Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

How's your pension?

13

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,086 ✭✭✭Nijmegen


    DubDani wrote: »
    I am lucky as in that my employer has always been very good in all aspects of social security (Pension, Life insurance, Health Insurance, Travel Insurance etc.). They match up to 12% of my salary, i.e. right now I pay 15% of my salary into the pension every month and they add another 12% to it. They also add the Social Insurance contributions they save by me giving up 15% of my salary to the Pension pot as well. Decent pot right now, but another 20 years to go and who knows how many crashes we will see by then.

    Don't worry too much about crashes for the next while at least. Your fund might have got hosed in 2008, for example, but today the value of those equities is significantly higher than it was even at the depth of the recession. Meanwhile, if you were still contributing to your pension during the downturn you were following Warren Buffets advice to "buy to the sound of cannons, and sell to the sound of trumpets." Every contribution during the crash bought stocks at depressed prices that have since bounced back and then some. Cash out when the economy looks really strong and you're closing in on retirement to the safer, boring bets like government bonds. And as I mentioned earlier, prepare to become one of those people who is like "Gulp.... Erm, guys, why don't we not burn the bondholders?!"


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,138 ✭✭✭Salary Negotiator


    If the age limit % is 15% and the employer contributes 7% does this not mean the employee can only contribute 8%? Or is the employer contribution excluded from the age related earnings percentage limit?

    Employer contribution is excluded.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 12,622 Mod ✭✭✭✭Amirani


    If the age limit % is 15% and the employer contributes 7% does this not mean the employee can only contribute 8%? Or is the employer contribution excluded from the age related earnings percentage limit?

    Age limit is for employee contributions only.

    As Nijmegen said, you can still add more on top of the age limit but you don't get the tax benefits.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,086 ✭✭✭Nijmegen


    Employer contribution is excluded.

    To a personal pension it is not excluded. To an occupational pension it is. You'd need to clarify what type of pension you have.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 220 ✭✭mlem123


    I'm in the public sector but a recent entrant so don't have the same cushy pension as those that work around me lol

    Would it be worth contributing to a private pot on top of that?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,443 ✭✭✭✭endacl


    Teachers pension (the old ‘good’ one) + AVC to max out allowable income from the other job + holiday apartment to rent or sell down the line.

    99% got lucky + 1% good choices. Should be grand. Planning to retire as early as possible from the teaching, travel, take photos and play music.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    Augeo wrote: »
    That's what the poster is worried about.

    It would want to be one hell of a tax to claw back the 40% tax relief on contributions.
    Just have a few questions if someone can answer.
    1) when can you take a limp sum out of the pension?
    Freudian slip?
    Concordia. It was originally through Canada Life but through Irish Life now. It closed in 2001, I think. I’m only putting a small amount in each month (less than €100) but it’s performing very very well and has done since inception.

    I can't find any details on the Irish Life site https://www.irishlife.ie/investments/fund-prices-and-performance/canada-life

    but this discussion gives a fairly different story;

    https://www.askaboutmoney.com/threads/canada-life-concordia-investment-policy.185238/

    25% year on year return is unknown, especially through recession years. Typical returns would be <10% each year.

    https://www.irishlife.ie/investments/maps-quarterly-update-q3-2019


    I think you may be misunderstanding this.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,443 ✭✭✭✭endacl


    mlem123 wrote: »
    I'm in the public sector but a recent entrant so don't have the same cushy pension as those that work around me lol
    Would it be worth contributing to a private pot on top of that?

    Yes. My AVC is only 3 years old but is already worth substantially more than I put in. Also, if you are taking a tax free lump sum in retirement, you can take it from that fund, leaving your ‘main’ pension intact. Not so important on a defined benefit, but for most people this would be a consideration.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 75 ✭✭Fccwontletmebe


    Nijmegen wrote: »
    Consider moving your pension so, there's much better deals you can get. Talk to a broker.



    You can access your pension at 60, in answer to both question 1 and 2.

    If you want to retire early a pension is really the most efficient way to maximise your money so you can do so - you end up saving €2 rather than €1. Your €100k saved you likely paid, what, another €70-90k in tax to get to that if it came from your wages.

    The benefit of the pension is the tax breaks. So you can draw down 25% of the fund up to €200k of a pension tax free and another €300k at the lower rate of 20% income tax.

