South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Playing devils advocate and throwing it out there

What benefit is to Derry to cast aspersions on Lucy? She could be bad but what if he was taking her down with him, what benefit would that be?

Eva WW wrote: »

If Derry was bad and Lucy was good, there'd have been no benefit to Derry lying and saying Lucy was bad. We'd have lynched Lucy and if Lucy showed as good, immediately known Derry was bad.

Since Derry was bad, he literally HAD to say Lucy was good.

Yeah he had to say she was good. But that doesn't help us in determining whether she is or not.

Isla WW wrote: »

why bother you already know if shes on your team or not.

Funny and nearly subtle:D:pac:

So I think we’ll know for definite if my kill on Emily was successful

Orla WW wrote: »

I’m inclined to think the poisoner is a good role but possibly the curer is bad?

I’d be wary of blocking players from back rooms unless you’ve got good reason to suspect they’re evil.

#FFA2 (I think, even though I’m pretty sure I tagged yesterday as 2 too)

Lucy - I don’t think the fact that Derry cleared her automatically makes her bad, but that’s where my vote was before she was cleared. Also I think good or bad there’s always going to be a question over her and we need to resolve it.

Brendan - for the boosting of his post count carry on yesterday without actually contributing anything.

Tegan - like Lucy I think you’re going to have to be taken out at some stage to resolve the questions over you. I don’t see how vote manipulation helps the village so it makes sense that it would be an evil power. Why would the furballs want to save a villager? It could be to set you up but you were well on your way out anyway so if I were a wolf with that power I wouldn’t have used it yesterday unless it was to save a teammate.

If the curer is on the wolf team, why didnt they cure Derry? Im still assuming Derry died from poison.

Whoever you hit wont die till tomorrow munch?

Orla WW wrote: »

I’m inclined to think the poisoner is a good role but possibly the curer is bad?

I’d be wary of blocking players from back rooms unless you’ve got good reason to suspect they’re evil.

#FFA2 (I think, even though I’m pretty sure I tagged yesterday as 2 too)

Lucy - I don’t think the fact that Derry cleared her automatically makes her bad, but that’s where my vote was before she was cleared. Also I think good or bad there’s always going to be a question over her and we need to resolve it.

Brendan - for the boosting of his post count carry on yesterday without actually contributing anything.

Tegan - like Lucy I think you’re going to have to be taken out at some stage to resolve the questions over you. I don’t see how vote manipulation helps the village so it makes sense that it would be an evil power. Why would the furballs want to save a villager? It could be to set you up but you were well on your way out anyway so if I were a wolf with that power I wouldn’t have used it yesterday unless it was to save a teammate.

Grand but I cant help but read this and think that it could be a wolf trying to get rid of a villager so I don't harm wolves.

Senan WW wrote: »

It went in, before that announcement

It didn’t say it was a bullet though, just a kill

I’m sure we’ll see soon enough

Too quick if you ask me! On line talking about it at 13:08. Online Chatting 13:09 Announced by Mods that it's done @13:10.
This is a classic case of 2 wolves working together & sharing powers. I did similar in Batman WW and it worked well. Unfortunately (for you Senan) you've been busted.

Isla WW wrote: »

We don't know if Laim or Derry was poisoned but one of them was yesterday. It was today Derry died not Yesterday when he had been potentially poisoned.

What do you think happened to Derry?

Wendy WW wrote: »

Too quick if you ask me! On line talking about it at 13:08. Online Chatting 13:09 Announced by Mods that it's done @13:10.
This is a classic case of 2 wolves working together & sharing powers. I did similar in Batman WW and it worked well. Unfortunately (for you Senan) you've been busted.

What are you on about? The kill order was acknowledged at 13.08.

I don’t know why it didn’t go through but I put it in for Emily

These were my main wolf suspects at the start of the day

Regan, Derry, Liam. Eva, Wendy


Liam gets downgraded since im leaning it less likely that both poisoned people would be wolves as well as a silent cure giver. Not quite full null as he like Derry Genied just when they were being put forward as peek recipients. He would now be on a similar level to Lucy who is back in the fray with me thinking Derry didn't peek her at all and just said she was good.

The ISO done on Emily highlights why she might join the list but it would seem she has been targetted for an earlier death even if that is taking its' time

Regan is now Tegan and her Towlie claim fits but role does not equal alignment

Wendy was my most likely Jester and probably still fills this role so I doubt I will lynch here esp not while hoping she has real poison and is not healed.

Vern almost absolving the poisoner with a conversation that didn't happen is sticking with me maybe more than it should and get is putting him in the discussion for me too at this stage.

#FFA2

1.Vern
2.Regan
3.Wendy/Lucy (Jester potentials)

Eva/Liam are probably next in line but neither have made me feel dodgy about them more so since I voted for them while others are thrusting themselves into the spotlight.

btw the number in my FFA don't mean anything, it's not weighted

I’ve asked what the story is, got a gif of one of those lads kicking the other up the ar$e

I don’t know what to say

Senan WW wrote: »

I’ve asked what the story is, got a gif of one of those lads kicking the other up the ar$e

I don’t know what to say

If that was Terrence and Phillip I don't think they were kicking each other and I think that is this games *Shrug*

Ok so a lot of stuff has happened today, then.

Necro wrote: »

Derry WW was





Big Gay Al - Harlot


And also....

EVIL

Holly WW was...





Jesus - Angel


And also....

Good

Necro wrote: »

Moderator Morning Announcements:




Abigail WW was found dead, mostly eaten.


In a surprising turn of events, Derry WW was also found dead at the scene

Their soul still hangs by a thread for up to an hour though

Wendy WW and Winifred WW have been poisoned.

One is fake, one is real.

They have until lynch to be cured, or....

Who or what killed Derry? Derry was found dead, nearly like he died because Abigail was munched, some of connection?

Also the Senan Bullet use is the exact same notice we got for the bullet that killed Gertie.”a shot has been fired”. It seems like the power is similar to the one used agaisnt Gertie which would mean it may not kill the target until the morning.

The wolves have prob thought of this in their BR Senan, is there something you aren’t telling us? Was Senan coming under some heat when he came out with his bullet, this would give a wolf a motive for distracting.

In terms of powers , once you come out on thread we have to assume it’s ok to ask most questions and warn outed villagers of potential consequences. I always take it that if I think of something on my own, there’s a likely probability that a group of baddies can equally come up with the same idea. So by all means don’t answer questions you don’t want to but I think a responsible villager at least posses concerns and questions.

And Senan I am not saying you are bad but having a power that may end up killing a goodie is not a positive. You coming out could be a bad power trying to look good with an easy goody target to pick. I don’t know who you have chosen but if you were bad , you know who is good and can easily manipulate the situation whereby you kill a goody who was a person that people suspect and may not be suspicious about being killed.

If Senans kill order doesn’t work out until the morning (like gerties kill) We will have to consider the possibility that these deaths may be linked.


And Senan, if your choice ends up being bad, good job....