Clare GAA discussion thread

Stationmaster · 18-09-2018 07:37AM

Where are all these new backs going to come from? Anyone that's even close to county standard has been on and off the panel for the last few years.

Henno30 · 18-09-2018 08:39AM

Stationmaster wrote: »

Where are all these new backs going to come from? Anyone that's even close to county standard has been on and off the panel for the last few years.

O'Brien & Hayes have been carrying injuries. Dillon was away. Diarmuid Ryan is only 19 or so. I think O'Brien & Hayes are both good enough to make it. But both of them won't unless Jack Browne goes to full-back.

Decent competition at the back next year if everyone is fit:

O'Brien
Browne
Patch
Hayes
Dillon
DMc
Cleary
Morey
D Fitz
Shanahan
McCarthy

At least one of Fitz, Morey, & Shanahan will be tried further upfield. More likely two. Big year for David Fitz. Has the raw materials but not putting it all together so far.

Clareman · 18-09-2018 09:11AM

For me we've spent a year getting our defence right now it's time to get our midfield and half forwards right. I'd say SoD going to the States is a blessing in disguise and I'd look to give Kelly, Conlon, Galvin and McInerney some time off as well, give them until next April to come back, not only will it give them a break but it'll give other players a chance.

ShortKickOut · 18-09-2018 12:01PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

Tbh and this is my opinion that a debate on clare county football championship is not toò interesting to many clare fans when at a time especially when the heartland of clare football i.e west clare is in danger of been wiped out of senior grade completely. Kilrush the biggest town in the west of the county does not play senior anymore and 31 years since won the senior championship something terribly wrong.
Kilkee another town closeby and they dont play senior anymore either. Now Doonbeg could loose their senior status. Miltown and Kilmhil had no senior teams either up to recently. Its a miracle at all that there is a senior championship with the heart of the west tradition which appears to be gone forever. I cant then understand why one would be remotely interested in the senior club football championship. Cooraclare also not far ahead of the relegation pack who will struggle to stay senior too next year and years after given their display last weekend. And here we are well into september and no closer to the final despite the intercounty championship been kicked around in both hurling and football and been condensed and finished off too early for nothing! It seems like winter since mid august! And no sign yet of a county final been played before October! Clubs are messing all the time.

Embarrassing post and to put it up three times sums it up!

Gael85 · 18-09-2018 12:14PM

Stationmaster wrote: »

Where are all these new backs going to come from? Anyone that's even close to county standard has been on and off the panel for the last few years.

I hear the Lohan brothers and Seanie Mc are coming back on board next season

Gael85 · 18-09-2018 12:16PM

ShortKickOut wrote: »

Embarrassing post and to put it up three times sums it up!

Is that poster even from Clare?

Gael85 · 18-09-2018 12:28PM

Shane_ef wrote: »

Any thoughts on the weekends football?

I was at the double header in Kilrush

2* minor annoyances, firstly the Game times, 5pm is very late for a game on Sunday especially for any student returning to college in Dub, Waterford etc
Not sure why they couldn't have been 1:15 and 3pm games

And While Kilrush did a good job accommodating the large corwd, I still have issues with the parking they do.. I know of 2 people boxed in for 5 -10 mins after deciding to leave the second game just on half time (a common occurrence during double headers) and I know it's not a big deal but in the event of someone having to leave extremely quickly those few minutes could be vital

Game wise, (I'm not reporter )
Clondegad were comfortable against Kilmihil, looked like Kilmihil were playing the wrong kind of game, some great passages of play on both side, but the TK - Gary Brennan combo is hard to beat.

Cooraclare were the better team on the day, the game could have gotten away from the Ref as there was more and more cynical play, lots of off the ball stuff, I must have seen Pierce Lillis get hopped 6-7 times off the ball, some super scores given the swirling winds

Should be some good quarter finals

Pot A: KIB, Cratloe, Miltown, Ennistymon

Pot B: Cooraclare, Eire Óg, Clondegad, Corofin

Repeat pairings will be avoided as far as is possible

And the Senior B won't be a dull affair either
St Breckans, Doonbeg, kilmihil, Lissycasy (After they started so well) Losing Loser gets Relegated

Worse the county board usually fix football championship games during the summer on Sundays @6-30. Games are often fixed on bank holiday Mondays evening too. Disaster for people who have to travel up the country after. Are senior hurling championship games played on Sunday evenings?