    To be honest if your employer is offering 8% then you are just foregoing salary by not taking it. I'm assuming if you can afford to save €2k per month that you are earning in the higher tax band, so basically for every €1 you put into the pension yourself to get that match you're only really seeing €0.50 come out of your net paycheque. You're saving €100k every four years after tax. You could be saving €200k in that time plus your employer contribution if the %'s work, and then be drawing down that money or a big lump of it tax free at 60. That's a pretty sweet deal and if you have savings on hand it sounds like you have options to do whatever you want and/or deal with a short term emergency with cash on hand.

    I'd suggest at the very least that you go talk to a planner who can show you the different scenarios available to run out. When you sit and look at the amount of tax you'll be paying over the next 29 years if you just continue as is you might have a little rethink.

    Thanks for that, any recommendations on who you can talk to about it. Definitely not planning on maxing it out though as don’t want my money tied up for 29 years.

    Might consider putting the 8% in but I’ll see.

    At the rate I’m going i should have 600K by the time I’m 50.

    I would then have 1600 a month for the next 30 years which would do me perfectly fine on top of the state pension.

    Okay after that last sentence I’m realizing I’m better off definitely putting something into it but do plan on retiring as early as I can, hopefully 50 so I’ll have do the maths and get a financial advisor. Will probably still work 3 months a year on some contract roles.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,944 ✭✭✭Sgt Hartman


    I'm in the public service for the last 14 years and I also have an AVC which isn't worth that much at the moment (about 6k) I'm 40 now and I'm seriously thinking about starting a personal pension just to top up my measly public pension when I finally retire

    ”If I offended you, you needed it!!” - Corey Taylor



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,086 ✭✭✭Nijmegen


    Thanks for that, any recommendations on who you can talk to about it. Definitely not planning on maxing it out though as don’t want my money tied up for 29 years.

    Might consider putting the 8% in but I’ll see.

    At the rate I’m going i should have 600K by the time I’m 50.

    I would then have 1600 a month for the next 30 years which would do me perfectly fine on top of the state pension.

    Okay after that last sentence I’m realizing I’m better off definitely putting something into it but do plan on retiring as early as I can, hopefully 50 so I’ll have do the maths and get a financial advisor. Will probably still work 3 months a year on some contract roles.

    I really think you should talk to someone. Like, really really think you should talk to someone. You can achieve what you want to achieve in a far more tax efficient manner and your current plan takes no account of inflation. €20k in 29 years will not be €20k in today's money. Assume an average inflation rate of 3% over the period to be safe and your €20k will be worth €8.2k or so in 30 years. 1% inflation will make your €20k be worth €15k in real money. You need to be putting your money somewhere that it is growing faster than inflation, be inflation 1% or inflation 3% or whatever.

    You also need to take account of things like deposit guarantees. Only €100k of your money is covered in case an institution goes belly up if you're holding it in a bank. So never hold more than that across all your accounts in any one bank.

    Now lets say you want to retire early still. You can totally plan for that. Lets talk in today's money and bear in mind you will need to get advice on what to do with non-pension funds so that inflation doesn't kill them. For example, if you want €1,666 (propitious!) per month from age 50 to age 60, you only actually need €200k in cash. Another €100k from where you are today will set you back €438 per month over the next 19 years. The other €1,500 you're currently saving (let alone escalation, which I imagine you have in mind to get to €600k by 50 from 31) from your after tax income could go into a pension without tax (ie, be doubled if you're paying the higher rate of tax) and get you €684k in contributions over that same period, before the fund started to grow from the investments its in. You contribute nothing more till you're 60 and that fund will still be considerable. Now you're pulling down big lump sums and taking a raise at 60 before waiting for the state pension.

    Head over to the Ask About Money recommendations forum to find someone to talk to. Genuinely, your case as you describe it needs some professional planning beyond what I might offer as a punters opinion on boards!


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 247 ✭✭car_radio19834


    I have a one but tey confuse the hell out of me.

    I'm looking at calculators. I'm saying I want 20k per year in a pension. Meaning currently it would be 12k state pension and 8k of my own.

    But using the same figures, my pension pot would be like 250k

    So how woud it make sense I would get 8k of my own money a year from a pot of 250k????

    Sounds like half my money would be lost to the pension company...


