. I am suss of this being distancing from Gabs.



    I just quoted this to cross reference with the lynch thread and see if he's screwed around at all. He hadn't.



    Voting to save Conor who he bit :D




    So all in, this makes me think that *if* his posts indicate a teammate, it would be gabby
    Holly WW wrote: »
    #FFA2

    1. Gabriel - Based on the ISO I did of Nigel I found all those interactions, his FFA and voting odd and think they might have been a team
    2. Liam - Not just because he's gunning for me for being a low poster (although that is a factor both because I hate that strategy this early and have done a bit of work on the thread since i stopped working today), but also the posts of his I quoted whihc I found contradictory. Acting like a pro player much of the time and then acting dumb about backrooms
    3. Phil - Seems this will be an unpopular opinion but I don't know if confusion helps the village or baddies right now


    Holly is a really on the edge of this game drifting, having a quick look at her FFA really kinds hits it for me.


    Includes Gab on the basis of the one bit of research she did


    Really seems to have included Liam because he was gunning for her tbh


    Phil - Puts him on cause he was causing confusion? He had mad a blatant role claim that wasnt countered.


    It seems a lazy FFA to just chuck out to tick a box


  • #1428
    Angus WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,977 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Ewan WW wrote: »
    So you want to string me up for something you did the exact same on both nights?

    Late votes on Lucy and Jake.

    Earlier you said I wasnt a wolf so which is it Angus, you seem to spinning a narrative that keeps me at the forefront and your own opinions dont actually matter


    The last time you were a wolf you picked up on something innocuous and ran with it as reason for lynching someone - you've done similar here.
    You've done very little wagonomics cause you know that will leave you with very little place to hide. I don't understand you're jumping on voting, just to be seen to be an unsure villager


  • #1429
    Ewan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 2,568 ✭✭✭Ewan WW


    Now I'm going back to work or do I need permission to earn a living.

    Honestly people need to step back and realise others have jobs and stuff and cant be online all day. I'm legit annoyed about this, game sh1t aside.


  • #1430
    Angus WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,977 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Ewan WW wrote: »
    Now I'm going back to work or do I need permission to earn a living.

    Honestly people need to step back and realise others have jobs and stuff and cant be online all day. I'm legit annoyed about this, game sh1t aside.

    Phil will be along shortly to grant permission no doubt


  • #1431
    Ewan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 2,568 ✭✭✭Ewan WW


    Conor I'm gonna follow the rules here and ask you to lay off.

    You're goading me into a reaction here and I don't appreciate your attitude


  • Advertisement
  • #1432
    Orla WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,233 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    Angus WW wrote: »
    Unremarkable - thats incredibly harsh, we'll see who's laughing when you swing boy


    Angus to Jake - Who then proceeded to vote Gabs on the lynch thread 6 minutes after

    Angus WW wrote: »
    I've liked Gertie's posts in the last half an hour and reading Jakes I dont like his, he seems overly defensive about his links with Nigel
    A few minute later comes back on to post the above before changing votes from Gabriel to Jake


    Did you change votes cause you were called unremarkable? You thought you voted Gertie but actually voted Gabriel before jumping on the wagon


  • #1433
    Phil WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,145 ✭✭✭Phil WW


    Angus WW wrote: »
    Phil will be along shortly to grant permission no doubt

    Hardworking taxpayers are always welcome in my Kingdom.


  • #1434
    Eva WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Angus WW wrote: »
    I’ll expand on that

    Their voting patterns

    Conor is on the same counter wagon both nites. Strange on two accounts
    Eva is away from any kind of a wagon both nites, fair enough D1 but D2 she’s just avoiding trouble

    Ewan for his shifting votes, obviously I did similar but I know I’m good

    I think that me, you and Holly could be considered relatively unknown quantities and as such are reasonable candidates for a low posting lynch Strategy by day 3 if a better target is not found tonight. A big reason I find you more suspect then me or Holly is your insinuations against people which I find flimsy.

    But your insinuation of Ewan and your general insinuation of others can be kind of flakey. So Ewan could be bad for a reason that you yourself confirm could be thrown against you, but nobody should find you dodgy for the same reason because ?

