Dee Forbes banging the RTE TV licence drum again 60m uncollected fee poll not working - pl ignore

NIMAN · 21-10-2019 08:51PM

ToBeFrank123 wrote: »

He was overpaid, I don't argue with that.

The point is he is a far better broadcaster than Duffy, no-one can seriously argue with that. Duffy is paid far in excess of his talents as a broadcaster.

Say what you want about PK, but he is in a different league to JD.

Pat is really intelligent. He knows his politics, can hold complex debates with high powered people.

JD is only good at chatting nonsense to old folk on his radio show and asking very average questions. He would be severely out of his depth if he had to hold a topical debate on a serious issue such as Brexit, economics, etc

fritzelly · 21-10-2019 08:58PM

One thing JD is good at is if there is a whiff of a death or serious illness he won't let it go even if the other person doesn't want to talk about it

In fact even if there is no mention he delves deeper about the callers health

Gutter drenching sensationalism

SPDUB · 21-10-2019 09:13PM

fritzelly wrote: »

One thing JD is good at is if there is a whiff of a death or serious illness he won't let it go even if the other person doesn't want to talk about it

What a load of bollocks

You don't ring up Liveline if you don't want to talk about it .

Boggles · 22-10-2019 07:09AM

NIMAN wrote: »

Say what you want about PK, but he is in a different league to JD.

They are completely different types of shows, neither could do what the other do.

NIMAN · 22-10-2019 07:12AM

Boggles wrote: »

They are completely different types of shows, neither could do what the other do.

They were being compared .... hence why I commented.

My point also highlighted that PK is presenting a programme that requires a lot more intelligence. Anyone could do what Duffy does, lets be honest.

He is incredibly well paid for what he does. PK is overpaid too imho, but he has a much harder job.

Boggles · 22-10-2019 07:18AM

NIMAN wrote: »

They were being compared .... hence why I commented.

My point also highlighted that PK is presenting a programme that requires a lot more intelligence. Anyone could do what Duffy does, lets be honest.

He is incredibly well paid for what he does. PK is overpaid too imho, but he has a much harder job.

I like Pat but has proved beyond doubt he can't do the light stuff.

NIMAN · 22-10-2019 07:20AM

Boggles wrote: »

I like Pat but has proved beyond doubt he can't do the light stuff.

I'd agree, but the light stuff is easily done.
It shouldn't require a massive wage the likes of D'arcy and Duffy are getting.

retalivity · 22-10-2019 07:39AM

NIMAN wrote: »

I'd agree, but the light stuff is easily done.
It shouldn't require a massive wage the likes of D'arcy and Duffy are getting.

D'arcy can no longer do light, dark, heavy or political stuff.

He'd kick your ass at pushups though

Boggles · 22-10-2019 07:46AM

NIMAN wrote: »

I'd agree, but the light stuff is easily done.
It shouldn't require a massive wage the likes of D'arcy and Duffy are getting.

Again though when Ray was on Today Fm he was universally liked, since taking a wage off the state it is like he invented child cancer.

Same with Pat, absolutely lampooned on RTE "The Plank", Irelands greatest journalist since he left.

Do you like anyone on RTE?

NIMAN · 22-10-2019 07:49AM

Boggles wrote: »

Again though when Ray was on Today Fm he was universally liked, since taking a wage off the state it is like he invented child cancer.

Same with Pat, absolutely lampooned on RTE "The Plank", Irelands greatest journalist since he left.

Do you like anyone on RTE?

I like lots of stuff on RTE.
Just not people stealing a living from a bankrupt broadcaster.

Boggles · 22-10-2019 07:50AM

NIMAN wrote: »

I like lots of stuff on RTE.

What or who specifically?

NIMAN · 22-10-2019 07:54AM

Boggles wrote: »

What or who specifically?

Off the top of my head:

A lot of stuff on RTE Radio 1. Morning Ireland, Doc On One etc. I listen quite a lot to it.
John Creedon Show
RTE TV news
RTE's investigations and documentaries
Some of their drama....latest one being Dublin Murders.
When they cover sport, they tend to do it very well.
Prime Time

Elmo · 22-10-2019 08:29AM

NIMAN wrote: »

Off the top of my head:

Some of their drama....latest one being Dublin Murders.

Dublin Murders is a BBC production, RTÉ funded very little of the series.

RTÉ have very little Drama output of their own. This year they have had one co-production in The Resistance, one home produced comedy Bridget and Eamon, a BBC drama (Dublin Murders) and The Young Offenders, not sure how much of it they funded.

Interestingly 2018 had more drama (including co-pros and FDI). I wonder what their Head of Drama does.