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    not paying into my works pension which matches 8%.

    Their 'matching' is giving you an immediate 100% return on your investment. You double your money from day 1. This is an unbeatable return. You won't get it anywhere else.

    Now, add in the tax relieve on your contribution, so your 8% will actually cost you about 5% in reduced net salary. So you've more than doubled your money from day 1.

    You'd be crazy to leave this money on the table. It is definitely long term money, so if you're currently in debt or paying crazy mortgage rates, you should be concentrating on those.

    But beyond that, you should jump in straight away. Many private pension funds will allow you to 'retire' from age 50 if you are no longer with that employer. You'd need to check the rules for your own employer.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 619 ✭✭✭sonyvision


    Started my pension in Dec 2016 when I changed employer. They pay 10% flat regardless of what I put in but I choose 5%.

    Under 30 thought I was capped out at 15% turns out my pension is an executive scheme and their contributions isn't added to mine. January this year I upped mine to 17% of my salary to flex for cash bonus and my employer still pays 10%.

    Next year I will be upping it to 20% of my salary and paying 20% of my bonus straight in.

    Forecast tool on the Portal estimates my pot is €1.7m in 38 years time... prob bull**** but since Dec 2016 to right now my fund is 20% higher then premium paid in.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    I have a one but tey confuse the hell out of me.

    I'm looking at calculators. I'm saying I want 20k per year in a pension. Meaning currently it would be 12k state pension and 8k of my own.

    But using the same figures, my pension pot would be like 250k

    So how woud it make sense I would get 8k of my own money a year from a pot of 250k????

    Sounds like half my money would be lost to the pension company...

    The pension/insurance company are taking a gamble. They'll pay you €8k a year whether you live for two years or forty years after retirement. You pay a price for this lifetime guarantee.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,071 ✭✭✭sunnysoutheast


    Concordia. It was originally through Canada Life but through Irish Life now. It closed in 2001, I think. I’m only putting a small amount in each month (less than €100) but it’s performing very very well and has done since inception.

    It can't be a 25% annualized return surely?

    At that rate you wouldn't have to worry about putting the kids through college you could just buy your own college!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,642 ✭✭✭topmanamillion


    In the case of an AVC, Say for example you're paying 40% on a small portion of your wages.
    Would you get tax relief at 40% for the year?
    Or just 40% for the part of the year/income you're paying the higher rate.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 247 ✭✭car_radio19834


    The pension/insurance company are taking a gamble. They'll pay you €8k a year whether you live for two years or forty years after retirement. You pay a price for this lifetime guarantee.

    Yeah but that's my 250k.

    When I'm 72 or so I'll be smelling of piss and biscuits and getting boils from sitting in a chair all day. A state pension would do me then.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 945 ✭✭✭Kremin


    The pension/insurance company are taking a gamble. They'll pay you €8k a year whether you live for two years or forty years after retirement. You pay a price for this lifetime guarantee.

    That's just not true at all. Pension companies make money by charging a management fee i.e 1.5% of your fund per annum. The reason the 250k doesn't match say 20x8k now is because 160k in today's money will be worth 300k then etc due to inflation


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    In the case of an AVC, Say for example you're paying 40% on a small portion of your wages.
    Would you get tax relief at 40% for the year?
    Or just 40% for the part of the year/income you're paying the higher rate.
    Just on the part of the year/income that you're paying the higher rate. You can't get tax relief on tax you haven't paid.

    Which shows why pension tax relief is a big public subsidy to the middle and higher earners.
    Yeah but that's my 250k.

    When I'm 72 or so I'll be smelling of piss and biscuits and getting boils from sitting in a chair all day. A state pension would do me then.

    If you're trying to save money outside of a pension fund, you won't get tax relief on your contributions. So your savings might be something like €150k not €250k.

    There was provision that if you could show other substantial income, you didn't have to buy an annuity. I'm not sure if that is still the case.


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 75 ✭✭Fccwontletmebe


    Yeah but that's my 250k.

    When I'm 72 or so I'll be smelling of piss and biscuits and getting boils from sitting in a chair all day. A state pension would do me then.

    I have that attitude as well but wouldn’t word it the same haha.

    It is nice to have money but I could be maxing out my pension for the next 29 years and be dead by then.

    I really hate the idea you can’t touch it until your 60.

