Residential Log Cabin

trixychic · 26-06-2017 5:23pm #1

Hi guys,

So myself and OH have been renting together now for 10 yrs. We have 2 kids and are getting to the point now where we feel like we will never get onto the property market. We find ourselves in a position at the moment where we must take a leap of Faith now or keep on waiting.

So we are trying to find an alternative way in. We are looking into buying a residential log cabin (3bed) and putting it on a site. Planning permission is looking like it is a possibility but i need to know more as I will not go forward with this on a whim.

I have looked at pricing for insulation, electrics, plumbing... I think I found a company that will do an insurance deal for us.

But what other pit falls are there?? What are the questions I should be asking??

This is not our permanent solution but it is our way out of this disgracful rental disaster that's there at the minute. We hope to be in this for 10-20 yrs, pay it off and then work on our mortgage. We are both still young enough but with the way the renting is now, owning a house is just not looking possible before 40yrs old the regular way.

Tia.

Samuel T. Cogley · 26-06-2017 5:33pm

Log cabins seem to come up on a very regular basis so a quick search might be worth it. However it seems to me, to be a distraction from actually buying somewhere. The cabins aren't cheap and one would think if you could afford one you'd be in a position to put down a deposit on a house.

Gumbo · 26-06-2017 5:40pm

trixychic wrote: »

Hi guys,

So myself and OH have been renting together now for 10 yrs. We have 2 kids and are getting to the point now where we feel like we will never get onto the property market. We find ourselves in a position at the moment where we must take a leap of Faith now or keep on waiting.

So we are trying to find an alternative way in. We are looking into buying a residential log cabin (3bed) and putting it on a site. Planning permission is looking like it is a possibility but i need to know more as I will not go forward with this on a whim.

I have looked at pricing for insulation, electrics, plumbing... I think I found a company that will do an insurance deal for us.

But what other pit falls are there?? What are the questions I should be asking??

This is not our permanent solution but it is our way out of this disgracful rental disaster that's there at the minute. We hope to be in this for 10-20 yrs, pay it off and then work on our mortgage. We are both still young enough but with the way the renting is now, owning a house is just not looking possible before 40yrs old the regular way.

Tia.

What county is this in?
Planning generally doesn't get granted for log cabins.

Next question is how you can make this log cabin meet our current building regulations.

trixychic · 26-06-2017 5:50pm

kceire wrote: »

What county is this in?
Planning generally doesn't get granted for log cabins.

Next question is how you can make this log cabin meet our current building regulations.

They are done by a company called timber living. My sister in laws friend got one a couple of yes back. It's lovely... although hers is just a 2 bed. She was in wexford. Im in co. Carlow. It seems to have met the building regulations but that is something I will look into. Thanks.

Again this is just something im trying to see if it's a possibility. As it seems we could make it work for under €100k.

Graham · 26-06-2017 5:56pm

trixychic wrote: »

They are done by a company called timber living. My sister in laws friend got one a couple of yes back. It's lovely... although hers is just a 2 bed. She was in wexford. Im in co. Carlow. It seems to have met the building regulations but that is something I will look into. Thanks.

Again this is just something im trying to see if it's a possibility. As it seems we could make it work for under €100k.

I'd start by searching for your sister in laws friends planning application/permission for the log cabin.

If you find an application, you'll learn exactly how difficult it is to get permission for a residential log-cabin that is planning compliant.

trixychic · 26-06-2017 5:59pm

Graham wrote: »

I'd start by searching for your sister in laws friends planning application/permission for the log cabin.

If you find an application, you'll learn exactly how difficult it is to get permission for a residential log-cabin that is planning compliant.

That's a fantastic idea. Thank you.

Lumen · 26-06-2017 8:07pm

On a point of pedantry, I have never actually seen a "log cabin" in Ireland that is made of whole logs.

I suppose "pressure-treated plank cabin" doesn't really have the same appeal.

trixychic · 26-06-2017 8:34pm

Lumen wrote: »

On a point of pedantry, I have never actually seen a "log cabin" in Ireland that is made of whole logs.

I suppose "pressure-treated plank cabin" doesn't really have the same appeal.