    Then Patrick on your FFA
    Angus WW wrote: »
    Patrick - could definitely be a wolf, could definitely be a villager. Seems to interact with people without getting too involved

    And last night you jump on Jake, the easiest wagon, with a few minutes to go when it was obvious what was going to happen. You didn't like his responses. Turned out right, but could easily be a wolf jumping on an already dead teammate. Its interesting that all 5 who were on Lucy are all still alive, if I was betting on at least one wolf in that pack, you would be my first choice.

    The best FFA you did was on me, suggesting I could be a low lying wolf. I think that's a very fair assumption and one that will have to be resolved either by me posting more (not sure I will be around as much as I would like while I am alive) or death. As it stands, any baddy kill appears to be the same (two "munches") this morning, but the ideal one would be the wolf who peaks good.

    I would think whoever we think is the most likely to be that wolf (looking for a peak, maybe being bravado on thread or others suggesting a peak target) should be a priority for Geralt, Barge (if hes killing people daily) and the lynch for tonight.


  • #1435
    Conor WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 5,361 ✭✭✭Conor WW


    Ewan WW wrote: »
    Conor I'm gonna follow the rules here and ask you to lay off.

    You're goading me into a reaction here and I don't appreciate your attitude


    Laying off as asked x


  • #1436
    Angus WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,977 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Orla WW wrote: »
    Angus to Jake - Who then proceeded to vote Gabs on the lynch thread 6 minutes after



    A few minute later comes back on to post the above before changing votes from Gabriel to Jake


    Did you change votes cause you were called unremarkable? You thought you voted Gertie but actually voted Gabriel before jumping on the wagon


    That was a legitimate mistake, Gertie was where my vote was meant to be


  • #1437
    Gabriel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,635 ✭✭✭Gabriel WW


    Ewan you ok mate? Wanna hug it out?


  • #1438
    Eva WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Ewan WW wrote: »
    Now I'm going back to work or do I need permission to earn a living.

    Honestly people need to step back and realise others have jobs and stuff and cant be online all day. I'm legit annoyed about this, game sh1t aside.

    When I haven't been working, Ive been struggling with Bad sleep and when I have tried to come on and catch-up Ive had the kids looking to play with them. I don't understand it because last few weeks they have left me alone. Think it was because I went for a lovely walk on beach with my youngest on Sunday and the others realised they can get some quality alone time with daddy.....

    I have actually read the entire thread, but my brain has been relative pudding for a lot of the game.

    RL doesn't imply any leanings to be fair, we are all in the same boat.


  • #1439
    Orla WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,233 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    Angus WW wrote: »
    Just catching up, I'll give some quick thoughts and then I'm going to try and read the full thread

    Phil - I don't believe anything this lad is coming out with so I've decided to ignore for now - I'm sure as the game goes on that one of the wolf teams will decide to take him out

    Conor - I can't decide whether Conor is a really helpful villager or a wolf spewing about everyone in a bid to look helpful and hide his tracks. I think if he is a helpful villager that he'll be munched at some stage, or he'll survive long enough for us kill him - the Necro paradox if you will. I do think ISOing half way through D1 is ridiculous

    Barbara - I can't see how she is so sure about Phil - he claimed seer with the Orla is NRV yesterday even though the OP tells us that the seer only got their pick on N1 - I know I voted to save Barbara on D1 but thats what double standards are for - I'm also upfront about it just being a hunch, I've no solid proof. I also need to apologise to her - I did say she went back on her word but she has clarified that she wouldn't self-pres on Phil

    Derry - I don't buy that the BG had protected him this morning - I still think my three options are the most likely - again self-resolving - we'll see what the munches throw up

    Jake/Ewan/Orla/Liam - there seemed to serious of he said she said today with these three and maybe more at the centre - I dont know what to make of it - it seemed to me to be a little pedantic


    And I do accept that my tactic last nite could have gotten an RV killed without giving them a chance to defend themselves - that was foolish and wasn't something I'd considered.

    The more I look at Angus the lack of interaction with Jake is a bit baffling considering he did a late switch vote onto him, he actually though all the chat was pedantic, thought our seer was full of **** and doesnt believe a word out of Phils mouth. This was shortly before voting for Gabriel but doesnt mention him in his catch up!


  • #1440
    Angus WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,977 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Like I said Gabs was a mistake, should have been Gertie


  • Advertisement
  • #1441
    Angus WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,977 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    I see the wind has changed again Conor


Advertisement