Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

Baggly · 08-05-2019 07:57PM

Pter wrote:

I still think you may be a wolf though, so I'll stick with my vote on you. But I hope whatever you flip as, and whatever thst happens, we can have a laugh about it after the game.

*whenever that happens

sKeith · 08-05-2019 08:05PM

tusk wrote: »

any of you fine detectives have an updated list of current votes ?

sKeith · 08-05-2019 08:07PM

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:08PM

Updated notes for whatever they're worth.

Barney92 Sarcastic. Did homework on why Whippy. Focused on Clarabels posting too. Lean village.
Bounty Hunter Too chilled out? Having fun at least! Questioned sKeith. Did somewhat detailed reads list.
Clarabel Asking questions. Newbie? Voted Duff yet FFAs 3 others. Updated FFA only has 2 names. Then says voted CTK. Shades Strawbs and Pter. Neutral to wolf.
crosstownk Still nada
Digital Solitude Sames
Dublinandy2 Think the Dandy/Skunk mutual support would be strange if wolfy but could be a pocket tactic? Do not like the quick switch from Pter is good to Pter is in my FFA. Interaction with Pter is defensive. One to watch
Duffman13 Returned Weds lunchtimeish. Nothing further since then. Quiet wolf?
Ectoplasm Still village
fixxxer Struggling for a read here. FFA seems wishy washy on readback. Leaning wolf for now.
Green&Red Really didn't like the "I like how you play interaction" - here's my pocket jump on in OR hello teammate? Claims starting bandwagon on Dandy was to get info but BH actually asked if it was this or contents of post and GnR originally said it was a little of both. Stays wolfy.
kitten_k Can't shake the feeling of wolf here. Only post of substance is FFA. Fact that she has G n R and sKeith on there feels a little bit bandwagony. Moving to first / second on my list. Possible vote here.
Kolido Whiplash ID'd him as wolf and died but also said 1st munch be most telling of the game? Setting village up to read more into it than necessary? He'd be less likely to do this surely, unless double bluff. Post about sKeith & Pter rings alarm bells though. Also says wolves less likely to throw shade due to no roles...eh? Soft defense of LoughC? Newbie likely a wolf. Definite wolf lean
Loughc Not a thing.
Pter Getting mostly village from him but interaction with Dandy needs more scrutiny. Still village, just about.
quickbeam Stays neutral for now.
sKeith Can't warm to style this game. Always annoys me when other people think how they play is how everyone should play though so keep this in mind. Interactions with G n R and safelisting of same are interesting. Consistent and paying attention. Still neutral.
Strawberry Milkshake Voted for kitten who is now my top wolf. Jokes about being lynched and volunteers for lynch. Strange play. Doing work re votes. Back to neutral for now.
Succubus_ Possible quiet wolf here.
TheSkunk Frustration with sKeith seems believable. Seems to be looking for holes in his "Lock Clear" stuff which is good. Defending Dandy could be a familiarity thing? Working hard. Village lean for now
Triceratops Ballet Did some reads on people. Feels neutral to village for now.
tritium Favours FFAs. Agrees re kitten. Leaning village today.
tusk Nothing strongly standing out. Neutral to village also.
Whiplashy Still dead. RIP.

tusk · 08-05-2019 08:14PM

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Updated notes for whatever they're worth.