AndyBoBandy · 22-10-2019 08:38AM

Elmo wrote: »

I wonder what their Head of Drama does.

Gets paid a lot.
Hopes to fcuk that very few people notice that Dublin Murders is BBC produced, so can take credit for it.

Boggles · 22-10-2019 08:39AM

Elmo wrote: »

Dublin Murders is a BBC production, RTÉ funded very little of the series.

How do you know?

Elmo · 22-10-2019 09:04AM

Boggles wrote: »

How do you know?

It was announced by the BBC in 2017. It airs first on the BBC and the following night on RTÉ. I wouldn't be surprised if RTÉ just a paid a broadcast fee much like any other import.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2017/the-dublin-murders
https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2018/dublin-murders

AndyBoBandy · 22-10-2019 09:09AM

Elmo wrote: »

I wouldn't be surprised if RTÉ just a paid a broadcast fee much like any other import.

and got their name/logo in the credits because they supplied the catering vans for the sets in Dublin, with none other than himself below running the vans and creating the menu;

Boggles · 22-10-2019 09:11AM

Elmo wrote: »

It was announced by the BBC in 2017. It airs first on the BBC and the following night on RTÉ. I wouldn't be surprised if RTÉ just a paid a broadcast fee much like any other import.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2017/the-dublin-murders
https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2018/dublin-murders

Oh right I thought you actually knew.

I imagined they joined the production because it was produced in Ireland.

Either way they should be done far more collaborations like this.

Elmo · 22-10-2019 09:27AM

Boggles wrote: »

Oh right I thought you actually knew.

I imagined they joined the production because it was produced in Ireland.

Either way they should be done far more collaborations like this.

As I said:-
Interestingly 2018 had more drama (including co-pros and FDI). I wonder what their Head of Drama does.

And fair dues to them in 2018 for being able to provide one drama/comedy a week between Jan and June 2018.

Same can't be said of 2019. RTÉ should be insuring that the seek to not only collaboration but also some of their own dramas in case that collaboration isn't available.

There will be times when FDIs and Co-pros won't happen. If the BBC had not developed Dublin Murders it wouldn't have been produced, RTÉ should be developing dramas and looking for that Co-pro opportunity, and in some case in the event that FDI or Co-pro aren't there try to continue it themselves.

Otherwise they should defiantly continue to spend 25m on Imported programming.

glenfieldman · 22-10-2019 01:35PM

SPDUB wrote: »

What a load of bollocks

You don't ring up Liveline if you don't want to talk about it .

What about when the caller mentions “ when your researcher called me “

end of the road · 22-10-2019 02:21PM

glenfieldman wrote: »

What about when the caller mentions “ when your researcher called me “

the individual called by the researcher would still have to agree to go on the program.
if they are agreeing to go on the program then i would imagine they are happy to talk, otherwise they have an absolute right to refuse to go on the program.

ToBeFrank123 · 22-10-2019 02:53PM

Also consider the long list of broadcasting talent let through their hands by RTE who were able to make it big in the UK. RTE were unable to use this talent to the best of their abilities

Terry Wogan
Graham Norton
Dara O'Briain
Dermot Morgan
Sharon Horgan
Aisling Bea
Chris O'Dowd

They only recruited some of these back after they made it big abroad.

eg Sharon Horgan

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharon_Horgan

Sharon Lorencia Horgan (born 13 July 1970)[1] is an Anglo-Irish actress, writer, comedian and producer. In 2004, after a rapid rise in London as a comedy writer and actress, Irish TV channel RTE rejected the idea of her comedy entertainment series The Sharon Horgan Show which would be driven by interviews, sketches and stand up guests.

There are others too like Baz Ashmawy.

Despite many of these comic talents, RTE have still failed utterly to come up with even one decent sitcom and instead have come up with unfunny after unfunny comedies that fail to raise even a single laugh.

All these mostly young talents were turned away by RTE or not even considered, so RTE could keep pensioner presenters in jobs.

No wonder many young people have stopped tuning into RTE.

James Brown · 22-10-2019 02:56PM

ToBeFrank123 wrote: »

Also consider the long list of broadcasting talent let through their hands by RTE who were able to make it big in the UK. RTE were unable to use this talent to the best of their abilities

Terry Wogan
Graham Norton
Dara O'Brian
Dermot Morgan
Sharon Horgan
Aisling Bea
Chris O'Dowd

They only recruited some of these back after they made it big abroad.

eg Sharon Horgan

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharon_Horgan

There are others too like Liz Bonin and Baz Ashmawy.

