Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Orla WW · 17-09-2018 02:02PM

Gabriel WW wrote:

To be clear; i want everyone to do an FFA.

Good luck with that Gab :P

I'm giving a readslist later in an effort to try something different. No FFA from me.
Take my reads list as my entry when I post it if you like but I abhor FFAs. I have seen the light.

You want engagement, involvement and people posting?

Get folks to post their opinion on everyone, even if it's null it's info we can use later if that person flips wolf.

Frank WW · 17-09-2018 02:03PM

Also unsure how Desmond got 4 from the hospitalized message if its the same as mine

Derry WW · 17-09-2018 02:04PM

Riona WW wrote: »

So would you surmise that the 4 of you were singled out by the Sk who is in essence taunting you before killing one of you?

Not 100% sure.

As pointed out, the hospitalization occurred before the munch. The SK apparently gets his kills between munches. There could be a mechanic though that the SK has to pick from us?

I wonder if the wolf who has the power to kill in an unusual way can target 4 people, "hospitalize" them and then the SK picks one of the four?

Anyway, at the moment, Nigel and Doris are two names that register on my "Suspicious" list.

Barbara WW · 17-09-2018 02:04PM

Brendan WW wrote: »

No there is still one person to reveal on thread but that is up to them to do.

Any reason you can think of why the fourth player wouldn’t reveal? It seems odd to stay quiet when three players know who you are. Not asking the three to name them but this hospital thing is more and more confusing

Oisin WW · 17-09-2018 02:06PM

Liam WW wrote: »

User Name| Posts
Orla WW |78
Mary WW |48
Derry WW |35
Katie WW |33
Riona WW |31
Nigel WW |31
Conor WW| 27
Winifred WW |22
Clodagh WW| 22
Abigail WW |20
Brendan WW| 20
Doris WW| 18
Gabriel WW |16
Desmond WW| 16
Tegan WW |16
Wendy WW| 11
Steve WW |10
Frank WW| 9
Liam WW |6
Barbara WW| 5
Eva WW |1
Holly WW |1

So by my counting we've yet to hear from Gertrude, Isla and Oisín.

Reporting now, currently speed reading the thread.

Gabriel WW · 17-09-2018 02:06PM

Orla WW wrote: »

Gabriel WW wrote:

To be clear; i want everyone to do an FFA.

Good luck with that Gab :P

I'm giving a readslist later in an effort to try something different. No FFA from me.
Take my reads list as my entry when I post it if you like but I abhor FFAs. I have seen the light.

You want engagement, involvement and people posting?

Get folks to post their opinion on everyone, even if it's null it's info we can use later if that person flips wolf.

Of course its you. Sigh.

Barbara WW · 17-09-2018 02:07PM

Frank WW wrote: »

Just to add to the confusion I was hospitalised this morning at 8:27 aswell. Only on now so didn't see it. Catching up now but meh no point me not saying it

Sorry frank, just saw this now

Isla WW · 17-09-2018 02:07PM

Hey guys

Brendan WW · 17-09-2018 02:08PM

Frank WW wrote: »

Also unsure how Desmond got 4 from the hospitalized message if its the same as mine

If you read the PM on the full site you can see who it was sent to. Can't see it on the phone.

Barbara WW wrote: »

Any reason you can think of why the fourth player wouldn’t reveal? It seems odd to stay quiet when three players know who you are. Not asking the three to name them but this hospital thing is more and more confusing

They have now revealed.

Brendan WW · 17-09-2018 02:09PM

Liam WW wrote: »

User Name| Posts
Orla WW |78
Mary WW |48
Derry WW |35
Katie WW |33
Riona WW |31
Nigel WW |31
Conor WW| 27
Winifred WW |22
Clodagh WW| 22
Abigail WW |20
Brendan WW| 20
Doris WW| 18
Gabriel WW |16
Desmond WW| 16
Tegan WW |16
Wendy WW| 11
Steve WW |10
Frank WW| 9
Liam WW |6
Barbara WW| 5
Eva WW |1
Holly WW |1

So by my counting we've yet to hear from Gertrude, Isla and Oisín.