Ha ha ha defo not. Log cabin sounds much more appealing. Ha

Marcusm · 26-06-2017 8:41pm

Would it not be easier to call it a prefab?

Gumbo · 26-06-2017 9:52pm

trixychic wrote: »

That's a fantastic idea. Thank you.

And you might point us to the application online on the councils website.
Nobody has ever been able to provide a link to a granted log cabin that has subsequently been constructed to our current building regulations.

Now a normal built home with a timber clad is a different storey.
I look forward to the link.

ProudDUB · 27-06-2017 11:40am

Wasn't last years winner of Home of The Year, a log cabin, over looking a lake somewhere in the midlands?

Didn't look overly fussy or authenitically log cabin-y from the outside, but the interior layout and design of of the inside spaces was incredibly well thought out and planned. I'd say it would be a hard enough to pull off, without a very good architect who'd know how to integrate the basic shell of the cabin into modern life styles and needs.

Graham · 27-06-2017 2:06pm

Log cabins do occasionally get permission. The proper log-cabins that is, made of actual logs.

I don't think I've ever come across one of the pressure treated plank 'cabins' that's been granted planning for residential use.

Lumen · 27-06-2017 2:44pm

ProudDUB wrote: »

Wasn't last years winner of Home of The Year, a log cabin, over looking a lake somewhere in the midlands?

Graham wrote: »

I don't think I've ever come across one of the pressure treated plank 'cabins' that's been granted planning for residential use.

http://www.thejournal.ie/westmeath-cabin-rte-home-of-the-year-2741813-Apr2016/

Has bedroom and bathroom so I assume it has planning for residential use. Would be much of a "home" otherwise.

?width=630&version=2741849

GoneHome · 27-06-2017 2:55pm

As it seems we could make it work for under €100k.[/QUOTE]

A quick search of Daft brings up 13 houses in Co. Carlow under €100,000, would one of those not be a better investment than a "log cabin"?

Lumen · 27-06-2017 2:57pm

GoneHome wrote: »

A quick search of Daft brings up 13 houses in Co. Carlow under €100,000, would one of those not be a better investment than a "log cabin"?

This one? :pac:

YzU3M2FiOTkxYzA3OTk1ZDhiOWY2Y2JiOWU2ZDZkMzQjFfSNNs9i5P6heSQoZrB-aHR0cDovL3MzLWV1LXdlc3QtMS5hbWF6b25hd3MuY29tL21lZGlhbWFzdGVyLXMzZXUvYi85L2I5NWI5YTAzNjRkNDE0ZTc1OGRhMGRhMmMzZjZmOWYwLmpwZ3x8fHx8fDYwOXg0NTd8aHR0cDovL3d3dy5kYWZ0LmllL2kvd2F0ZXJtYXJrX2RhZnQucG5nfHx8.jpg

YzU3M2FiOTkxYzA3OTk1ZDhiOWY2Y2JiOWU2ZDZkMzQjFfSNNs9i5P6heSQoZrB-aHR0cDovL3MzLWV1LXdlc3QtMS5hbWF6b25hd3MuY29tL21lZGlhbWFzdGVyLXMzZXUvYi85L2I5NWI5YTAzNjRkNDE0ZTc1OGRhMGRhMmMzZjZmOWYwLmpwZ3x8fHx8fDYwOXg0NTd8aHR0cDovL3d3dy5kYWZ0LmllL2kvd2F0ZXJtYXJrX2RhZnQucG5nfHx8.jpg

Seriously, none of those houses under 100k are built to current regs, so it's not comparing like with like.

The Bishop Basher · 27-06-2017 2:59pm

There are a handful of people building proper log homes in Ireland but planning is a nightmare.

We were told, in writing, by the head of planning, that our "Hansel and Gretel" style house would be out of keeping with the character of the local area...

It wasn't of course but they needed a reason to turn it down..

When I saw the term he used to described the house i knew we hadn't a hope..

So sustainability went out the window and we built with concrete instead.

Its such a shame because they make beautiful houses that last for generations when built correctly..

Graham · 27-06-2017 3:08pm

Lumen wrote: »

http://www.thejournal.ie/westmeath-cabin-rte-home-of-the-year-2741813-Apr2016/

Has bedroom and bathroom so I assume it has planning for residential use. Would be much of a "home" otherwise.

