Silent Hill Werewolf Game Thread!

Tegan WW · 03-12-2019 07:53PM

Am out for a while. Will let ye know about the prize as soon as I have it.

Henry WW · 03-12-2019 07:54PM

Tegan WW wrote: »

Ok, so I've been reading back and noticed that Isla had disappeared. I was all set to accuse and then I iso'd her posts and noticed that she said she wasn't well, so hopefully that's the reason and get well soon.

My ~FFA based on reading back is

Nigel - Reading back most of Nigel's posts seem to be catching up or commenting on other people's interactions. His suggestion that we should just all randomly guess at the puzzle answer was a good way of using up guesses and when I pointed that out, he just seemed to ignore it. Now I know we've done no better with solving the puzzle but at least they were considered. Seems to softly suggest things and then back off again. Posting just enough not to draw attention. My vote is going here for now.

Oisin - Voted No Lynch again, when challenged about it and explanations given has stuck with that vote and not changed it. Also somewhat basing this on a high/mid/low wolf theory. Brendan seems to be working away, Phil is TWTBAW and Patrick kind of falls into the same category but actually I just think Patrick maybe a newcomer to these parts.

Henry - This is my least likely and based again on high/mid/low. I really didn't like the comment about not caring if someone is lynched or munched. He also pushed for a no lynch and corrected Orla on her vote which I somehow managed to miss last night.

Well I corrected her cause I wanted her vote to count, hardly a mystery or surprising

Derry WW · 03-12-2019 07:56PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Derry and Barbara....what's your position tonight?

Hi Clodagh.
I don't do no lynch votes.
Last nights vote for Nigel was on the basis of next to know meaningful engagement at the time and just a sense of general drop ins to show engagement.

My sense tonight is that Nigel (who has improved the substance of his engagement today), Barbara and Phil are in the mix for my lynch vote.

Barbara has probably taken over the position from Nigel in terms of poor level of engagement (not post count, but post substance).

Phil for a lot reasons starting off with the adhoc guesses and location picks without consultation. But further to this he's been a very high poster creating a lot of noise and using puzzles etc to cover this. Has disappeared a bit when small levels of heat have come on (the last part is my sense from a speed read today, and I need to fact check that)

At the moment I'm between Phil and Barbara for a vote tonight and it could go either way at this point.

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:04PM

Derry WW wrote: »

Hi Clodagh.
I don't do no lynch votes.
Last nights vote for Nigel was on the basis of next to know meaningful engagement at the time and just a sense of general drop ins to show engagement.

My sense tonight is that Nigel (who has improved the substance of his engagement today), Barbara and Phil are in the mix for my lynch vote.

Barbara has probably taken over the position from Nigel in terms of poor level of engagement (not post count, but post substance).

Phil for a lot reasons starting off with the adhoc guesses and location picks without consultation. But further to this he's been a very high poster creating a lot of noise and using puzzles etc to cover this. Has disappeared a bit when small levels of heat have come on (the last part is my sense from a speed read today, and I need to fact check that)

At the moment I'm between Phil and Barbara for a vote tonight and it could go either way at this point.

Thanks. I'm inclined to think Phil is just an over eager village.

I'm gonna have a wee chat with Nigel now, mainly (and please feel free to reply Nigel) I'm worried that his posts are just lots of whining about us not wolf hunting, which is valid but I might have missed the wolf hunting part. I don't think that makes him a wolf though.

Barbara would be solely cause she's not posting? Do you think that's a good village move? Could be seen as hiding a wolf vote again?

Spook_ie · 03-12-2019 08:04PM

Patrick WW wrote: »

Analyzing voting thread.

lynch 1
Liam, <-- look further.

lynch 2
Loiam again...

From just the voting thread alone, i'll be looking into liam ww.

Look as much as you like, 3 of you painted yourselves as targets and nothing I've read has given my any inclination to change my mind.

Gertrude WW · 03-12-2019 08:05PM

Spook ie youre naked

Derry WW · 03-12-2019 08:07PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Thanks. I'm inclined to think Phil is just an over eager village.

I'm gonna have a wee chat with Nigel now, mainly (and please feel free to reply Nigel) I'm worried that his posts are just lots of whining about us not wolf hunting, which is valid but I might have missed the wolf hunting part. I don't think that makes him a wolf though.

Barbara would be solely cause she's not posting? Do you think that's a good village move? Could be seen as hiding a wolf vote again?

My fear with Barbara or any such low poster is that RL is distracting them for playing but tbh it's probably better in the long run to get rid. However, I would also be fearful that they're a roled villager. But obviously they could be a wolf keeping low. It happens.