Oisin WW wrote: »

Reporting now, currently speed reading the thread.

Isla WW wrote: »

Hey guys

Interesting that you both post around the same time!

Gabriel WW · 17-09-2018 02:10PM

Orla WW wrote: »

Gabriel WW wrote:

To be clear; i want everyone to do an FFA.

Good luck with that Gab :P

I'm giving a readslist later in an effort to try something different. No FFA from me.
Take my reads list as my entry when I post it if you like but I abhor FFAs. I have seen the light.

You want engagement, involvement and people posting?

Get folks to post their opinion on everyone, even if it's null it's info we can use later if that person flips wolf.

You get that it will be impossible to go through read lists if EVERYONE does them.
FFAs are an aggregation tool to allow us to condense a huge amount of info. You have to know this.
Its great you value your opinion over the combined opinions of the entire village, but in recent history, villages have been very successful finding wolves using these methods.

Gabriel WW · 17-09-2018 02:11PM

*not impossible, but its certainly not as easy as collated FFAs.

Gabriel WW · 17-09-2018 02:11PM

Anti-FFAers = Anti-Vaxxers.
There, i said it.

Orla WW · 17-09-2018 02:11PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Of course its you. Sigh.

It's always me.

I'm happy with whatever but I wanna try the readslist thing as a new tactic.

If you have to you can take my bottom 3 as my FFA, but it's something I wanna try anyways.

Like look at Winnie (null to wolf lean at the mo for me btw), she's fired up three, now two names with no reasoning at all - it's a lazy way out.

Get people to say how they feel about EVERYONE - and then we have some tangible data.

Even if it's a null read/no opinion, it's a starting point.

Isla WW · 17-09-2018 02:11PM

Brendan WW wrote: »

Interesting that you both post around the same time!

Maybe its because its lunch time. I know thats why I am here and for a few minutes only. Will do the majority of my posting this evening

Barbara WW · 17-09-2018 02:13PM

There are talented individuals that have different traits and skills some of which will be revealed below and there are traits and skills that will only be revealed under certain circumstances.

Spotted this in the op. Seems possible that the hospital thing might be a role we don’t know about. Haven’t a clue how it might work though

Orla WW · 17-09-2018 02:13PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

You get that it will be impossible to go through read lists if EVERYONE does them.
FFAs are an aggregation tool to allow us to condense a huge amount of info. You have to know this.
Its great you value your opinion over the combined opinions of the entire village, but in recent history, villages have been very successful finding wolves using these methods.

From my reading of recent games, FFAs have had sweet FA to do with catching wolves.

I'm not asking you to agree, but don't start marching around like a dictator ordering people to do it your way either.

Frank WW · 17-09-2018 02:13PM

Brendan WW wrote: »

If you read the PM on the full site you can see who it was sent to. Can't see it on the phone.

They have now revealed.

Maybe that should have been reported to mods? I'm only reading on touch site though so didn't notice that

Isla WW · 17-09-2018 02:14PM

And as opposed to Oisin, I have read most of the thread

Abigail WW · 17-09-2018 02:16PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

You get that it will be impossible to go through read lists if EVERYONE does them.
FFAs are an aggregation tool to allow us to condense a huge amount of info. You have to know this.
Its great you value your opinion over the combined opinions of the entire village, but in recent history, villages have been very successful finding wolves using these methods.

I generally agree that FFAs are the way forward but I did mention previously that in the last game big numbers of players did not bother with FFAs and as a result the ones who did just drew heat on themselves. I will do FFAs happily this time if it seems like the village will do it as a unit but I dont want to just have half of us doing it.

Brendan WW · 17-09-2018 02:16PM

Frank WW wrote: »

Maybe that should have been reported to mods? I'm only reading on touch site though so didn't notice that

I never actually noticed it myself until Des pointed it out.