With Corofin beating Lissycasy, Kilmihil will probably be favourites for the drop to intermediate.

Gael85 · 18-09-2018 12:36PM

Henno30 wrote: »

O'Brien & Hayes have been carrying injuries. Dillon was away. Diarmuid Ryan is only 19 or so. I think O'Brien & Hayes are both good enough to make it. But both of them won't unless Jack Browne goes to full-back.

Decent competition at the back next year if everyone is fit:

O'Brien
Browne
Patch
Hayes
Dillon
DMc
Cleary
Morey
D Fitz
Shanahan
McCarthy

At least one of Fitz, Morey, & Shanahan will be tried further upfield. More likely two. Big year for David Fitz. Has the raw materials but not putting it all together so far.

How come Paul Flanagan hasn't got too many chances at senior level? Always that he decent on them 21 teams.What is David Fitz best position?

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 12:40PM

Gael85 wrote: »

Worse the county board usually fix football championship games during the summer on Sundays @6-30. Games are often fixed on bank holiday Mondays evening too. Disaster for people who have to travel up the country after. Are senior hurling championship games played on Sunday evenings?

With Corofin beating Lissycasy, Kilmihil will probably be favourites for the drop to intermediate.

The football club championship is not really a talking point in Clare anymore in my opinion because for the very reason that when a clare county team takes on even a kerry senior team in transition they just flop. So many clare fans even previous clare football fans now follow hurling in Clare at club and county level end of story. The debates and discussions on clare club football are really for a small minority with no long term success goals at least with the county. Fair play though that they remain loyal but its really understandable why clare people see no long term effort following clare club and county football. This thread as such is a hurling thread but was hijacked lately by football issues.

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 12:42PM

Gael85 wrote: »

Is that poster even from Clare?

Am afraid sorry t say but yea a true and true clare person. What year will Clare win Sam ðŸ˜

ShortKickOut · 18-09-2018 01:42PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

The football club championship is not really a talking point in Clare anymore in my opinion because for the very reason that when a clare county team takes on even a kerry senior team in transition they just flop. So many clare fans even previous clare football fans now follow hurling in Clare at club and county level end of story. The debates and discussions on clare club football are really for a small minority with no long term success goals at least with the county. Fair play though that they remain loyal but its really understandable why clare people see no long term effort following clare club and county football. This thread as such is a hurling thread but was hijacked lately by football issues.

Your probably trolling but the support a club team gets is not dependent on the senior inter county team. If anything the vast majority of club people have a passing interest in the county team and the club is the priority. Club football is well debated in Clare as in any other county so please don't base your judgements on the contributors to this thread. You might find the hard to believe but this thread is not a 'talking point' among the majority of people. Imagine that!

I'm not a big hurling man but I do enjoy reading peoples opinions on the Clare team going forward without the feeling the need to pick holes in the condition of Clare hurling.

And the club football championship is set up for a wonderful climax if weather is kind to us.

Sterling Archer · 18-09-2018 02:04PM

ShortKickOut wrote: »

Embarrassing post and to put it up three times sums it up!

Just put them on the ignore list, it's great, I did it after mods discovered they were using two profiles "viewpoint 2"

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 02:05PM

ShortKickOut wrote: »

Your probably trolling but the support a club team gets is not dependent on the senior inter county team. If anything the vast majority of club people have a passing interest in the county team and the club is the priority. Club football is well debated in Clare as in any other county so please don't base your judgements on the contributors to this thread. You might find the hard to believe but this thread is not a 'talking point' among the majority of people. Imagine that!

I'm not a big hurling man but I do enjoy reading peoples opinions on the Clare team going forward without the feeling the need to pick holes in the condition of Clare hurling.

And the club football championship is set up for a wonderful climax if weather is kind to us.