For me it's 2 v 1 in favour of voting for them where 2=reasons to vote and 1=reason not to vote for them.

Isla WW · 03-12-2019 08:07PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Thanks. I'm inclined to think Phil is just an over eager village.

I'm gonna have a wee chat with Nigel now, mainly (and please feel free to reply Nigel) I'm worried that his posts are just lots of whining about us not wolf hunting, which is valid but I might have missed the wolf hunting part. I don't think that makes him a wolf though.

Barbara would be solely cause she's not posting? Do you think that's a good village move? Could be seen as hiding a wolf vote again?

Any thoughts on Barbaras first and only post yesterday?

Am I reading too much into her defense of Conor yesterday? Her level of posting hasnt done anything to eliminate my dounts

Nigel WW · 03-12-2019 08:08PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Thanks. I'm inclined to think Phil is just an over eager village.

I'm gonna have a wee chat with Nigel now, mainly (and please feel free to reply Nigel) I'm worried that his posts are just lots of whining about us not wolf hunting, which is valid but I might have missed the wolf hunting part. I don't think that makes him a wolf though.

Barbara would be solely cause she's not posting? Do you think that's a good village move? Could be seen as hiding a wolf vote again?

You've posted pretty much fluff, have you an FFA yourself to dissect? Mine is up and available to read on the last page?

Gertrude WW · 03-12-2019 08:08PM

Any update on when we arrive at med centre as it was bolded but no response

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:10PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

You've posted pretty much fluff, have you an FFA yourself to dissect? Mine is up and available to read on the last page?

That's quite defensive, woah. I was checking you were about so we could have a chat. It's better that way.
I'll go have a read. I've been gone most of the day i skimmed and saw your position about wolf hunting (as I said which I agree).

I'll be back

Nigel WW · 03-12-2019 08:12PM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Any update on when we arrive at med centre as it was bolded but no response

Why does it matter, we are going there, we will be there eventually, this is literally a distraction! Hopefully Tegan gets a good prize tonight cause I'm finding this game fairly frustrating

Gertrude WW · 03-12-2019 08:14PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Why does it matter, we are going there, we will be there eventually, this is literally a distraction! Hopefully Tegan gets a good prize tonight cause I'm finding this game fairly frustrating

Im finding it the same, it doesnt matter just thought it might be missed as was on previous page is all.

I think this is the first game Ive played where people are very tetchy with one another and the riddles to cryptic bar the cipher

Nigel WW · 03-12-2019 08:14PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

That's quite defensive, woah. I was checking you were about so we could have a chat. It's better that way.
I'll go have a read. I've been gone most of the day i skimmed and saw your position about wolf hunting (as I said which I agree).

I'll be back

It's not defensive but how do we find a wolf, we rattle cages, compile FFAs and later in the game we've info to eliminate wolves and find connections. As we stand all day 1 is going to give us is

56
57
6000
Legion
1/12
1/3
And more random stuff as opposed to an actual way to line up connections. On top of this we've people advocating no votes from first thing in the morning

Nigel WW · 03-12-2019 08:16PM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Im finding it the same, it doesnt matter just thought it might be missed as was on previous page is all.

I think this is the first game Ive played where people are very tetchy with one another and the riddles to cryptic bar the cipher

Sorry I am being tetchy however I'm reading back on posts from people and the only content in the vast majority is riddle talk

Gertrude WW · 03-12-2019 08:17PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Sorry I am being tetchy however I'm reading back on posts from people and the only content in the vast majority is riddle talk

Sorry Nigel, wasn't meaning just you, there are a few short fuses today and yesterday maybe the fog is affecting everyone

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:18PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Right folks #FFA for this evening

Very difficult to interpret a lot of posts around the whole riddle situation. I was hoping once the guessing was done a few more would do FFAs

I'm basing these on voting patterns and times

Emily WW

Didn't really register with me till she said the following

Popping out after voting in the wrong thread

Realised the error of her ways by keeping an eye on thread. As soon as her name was mentioned post 9pm she appeared on thread which makes me think she's an eye on the game more than she's made out. Also at the time no lynch, Patrick, Phil and Conor was on the table, if she's bad it may look in one of Patrick or Phil

Oisin WW

I fundamentally disagree with the strategy of no lynching especially two nights in a row. If it's near end game then right fair enough but I mean we got to be wolf hunting and Oisin isn't wolf hunting at all, voting no lynch takes pressure off wolves throughout the game. Them being on the block and reactions are what will win the game

Phil WW
Day 1 shennagins of diving on the selection of options. I've liked his interactions a bit more in the cage rattling stakes since but still not sitting right with me.