    Things can change easily within 29 years.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,135 ✭✭✭Better Than Christ


    Long history of heart disease and cancer in my family, so I'm gambling on the fact that I'll have already assumed room temperature when the time comes.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,086 ✭✭✭Nijmegen


    Yeah but that's my 250k.

    When I'm 72 or so I'll be smelling of piss and biscuits and getting boils from sitting in a chair all day. A state pension would do me then.

    You can choose to buy an annuity, which is an insurance product.

    Or you can draw down from the fund, which will usually give you a higher return but at the risk of variable income if the markets shift.

    What a lot of folks do is draw down from a fund still exposed to the market until they decide certainty is a bigger win (there's a difference between being 65 and being 75, basically) and use what's left to buy an annuity. Less income but, as you say, less doing.
    I have that attitude as well but wouldn’t word it the same haha.

    It is nice to have money but I could be maxing out my pension for the next 29 years and be dead by then.

    I really hate the idea you can’t touch it until your 60

    I really hate the idea of the taxman touching 50% of my money when I could be putting it away tax free and seeing a big lump of it later, tax free!


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 75 ✭✭Fccwontletmebe


    Nijmegen wrote: »

    I really hate the idea of the taxman touching 50% of my money when I could be putting it away tax free and seeing a big lump of it later, tax free!

    I do get that and thanks for your previous advice.

    It’s just something I need to get out my head.

    I’m going to seek out an advisor as you suggested.

    I might plan for 60-75 or something like that.

    I’m young, single with no intention of ever getting married so things can easily change for me. Probably would be maxing it out if I had a family.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 32,688 ✭✭✭✭ytpe2r5bxkn0c1



    When I'm 72 or so I'll be smelling of piss and biscuits and getting boils from sitting in a chair all day. A state pension would do me then.

    I hope that notion is in jest. 72 is not old and is an age where you are active and enjoying life. I'm 76 and enjoying my 22nd year of retirement thanks to a private pension. We are living longer and living more active lives. Plan for it. It would be a shame to have to miss out on so much after you retire.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,003 ✭✭✭Dufflecoat Fanny


    How would ye rate the CWPS? Is there better out there I could switch to?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 273 ✭✭Turkish1


    Thanks for that, any recommendations on who you can talk to about it. Definitely not planning on maxing it out though as don’t want my money tied up for 29 years.

    Might consider putting the 8% in but I’ll see.

    At the rate I’m going i should have 600K by the time I’m 50.

    I would then have 1600 a month for the next 30 years which would do me perfectly fine on top of the state pension.

    Okay after that last sentence I’m realizing I’m better off definitely putting something into it but do plan on retiring as early as I can, hopefully 50 so I’ll have do the maths and get a financial advisor. Will probably still work 3 months a year on some contract roles.

    I second seeing a financial planner. e.g. you could put the 8% in to get your employer to match your contributions and with the balance of your saving look into something like the EII qualified fund, not completely familiar but essentially you can invest into certain companies/funds and get tax relief for your contribution. Not quite as good as the relief on pension but close.

    I.e. if you contributed €40k in the year, you get 40% relief on 75% of that (40k * 75% *40% = €12k relief). So your €40k investment actually costs you €28k. It is locked away for 4 years though.

    Possibly worth looking into, as I said I am not overly familiar only starting to assess that option myself but wouldn't be just leaving it sitting there in cash. Much better ways of using it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 503 ✭✭✭Rufeo


    There's land in our family. Neither me or my brother have a woman.

    I fancy we'll flog a field when we're closer to 65.

    Hardly a great idea, but hopefully it will cover us.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,283 ✭✭✭✭Geuze


    I'm in the public service for the last 14 years and I also have an AVC which isn't worth that much at the moment (about 6k) I'm 40 now and I'm seriously thinking about starting a personal pension just to top up my measly public pension when I finally retire

    You can't have a personal pension plus a PS pension.

    Well, what I mean is, the personal pension you can have is the AVC, that's it.


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 247 ✭✭car_radio19834


    Still don't understand why the payout is so low.

    I used a calculator.

    If I put in 4000 a year for the next 40 years that amounts to 168k.

    But the calculator tells me I'll only get around 7k per year from that. I'd have to last 24 years to make my money back.


Advertisement
Advertisement