Despite many of these comic talents, RTE have still failed utterly to come up with even one decent sitcom.

All these mostly young talents were turned away by RTE or not even considered, so they could keep their pensioner presenters in jobs.

No wonder many young people have stopped watching RTE.

Hold it now, Baz made his name by appearing on RTE. While he seems to have a level of reality stardom, his appeal is beyond my comprehension.
Liz Bonin 'won' an RTE talent show/competition looking for a presenter. It was rigged. So they had her. She's decent but hardly up there with Norton or the like.

Yep, RTE need their hands on, in and around everything. That's why their output is generally sub-par.

ToBeFrank123 · 22-10-2019 02:58PM

Matt Barrett wrote: »

Hold it now, Baz made his name be appearing on RTE. While he seems to have a level reality stardom, his appeal is beyond my comprehension.
Liz Bonin 'won' an RTE talent show/competition looking for a presenter. It was rigged. So they had her. She's decent but hardly up there with Norton or the like.

You can pick and choose. What about Wogan, Norton, Morgan, Horgan...no room in RTE long term for them?

These people work wonders in the right environment, but RTE is not the right environment.

Unless they are friends with or related to someone in RTE, they are shown the door.

ToBeFrank123 · 22-10-2019 03:05PM

Laura Whitmore, Craig Doyle, Donal McIntyre, Fergal Keane, all good enough for the UK, couldn't get a look in at RTE.

Just a really badly run institution which deserves no more cash until they genuinely get their house in order.

James Brown · 22-10-2019 03:07PM

ToBeFrank123 wrote: »

You can pick and choose. What about Wogan, Norton, Morgan, Horgan...no room in RTE long term for them?

These people work wonders in the right environment, but RTE is not the right environment.

Unless they are friends with or related to someone in RTE, they are shown the door.

Yep.
I think Lottie Ryan is the poster girl for this.
She got a few spots on daytime TV, she got her own show created for her. She wasn't any use on TV so they put her on radio. She's no use there either.
But they'll keep her in a job for life.

James Brown · 22-10-2019 03:08PM

ToBeFrank123 wrote: »

Laura Whitmore, Craig Doyle, Donal McIntyre, Fergal Keane, all good enough for the UK, couldn't get a look in at RTE.

Just a really badly run institution which deserves no more cash until they genuinely get their house in order.

Whitmore won an MTV competition to be a presenter straight out of college. I'd say all work after that being UK based was more organic.

ToBeFrank123 · 22-10-2019 03:10PM

Matt Barrett wrote: »

Yep.
I think Lottie Ryan is the poster girl for this.
She got a few spots on daytime TV, she got her own show created for her. She wasn't any use on TV so they put her on radio. She's no use there either.
But they'll keep her in a job for life.

Agreed, because fundamentally RTE is not based on talent or merit but on who you know.

TheBlock · 22-10-2019 03:31PM

Elmo wrote: »

As I said:-
Interestingly 2018 had more drama (including co-pros and FDI). I wonder what their Head of Drama does.

And fair dues to them in 2018 for being able to provide one drama/comedy a week between Jan and June 2018.

Same can't be said of 2019. RTÉ should be insuring that the seek to not only collaboration but also some of their own dramas in case that collaboration isn't available.

There will be times when FDIs and Co-pros won't happen. If the BBC had not developed Dublin Murders it wouldn't have been produced, RTÉ should be developing dramas and looking for that Co-pro opportunity, and in some case in the event that FDI or Co-pro aren't there try to continue it themselves.

Otherwise they should defiantly continue to spend 25m on Imported programming.

In any Given year RTÉ develop multiple Dramas and Comedies to various scritp stages. They then have to decide if any are good enough to comission. They ofetn aren't and are better dropped than produced as there would be uproar if some of the ****e got on screen.

Head of Drama left in 2018 and replacement is only up and running with their own slate of developments.

Boggles · 22-10-2019 03:36PM

ToBeFrank123 wrote: »

Laura Whitmore, Craig Doyle, Donal McIntyre, Fergal Keane, all good enough for the UK, couldn't get a look in at RTE.

Just a really badly run institution which deserves no more cash until they genuinely get their house in order.

Whitmore won a competition. She isn't on tv anymore AFAIK.

Doyle was given a chat show and several other shows on RTE.

McIntyre can't get on telly anymore because his shows were a load of expensive nonsense.

Keane started on RTE and was head hunted by the BBC.

Dee Forbes banging the RTE TV licence drum again 60m uncollected fee *poll not working - pl ignore*

Comments

Dee Forbes banging the RTE TV licence drum again 60m uncollected fee poll not working - pl ignore