All Ireland Senior Hurling (Liam Mccarthy Cup) 2019

Sawduck · 28-07-2019 04:24PM

I knew the moment I heard the ref was from kilkenny that we were going to have a hard battle but this is ridiculous,that ref is disgusting

Happy4all · 28-07-2019 04:25PM

dastardly00 wrote: »

So you think he got the call and then decided to let the play continue on just for the sh1ts & giggles??

Supposedly it takes 15 secs, he is so incompetent I am suggesting he forgot to blow sooner, which could have avoided the ball ending up in the Wexford net. I've no idea why he disallowed the first goal

RMAOK · 28-07-2019 04:25PM

Stoner wrote: »

Thought it was a free out myself.

It would have been if he hadn't taken the 3 or 4 steps before going into the tackle.

Say Your Number · 28-07-2019 04:25PM

I know it's a rule that's rarely enforced, but he took at least six steps for the disallowed goal.

marvin80 · 28-07-2019 04:25PM

lawred2 wrote: »

Obviously the angle on TV isn't clear but it doesn't look to me that the ball cleared the bar.

Can see Tipp running out of steam with about 20 to go

Looked like Hogan's hand was a little away from the bar but what can you do.

Surely Wexford can't keep this pace up either (hopefully anyway!).

Exciting second half ahead.

iebamm2580 · 28-07-2019 04:25PM

I thought Hawkeye only judges between uprights not over the bar, also tipps first goal should have been allowed, disgraceful.

martingriff · 28-07-2019 04:25PM

citykat wrote: »

Whatever about the hawkeye point, there was absolutely nothing wrong with Tipps disallowed goal

None except as the game would have had to happen with a kick out (what you call it in hurling). Wexford players would have been set and back

citykat · 28-07-2019 04:27PM

martingriff wrote: »

None except as the game would have had to happen with a kick out (what you call it in hurling). Wexford players would have been set and back

Do keep up!ðŸ˜

dastardly00 · 28-07-2019 04:27PM

Happy4all wrote: »

Supposedly it takes 15 secs, he is so incompetent I am suggesting he forgot to blow sooner, which could have avoided the ball ending up in the Wexford net. I've no idea why he disallowed the first goal

Where did you hear 15 seconds?
The Sunday Game said 30 seconds

BarryNumber1 · 28-07-2019 04:27PM

walshb wrote: »

There was. It happened from an incorrect resumption of the game..

But the ref played on. Why can’t he allow the goal after the event, just like he awarded the point?

weldoninhio · 28-07-2019 04:27PM

citykat wrote: »

Whatever about the hawkeye point, there was absolutely nothing wrong with Tipps disallowed goal

Except that the ball had gone out of play before it.

threeball · 28-07-2019 04:28PM

fullstop wrote: »

threeball wrote: »

But he did touch it. No way that ball was over. He can't catch the ball with the whole thing over the bar. Not a chance.

Of course you can. How many mm is a sliotar? You can easily catch it from behind the line.

Not at the height it was clearing the crossbar. Human arm can't do what's suggested.

citykat · 28-07-2019 04:28PM

weldoninhio wrote: »

Except that the ball had gone out of play before it.

Aw Jesus ðŸ˜

Mushy · 28-07-2019 04:28PM

weldoninhio wrote: »

Except that the ball had gone out of play before it.

Tipp have had two disallowed goals, he means the first one

TheRiverman · 28-07-2019 04:28PM

C__MC wrote: »

Jesus Cantwell is dire
Youd miss lyster

Jesus Cantwell,who is he ? 😊

Bridge93 · 28-07-2019 04:29PM

Hawkeye takes on average 30 seconds, this took 32 apparently so it’s not that much longer. It seems like it took longer as the ball was back in play. Usually when it’s needed the ball is dead anyway so everyone is waiting.

I’m going to back Hawkeye being correct rather than those here saying it wasn’t over based only on a shot from a bad camera angle

Happy4all · 28-07-2019 04:29PM

martingriff wrote: »

None except as the game would have had to happen with a kick out (what you call it in hurling). Wexford players would have been set and back

By that logic, it you called the play back for every missed foul, we would have scores ruled out all day long.

Mokuba · 28-07-2019 04:29PM

I'm in the stands and the Tipp fans are in disbelief. Not just the two goal calls. Everything else too. Reading through some of the reaction here at half time but from the stands I've never seen anything as biased.

I thought Kilkenny got rode by the ref yesterday but this is on a different level again.

Fast Twitch · 28-07-2019 04:29PM

martingriff wrote: »

None except as the game would have had to happen with a kick out (what you call it in hurling). Wexford players would have been set and back

Are you the full shilling? 'What you call it in hurling'.

PressRun · 28-07-2019 04:30PM

fullstop wrote: »

It’s not really, is it? Ball was over the bar so it had to be called back.

I mean it clearly is given the amount of debate about it already.

Mantis Toboggan · 28-07-2019 04:30PM

Tipperary rode for two goals so far, Cleere is a kilkenny man, should never have been given the job.

Mushy · 28-07-2019 04:30PM

Bridge93 wrote: »

Hawkeye takes on average 30 seconds, this took 32 apparently so it’s not that much longer. It seems like it took longer as the ball was back in play. Usually when it’s needed the ball is dead anyway so everyone is waiting.

I’m going to back Hawkeye being correct rather than those here saying it wasn’t over based only on a shot from a bad camera angle

But Hawkeye only tracks ball flight and if it's between the posts. Ugh way hogans wrists were, and not touching the crossbar, there's no way it was over the bar

C__MC · 28-07-2019 04:31PM

Mokuba wrote: »

I'm in the stands and the Tipp fans are in disbelief. Not just the two goal calls. Everything else too. Reading through some of the reaction here at half time but from the stands I've never seen anything as biased.

I thought Kilkenny got rode by the ref yesterday but this is on a different level again.

Anyone who knows hurling knows the intense rivalry of kk and tipp , it was unfair to give this game to the kk man

walshb · 28-07-2019 04:31PM

BarryNumber1 wrote: »

But the ref played on. Why can’t he allow the goal after the event, just like he awarded the point?

I kind of agree. Play resumed. At that moment in time, and the moments after, play was resumed.

Bridge93 · 28-07-2019 04:31PM

Mushy wrote: »

But Hawkeye only tracks ball flight and if it's between the posts. Ugh way hogans wrists were, and not touching the crossbar, there's no way it was over the bar

It doesn’t just track whether it was between the posts. It tracks everything.

citykat · 28-07-2019 04:32PM

C__MC wrote: »

Anyone who knows hurling knows the intense rivalry of kk and tipp , it was unfair to give this game to the kk man

Thank Limerick for that ****up

iebamm2580 · 28-07-2019 04:32PM

Bridge93 wrote: »

Hawkeye takes on average 30 seconds, this took 32 apparently so it’s not that much longer. It seems like it took longer as the ball was back in play. Usually when it’s needed the ball is dead anyway so everyone is waiting.

I’m going to back Hawkeye being correct rather than those here saying it wasn’t over based only on a shot from a bad camera angle

Hawkeye isn't there to judge distance over crossbar hence why its not used for goals Hawkeye shouldn't have came into it.

ClanofLams · 28-07-2019 04:32PM

Cantwell is grand. Don’t get the complaints.

Happy4all · 28-07-2019 04:32PM

Your one on the panel accent is very hard on the ears

Mushy · 28-07-2019 04:32PM

Bridge93 wrote: »

It doesn’t just track whether it was between the posts. It tracks everything.

So it acts as goalline technology as well?

All Ireland Senior Hurling (Liam Mccarthy Cup) 2019

Comments