I agree with some of what you say but disagree with the word trolling. Also just making the point that the auld club football championship seems t pop up here so much as if there was no club hurling championship taking place or it pops up when we are discussing more important matters like what we should be doing and saying to get our county team doing well next year that is the hurling team. No good referring to the county football team for reasons I already mentioned in this thread and anyways yes people who follow club football as you said have only a passing interest in the county team. So that is it confirmed from you who claim not to be a big hurling man. Well no wonder so the Clare football team doesnt win anything because the grassroots are not interested in Clare! Well why would hurling people so show any interest in club football or toerate a debate on it here hijacking the county hurling team discussion when clare club football people themselves are more interested in the mickey mouse poor quality football club game than the Clare football team!

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 02:13PM

Ps not one football club fan has come out and given a reason why despite the all ireland hurling final been played in mid august and the football final in early september, why Clare have not already ran off their club football final and for that matter their hurling club final.
There is too much messing going on with the clare football and hurling championships running and prolonging the poor quality competitions in league groups. If both reverted to the traditional knock out twould be over in a few weeks and put us out of our misery! Then we could concentrate on the county team for next year ie the hurling county team. Yawn Yawn this club championship stuff. The last good football club match within clare was the 1989 and 1992 finals. There hasnt been one good senior game since but plenty of talk about the ball of wind!

Hidalgo · 18-09-2018 02:25PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

The football club championship is not really a talking point in Clare anymore in my opinion because for the very reason that when a clare county team takes on even a kerry senior team in transition they just flop. So many clare fans even previous clare football fans now follow hurling in Clare at club and county level end of story. The debates and discussions on clare club football are really for a small minority with no long term success goals at least with the county. Fair play though that they remain loyal but its really understandable why clare people see no long term effort following clare club and county football. This thread as such is a hurling thread but was hijacked lately by football issues.

The title of the thread gives a fair clue as to what the the thread is for/about.
It's to discuss Clare GAA, not just hurling.
If posters want to talk about football, more luck, they're in the correct thread to do so

square ball · 18-09-2018 03:03PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

Ps not one football club fan has come out and given a reason why despite the all ireland hurling final been played in mid august and the football final in early september, why Clare have not already ran off their club football final and for that matter their hurling club final.
There is too much messing going on with the clare football and hurling championships running and prolonging the poor quality competitions in league groups. If both reverted to the traditional knock out twould be over in a few weeks and put us out of our misery! Then we could concentrate on the county team for next year ie the hurling county team. Yawn Yawn this club championship stuff. The last good football club match within clare was the 1989 and 1992 finals. There hasnt been one good senior game since but plenty of talk about the ball of wind!

Cooraclare and Breckans first round game this year was as good a championship game seen anywhere in the country.

There is no 'league group' in either senior championship in Clare for the past couple of years.

Limestone Cowboy · 18-09-2018 03:09PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

Ps not one football club fan has come out and given a reason why despite the all ireland hurling final been played in mid august and the football final in early september, why Clare have not already ran off their club football final and for that matter their hurling club final.
There is too much messing going on with the clare football and hurling championships running and prolonging the poor quality competitions in league groups. If both reverted to the traditional knock out twould be over in a few weeks and put us out of our misery! Then we could concentrate on the county team for next year ie the hurling county team. Yawn Yawn this club championship stuff. The last good football club match within clare was the 1989 and 1992 finals. There hasnt been one good senior game since but plenty of talk about the ball of wind!

Did you forget where the county players start and finish playing. The club is the reason we have county teams regardless of what level it's played at.

Henno30 · 18-09-2018 05:02PM

Gael85 wrote: »

How come Paul Flanagan hasn't got too many chances at senior level? Always that he decent on them 21 teams.What is David Fitz best position?

He got some league starts under Davy. Don't know why he hasn't staked a stronger claim, but it's possible he's a better hurler than defender like many of this group.

Figerty · 18-09-2018 07:45PM

Henno30 wrote: »

He got some league starts under Davy. Don't know why he hasn't staked a stronger claim, but it's possible he's a better hurler than defender like many of this group.

I'd be more wondering why Niall Deasy hasn't made an impact with Clare this year. Even as a sub. Had a great year with Ballyea the year before.