Captain Hindsight Isla for an honourable mention but I'll be voting Emily at the moment.

I hadn't looked at Emily before. That's a good spot. Has she been around much today?

I'm not sure how I feel about this no lynch thing. It saves a villager I get that but it really gives us no help in finding wolves.. ground hog day right? Day 1 probably okay. Day 2 you need to be nailing to a cross. But I can see where he's coming from. Henry said the last time he was a wolf it annoyed him that the village were voting no lynch. Guess it's more time you'd have to hide as a wolf. I think there's merit in that argument.

Phil I've said above

Nigel WW · 03-12-2019 08:20PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

I'm not sure how I feel about this no lynch thing. It saves a villager I get that but it really gives us no help in finding wolves.. ground hog day right?

Potentially saves a villager..... Also potentially kills a wolf or forces a trip

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:21PM

Isla WW wrote: »

Any thoughts on Barbaras first and only post yesterday?

Am I reading too much into her defense of Conor yesterday? Her level of posting hasnt done anything to eliminate my dounts

Do you have donuts ?

Are you keeping them from the group?

Derry WW · 03-12-2019 08:21PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Why does it matter, we are going there, we will be there eventually, this is literally a distraction! Hopefully Tegan gets a good prize tonight cause I'm finding this game fairly frustrating

One thing just worth keeping in mind is that some villagers (in a collective sense) have received items on this journey it seems. How they play out in the game is interesting and it's something, while we can't do anything yet, we may need to consider decision making (including lynch voting) while having these items in mind, when we have more information, or course.

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:23PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Potentially saves a villager..... Also potentially kills a wolf or forces a trip

Do we have any strong leads though?
(I'm trying to tease this out, my guts says vote and lynch a potential wolf)
But you're very strongly advocating lynching, which according to an ex-wolf this could make you prime wolf suspect?

Nigel WW · 03-12-2019 08:25PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Do we have any strong leads though?
(I'm trying to tease this out, my guts says vote and lynch a potential wolf)
But you're very strongly advocating lynching, which according to an ex-wolf this could make you prime wolf suspect?

I was a wolf in a lot of previous game, a no lynch especially a predetermind one is not a worry for wolves, they can spread everywhere and it's no sweat. I'm advocating lynching someone who I believe is a wolf

Rikand · 03-12-2019 08:26PM

Tegan WW wrote: »

Hill View Medical Centre

Due to my IT issues, this was processed later than i would have liked, so I'm going to use the time that I had intended for the group to leave at, which would have been 6:30. This would have been the time of departure no matter what location was chosen.

From the school to the medical centre it is going to take the group 3 hours to get there. That makes an arrival time of 9:30....... not everyone is going to make it.....

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:26PM

Isla WW wrote: »

Any thoughts on Barbaras first and only post yesterday?

Am I reading too much into her defense of Conor yesterday? Her level of posting hasnt done anything to eliminate my dounts

Game mods also wish to inform players that there is a 5 post minimum requirement per cycle, which will begin from Monday morning at 10am.

This wrecks my head. I didn't realise she'd only posted once. I'm fairly sure I saw more of her today. I think it was mainly riddle solving though. I'd have to go back and have a proper look.

Derry WW · 03-12-2019 08:30PM

Rikand wrote: »

.... not everyone is going to make it.....

Very ominous.

Clodagh WW · 03-12-2019 08:31PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

I was a wolf in a lot of previous game, a no lynch especially a predetermind one is not a worry for wolves, they can spread everywhere and it's no sweat. I'm advocating lynching someone who I believe is a wolf

Okay but I can't see what about that makes osisin a wolf?

Isla WW · 03-12-2019 08:33PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Okay but I can't see what about that makes osisin a wolf?

Would a wolf push the no lynch idea as hard as Ois?

Angus WW · 03-12-2019 08:34PM

Ah my catch up hasn’t exactly given any great insights. Two days of thread and so much of it full of puzzle stuff. I don’t know where I’ll vote tonight yet but I’ll try to iso some folks and see if it gleans anything more

Rikand · 03-12-2019 08:35PM

A siren begins to sound overhead

The group must run quickly to the medical centre

Patrick WW · 03-12-2019 08:36PM

Spook_ie wrote: »

Look as much as you like, 3 of you painted yourselves as targets and nothing I've read has given my any inclination to change my mind.

I am only one person, Patrick.

Please expand on what you mean by '3 of you'.......

Are you going to munch me?

:eek:

Silent Hill Werewolf Game Thread!

Comments