Barney92 Sarcastic. Did homework on why Whippy. Focused on Clarabels posting too. Lean village.
Bounty Hunter Too chilled out? Having fun at least! Questioned sKeith. Did somewhat detailed reads list.
Clarabel Asking questions. Newbie? Voted Duff yet FFAs 3 others. Updated FFA only has 2 names. Then says voted CTK. Shades Strawbs and Pter. Neutral to wolf.
crosstownk Still nada
Digital Solitude Sames
Dublinandy2 Think the Dandy/Skunk mutual support would be strange if wolfy but could be a pocket tactic? Do not like the quick switch from Pter is good to Pter is in my FFA. Interaction with Pter is defensive. One to watch
Duffman13 Returned Weds lunchtimeish. Nothing further since then. Quiet wolf?
Ectoplasm Still village
fixxxer Struggling for a read here. FFA seems wishy washy on readback. Leaning wolf for now.
Green&Red Really didn't like the "I like how you play interaction" - here's my pocket jump on in OR hello teammate? Claims starting bandwagon on Dandy was to get info but BH actually asked if it was this or contents of post and GnR originally said it was a little of both. Stays wolfy.
kitten_k Can't shake the feeling of wolf here. Only post of substance is FFA. Fact that she has G n R and sKeith on there feels a little bit bandwagony. Moving to first / second on my list. Possible vote here.
Kolido Whiplash ID'd him as wolf and died but also said 1st munch be most telling of the game? Setting village up to read more into it than necessary? He'd be less likely to do this surely, unless double bluff. Post about sKeith & Pter rings alarm bells though. Also says wolves less likely to throw shade due to no roles...eh? Soft defense of LoughC? Newbie likely a wolf. Definite wolf lean
Loughc Not a thing.
Pter Getting mostly village from him but interaction with Dandy needs more scrutiny. Still village, just about.
quickbeam Stays neutral for now.
sKeith Can't warm to style this game. Always annoys me when other people think how they play is how everyone should play though so keep this in mind. Interactions with G n R and safelisting of same are interesting. Consistent and paying attention. Still neutral.
Strawberry Milkshake Voted for kitten who is now my top wolf. Jokes about being lynched and volunteers for lynch. Strange play. Doing work re votes. Back to neutral for now.
Succubus_ Possible quiet wolf here.
TheSkunk Frustration with sKeith seems believable. Seems to be looking for holes in his "Lock Clear" stuff which is good. Defending Dandy could be a familiarity thing? Working hard. Village lean for now
Triceratops Ballet Did some reads on people. Feels neutral to village for now.
tritium Favours FFAs. Agrees re kitten. Leaning village today.
tusk Nothing strongly standing out. Neutral to village also.
Whiplashy Still dead. RIP.

I like the utility of this. Will definitely use if I have the stones for another game after this one.

Clarabel · 08-05-2019 08:14PM

Triceratops Ballet wrote: »

Ok I've been doing some reading, I haven't read everyone's iso yet cos there's a lot of chaff from the weekend.

so far here are my thoughts:

Very low posters (I categorised this as anyone who's posted less than the mods!)
Digi, CTK, LoughC, Succubus
For obvious reasons I've not read on these, inclined to give the benefit of the doubt for the next day or so as RL can get in the way and there's bound to be a reason they picked a slow game to play.

I won't be voting from the v low poster group...this time

Next Level (players who've posted up to and around my level so far....spoiler alert this is as far as I've gotten)
Duffman - was very chatty all weekend kind of went a bit hard on peope "who forgot the game was starting" led us down a meta convo route with skeith, and agreed with QB that constantly changing nicknames was unfair on newbs. absent since then. could be RL could be more.

Tusk- first game trying to figure out what kind of villager they are (their words not mine) has soem interractions with other (barney and Fixxer) players wants to understand their reasoning for accusations a little. still catching up on thread.

Trit- Not loads of posts but lots of good questioning of motives of other posters, in favour of FFA and favours posters declaring their vote on thread

Ecto - again not loads of posts, but true to her word yesterday deliverd a detailed post of her thoughts on everyone yesterday

Triceratops Ballet - a majestic and graceful creature with a three horned face! She's been a little MIA so far this game but that's ok cos it was a bank holiday and this is a slow burning game and she has work to do!!!

Clarabel - also "forgot about the game" asks a lot of questions, has submitted 2 different FFA's and voted twice both times for people not on her FFA

Out of the above list so far I'm suss on Clara and Duffer, Clara can you clarify why neither of your votes were for people on your FFAs?

When I get a chunk of time again later I'll look at further posters and be back with questions, as a placeholder I'll be voting Duffer (I think)

Sure cause my FFA were high chatters and I didn't want to vote people who are talking. I think they'll help the game in the long run.

08-05-2019 08:15PM

Day one votes so far

Tuesday
10:03 strawbs votes kitten
10:07 Pter votes Andy
10:18 green votes Andy
13:02 fixer voting trit or Barney with side of Keith
15:08 Andy voting green
15:26 Kolido voting tomorrow (today) for someone not throwing out accusations
16:33 Andy reiterating their vote on green
16:40 green states open to change his Andy vote
16:44 Trit thinks green and Andy interactions interesting and probably vote green out of 2
18:34 bounty will probably placeholder green or strawberry soon. Confirmed at 12:49 Wednesday that he put vote on strawberry.
20:35 clarabel votes duffman
21:45 Pter reiterating vote staying on Andy
22:26 clarabel unvotes duffman and votes crosstownk
Wednesday
01:57 Keith votes fixxxer
05:38 bounty says skunk has voted Keith think I missed skunk saying this (check ffa at 19:26 Tuesday)
07:36 Kolido votes loughc
09:45 Andy unvoting green and leaning towards Pter
09:57 strawberry unvotes kitten and votes Kolido
10:13 Qb votes for skunk
10:59 green reiterating they haven’t moved off Andy but Andy bringing them around
12:33 kitten says she hasn’t voted yet but will do so before she leaves work this afternoon.
12:40 triceratops says she is putting a placeholder on duffman (she thinks).
12:49 ectoplasm says she hasn’t voted yet and won’t until she is home.
12:52 fixxxer says leaning strongly on a green vote after reading back. Waiting to see more info before switching to Keith.
13:01 triceratops confirms vote on duffman
13:15 tusk states that they put a vote on skunk some time Tuesday.
15:15 skunk think of voting green but not definite
15;34 kitten votes Keith
16:04 tritium clarifies that he hasn’t put a vote in yesterday
17:20 green says he’s leaving vote on Andy
18:47 tritium puts placeholder vote on green
18:56 tritium tempted to switch to kitten
19:10 tritium unvotes green and votes kitten
19:18 ectoplasm votes kitten
19:42 strawberry unvotes Kolido and votes kitten
19:47 pter states his vote staying on Andy

Clarabel · 08-05-2019 08:20PM

Barney92 wrote: »

Okay, was just wondering if there was anything specific that made you change your mind.

I can't recall to be honest. It's all quite gut at the moment. I'm digesting hours of posts in a quick time period. I'll try be more descriptive and give deeper reasons next time.

I'm not feeling SK as wolf but can see why people are saying that.

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:20PM

And for brevity...

Kitten K Wolfiest
Kolido Wolfy
Fixxer Wolfy
Clarabel Wolfyish
Duffman Wolfyish
Green & Red Wolfyish
Succubus Wolfyish
sKeith Neutral to Wolf
Strawbs Neutral to Wolf
D Andy Neutral to Wolf
Tusk Neutral to Village
TB Neutral to Village
QB Neutral to Village
Pter Villagish
Bounty Hunter Villagish
Barney Village
Skunk Village
Tritium Village
Me Village
CTK Still nothing to go on
Lough C Still nothing to go on
Digi Still nothing to go on

sKeith · 08-05-2019 08:21PM

moving ecto into my village circle for now and if nobody else joins my fixxer wagon by 8:30, i'll give it up today and join trit ecto and strawberry, now 3 of my village leans on kitten.

Clarabel · 08-05-2019 08:24PM

Kolido wrote: »

I'm not suggesting the game was drafted, but odds are odds.

That is not my only reason, I was working of Keithys reads also. Let me clarify Clarebel, I dont think you're a wolf because you're newish. Convince me you're on the level.

Can you show me the maths of these odds please?

On what level, not sure I understand your question.

Kolido · 08-05-2019 08:24PM

Really like Strawbs summary points, nice work.

*This should not be thought of as pocketing.

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:25PM

tusk wrote: »

I like the utility of this. Will definitely use if I have the stones for another game after this one.

It takes some time to do but it is worth it and gets easier as game goes on. Not easy if you're on mobile.

Unfortunately it's also got me munched in the past, BUT, at least all my thoughts are out there if that happens.

And you should definitely play more games. They're good craic, especially as games go on. Just need to remember not to take anything said on here too seriously and that it is just a game.

Obviously I'm excellent at remembering it is just a game. It's not like I've spent time shouting at my computer or anything...

08-05-2019 08:26PM

Where is everyone? I’m looking forward to a Chinese fire drill (someone else explain what that is). Don’t move yet, Keith as I could be swayed and fixxxer is dodgy.

Baggly · 08-05-2019 08:26PM

At least you have never broken a laptop over a game....... Eh duffman

Necro · 08-05-2019 08:28PM

Game Mod:

Just over 30 mins to vote.

Clarabel · 08-05-2019 08:29PM

kitten_k wrote: »

#FFA1

sKeith - not liking his antagonistic play. keeps saying he is lock clear village but this is only to him as there is no way in the game to prove this but still hell bent on trying to get everyone to accept this. I feel like his play is a bluff to make us think that a wolf surely wouldn't play like that.

G&R - I feel like he is trying to hard to come across as a villager and doesn't like when people go against his thoughts or call him out on things.

Clarabel - there is more a feeling as there is something about her posts that are not sitting right with me but can't pin point exactly what. I know she said she would have limited availability until today so hopefully when she starts to get more involved it will help.

Vote going in now for sKeith.

I don't think I said until today, I'm never gonna be around much during the day. I'm pulling 12-15 hours at work and go live has just been moved out a week. I'm really struggling to keep up with reading. I'm here an hour already. In two weeks I'll be unemployed and free to post all day every day. You gonna have to give me a break til then. I'm trying to keep up.

08-05-2019 08:30PM

Kolido wrote: »

Really like Strawbs summary points, nice work.

*This should not be thought of as pocketing.

Awwwww thanks

Kolido · 08-05-2019 08:32PM

Clarabel wrote: »

Can you show me the maths of these odds please?

On what level, not sure I understand your question.

Afraid not. I may have phrased my original post incorectly. On the level I mean convince me your a villager.

Kolido · 08-05-2019 08:33PM

Kolido wrote: »

Really like Strawbs summary points, nice work.

*This should not be thought of as pocketing.

Also Ectos summaries, nice work.

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:35PM

Pter, can you explain your thinking on DAndy? I've read back and I don't see it.

Also what's your thinking on Kitten?

sKeith · 08-05-2019 08:35PM

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Where is everyone? I’m looking forward to a Chinese fire drill (someone else explain what that is). Don’t move yet, Keith as I could be swayed and fixxxer is dodgy.

Its the equivelant to this video, but with voting.

Baggly · 08-05-2019 08:39PM

Ectoplasm wrote:

Pter, can you explain your thinking on DAndy? I've read back and I don't see it.

I think his original long posts were too polished and organized, with a view to keep him out of trouble, for a new player. I also think his flip onto me when I stuck on him after gnr softened (imo) was wolfy.

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:40PM

Thoughts on Kitten?

Also where tf is everyone?

08-05-2019 08:40PM

Necro and sully are gonna hate me.

I’m not sure on kitten. I always vote for her every game without fail. I’ve put my vote back on Kolido

Baggly · 08-05-2019 08:41PM

Ectoplasm wrote:

Thoughts on Kitten?

I understand where people are coming from but there wouldn't be enough for me. Happier with dandy or gnr.

sKeith · 08-05-2019 08:42PM

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Necro and sully are gonna hate me.

I’m not sure on kitten. I always vote for her every game without fail. I’ve put my vote back on Kolido

Moving my vote to kitten.

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:42PM

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Necro and sully are gonna hate me.

I’m not sure on kitten. I always vote for her every game without fail. I’ve put my vote back on Kolido

Why Kolido over fixxer out of curiosity?

Ectoplasm · 08-05-2019 08:43PM

The lack of defense worries me.

sKeith · 08-05-2019 08:43PM

Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

Comments