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 07:48PM

Anyway lets get back to the hurling with our county playing again in Div 1 A next year isnt it great altogether. Isnt it mighty that give a take or year here and there Clare have been a strong county in hurling since 95 and always was a hurling county its the main gaa code played for intercounty success anyway and acourse St Flannans were teriffic too a while back. It would be nice t see them come strong again so that hopefully Clare will at least another 3 more all ireland senior hurling titles in the next 23-25 years. We could win one much sooner if we sort out the supply or strength in the half forward line ( have surely enough forward options and X forwards that used to be on panel and fringe forwards) if thought about it right rather than hoping it happens! But even if thats tweaked the main problem is the loose defence and if that was improved it would take a lot of pressure off. No matter what the forwards scored this year in high scoring games not t mention what they didnt convert from their dominance and the struggle in the half forward line to win the dirty ball, not withstanding all that it was the backs that leaked a lot and undid all the scoring power upfront ultimately loosing the big tight games v Cork and Galway replay. If this is not sorted Clare wont win silverware next year again with great potential. Its a pity the auld footballers cant make the breakthrough and win Sam Maguire. I suppose we wont never see it coming to Clare! Pity with the unusual deep interest that the loyal few football club fans show going to club games when not many else in the county knows they are even on or follows them games anymore.

Reputable Rog · 18-09-2018 07:56PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

Anyway lets get back to the hurling with our county playing again in Div 1 A next year isnt it great altogether. Isnt it mighty that give a take or year here and there Clare have been a strong county in hurling since 95 and always was a hurling county its the main gaa code played for intercounty success anyway and acourse St Flannans were teriffic too a while back. It would be nice t see them come strong again so that hopefully Clare will at least another 3 more all ireland senior hurling titles in the next 23-25 years. We could win one much sooner if we sort out the supply or strength in the half forward line ( have surely enough forward options and X forwards that used to be on panel and fringe forwards) if thought about it right rather than hoping it happens! But even if thats tweaked the main problem is the loose defence and if that was improved it would take a lot of pressure off. No matter what the forwards scored this year in high scoring games not t mention what they didnt convert from their dominance and the struggle in the half forward line to win the dirty ball, not withstanding all that it was the backs that leaked a lot and undid all the scoring power upfront ultimately loosing the big tight games v Cork and Galway replay. If this is not sorted Clare wont win silverware next year again with great potential. Its a pity the auld footballers cant make the breakthrough and win Sam Maguire. I suppose we wont never see it coming to Clare! Pity with the unusual deep interest that the loyal few football club fans show going to club games when not many else in the county knows they are even on or follows them games anymore.

I think your post could benefit from some punctuation and paragraphing.

LuckyGent88 · 18-09-2018 08:32PM

Gaatalk wrote: »

Anyway lets get back to the hurling with our county playing again in Div 1 A next year isnt it great altogether. Isnt it mighty that give a take or year here and there Clare have been a strong county in hurling since 95 and always was a hurling county its the main gaa code played for intercounty success anyway and acourse St Flannans were teriffic too a while back. It would be nice t see them come strong again so that hopefully Clare will at least another 3 more all ireland senior hurling titles in the next 23-25 years. We could win one much sooner if we sort out the supply or strength in the half forward line ( have surely enough forward options and X forwards that used to be on panel and fringe forwards) if thought about it right rather than hoping it happens! But even if thats tweaked the main problem is the loose defence and if that was improved it would take a lot of pressure off. No matter what the forwards scored this year in high scoring games not t mention what they didnt convert from their dominance and the struggle in the half forward line to win the dirty ball, not withstanding all that it was the backs that leaked a lot and undid all the scoring power upfront ultimately loosing the big tight games v Cork and Galway replay. If this is not sorted Clare wont win silverware next year again with great potential. Its a pity the auld footballers cant make the breakthrough and win Sam Maguire. I suppose we wont never see it coming to Clare! Pity with the unusual deep interest that the loyal few football club fans show going to club games when not many else in the county knows they are even on or follows them games anymore.

How about we talk about the weekend hurling matches in the county championship and leave the inter county stuff till after that’s finished? It’s months away yet ffs and some counties don’t even have managers yet.