Fantastic looking place, looks like it was a renovation of an existing cabin. Would be interesting to see if something like that would get planning now.

Gumbo · 27-06-2017 3:12pm

Graham wrote: »

Fantastic looking place, looks like it was a renovation of an existing cabin. Would be interesting to see if something like that would get planning now.

+1
And terms like forest cabin, and lakeside cabin make me think this is not officially classed as a dwelling. Would be interesting to see the planning status of it.

May the OP can clarify, are you looking for a "log cabin" that you buy for 20k or are you thinking of a proper built house with external timber cladding.

I asked earlier but it has still gone unanswered.

GoneHome · 27-06-2017 3:18pm

Lumen wrote: »

Seriously, none of those houses under 100k are built to current regs, so it's not comparing like with like.

I was thinking more along the lines of this one
http://www.daft.ie/carlow/houses-for-sale/carlow-town/79-the-laurels-tullow-road-carlow-town-carlow-1480805/

Graham · 27-06-2017 3:23pm

GoneHome wrote: »

I was thinking more along the lines of this one
http://www.daft.ie/carlow/houses-for-sale/carlow-town/79-the-laurels-tullow-road-carlow-town-carlow-1480805/

Without even considering planning permission that would probably work out cheaper than even the cheapest 'log cabin' by the time you've taken into account electricity, water, waste, local authority contributions, foundations etc etc etc.

ProudDUB · 28-06-2017 12:46am

Swanner wrote: »

There are a handful of people building proper log homes in Ireland but planning is a nightmare.

We were told, in writing, by the head of planning, that our "Hansel and Gretel" style house would be out of keeping with the character of the local area...

It wasn't of course but they needed a reason to turn it down..

When I saw the term he used to described the house i knew we hadn't a hope..

So sustainability went out the window and we built with concrete instead.

Its such a shame because they make beautiful houses that last for generations when built correctly..

Which would be understandable if you lived in say...the Cotswolds, where there is a distinct local building tradition, of immense charm and beauty. But most of Irelands housing stock is bog standard housing estates, with bog standard 3 bed semi detached houses...or bog standard bungalow blitz style dormer bungalow, after bog standard bungalow blitz style dormer bungalow. I've a hard time seeing how deviating from that, could be at all wrong, regardless of what you want to build.

jamesthepeach · 28-06-2017 8:10am

I was house hunting about 3 years ago.
I came across two log cabins, one which was proper logs and seemed to be holding up very well was near glendalough.

Another which was more the flat timber planks was in Donabate on a nice big site, but the structure itself was icky and I think probably needed lots of work.

Both put questions of how long they would last into my mind. The real log one I would say fared better over time.

The Bishop Basher · 28-06-2017 10:26am

ProudDUB wrote: »

Which would be understandable if you lived in say...the Cotswolds, where there is a distinct local building tradition, of immense charm and beauty. But most of Irelands housing stock is bog standard housing estates, with bog standard 3 bed semi detached houses...or bog standard bungalow blitz style dormer bungalow, after bog standard bungalow blitz style dormer bungalow. I've a hard time seeing how deviating from that, could be at all wrong, regardless of what you want to build.

Absolutely..

I wouldn't mind but the house next door, less then 10ft away, was timber clad and there's another log home within 2 minutes walk..

There is no character to be in keeping with as the houses in this area were built over many decades and span many shapes, sizes and styles.. No 2 are the same...

When we did finally get some feedback via a third party, we were told they wanted us to design a house, similar to those in a nearby estate.. Why they wanted this I'll never understand but to us it felt like a case of computer says no.. I don't think they can handle anything that strays off the manual. We did ask for pre planning meetings but were told the only way to find out if plans would be accepted would be to lodge an application.

So after a few rounds of that we just gave up and built the concrete box they wanted us to build..

trixychic · 29-06-2017 2:23pm

kceire wrote: »

+1
And terms like forest cabin, and lakeside cabin make me think this is not officially classed as a dwelling. Would be interesting to see the planning status of it.

May the OP can clarify, are you looking for a "log cabin" that you buy for 20k or are you thinking of a proper built house with external timber cladding.

I asked earlier but it has still gone unanswered.

Sorry my young man's birthday party is tomorrow and im up to my eyeballs.

Im looking to get a "log cabin" for €30-40k. It would be the first step to getting the property ladder started for us.

SIL friend is off on holidays at the min so will be talkin to her when she gets back and I've booked appoint with planning commitee so we'll just go from there.

trixychic · 29-06-2017 2:30pm

GoneHome wrote: »

I was thinking more along the lines of this one
http://www.daft.ie/carlow/houses-for-sale/carlow-town/79-the-laurels-tullow-road-carlow-town-carlow-1480805/

There is a reason that the houses in the laurels and Burrin manor are so cheap. We are a family with 2 young children. My eldest has Autism and my youngest is in the process of being assessed. I would be terrified to move into those estates. They are filled with drugs and violence.

It may sound like im being picky but I lived in estates like that as a child with very traumatic outcomes. I'll keep renting before I go back tk one of those.

Besides like I said. According to the bank we are still coming up short on mortgage criteria. We were hoping ti take out a large personal loan instead to pay for things.

Graham · 29-06-2017 2:43pm

trixychic wrote: »

Sorry my young man's birthday party is tomorrow and im up to my eyeballs.

Im looking to get a "log cabin" for €30-40k. It would be the first step to getting the property ladder started for us.

Realistically even if you miraculously got planning permission, you'd spend the largest part of your budget before you got anywhere near a cabin.

Have a search through the other threads about 'log cabins', the idea comes up very regularly and none of them have ever resulted in a poster coming back with good news.

The headline prices you see is usually for an outbuilding. Something you might use as a games room/studio/office. For any other purposes you're going to need to invest in water/drains/biocycle/electricity/architects/local authority contributions and additional expense to make the cabin compliant with building regs.

Take a look at the development contributions required for Carlow, it looks like they start at €5k before you look at the charges from Irish Water: http://www.carlow.ie/wp-content/documents/uploads/Development-Contribution-Schemes-Applicable-for-Town-and-County-010716.pdf

Michael D Not Higgins · 29-06-2017 3:07pm

Graham wrote: »

Realistically even if you miraculously got planning permission, you'd spend the largest part of your budget before you got anywhere near a cabin.

Agreed, I'm sorry trixy but these log cabins aren't the amazing low cost housing solution the vendors make them out to be.

trixychic · 29-06-2017 3:23pm

Dam maybe not. May come up with something else. Ok. Thanks

Gumbo · 29-06-2017 3:32pm

trixychic wrote: »

Sorry my young man's birthday party is tomorrow and im up to my eyeballs.

Im looking to get a "log cabin" for €30-40k. It would be the first step to getting the property ladder started for us.

SIL friend is off on holidays at the min so will be talkin to her when she gets back and I've booked appoint with planning commitee so we'll just go from there.

I think you should start preparing for a Plan B.
This will not work out.

The Bishop Basher · 29-06-2017 3:45pm

Michael D Not Higgins wrote: »

Agreed, I'm sorry trixy but these log cabins aren't the amazing low cost housing solution the vendors make them out to be.

It may have changed in recent years but to fair to them, the vendors we dealt with were both clear and direct on prices..

Not one of them pushed a log home as a low cost solution.

Quite the opposite in fact..

It was obvious they were used to people looking for a cheap alternative to bricks and mortar and so they put us straight on that at the outset.

I agree though.. Log homes aren't cheap.. If you don't have the funds to build a regular house, you won't have the funds to build a log house..

Best of luck OP and i hope you find a solution..

trixychic · 29-06-2017 11:09pm

Thanks guys. We have a few ideas in place and we are just looking into options... very thoroughly.

It's important for our boys we get some stability sorted. And as close to their school as possible. Change can be very difficult for my boys. We need to be very sure of our next move before we take it.

I appreciate all the input from yous.

Benny122 · 27-01-2019 11:55am

Hi there

Looking for advise please in relation to planning etc

I have been left a 3-4 acre field with a house on it.

I have the option to sell it. However I’m thinking how would it work to have 6 or 7 log cabin houses in there and all rented? I’d obviously need planning permission

Was thinking of each having their own little garden, concerted patio it’s a big undertaking with a lot of cost but if I rented each out of €500/€600 I’d be dong well.