Isla WW · 17-09-2018 02:16PM

Orla WW wrote: »

From my reading of recent games, FFAs have had sweet FA to do with catching wolves.

I'm not asking you to agree, but don't start marching around like a dictator ordering people to do it your way either.

They are a good way to force people to give reads though. People who include something wishy-washy have had a higher propensity to not be villagers

Gabriel WW · 17-09-2018 02:17PM

Orla WW wrote: »

Gabriel WW wrote: »

You get that it will be impossible to go through read lists if EVERYONE does them.
FFAs are an aggregation tool to allow us to condense a huge amount of info. You have to know this.
Its great you value your opinion over the combined opinions of the entire village, but in recent history, villages have been very successful finding wolves using these methods.

From my reading of recent games, FFAs have had sweet FA to do with catching wolves.

I'm not asking you to agree, but don't start marching around like a dictator ordering people to do it your way either.

Yet again being aggressively defensive.
Im not marching or ordering anyone Orla, and you are misleading people to say it.
Its not MY way, its the organised way the village can gather our information together.

Gertrude WW · 17-09-2018 02:17PM

Hey guys signing in. Have read yesterday and this morn up to the death. Need to reread op and hospital stuff. There was a lot of boasting yesterday by a number of people. People really don't like to be left out of praise if they do something positive do they, Katie?

Im prob gona disregard everything from before hospitalisation this morning as a team building exercise. But did anyone consider the solving of the puzzles having positive wolf rewards? As in the people solving and pushing were doing so for nefarious reasons?

Brendan WW · 17-09-2018 02:17PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

Spotted this in the op. Seems possible that the hospital thing might be a role we don’t know about. Haven’t a clue how it might work though

You could be right though when I read that first I assumed the certain circumstances was the solving of the riddles??

Isla WW · 17-09-2018 02:18PM

The 3 remaining zero posters arriving together. What a coincidence

Barbara WW · 17-09-2018 02:20PM

Abigail WW wrote: »

I generally agree that FFAs are the way forward but I did mention previously that in the last game big numbers of players did not bother with FFAs and as a result the ones who did just drew heat on themselves. I will do FFAs happily this time if it seems like the village will do it as a unit but I dont want to just have half of us doing it.

I’m good with ffas. If someone doesn’t want to do them then that might tell something in itself.

Isla WW · 17-09-2018 02:20PM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Hey guys signing in. Have read yesterday and this morn up to the death. Need to reread op and hospital stuff. There was a lot of boasting yesterday by a number of people. People really don't like to be left out of praise if they do something positive do they, Katie?

Im prob gona disregard everything from before hospitalisation this morning as a team building exercise. But did anyone consider the solving of the puzzles having positive wolf rewards? As in the people solving and pushing were doing so for nefarious reasons?

I thought about this and I think the wolves would be more likely to not want people to solve them. The more time the village spends solving riddles is less time wolf hunting

Orla WW · 17-09-2018 02:20PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Yet again being aggressively defensive.
Im not marching or ordering anyone Orla, and you are misleading people to say it.
Its not MY way, its the organised way the village can gather our information together.

Well I'm not doing it. And why am I being aggressive and defensive yet, it is you who stated:

'I want FFAs from everyone, by the way.'

I'm trialling a new method, and if that makes me a target, so be it.

Gabriel WW · 17-09-2018 02:21PM

Abigail WW wrote: »

Gabriel WW wrote: »

You get that it will be impossible to go through read lists if EVERYONE does them.
FFAs are an aggregation tool to allow us to condense a huge amount of info. You have to know this.
Its great you value your opinion over the combined opinions of the entire village, but in recent history, villages have been very successful finding wolves using these methods.

I generally agree that FFAs are the way forward but I did mention previously that in the last game big numbers of players did not bother with FFAs and as a result the ones who did just drew heat on themselves. I will do FFAs happily this time if it seems like the village will do it as a unit but I dont want to just have half of us doing it.

I agree with this. But even that (not doing them) gives us information for later.

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments