The Witcher Werewolf - GAMETHREAD

Ewan WW · 28-04-2020 08:13PM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Oh this is interesting, care to give any reasoning as to why you think that and so give me a chance to defend myself?

Even more interesting that you were taking me to task about him earlier

I feel Vern is just firing sh1t at the wall here and hoping something will stick

Phil WW · 28-04-2020 08:13PM

Holly WW wrote: »

#FFA2

3. Phil - Seems this will be an unpopular opinion but I don't know if confusion helps the village or baddies right now

What confusion?

Emily WW · 28-04-2020 08:14PM

Liam WW wrote: »

Come on, you have like 14 posts in the thread!

having said that, it's not really a strategy on my part...more like er..i have to vote for someone.

So we're at the end of day 2; you've voted for Holly twice and you have no reasoning for it on either day?

Jake WW · 28-04-2020 08:14PM

For what it is worth

Conor wolf in plain sight
Phil dodgy as I have said it from beginning
Derry got spooked by something but has influence wolf
Holly the invisable girl
Patrick thinking village
Liam village
Babs unknown
Eva dont know today
Orla wolfy monster vibe
Ewan thinks a lot maybe village
Vernon think village but not sure
Gabriel leaning wolf
Gertrude leaning village
Angus unremarkable unknown

Gabriel WW · 28-04-2020 08:17PM

Ewan WW wrote: »

Incidentally, what would be your FFA Gabby Agbonlahor?

It would be Jake, Barbara, Vernon and Angus.

Holly WW wrote: »

Not yours. Nidge's and his reference to you. I posted about it before.

Shouldn't be too hard to find out of my 14 posts

Ah I understand, I picked you up wrong. So I'm being blamed for something Nigel did? Great. I can't really mount a defence against that now can I? :rolleyes:

Orla WW · 28-04-2020 08:17PM

Jake WW wrote: »

For what it is worth

Conor wolf in plain sight
Phil dodgy as I have said it from beginning
Derry got spooked by something but has influence wolf
Holly the invisable girl
Patrick thinking village
Liam village
Babs unknown
Eva dont know today
Orla wolfy monster vibe
Ewan thinks a lot maybe village
Vernon think village but not sure
Gabriel leaning wolf
Gertrude leaning village
Angus unremarkable unknown

copy and pasted from the backroom?

Babs unknown 2 seconds after you just voted for her despite you having loads of wolf leads?

Angus WW · 28-04-2020 08:18PM

Unremarkable - thats incredibly harsh, we'll see who's laughing when you swing boy

Conor WW · 28-04-2020 08:19PM

10:04 Derry votes Jake
Jake = 1 vote

11:42 Gabriel votes Jake
Jake = 2 votes

14:52 Vernon votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote

17:04 Ewan votes Conor
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote
Conor = 1 vote

18:29 Gertrude votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:08 Conor votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:19 Patrick votes Jake
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:20 Emily votes Angus
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:41 Barbara votes Jake
Jake = 4 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:49 Orla votes Jake
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:57 Liam votes Holly
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

19:58 Holly votes Gabriel
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:14 Jake votes Barbara
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

Ewan WW · 28-04-2020 08:19PM

For the record, I don't think, I just act Jake :P

As is evident in my posting

Jake WW · 28-04-2020 08:19PM

Orla WW wrote: »

copy and pasted from the backroom?

Babs unknown 2 seconds after you just voted for her despite you having loads of wolf leads?

No Word, you might have heard of it.. basically cause she voted for me and is next in number of votes so self preservation so I might get to stay

But if i am going the wolves are where I would look

Conor WW · 28-04-2020 08:21PM

You need to hashtag it or we’ll never look at it again

Barbara WW · 28-04-2020 08:21PM

Patrick WW wrote: »

Well I'm with you on Babs. I find her very suspicious and Angus is in my ones to watch pile. The only thing I wonder is would wolves be quite as blatant.

You seem to have mostly ignored my response to your thoughts on my FFA. I asked you a question in there about why you voted for me yesterday.

Jake WW · 28-04-2020 08:22PM

Conor WW wrote: »

You need to hashtag it or we’ll never look at it again

Knowing ye lot you will have the total vowel count of all my posts before my corpse hits the ground:D:P

Conor WW · 28-04-2020 08:23PM

17:04 Ewan votes Conor
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote
Conor = 1 vote

18:29 Gertrude votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:08 Conor votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:19 Patrick votes Jake
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:20 Emily votes Angus
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:41 Barbara votes Jake
Jake = 4 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:49 Orla votes Jake
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:57 Liam votes Holly
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

19:58 Holly votes Gabriel
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:14 Jake votes Barbara
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:22 Ewan unvotes Conor votes Jake
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

Ewan WW · 28-04-2020 08:24PM

Switched to Jake there, that list and vote was wolfy AF

Vernon WW · 28-04-2020 08:24PM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Well no I wanted to look back over his posts because as I said I had a good feeling about him so wanted to see his thought process behind it.

I wanted to trust what he was saying but it didn't go in line with my own theory so I thought I'll have a look back over which I did and Jakes posts and nothing swayed me strongly enough to change my viewpoint on the other three.

I asked the opinion of other posters too because I wanted an outsider view on what I was thinking

it seems more to me like cozying up

Patrick WW · 28-04-2020 08:24PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

You seem to have mostly ignored my response to your thoughts on my FFA. I asked you a question in there about why you voted for me yesterday.

Sorry I must have missed it. On phone. Will look back now

Gertrude WW · 28-04-2020 08:25PM

If Jake flips village and Barbara gets off the hook again I'm going to be so mad

Conor WW · 28-04-2020 08:26PM

10:04 Derry votes Jake
Jake = 1 vote

11:42 Gabriel votes Jake
Jake = 2 votes

14:52 Vernon votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote

17:04 Ewan votes Conor
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote
Conor = 1 vote

18:29 Gertrude votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:08 Conor votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:19 Patrick votes Jake
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:20 Emily votes Angus
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:41 Barbara votes Jake
Jake = 4 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:49 Orla votes Jake
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:57 Liam votes Holly
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

19:58 Holly votes Gabriel
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:14 Jake votes Barbara
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:22 Ewan unvotes Conor votes Jake
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:24 Angus votes Gabriel
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 2 votes

Angus WW · 28-04-2020 08:27PM

Ewan - just seems to accept Phil is tasking away? seems strange. Then goes after Eva for suggesting Frank migght have been tasking - as if she was giving something away - I dont see it - watching brief for now

Gertie - her FFA stinks of trying to pick a wolf out of the Lucy voters who isnt herself - you've come up with a theory and talk about a powerful wolf and three of us protecting that powerful wolf - what role is this exactly? To blow a massive hole in your theory Barbara could have easily self-presed by switching to Phil - if the two of them were on a team then Ewan and myself couldn't also be on that team. You're projecting I feel

Holly - Does an ISO of Nigel and comes to a Gabs conclusion - has voted that way - good look

Emily - I like her posts - I do not like her vote but I can understand it, I've apologised for my tactics last nite

More comments to follow on the remaining players

Gertrude WW · 28-04-2020 08:27PM

Vernon WW wrote: »

it seems more to me like cozying up

I haven't had any other interaction with Derry nor have I as you put it tried to cozy up to anyone else so why would this be any different? Especially considering I didn't change my vote. Would have been a different story had I done a complete turnaround and then agreed with him but I didn't

28-04-2020 08:30PM

30 minutes left to vote, there are still some outstanding.

Gertrude WW · 28-04-2020 08:32PM

Angus WW wrote: »

Ewan - just seems to accept Phil is tasking away? seems strange. Then goes after Eva for suggesting Frank migght have been tasking - as if she was giving something away - I dont see it - watching brief for now

Gertie - her FFA stinks of trying to pick a wolf out of the Lucy voters who isnt herself - you've come up with a theory and talk about a powerful wolf and three of us protecting that powerful wolf - what role is this exactly? To blow a massive hole in your theory Barbara could have easily self-presed by switching to Phil - if the two of them were on a team then Ewan and myself couldn't also be on that team. You're projecting I feel

Holly - Does an ISO of Nigel and comes to a Gabs conclusion - has voted that way - good look

Emily - I like her posts - I do not like her vote but I can understand it, I've apologised for my tactics last nite

More comments to follow on the remaining players

Do you honestly think that me as a baddie on either side keeps banging the same drum all day long if I knew you were going to flip village? I've explained myself numerous times, I was first vote on Lucy yesterday so no I don't include myself in the bad Holly voters. If Barbara had of voted for Phil or any of you for that matter and he flipped an RV after everything he'd said you would all be hanged for it so that point is invalid. It was less risky to vote for Lucy who was an unknown and then be able to say later why would three wolves vote that way? The powerful wolf role would be Fringila who can block powers, with only three wolves that makes that a powerful role if you ask me

Ewan WW · 28-04-2020 08:34PM

Angus WW wrote: »

Ewan - just seems to accept Phil is tasking away? seems strange. Then goes after Eva for suggesting Frank migght have been tasking - as if she was giving something away - I dont see it - watching brief for now

He's either the bard or he's a big filthy lying wolf and the real bard is just letting him run roughshod over the thread.

It wasn't that she suggested Frank was tasking, it was that she jumped immediately to that being the reason he was munched.

Nobody else seems to agree but I've had to die before to get people to believe me over a player so I'm sticking with my theory on it. Stubborn and foolish, maybe. But its my read and I'm sticking with it

Conor WW · 28-04-2020 08:34PM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

30 minutes left to vote, there are still some outstanding.

Stu’s looking at yous

Eva WW
Phil WW

Jake WW · 28-04-2020 08:35PM

Phil busy in backroom with wolves

Holly WW · 28-04-2020 08:37PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Ah I understand, I picked you up wrong. So I'm being blamed for something Nigel did? Great. I can't really mount a defence against that now can I? :rolleyes:

I mean you could give it a lash!

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Hmm that's not how I read the OP at all:
Striga: A formidable opponent. Each night the haunting Striga chooses 2 targets to attack, their fates to be revealed at 9pm in a potentially fatal outcome. Triss Merigold will have a chance to heal 1 target by 9pm.

I took that as meaning both are bitten, one will die, Triss decides which one. What's a fake bite?

Gabriel WW wrote: »

If Nidge voted for Babs its unlikely that Babs is the Kikimora. He would never risk a vote on his only teammate.
She could still be Nilfgard tho.

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Oh! Did the Striga get another go or is this a different poison?

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I think your way makes sense too. My way makes Triss pretty powerful against the Monster team. Assuming of course that she's not just NRV now that the Striga is dead which I actually think she would be.

I also thought you showed too much interest in the Monster team in your posts

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Or Derry was protected by the BG overnight?

Sorry I didn't mean infected, I meant attacked. I didn't have my quote in front of me when I was answering you.

Wonderful timing Derry. Nice one dodging that bite! Must be your swift feet.[/QUOTE]

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Wonderful timing Derry. Nice one dodging that bite! Must be your swift feet.

I also felt like these two posts about Derry made it seem like you knew something we didn't or were BG hunting

Patrick WW · 28-04-2020 08:38PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

I was the first person to accuse Gabriel yesterday for his strong post replying to Frank. I thought everyone knew that, so no it is not retaliatory. Why did you vote for me yesterday if you didn't know why I suspected Gabriel? Most people voted for me in part at least because they thought I was hedging on Gabriel. Now you say you don't know why I suspect him.

I've now realised that Conor is almost certainly not Nigel's teammate. Jake hasn't been ruled out. I based that on my read of Nigel's posts and who he interacted with, which I had posted previously. I didn't just pick names out of a hat. If you have a look back you can find it.

You, I put on because I didn't like your reasoning. I thought it left out some things that didn't fit with your picture, but that didn't stop you trying to case shade. It even says in the post you quoted that I was replying to some and you ignored it. You felt it important enough to note that conor's mention was in reference to someone else, so why not mine?

Sorry I was foolish enough to think you had more than 'I suspected him yesterday' as your reason. I did feel you were hedging yesterday but not only about Gabriel about everything. I felt your entire tone was too reasonable, too wishy washy.

As for the thing about Conor as I said, it was context AND timing that had me separating it and the timing was more significant to me. Also Conor was literally referencing the fact that Liam mentioned Columbo. Your post read differently to me.

Holly WW · 28-04-2020 08:38PM

Angus WW wrote: »

Holly - Does an ISO of Nigel and comes to a Gabs conclusion - has voted that way - good look

There was a logical thread in the post. Wasn't an ISO of all quotes and no trying to put together a theory for why they'd be a team

Phil WW · 28-04-2020 08:40PM

The King has decided not to partake in the voting process.

The Witcher Werewolf - GAMETHREAD

Comments