The field is right on a main road with access into the existing house

Appreciate any feedback

awec · 27-01-2019 11:56am

No chance of PP.

Building regulations too.

Also reckon there'd be fire safety implications in building a cluster of log cabins.

Benny122 · 27-01-2019 11:59am

awec wrote: »

No chance of PP.

Building regulations too.

Also reckon there'd be fire safety implications in building a cluster of log cabins.

Hmmm ok thanks

The Bishop Basher · 27-01-2019 12:11pm

Check out the log home company in Greenan.

He’s done exactly what your trying to do. He’s built a 5 or 6 stunning log homes together on a beautiful site near Rathdrum in Wicklow..

He lives in one and rents out the rest as holiday homes.

It would be worth having a chat with him.

skooterblue2 · 27-01-2019 12:17pm

Marcusm wrote: »

Would it not be easier to call it a prefab?

Please dont joke, I was in school in some for over 12 years. In the summer sweat and the winter you freeze. I would rather live in a homeless shelter than one of those.

an_fathach · 27-01-2019 3:08pm

awec wrote: »

No chance of PP.

Building regulations too.

Also reckon there'd be fire safety implications in building a cluster of log cabins.

Building a cluster of wooden houses is not dangerous.

I think they are not many builders with good know how to construct log houses but there is a few examples around.

Mariset · 06-02-2019 4:21am

I live in a solid log home which was imported in kit form from Finland. It was not a problem getting the planning permission. The house is amazing,
it looks beautiful. It doesn't cost a fortune to heat because its not made from cold concrete blocks that takes hours or days to heat up. It's a warm comfortable home for our family and it will still be here for several more generations to come.

notharrypotter · 06-02-2019 6:43am

Mariset wrote: »

I live in a solid log home which was imported in kit form from Finland. It was not a problem getting the planning permission. The house is amazing,
it looks beautiful. It doesn't cost a fortune to heat because its not made from cold concrete blocks that takes hours or days to heat up. It's a warm comfortable home for our family and it will still be here for several more generations to come.

Can you link the grant of planning?

Graces7 · 06-02-2019 8:16am

skooterblue2 wrote: »

Please dont joke, I was in school in some for over 12 years. In the summer sweat and the winter you freeze. I would rather live in a homeless shelter than one of those.

I live in the modern equivalent of a prefab; "demountable dwelling". They are well insulated and very easy to heat.

Far preferable to a shelter which was almost my alternative.

Graces7 · 06-02-2019 8:32am

Co Cavan has three separate devts of timber house like this one

https://www.daft.ie/cavan/houses-for-sale/belturbet/22-the-lodges-cornadarragh-belturbet-cavan-1921596/#img=19

look at the map setting here?

Graces7 · 06-02-2019 9:22am

and this lovely place..

https://www.daft.ie/cavan/houses-for-sale/bawnboy/owengallis-bawnboy-cavan-1846613/

so clearly planning IS possible

Graham · 06-02-2019 10:18am

Graces7 wrote: »

Co Cavan has three separate devts of timber house like this one

https://www.daft.ie/cavan/houses-for-sale/belturbet/22-the-lodges-cornadarragh-belturbet-cavan-1921596/#img=19

look at the map setting here?

Holiday homes. My guess would be they cost more to construct than the current asking price.

In the context of discussion about 'residential log cabins' that usually crops up here, people are usually referring to the €10k - €30k cabins they've seen on the internet. The assumption being they're the first to discover an incredibly cheap way to house their family.

The reality is log cabins suitable as domestic dwellings are nowhere near the €10k - €30k bracket, often being more expensive than traditional construction methods. That's before you even get into the battles with local planners.

Is it possible to get planning permission for a log cabin, yes. Is it likely, no. Is it going to be a cheap build, almost definitely not.

mean gene · 06-02-2019 10:24am

There be no planning permission for these the greedy syndicates and cronyism in Ireland has a few years to run yet

Kamil1981 · 18-04-2019 6:40pm

What about getting planing permition for something like this,looks like normal home with insulation,fundation and others,not chesp to...???

<SNIP>

Residential Log Cabin

Comments