Your constantly whining about our defenders but not once have you put any names forward. How about you fill us in on some of the emerging talent you have seen so far in the county championship or have you even bothered to turn up to any game.

Henno30 · 18-09-2018 09:52PM

Figerty wrote: »

I'd be more wondering why Niall Deasy hasn't made an impact with Clare this year. Even as a sub. Had a great year with Ballyea the year before.

It's a big step up. He hasn't been there for long. Look how far Peter Duggan has come in 3 or 4 years.

Gael85 · 18-09-2018 10:05PM

Does anyone have the odds for football championship? Eire Og seem to be coming good at the right time.

funnyname · 18-09-2018 10:15PM

Kilmurry Ibrickane
6/4
Cratloe
7/2
St Josephs Miltown Malbay
4/1
Eire Og Ennis
5/1
Clondegad
15/2
Cooraclare
14/1
Ennistymon
14/1
Corofin
80/1

funnyname · 18-09-2018 10:16PM

Sixmilebridge
7/4
Ballyea
4/1
Cratloe
9/2
Clooney Quin
11/2
Eire Og Ennis
7/1
Kilmaley
10/1
Inagh Kilnamona
12/1
O'Callaghan Mills
16/1

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 10:54PM

LuckyGent88 wrote: »

How about we talk about the weekend hurling matches in the county championship and leave the inter county stuff till after that’s finished? It’s months away yet ffs and some counties don’t even have managers yet.

Your constantly whining about our defenders but not once have you put any names forward. How about you fill us in on some of the emerging talent you have seen so far in the county championship or have you even bothered to turn up to any game.

I am entitled to complain about the clare defence this year or for that matter the same defence last summer that also leaked high scores to Tipperary down in Cork and lost despite scoring 3 goals that day and a lot of points! Look if its not flagged now and constantly flagged before the preseason starts
then will be looking at the same defence more or less give or take next january and so on up t the championship. You have t plan early if want a new unit settling in.

Rory Hayes is a player could be tried more.
What about the 2009 first all ireland winnning u21 captain Ciaran Doherty he was one of the best defenders Clare has seen since the 90's!
Why could he not be convinced or at least sussed out. Cian Dillon was good enough to be a defender in the 2013 setup all ireland winning team yet wasnt on the team this year at any stage even when Galway ran riot at them the two days at the start. There was James Mc Inerney from Newmarket a former back on the Clare panel he hasnt been recalled in the last few years either and had at least a physical presence. The goalie Pat Kelly of the all ireland winning team has been left off the setup too!
Also Garry Brennan could have been enticed into the hurling team/panel and his physical presence alone would help the defence or the midfield area and as a bonus he is a skilful enough hurler.

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 11:03PM

Gael85 wrote: »

Does anyone have the odds for football championship? Eire Og seem to be coming good at the right time.

Ah if Eire Og win it they usually shame clare with the hammerings they get in the munster club. Check it out! Better if they concentrated on hurling which is or was the main game played in Ennis and which has or had tradition. Clare needs more hurlers like Shane O'Donnell from Ennis (when on form) like was at the latter part of this years championship, popping up playing hurling for Clare. Playing football for Ennis wont secure a munster club title or a Liam Mc Carthy cup or all ireland hurling medal. Noone or I dont care about the football championship.

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 11:09PM

LuckyGent88 wrote: »

How about we talk about the weekend hurling matches in the county championship and leave the inter county stuff till after that’s finished? It’s months away yet ffs and some counties don’t even have managers yet.

Your constantly whining about our defenders but not once have you put any names forward. How about you fill us in on some of the emerging talent you have seen so far in the county championship or have you even bothered to turn up to any game.

Also the barretts from Newmarket and Barry Duggan Cratloe and Damien Browne Cratloe could or should have been called or invited onto panel to see if they could tighten up the defence unit for Clare. Could not be much worse than present.

Gaatalk · 18-09-2018 11:13PM

Reputable Rog wrote: »

I think your post could benefit from some punctuation and paragraphing.

Ah now you could do with been less nasty . This isnt a teachers forum so lets see what the football response to this is and keep your auld punctuation to yourself.

Clare GAA discussion thread

Comments